ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,309
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-06-2026 08:47 AM)XLance Wrote: College football disappointed yesterday................too many lopsided scores.
I had no interest in watching so many non-competitive games.
What a waste of time.
The P4 is a combined 47-2 so far against G6 and FCS opposition, with the only losses coming to Tulsa (Oklahoma State) and UMass (Rutgers). That doesn't exactly make for Must See TV. At the very least we need to make those FCS buy games pre-season exhibitions instead of regular season games. Give the P4 their 7 home games, but spare us from having to suffer through them in September.
|
|
| 09-07-2026 04:04 PM |
|
schmolik
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader

Posts: 12,645
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1106
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-06-2026 06:32 PM)EdwordL Wrote: I guess it is because of the nature of the college game, but our HS team had scrimmages with teams not on our schedule, and college basketball teams have scrimmages with other teams: Kansas has scrimmaged against Illinois and Louisville in recent years.
Basketball can afford scrimmages because the game isn't as physically trying and draining and there's less injury risk. There is no way most of these schools will agree to football scrimmages.
|
|
| 09-07-2026 04:38 PM |
|
HP-TBDPITL
Heisman

Posts: 5,529
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 250
I Root For: College Sports
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-06-2026 08:47 AM)XLance Wrote: College football disappointed yesterday................too many lopsided scores.
I had no interest in watching so many non-competitive games.
What a waste of time.
Such a premature post. There is A LOT of football being televised. You just have to watch the stuff that is good.
Boise v Oregon was a good game
So was Auburn v Baylor
WMU beat Michigan...until they didnt.
UMass beat down Rutgers on the road to end its futility.
Louisville v Ole Miss was a FUN watch.
Notre Dame killing Wisconsin and LSU killing Clemson told us a lot about all 4 teams.
SMU beating FSU on the road and Tulsa beating Oklahoma St at home are keeping things interesting, in my opinion.
In today's college football-week 0 and week 1 are extremely important because most of these teams are being put together in the off season...you have no idea until they hit the field what will really happen. There used to be lopsided games because of the schedule, but now its because a team was put together AND the schedule. You cant be lazy and expect the good football to find you-you have to go find it...it's still there and its being televised. Stop being lazy and go find it.
(This post was last modified: 09-08-2026 02:27 PM by HP-TBDPITL.)
|
|
| 09-08-2026 05:33 AM |
|
Bear Catlett
Hall of Famer

Posts: 18,747
Joined: Jan 2020
Reputation: 2303
I Root For: UC
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
Week one and people are already complaining.
Maybe some Metamucil is in order for some of you.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 06:10 AM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
I had a blast. It was fun to set up the "man cave" for the first time in nine or so months, watch "Game Day" for two hours, and I was able to find fun games by switching my eyes to different TVs.
Plus, it was just so cool to have a full slate of CFB on I wasn't really in a critical mindset.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 07:05 AM |
|
CliftonAve2
2nd String

Posts: 338
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 43
I Root For: Jimmy Nippert
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-07-2026 04:38 PM)schmolik Wrote: (09-06-2026 06:32 PM)EdwordL Wrote: I guess it is because of the nature of the college game, but our HS team had scrimmages with teams not on our schedule, and college basketball teams have scrimmages with other teams: Kansas has scrimmaged against Illinois and Louisville in recent years.
Basketball can afford scrimmages because the game isn't as physically trying and draining and there's less injury risk. There is no way most of these schools will agree to football scrimmages.
In this era of massive portal changes on the roster, it seems there is some momentum from the coaches to have something. I am not saying it will be a full blown scrimmage but I would not be surprised to see joint practices and game simulation in the near future. They might even start simple and just have a local FCS or DII participate.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 09:01 AM |
|
SFLFB
Special Teams

Posts: 843
Joined: Sep 2023
Reputation: 245
I Root For: USF
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
Didn't someone mention, or try to have, a "joint spring game" so they can 'play' against another school? IMO that could be a decent addition. Also with most conferences going to 9+1, competitive OOC games to fill the other 2 weeks are going to become much less common until someone steps up to pay for it.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 09:24 AM |
|
WhidbeyWolf
1st String

Posts: 1,602
Joined: Jul 2025
Reputation: 242
I Root For: Wolfpack
Location: Olympic Shadow
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-08-2026 05:33 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (09-06-2026 08:47 AM)XLance Wrote: College football disappointed yesterday................too many lopsided scores.
I had no interest in watching so many non-competitive games.
What a waste of time.
Such a premature post. There is A LOT of football being televised. You just have to watch the stuff that is good.
Boise v Oregon was a good game
So was Auburn v Baylor
WMU beat Michigan...until they didnt.
UMass beat down Rutgers on the road to end its futility.
Louisville v Ole Miss was a FUN watch.
Notre Dame killing Wisconsin and LSU killing Clemson told us a lot about all 4 teams.
SMU beating FSU on the road and Tulsa beating Oklahoma St at home are keeping things interesting, in my opinion.
In today's college football-week 0 and week 1 are extremely important because most of these teams are being put together in the off season...you have no idea until they hit the field what will really happen. There used to be lopsided games because of the schedule, but now its because a team was put together AND the schedule. You cant be lazy and expect the goof football to find you-you have to go find it...it's still there and its being televised. Stop being lazy and go find it.
Good points. And why was he watching the 30-point spread games?
|
|
| 09-08-2026 11:21 AM |
|
e-parade
All American

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-08-2026 11:21 AM)WhidbeyWolf Wrote: (09-08-2026 05:33 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (09-06-2026 08:47 AM)XLance Wrote: College football disappointed yesterday................too many lopsided scores.
I had no interest in watching so many non-competitive games.
What a waste of time.
Such a premature post. There is A LOT of football being televised. You just have to watch the stuff that is good.
Boise v Oregon was a good game
So was Auburn v Baylor
WMU beat Michigan...until they didnt.
UMass beat down Rutgers on the road to end its futility.
Louisville v Ole Miss was a FUN watch.
Notre Dame killing Wisconsin and LSU killing Clemson told us a lot about all 4 teams.
SMU beating FSU on the road and Tulsa beating Oklahoma St at home are keeping things interesting, in my opinion.
In today's college football-week 0 and week 1 are extremely important because most of these teams are being put together in the off season...you have no idea until they hit the field what will really happen. There used to be lopsided games because of the schedule, but now its because a team was put together AND the schedule. You cant be lazy and expect the goof football to find you-you have to go find it...it's still there and its being televised. Stop being lazy and go find it.
Good points. And why was he watching the 30-point spread games?
Hey now, that UMass game was a 29.5 point spread!
|
|
| 09-08-2026 12:53 PM |
|
No Bull
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,785
Joined: Jul 2008
Reputation: 1220
I Root For: UCF
Location: Deadwood
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
The Ole Miss vs Louisville games was awesome. I was lucky I picked it out o watch.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 01:08 PM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,987
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13535
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-08-2026 01:08 PM)No Bull Wrote: The Ole Miss vs Louisville games was awesome. I was lucky I picked it out o watch.
Only because neither side had a semblance of downfield coverage on receivers and neither secondary could tackle. Like the Auburn / Baylor game and the Ole Miss / Louisville game the game was highly competitive because in each of those 3 games the weaknesses for both opponents were the same. They were good games because each school was deficient in the same area as their opponent. Good games but bad football.
(This post was last modified: 09-08-2026 01:12 PM by JRsec.)
|
|
| 09-08-2026 01:11 PM |
|
Outsider
All American

Posts: 2,539
Joined: Jul 2021
Reputation: 60
I Root For: ACU & Tulane
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-06-2026 11:22 AM)XOVERX Wrote: Here’s some random thoughts …
First, college football still sets records for viewers. It’s really popular. Even with early blowouts. But yes, college football can be improved.
Second, to increase interest further, college ball needs to go to a 24-school playoff (set up like the FCS) because the benefits will trickle down even to week 1.
Third, FCS is FCS. FBS is FBS. FBS vs FCS almost always results in a FBS blowout. Like in week 1 this year. We need more A&M vs ASU games next week and no more Southern vs Houston games next week. Where is Southern anyway? You reckon’ this Southern game will be “interesting” to 99% of college football fans? Yeah, me neither.
Fourth, FBS schools should be penalized by the CFP committee for scheduling FCS opponents. These are the primary blowout games in this week 1 (or in any week). “W padding” should be severely discouraged. Not all, but most all FBS vs FCS games are horrible. There are - what? - 136-something FBS schools out there? Scheduling FCS vs FBS will decrease the super-blowouts. Witness Western Michigan vs Michigan yesterday.
Fifth, more Clemson at LSU games should be encouraged. Yeah, it was a blowout this year, but it’s usually not a sleeper. A 24-school playoff will encourage more interesting nonconference big games because a school can lose that big game, plus lose a couple in conference, and still likely make the 24-school championship payoff. We want to encourage Texas A&M vs Notre Dame quality games, not discourage them.
Except you had what, 3 FCS over FBS upsets, and a few others that beat the spread? The reality is that there is still overlap between the lower end of FBS and upper end of FCS, just like there is the lower end of FCS and upper end of DII. Also, you still get competitive games, at least FBS v FCS games that are as competitive as some FBS v FBS games. Either get rid of the P4 and let them be a farm league, then let the rest of college DI be college DI or get things under control. There will always be FCS schools beating FBS schools, just like there will always be some blowouts. Doesn't mean you kill them altogether.
(This post was last modified: 09-08-2026 02:24 PM by Outsider.)
|
|
| 09-08-2026 02:13 PM |
|
No Bull
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,785
Joined: Jul 2008
Reputation: 1220
I Root For: UCF
Location: Deadwood
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-08-2026 01:11 PM)JRsec Wrote: (09-08-2026 01:08 PM)No Bull Wrote: The Ole Miss vs Louisville games was awesome. I was lucky I picked it out o watch.
Only because neither side had a semblance of downfield coverage on receivers and neither secondary could tackle. Like the Auburn / Baylor game and the Ole Miss / Louisville game the game was highly competitive because in each of those 3 games the weaknesses for both opponents were the same. They were good games because each school was deficient in the same area as their opponent. Good games but bad football.
I can’t say that I disagree.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 03:22 PM |
|
toddjnsn
Hall of Famer

Posts: 12,965
Joined: Sep 2009
Reputation: 167
I Root For: WMU, MAC
Location: Grand Rapids, MI
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
Quote:FCS vs. FBS games need to end.
With how they roll for many, yes. I would say though that the Top 5 or so from FCS can play even the above-half FBS better, but you get down to, say, ~#15 of FCS, and a 4-8 G6 FBS team will take them but it'll just be close.
IMO, it should be projected ~Top 6 FCS teams can play who they want. Top 7-20 FCS can schedule any FBS not projected as ranked. Projected Top 21 to multiple votes in FCS to play FBS well away from .500 in P4, and the FBS projected to be not anything higher than .500 in G6. OR just have it that if FCS projected to have ranking votes for said year, but not their Top 5, only schedule to play FBS teams not projected to be ranked.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 03:34 PM |
|
Outsider
All American

Posts: 2,539
Joined: Jul 2021
Reputation: 60
I Root For: ACU & Tulane
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-08-2026 03:34 PM)toddjnsn Wrote: Quote:FCS vs. FBS games need to end.
With how they roll for many, yes. I would say though that the Top 5 or so from FCS can play even the above-half FBS better, but you get down to, say, ~#15 of FCS, and a 4-8 G6 FBS team will take them but it'll just be close.
IMO, it should be projected ~Top 6 FCS teams can play who they want. Top 7-20 FCS can schedule any FBS not projected as ranked. Projected Top 21 to multiple votes in FCS to play FBS well away from .500 in P4, and the FBS projected to be not anything higher than .500 in G6. OR just have it that if FCS projected to have ranking votes for said year, but not their Top 5, only schedule to play FBS teams not projected to be ranked.
Except you had top 15-20 FCS take P4 teams to overtime and or be competitive and beat the spread, top rated P4 teams. So, formulas look pretty, but... Like others have said, the current schedules push towards a G6 or FCS game and that likely isn't going to change soon. Besides, FCS has proven to surprise or be just as competitive at times, and that is what college sports is about. I can buy any one of you some metamucil if you need it.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 04:08 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,931
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5070
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-08-2026 04:08 PM)Outsider Wrote: (09-08-2026 03:34 PM)toddjnsn Wrote: Quote:FCS vs. FBS games need to end.
With how they roll for many, yes. I would say though that the Top 5 or so from FCS can play even the above-half FBS better, but you get down to, say, ~#15 of FCS, and a 4-8 G6 FBS team will take them but it'll just be close.
IMO, it should be projected ~Top 6 FCS teams can play who they want. Top 7-20 FCS can schedule any FBS not projected as ranked. Projected Top 21 to multiple votes in FCS to play FBS well away from .500 in P4, and the FBS projected to be not anything higher than .500 in G6. OR just have it that if FCS projected to have ranking votes for said year, but not their Top 5, only schedule to play FBS teams not projected to be ranked.
Except you had top 15-20 FCS take P4 teams to overtime and or be competitive and beat the spread, top rated P4 teams. So, formulas look pretty, but... Like others have said, the current schedules push towards a G6 or FCS game and that likely isn't going to change soon. Besides, FCS has proven to surprise or be just as competitive at times, and that is what college sports is about. I can buy any one of you some metamucil if you need it.
Wasn't the P4 47-2 last weekend vs. G and FCS?
FCS has gone 10-237 vs. FBS the last two years. The P4 went 95-17 vs. G schools last year and only 2 of those losses were to CUSA, MAC or Sun Belt schools (8 to American, 5 to MWC, 2 to UConn).
|
|
| 09-08-2026 05:11 PM |
|
Outsider
All American

Posts: 2,539
Joined: Jul 2021
Reputation: 60
I Root For: ACU & Tulane
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-08-2026 05:11 PM)bullet Wrote: (09-08-2026 04:08 PM)Outsider Wrote: (09-08-2026 03:34 PM)toddjnsn Wrote: Quote:FCS vs. FBS games need to end.
With how they roll for many, yes. I would say though that the Top 5 or so from FCS can play even the above-half FBS better, but you get down to, say, ~#15 of FCS, and a 4-8 G6 FBS team will take them but it'll just be close.
IMO, it should be projected ~Top 6 FCS teams can play who they want. Top 7-20 FCS can schedule any FBS not projected as ranked. Projected Top 21 to multiple votes in FCS to play FBS well away from .500 in P4, and the FBS projected to be not anything higher than .500 in G6. OR just have it that if FCS projected to have ranking votes for said year, but not their Top 5, only schedule to play FBS teams not projected to be ranked.
Except you had top 15-20 FCS take P4 teams to overtime and or be competitive and beat the spread, top rated P4 teams. So, formulas look pretty, but... Like others have said, the current schedules push towards a G6 or FCS game and that likely isn't going to change soon. Besides, FCS has proven to surprise or be just as competitive at times, and that is what college sports is about. I can buy any one of you some metamucil if you need it.
Wasn't the P4 47-2 last weekend vs. G and FCS?
FCS has gone 10-237 vs. FBS the last two years. The P4 went 95-17 vs. G schools last year and only 2 of those losses were to CUSA, MAC or Sun Belt schools (8 to American, 5 to MWC, 2 to UConn).
Who cares, wasn't arguing a number. It happens and that's why we like college football. Again, if you guys want the farm league, get the farm league. We can have a farm league fan forum and then one for college football fans. Week 1 wasn't a bust. It was college football, especially college football with major roster turnovers but still basic college football.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 05:49 PM |
|
dbackjon
Hall of Famer

Posts: 14,289
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 989
I Root For: NAU/Illini
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-08-2026 05:49 PM)Outsider Wrote: (09-08-2026 05:11 PM)bullet Wrote: (09-08-2026 04:08 PM)Outsider Wrote: (09-08-2026 03:34 PM)toddjnsn Wrote: Quote:FCS vs. FBS games need to end.
With how they roll for many, yes. I would say though that the Top 5 or so from FCS can play even the above-half FBS better, but you get down to, say, ~#15 of FCS, and a 4-8 G6 FBS team will take them but it'll just be close.
IMO, it should be projected ~Top 6 FCS teams can play who they want. Top 7-20 FCS can schedule any FBS not projected as ranked. Projected Top 21 to multiple votes in FCS to play FBS well away from .500 in P4, and the FBS projected to be not anything higher than .500 in G6. OR just have it that if FCS projected to have ranking votes for said year, but not their Top 5, only schedule to play FBS teams not projected to be ranked.
Except you had top 15-20 FCS take P4 teams to overtime and or be competitive and beat the spread, top rated P4 teams. So, formulas look pretty, but... Like others have said, the current schedules push towards a G6 or FCS game and that likely isn't going to change soon. Besides, FCS has proven to surprise or be just as competitive at times, and that is what college sports is about. I can buy any one of you some metamucil if you need it.
Wasn't the P4 47-2 last weekend vs. G and FCS?
FCS has gone 10-237 vs. FBS the last two years. The P4 went 95-17 vs. G schools last year and only 2 of those losses were to CUSA, MAC or Sun Belt schools (8 to American, 5 to MWC, 2 to UConn).
Who cares, wasn't arguing a number. It happens and that's why we like college football. Again, if you guys want the farm league, get the farm league. We can have a farm league fan forum and then one for college football fans. Week 1 wasn't a bust. It was college football, especially college football with major roster turnovers but still basic college football.
If it gets too far laughable, it will self-correct, IMHO. Arizona State played Morgan State -won 70-7 but could have scored 100. They shortened the game and were playing everyone on the bench.
Now, the discussion has turned to - did ASU gain anything from the game? Was it nothing more than a glorified scrimmage that leaves ASU unprepared for their game next week in College Station?
|
|
| 09-08-2026 06:19 PM |
|
Outsider
All American

Posts: 2,539
Joined: Jul 2021
Reputation: 60
I Root For: ACU & Tulane
Location:
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-08-2026 06:19 PM)dbackjon Wrote: (09-08-2026 05:49 PM)Outsider Wrote: (09-08-2026 05:11 PM)bullet Wrote: (09-08-2026 04:08 PM)Outsider Wrote: (09-08-2026 03:34 PM)toddjnsn Wrote: With how they roll for many, yes. I would say though that the Top 5 or so from FCS can play even the above-half FBS better, but you get down to, say, ~#15 of FCS, and a 4-8 G6 FBS team will take them but it'll just be close.
IMO, it should be projected ~Top 6 FCS teams can play who they want. Top 7-20 FCS can schedule any FBS not projected as ranked. Projected Top 21 to multiple votes in FCS to play FBS well away from .500 in P4, and the FBS projected to be not anything higher than .500 in G6. OR just have it that if FCS projected to have ranking votes for said year, but not their Top 5, only schedule to play FBS teams not projected to be ranked.
Except you had top 15-20 FCS take P4 teams to overtime and or be competitive and beat the spread, top rated P4 teams. So, formulas look pretty, but... Like others have said, the current schedules push towards a G6 or FCS game and that likely isn't going to change soon. Besides, FCS has proven to surprise or be just as competitive at times, and that is what college sports is about. I can buy any one of you some metamucil if you need it.
Wasn't the P4 47-2 last weekend vs. G and FCS?
FCS has gone 10-237 vs. FBS the last two years. The P4 went 95-17 vs. G schools last year and only 2 of those losses were to CUSA, MAC or Sun Belt schools (8 to American, 5 to MWC, 2 to UConn).
Who cares, wasn't arguing a number. It happens and that's why we like college football. Again, if you guys want the farm league, get the farm league. We can have a farm league fan forum and then one for college football fans. Week 1 wasn't a bust. It was college football, especially college football with major roster turnovers but still basic college football.
If it gets too far laughable, it will self-correct, IMHO. Arizona State played Morgan State -won 70-7 but could have scored 100. They shortened the game and were playing everyone on the bench.
Now, the discussion has turned to - did ASU gain anything from the game? Was it nothing more than a glorified scrimmage that leaves ASU unprepared for their game next week in College Station?
And I'm still watching social media talk about how a top 12 win wasn't a good win because the team that played them held them to 4 FGs, as well as forced them to keep their 1st string in until the final few minutes. It's fun watching their excuses because it's always been about just more than the final score. Just more Metamucil to pass around for everyone. Now, my edit? Yes, it helped both teams get better even though it was FCS v FBS and both will be better because of it.
(This post was last modified: 09-08-2026 06:35 PM by Outsider.)
|
|
| 09-08-2026 06:34 PM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: Week 1 is a bust
(09-08-2026 05:33 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (09-06-2026 08:47 AM)XLance Wrote: College football disappointed yesterday................too many lopsided scores.
I had no interest in watching so many non-competitive games.
What a waste of time.
Such a premature post. There is A LOT of football being televised. You just have to watch the stuff that is good.
Boise v Oregon was a good game
So was Auburn v Baylor
WMU beat Michigan...until they didnt.
UMass beat down Rutgers on the road to end its futility.
Louisville v Ole Miss was a FUN watch.
Notre Dame killing Wisconsin and LSU killing Clemson told us a lot about all 4 teams.
(snip)
I concede that in the context of your entire post this is a pretty tiny nit, but as an Irish fan the bolded stood out. I wish I could put ND's win over Wisconsin in the same category as LSU's over Clemson.
My takeaway from the Wisky game, a game that was very close at the half and not decided until early in the fourth quarter, is that we have a lot of work to do. For a large swathe of the game, we didn't look much more athletic or better coached than a Wisconsin team that has almost nothing going for it right now. The final score was IMO very flattering to us, and if we want to live up to the preseason press clippings and seriously contend for a playoff slot and the title, we need to ramp our game up significantly.
In contrast, LSU was rampant against a Clemson team with significantly more talent than what we (ND) faced. They slashed and burned their way all over the field, dominating start to finish. I would favor LSU by two touchdowns over ND right now.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 06:41 PM |
|