So instead of the idea of the obvious football superconference discussion, let's turn this around and form a superconference based on (men's) basketball. Who would be included?
So I counted wins in the NCAA Men's Division Tournament since 2000. The top 16 teams would be...
Duke 64
Kansas 60
North Carolina 57
Michigan State 55
Connecticut 51
Kentucky 49
Florida 46
Gonzaga 45
Arizona 40
UCLA 37
Wisconsin 36
Villanova 34
Syracuse 32
Michigan 32
Purdue 31
Louisville 29
IMO the most surprising team on the list is Wisconsin. Gonzaga has the most wins of any team that has not won a national championship. UCLA hasn't won a national championship since 1995. Since 2000 UConn has won the most championships (five) but ranks fifth while Michigan State only won in 2000 and has more wins.
If we decide to have a "football" superconference and a "basketball" superconference, I would assume any school that qualifies for both would choose football over basketball since media companies would pay more for football than basketball. So I would guess Florida and Michigan would have a good chance of being chosen for a football superconference (I posted a thread about win % and both are in the upper tier).
The next teams on the list are...
Illinois 27
Tennessee 27 (also football conference candidate)
Texas 26 (also football conference candidate)
Maryland 25
If we put Florida and Michigan in the football superconference and make the basketball superconference all the teams with 25 or more wins without the "football" teams, the biggest omission likely is Indiana. Interestingly Indiana is pretty far down the list with just 15 wins since 2000. Obviously their 1987 national championship doesn't count but their 2002 runner up would count but they really don't have much behind that (2002 is the only year IU made it as far as the Sweet 16!) The two teams that won a national championship since 2000 that have won fewer than 25 wins since 2000 are Baylor who won 21 and Virginia who won 15. The only other team that has won a national championship since 1985 that won fewer than 25 wins since 2000 is Arkansas who also won just 15. I certainly can add all these schools.
Using a football superconference/basketball superconference format and 20 teams in each conference.
Football:
Ohio State, Alabama, Michigan, Notre Dame, Oklahoma, Texas, USC, Penn State, Nebraska, Tennessee, Georgia, Florida State, LSU, Miami, Clemson, Florida, Auburn, Arizona State, Texas A&M, Washington
The top 20 are the highest historical win % according to this chart:
https://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/schools/
The biggest surprise to me is ASU. Their win % is .609! (611-389-18). Washington (#20) is .601. Just missing the cut is Utah at .598 so .600 is the cutoff.
Basketball:
Duke, Kansas, North Carolina, Michigan State, Connecticut, Kentucky, Gonzaga, Arizona, UCLA, Wisconsin, Villanova, Syracuse, Purdue, Louisville, Illinois, Maryland, Baylor, Indiana, Virginia, Arkansas
Big 10:
Football: Ohio State, Michigan, USC, Penn State, Nebraska, Washington
Basketball: Michigan State, UCLA, Wisconsin, Purdue, Illinois, Maryland, Indiana
SEC:
Football: Alabama, Oklahoma, Texas, Tennessee, Georgia, LSU, Florida, Auburn, Texas A&M
Basketball: Kentucky, Arkansas
The SEC obviously laps the Big Ten in teams in the football superconference but the Big Ten more than makes up for it in the basketball superconference.
Missed the cut:
Big Ten: Oregon, Iowa, Minnesota, Rutgers, Northwestern
SEC: South Carolina, Vanderbilt, Mississippi, Mississippi State, Missouri
Oregon finished with 24 wins since 2000, just missing the 25 team cutoff for basketball!
Non P2's making superconferences:
ACC:
Football: (Notre Dame), Florida State, Miami, Clemson
Basketball: Duke, North Carolina, Syracuse, Louisville
Big 12:
Football: No Current Members
Basketball: Kansas, Arizona, Baylor
Big East:
Football: Not Applicable
Basketball: Connecticut, Villanova
WCC/Pac 12:
Football: No Current Members
Basketball: Gonzaga
With a 20 team basketball conference, you can have a 20 game conference schedule with every team playing 1 teams twice. Some of the permanent teams that would play twice annually would be obvious, Duke/North Carolina, Kentucky/Louisville, and Indiana/Purdue.
We then have three remaining former Big East schools (UConn, Villanova, Syracuse). Each can only play one twice annually. They will likely alternate. We also have three non Indiana Big Ten schools (Michigan State, Wisconsin, Illinois). Kansas and Baylor are the only Big 12 schools. UCLA and Arizona are the only former Pac 12 schools but you also have Gonzaga all by themselves and they would most want to play UCLA or Arizona twice and Kansas and Arizona are currently Big 12 rivals and might want to play twice so those games certainly can be rotated. Maryland and Virginia might be a permanent annual rivalry with the two of them bordering and no other schools likely wanting to play them twice often.