Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
Author Message
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #1
Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
Clifton Ave’s suggestion of an early Big 10 including Case Institute or Western Reserve got me thinking: did the Big 10’s membership decision in the early days of the league make the rise of Michigan and Ohio State inevitable?

Think about it—Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Indiana weren’t exactly huge states. Indiana and Purdue had to compete with each other for instate talent; Iowa had to contend with Iowa State. Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio by comparison are, and if we go back 110-120 years ago before air conditioning allowed the populations of California, Texas, and Florida to boom, were 3 of the 5 largest states, Pennsylvania and New York being the others.

Recruiting back then was much more local so your recruiting pool was a lot more limited. Illinois, while being big, had 3 Big 10 teams fighting for recruits. Michigan and Ohio State had their massive states all to themselves.

It’s no wonder that Michigan became one of the first dynasties outside of the Ivy League. The state was so big in fact, that Michigan State, without the benefit of being in a prestigious league, was able to rise as an independent in the shadow of big brother Wolverine.

Then there’s Ohio State. There time in the Ohio Conference was nothing remarkable. They were usually coming in 2nd or 3rd despite playing a home heavy schedule. Once invited to the Big 10, the Buckeyes started to separate themselves from the likes of Oberlin, Case, Western Reserve, Ohio, Miami, Ohio Wesleyan, Denison, and Kenyon. The affiliation gives them an edge. They stop losing to instate teams and become a conference and eventually a national power house. It also helped, that with so many other programs instate, no one could emerge as a clear #2.

It’s no wonder, with their demographic advantages that these two rose to the top of the league. It also begs the question if Michigan State and another Ohio school been admitted to the Big 10 in the early days, that it might have curtailed the success of the “Big 2”.


Thoughts?
06-11-2026 04:54 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #2
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
Minnesota claims 6 national championships from 1934-1960. Then the Vikings and the NFL arrived.
06-11-2026 05:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Bronco'14 Offline
WMU
*

Posts: 13,865
Joined: Aug 2012
Reputation: 265
I Root For: WMU Broncos
Location: Grand Rapids, MI
Post: #3
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
Interesting! Thank you for sharing!

We're familiar w/ Ohio St blocking the rest of the state, but I hadn't thought about the states' population affecting the teams.
06-11-2026 07:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Love and Honor Offline
Skipper
*

Posts: 7,465
Joined: Nov 2012
Reputation: 301
I Root For: Miami, MACtion
Location: Chicagoland
Post: #4
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
Ohio State’s dominance over Ohio was basically enshrined in law at the start of the 20th century when the legislature only permitted them to offer graduate programs among public universities. By the time it was repealed around WWII they were the top dog, and had the political influence to keep any other Ohio schools out of the question.
06-11-2026 07:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


Bill Marsh Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,634
Joined: Apr 2010
Reputation: 125
I Root For: UConn & Providence
Location: Connecticut
Post: #5
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
(06-11-2026 04:54 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Clifton Ave’s suggestion of an early Big 10 including Case Institute or Western Reserve got me thinking: did the Big 10’s membership decision in the early days of the league make the rise of Michigan and Ohio State inevitable?

Think about it—Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Indiana weren’t exactly huge states. Indiana and Purdue had to compete with each other for instate talent; Iowa had to contend with Iowa State. Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio by comparison are, and if we go back 110-120 years ago before air conditioning allowed the populations of California, Texas, and Florida to boom, were 3 of the 5 largest states, Pennsylvania and New York being the others.

Recruiting back then was much more local so your recruiting pool was a lot more limited. Illinois, while being big, had 3 Big 10 teams fighting for recruits. Michigan and Ohio State had their massive states all to themselves.

It’s no wonder that Michigan became one of the first dynasties outside of the Ivy League. The state was so big in fact, that Michigan State, without the benefit of being in a prestigious league, was able to rise as an independent in the shadow of big brother Wolverine.

Then there’s Ohio State. There time in the Ohio Conference was nothing remarkable. They were usually coming in 2nd or 3rd despite playing a home heavy schedule. Once invited to the Big 10, the Buckeyes started to separate themselves from the likes of Oberlin, Case, Western Reserve, Ohio, Miami, Ohio Wesleyan, Denison, and Kenyon. The affiliation gives them an edge. They stop losing to instate teams and become a conference and eventually a national power house. It also helped, that with so many other programs instate, no one could emerge as a clear #2.

It’s no wonder, with their demographic advantages that these two rose to the top of the league. It also begs the question if Michigan State and another Ohio school been admitted to the Big 10 in the early days, that it might have curtailed the success of the “Big 2”.


Thoughts?

National ranking of the above mentioned states in 1910 census:

1. New York
2. Pennsylvania
3. Illinois
4. Ohio
5. Texas
8. Michigan
9. Indiana
12. Wisconsin
14. Iowa
18. Minnesota
21. California
37. Florida
06-11-2026 09:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
IWokeUpLikeThis Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,110
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
Post: #6
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
(06-11-2026 09:00 PM)Bill Marsh Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 04:54 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Clifton Ave’s suggestion of an early Big 10 including Case Institute or Western Reserve got me thinking: did the Big 10’s membership decision in the early days of the league make the rise of Michigan and Ohio State inevitable?

Think about it—Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Indiana weren’t exactly huge states. Indiana and Purdue had to compete with each other for instate talent; Iowa had to contend with Iowa State. Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio by comparison are, and if we go back 110-120 years ago before air conditioning allowed the populations of California, Texas, and Florida to boom, were 3 of the 5 largest states, Pennsylvania and New York being the others.

Recruiting back then was much more local so your recruiting pool was a lot more limited. Illinois, while being big, had 3 Big 10 teams fighting for recruits. Michigan and Ohio State had their massive states all to themselves.

It’s no wonder that Michigan became one of the first dynasties outside of the Ivy League. The state was so big in fact, that Michigan State, without the benefit of being in a prestigious league, was able to rise as an independent in the shadow of big brother Wolverine.

Then there’s Ohio State. There time in the Ohio Conference was nothing remarkable. They were usually coming in 2nd or 3rd despite playing a home heavy schedule. Once invited to the Big 10, the Buckeyes started to separate themselves from the likes of Oberlin, Case, Western Reserve, Ohio, Miami, Ohio Wesleyan, Denison, and Kenyon. The affiliation gives them an edge. They stop losing to instate teams and become a conference and eventually a national power house. It also helped, that with so many other programs instate, no one could emerge as a clear #2.

It’s no wonder, with their demographic advantages that these two rose to the top of the league. It also begs the question if Michigan State and another Ohio school been admitted to the Big 10 in the early days, that it might have curtailed the success of the “Big 2”.


Thoughts?

National ranking of the above mentioned states in 1910 census:

1. New York
2. Pennsylvania
3. Illinois
4. Ohio
5. Texas
8. Michigan
9. Indiana
12. Wisconsin
14. Iowa
18. Minnesota
21. California
37. Florida

I would not have guessed Iowa was #14.
06-11-2026 09:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Mav Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,502
Joined: Jul 2016
Reputation: 180
I Root For: Omaha
Location:
Post: #7
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
(06-11-2026 07:33 PM)Love and Honor Wrote:  Ohio State’s dominance over Ohio was basically enshrined in law at the start of the 20th century when the legislature only permitted them to offer graduate programs among public universities. By the time it was repealed around WWII they were the top dog, and had the political influence to keep any other Ohio schools out of the question.
Wasn't that something Rutherford Hayes pushed for as governor? It's crazy to think that their dominance over the state has roots that deep.
06-11-2026 10:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


BruceMcF Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,765
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
Post: #8
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
(06-11-2026 07:33 PM)Love and Honor Wrote:  Ohio State’s dominance over Ohio was basically enshrined in law at the start of the 20th century when the legislature only permitted them to offer graduate programs among public universities. By the time it was repealed around WWII they were the top dog, and had the political influence to keep any other Ohio schools out of the question.

Yes, AFAIU, having those graduate programs meant that in the postwar boom, OSU were able to enroll and then deploy heaps of Graduate TA's to teach big lecture halls full of intro students, which was what allowed its growth to so much larger than the others during the decades when it was the open-access University and the other main four year Universities were "Board of Regents" selective admissions Universities.

Then in the 80's and going ahead, those big grad departments were leveraged for the shift to being a selective admission state flagship university.

The jokes from that school up North like "what do you get for driving too slowly through Downtown Columbus? An OSU degree" were from the open-access period of the 60s and 70s.
06-13-2026 01:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TerryD Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 16,979
Joined: Feb 2006
Reputation: 1269
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location: Grayson Highlands
Post: #9
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
(06-11-2026 04:54 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Clifton Ave’s suggestion of an early Big 10 including Case Institute or Western Reserve got me thinking: did the Big 10’s membership decision in the early days of the league make the rise of Michigan and Ohio State inevitable?

Think about it—Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Indiana weren’t exactly huge states. Indiana and Purdue had to compete with each other for instate talent; Iowa had to contend with Iowa State. Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio by comparison are, and if we go back 110-120 years ago before air conditioning allowed the populations of California, Texas, and Florida to boom, were 3 of the 5 largest states, Pennsylvania and New York being the others.

Recruiting back then was much more local so your recruiting pool was a lot more limited. Illinois, while being big, had 3 Big 10 teams fighting for recruits. Michigan and Ohio State had their massive states all to themselves.

It’s no wonder that Michigan became one of the first dynasties outside of the Ivy League. The state was so big in fact, that Michigan State, without the benefit of being in a prestigious league, was able to rise as an independent in the shadow of big brother Wolverine.

Then there’s Ohio State. There time in the Ohio Conference was nothing remarkable. They were usually coming in 2nd or 3rd despite playing a home heavy schedule. Once invited to the Big 10, the Buckeyes started to separate themselves from the likes of Oberlin, Case, Western Reserve, Ohio, Miami, Ohio Wesleyan, Denison, and Kenyon. The affiliation gives them an edge. They stop losing to instate teams and become a conference and eventually a national power house. It also helped, that with so many other programs instate, no one could emerge as a clear #2.

It’s no wonder, with their demographic advantages that these two rose to the top of the league. It also begs the question if Michigan State and another Ohio school been admitted to the Big 10 in the early days, that it might have curtailed the success of the “Big 2”.


Thoughts?


Or a Notre Dame program if one of its four applications to the Big Ten was approved between 1908 and 1924, instead of what actually happened.

History would have looked a lot different. Try to imagine a world where ND is a one-hundred-year-plus Big Ten member. Lol. Can you?

Would ND have become "ND" if it hadn't been an independent and instead had been a Big Ten school?

After all, ND would still have had Knute Rockne. Rockne was Rockne, no matter ND's affiliation status. Frank Leahy as an ND Big Ten coach? Ara Parseghian?

Would ND as a Big Ten member have impacted the conference dominance of Michigan and Ohio State, at all?
(This post was last modified: 06-14-2026 09:43 AM by TerryD.)
06-14-2026 09:32 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #10
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
(06-11-2026 09:36 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 09:00 PM)Bill Marsh Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 04:54 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Clifton Ave’s suggestion of an early Big 10 including Case Institute or Western Reserve got me thinking: did the Big 10’s membership decision in the early days of the league make the rise of Michigan and Ohio State inevitable?

Think about it—Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Indiana weren’t exactly huge states. Indiana and Purdue had to compete with each other for instate talent; Iowa had to contend with Iowa State. Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio by comparison are, and if we go back 110-120 years ago before air conditioning allowed the populations of California, Texas, and Florida to boom, were 3 of the 5 largest states, Pennsylvania and New York being the others.

Recruiting back then was much more local so your recruiting pool was a lot more limited. Illinois, while being big, had 3 Big 10 teams fighting for recruits. Michigan and Ohio State had their massive states all to themselves.

It’s no wonder that Michigan became one of the first dynasties outside of the Ivy League. The state was so big in fact, that Michigan State, without the benefit of being in a prestigious league, was able to rise as an independent in the shadow of big brother Wolverine.

Then there’s Ohio State. There time in the Ohio Conference was nothing remarkable. They were usually coming in 2nd or 3rd despite playing a home heavy schedule. Once invited to the Big 10, the Buckeyes started to separate themselves from the likes of Oberlin, Case, Western Reserve, Ohio, Miami, Ohio Wesleyan, Denison, and Kenyon. The affiliation gives them an edge. They stop losing to instate teams and become a conference and eventually a national power house. It also helped, that with so many other programs instate, no one could emerge as a clear #2.

It’s no wonder, with their demographic advantages that these two rose to the top of the league. It also begs the question if Michigan State and another Ohio school been admitted to the Big 10 in the early days, that it might have curtailed the success of the “Big 2”.


Thoughts?

National ranking of the above mentioned states in 1910 census:

1. New York
2. Pennsylvania
3. Illinois
4. Ohio
5. Texas
8. Michigan
9. Indiana
12. Wisconsin
14. Iowa
18. Minnesota
21. California
37. Florida

I would not have guessed Iowa was #14.

In 1860, Kentucky was 9th which is why Lincoln was so concerned about keeping Kentucky in the Union. Iowa was still filling in. By 1880 Kentucky was 8th and Iowa was 10th. But both states relatively declined after that as people moved further west.
06-14-2026 10:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


Love and Honor Offline
Skipper
*

Posts: 7,465
Joined: Nov 2012
Reputation: 301
I Root For: Miami, MACtion
Location: Chicagoland
Post: #11
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
(06-11-2026 10:12 PM)Mav Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 07:33 PM)Love and Honor Wrote:  Ohio State’s dominance over Ohio was basically enshrined in law at the start of the 20th century when the legislature only permitted them to offer graduate programs among public universities. By the time it was repealed around WWII they were the top dog, and had the political influence to keep any other Ohio schools out of the question.

Wasn't that something Rutherford Hayes pushed for as governor? It's crazy to think that their dominance over the state has roots that deep.

Nah, that was decades earlier when they founded OSU in the first place as Ohio’s land grant institution. Miami and Ohio U were way older but they weren’t politically viable based on state regional conflicts. Funny enough, OSU’s president (a former Miami president) in the early 1900s was the one who pushed for pro-OSU legislation; originally the state proposed an act that’d basically turn Miami and OU into two-year teacher colleges but that was shot down.
06-14-2026 10:45 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #12
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
(06-14-2026 09:32 AM)TerryD Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 04:54 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Clifton Ave’s suggestion of an early Big 10 including Case Institute or Western Reserve got me thinking: did the Big 10’s membership decision in the early days of the league make the rise of Michigan and Ohio State inevitable?

Think about it—Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Indiana weren’t exactly huge states. Indiana and Purdue had to compete with each other for instate talent; Iowa had to contend with Iowa State. Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio by comparison are, and if we go back 110-120 years ago before air conditioning allowed the populations of California, Texas, and Florida to boom, were 3 of the 5 largest states, Pennsylvania and New York being the others.

Recruiting back then was much more local so your recruiting pool was a lot more limited. Illinois, while being big, had 3 Big 10 teams fighting for recruits. Michigan and Ohio State had their massive states all to themselves.

It’s no wonder that Michigan became one of the first dynasties outside of the Ivy League. The state was so big in fact, that Michigan State, without the benefit of being in a prestigious league, was able to rise as an independent in the shadow of big brother Wolverine.

Then there’s Ohio State. There time in the Ohio Conference was nothing remarkable. They were usually coming in 2nd or 3rd despite playing a home heavy schedule. Once invited to the Big 10, the Buckeyes started to separate themselves from the likes of Oberlin, Case, Western Reserve, Ohio, Miami, Ohio Wesleyan, Denison, and Kenyon. The affiliation gives them an edge. They stop losing to instate teams and become a conference and eventually a national power house. It also helped, that with so many other programs instate, no one could emerge as a clear #2.

It’s no wonder, with their demographic advantages that these two rose to the top of the league. It also begs the question if Michigan State and another Ohio school been admitted to the Big 10 in the early days, that it might have curtailed the success of the “Big 2”.


Thoughts?


Or a Notre Dame program if one of its four applications to the Big Ten was approved between 1908 and 1924, instead of what actually happened.

History would have looked a lot different. Try to imagine a world where ND is a one-hundred-year-plus Big Ten member. Lol. Can you?

Would ND have become "ND" if it hadn't been an independent and instead had been a Big Ten school?

After all, ND would still have had Knute Rockne. Rockne was Rockne, no matter ND's affiliation status. Frank Leahy as an ND Big Ten coach? Ara Parseghian?

Would ND as a Big Ten member have impacted the conference dominance of Michigan and Ohio State, at all?

I think it would have certainly deepened the competition for the title race. The ND probably looks a lot different though. Probably no USC rivalry. I’m not sure if they have the long standing series with Army or Navy either.
06-14-2026 01:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Captain Bearcat Offline
All-American in Everything
*

Posts: 10,227
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 913
I Root For: UC
Location: Midwest, USA
Post: #13
RE: Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
(06-11-2026 07:33 PM)Love and Honor Wrote:  Ohio State’s dominance over Ohio was basically enshrined in law at the start of the 20th century when the legislature only permitted them to offer graduate programs among public universities. By the time it was repealed around WWII they were the top dog, and had the political influence to keep any other Ohio schools out of the question.

That only applied to state institutions.

It did not apply to private institutions (like Case and Western Reserve) or Municipal universities (Cincinnati, Toledo, Akron). The municipal schools didn't begin joining the state system until the late 1960s (for Cincinnati it was 1977).

Cincinnati had plenty of graduate programs at the time, including a law school that produced multiple supreme court justices, a US Vice President, and a US President. Cincinnati's med school dates back to the founding of the university. The school also definitely produced plenty of PhD graduates throughout the 1920s and 1930s.
(This post was last modified: 06-15-2026 01:11 PM by Captain Bearcat.)
06-15-2026 01:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.