Opinion: Big 10 membership decisions 100+ yrs ago made the rise of OSU/Mich inevitabl
Clifton Ave’s suggestion of an early Big 10 including Case Institute or Western Reserve got me thinking: did the Big 10’s membership decision in the early days of the league make the rise of Michigan and Ohio State inevitable?
Think about it—Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Indiana weren’t exactly huge states. Indiana and Purdue had to compete with each other for instate talent; Iowa had to contend with Iowa State. Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio by comparison are, and if we go back 110-120 years ago before air conditioning allowed the populations of California, Texas, and Florida to boom, were 3 of the 5 largest states, Pennsylvania and New York being the others.
Recruiting back then was much more local so your recruiting pool was a lot more limited. Illinois, while being big, had 3 Big 10 teams fighting for recruits. Michigan and Ohio State had their massive states all to themselves.
It’s no wonder that Michigan became one of the first dynasties outside of the Ivy League. The state was so big in fact, that Michigan State, without the benefit of being in a prestigious league, was able to rise as an independent in the shadow of big brother Wolverine.
Then there’s Ohio State. There time in the Ohio Conference was nothing remarkable. They were usually coming in 2nd or 3rd despite playing a home heavy schedule. Once invited to the Big 10, the Buckeyes started to separate themselves from the likes of Oberlin, Case, Western Reserve, Ohio, Miami, Ohio Wesleyan, Denison, and Kenyon. The affiliation gives them an edge. They stop losing to instate teams and become a conference and eventually a national power house. It also helped, that with so many other programs instate, no one could emerge as a clear #2.
It’s no wonder, with their demographic advantages that these two rose to the top of the league. It also begs the question if Michigan State and another Ohio school been admitted to the Big 10 in the early days, that it might have curtailed the success of the “Big 2”.
Thoughts?
|