Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Hometown Judge Says Sorsby Can Play
Author Message
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #201
RE: Hometown Judge Says Sorsby Can Play
(06-12-2026 10:40 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-12-2026 10:24 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-12-2026 09:46 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-12-2026 09:21 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-12-2026 08:22 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I think the prospect of Sorsby playing and the lengths to which Texas Tech is willing to bunker down is ridiculous.

However, Sorsby definitely brought out the big guns with Kessler. He is arguably the single best antitrust attorney in the country and has multiple scalps from the NCAA (including winning the Alston case at the Supreme Court and leading the House settlement). As I have pointed out before, Kessler isn’t at some two-bit plaintiff’s attorney firm, but rather one of the chairs of white shoe Big Law standby Winston & Strawn.

This is important context that a lot of people need to understand: the legal challenges of the NCAA aren’t coming from the stereotypical image of Lionel Hutz filling frivolous lawsuits for a shakedown, but rather the biggest and wealthiest law firms in the country that in almost all other cases woild be *defending* Corporate America and the establishment. When these law firms are using their vast resources for the *plaintiffs*, they’re a powerful force.

Sorsby getting Kessler for this suit is significant. It points out how much trouble the NCAA and college sports are in. It isn't clear any rules can be enforced. I don't think a P2 breakaway solves any issues. Although Division II and III (and maybe a good chunk of Division I) should be thinking it might finally be a good idea to separate themselves from the Power conferences.

The vultures are circling.

The NCAA is in trouble. The P2 breakaway does solve some problems. They don't have to take Texas Tech. But seriously they can set their own rules up. As a business entity they have the right to set their own rules for conduct and moral standing on issues like gambling associations. As long as they follow the rulings on Alston and House, they may govern themselves with existing Contract and Business law and set salary caps with collective bargaining. None of this is new, none of it controversial, and it was the recommendation of Justice Cavanaugh.

I don't know why so many have such a difficult time grasping the reality of those rulings. They effectively ditched the NCAA by destroying their organizing principle of amateurism. The effectively declared college football a business and told it to operate like one. The said it was time for hundred million dollar a year businesses to pay their workers/players. Told them that collective bargaining would be their tool for controlling costs. As to contracts controlling the portal that was obvious. Here we are. And since the ruling applies to all of FBS and FCS football in particular, it was expected that competing organizations would emerge as what was not a business prior to the rulings is now considered to be a business and not all businesses which compete are constituted the same way. More will be expected of what we call the P conferences than will be of the G5 or the FCS, but all will be expected to comply.

That means some will be able to afford it and some not, and the ability to sustain your model will distinguish the different levels at which the businesses operate. Well, that and public demand for the product. Smart people would never have gone to Congress to create another Chimera which doesn't really represent the past model nor satisfy what is requested by the Courts of a new one. And anti-trust exemptions are not needed if associations of schools can start their own business model and have their own rules and organizing principle. There will be competition for the college sports market.

Congress can not solve this problem. It is a matter of business. Congress however can make this problem unsolvable. Smart people would know that. Greedy people were never smart, and neither are the Savants which only know about what they do and do it very well for the most part, and that would be your Academicians.

And as a business, you have to comply with laws like the ADA. Which means, that if he wins his suit, you can't ban compulsive gamblers.

No, it doesn't if gambling is prohibited by your organization's code of conduct, and if there are other organizations that do not have that as a social policy who could hire Sorsby. But I will agree with one thing the nation has gotten stupid enough to possibly consider gambling as a disability instead of an addiction/power trip/adrenalin rush. That said its known and public presence in figure participating in a competition upon which others are betting is even bad for the gambling industry. Nobody but Sorsby wins if he is successful. Not College football, not the schools whose alumni have an expectation of fairness, not the conference in which he plays, not the gambling industry which has to have the appearance of fairness to attract betters, and not sports in general, and certainly not if he goes to the NFL. This case is particularly pernicious. And while he has hired a prominent attorney, a victory for him in this case is destructive to way too many in industries that make massive sums of money. I wouldn't want to be Sorsby if he wins. He should rehabilitate, then seek his year of eligibility. If he doesn't regain the appearance of self-control and reliability his presence is going to piss off a lot of very powerful people.

What other college football association are you talking about that would hire him?

Saying a DWI is a public safety threat is another scale different than the threat gambling poses. Its a high hurdle to overcome laws like the ADA.

As for Sorsby, without this case, I don't think he had any chance of getting re-instated. Can any of you come up with a case of someone betting on his team?

In fairness, some of those Iowa athletes (who did not bet on their own teams) thought they might still have a chance:

https://www.espn.com/college-sports/stor...estigation

"...Brock and Lee were cleared of criminal charges, but their playing careers are over. Lee is now an assistant defensive line coach for Idaho State. Brock began working as a marketing administrator. He said he felt both relieved and hollow when his case was dismissed.

"We definitely got our punishment, just because of how it played out with the NCAA," Brock said. "So if we're getting punished for doing something illegal, [DCI] should as well, because I think what they did was a lot more illegal than what we did."

In early September, Dekkers pleaded guilty to underage gambling, admitting that he placed all bets linked to his mother's account, including the one on ISU football. He appealed his permanent loss of eligibility but was told by an attorney his chances were slim because of that bet.

He lost the appeal.

While Dekkers acknowledged his mistake, he questioned whether he received too heavy a punishment. "For me to think that one singular bet would take away three full years of eligibility is super hard," he said.

He still hopes to play pro ball, and enrolled at Iowa Western Community College, which has won the past two junior college national championships. He will report with his new team later this month.


Like Dekkers, Bruce ended his criminal case by pleading to underage gambling. He figures he needs at least one more year of film to get noticed by NFL teams. He tried to get on with the Canadian Football League and an NAIA school in Kansas, but both turned him down. Now he's trying for a spot on a UFL team.

He said he understands the need to address illegal gambling, but that doesn't justify targeting athletes through invasive means.

"What I did was wrong, yes. But what they did was also wrong," he said. "It caught up to me. Same with DCI. So I'm sure that we both learned some valuable lessons from this.""
06-12-2026 12:07 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
OhioBoilermaker Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,172
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 130
I Root For: Purdue, NMSU
Location:
Post: #202
RE: Hometown Judge Says Sorsby Can Play
(06-12-2026 08:11 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-12-2026 01:21 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 12:49 PM)Hokie Mark Wrote:  
(06-08-2026 10:07 AM)mlb Wrote:  Does the NCAA appeal here? College sports has become total crap, I'm getting close to the point of not caring any more.

I certainly hope they do, but there are 2 huge obstacles:

1. The NCAA has filed an accelerated appeal to the Seventh Court of Appeals in Amarillo, where all four presiding justices are graduates of the Texas Tech School of Law. 03-banghead

2. The judge who granted the injunction set the court date for February 2027 - AFTER the season is over. Normally, you can't appeal a case that hasn't been heard yet, so I guess all they can really appeal is the injunction itself?
Probably.

So far the NCAA has filed a notice that they are going to appeal, and that gets sent to the lawyers and the district court, and then the appeals court reminds the NCAA attorneys that they have to provide the rule that justifies an accelerated appeal, then the court is directed to send the case records (from Lubbock to Amarillo). In this case, the appellate justices might recuse themselves based on a standard of giving an appearance of prejudice (it does not matter if there is an actual conflict or not). Three have clear ties to Lubbock. It would not surprise if some had season tickets to Red Raider football. They surely must know Dustin Burrow who is the Texas lawyer for Sorsby. I'm pretty sure the case could be transferred to another Court of Appeals (sometimes bulk transfers of dozens of cases are done for case load balancing - which also indicate the normal time frame for appeals that much of case backload can build up).

I know a lot of people make a big deal about where judges attended college or law school, but I don’t know of many (or any) cases of judges recusing themselves simply based on their alma mater appearing before the court.

This is pretty much what ACB did in Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board. Of course, there, a Notre Dame clinic was appearing as counsel, not a party.
06-13-2026 05:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #203
RE: Hometown Judge Says Sorsby Can Play
(06-12-2026 08:11 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-12-2026 01:21 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 12:49 PM)Hokie Mark Wrote:  
(06-08-2026 10:07 AM)mlb Wrote:  Does the NCAA appeal here? College sports has become total crap, I'm getting close to the point of not caring any more.

I certainly hope they do, but there are 2 huge obstacles:

1. The NCAA has filed an accelerated appeal to the Seventh Court of Appeals in Amarillo, where all four presiding justices are graduates of the Texas Tech School of Law. 03-banghead

2. The judge who granted the injunction set the court date for February 2027 - AFTER the season is over. Normally, you can't appeal a case that hasn't been heard yet, so I guess all they can really appeal is the injunction itself?
Probably.

So far the NCAA has filed a notice that they are going to appeal, and that gets sent to the lawyers and the district court, and then the appeals court reminds the NCAA attorneys that they have to provide the rule that justifies an accelerated appeal, then the court is directed to send the case records (from Lubbock to Amarillo). In this case, the appellate justices might recuse themselves based on a standard of giving an appearance of prejudice (it does not matter if there is an actual conflict or not). Three have clear ties to Lubbock. It would not surprise if some had season tickets to Red Raider football. They surely must know Dustin Burrow who is the Texas lawyer for Sorsby. I'm pretty sure the case could be transferred to another Court of Appeals (sometimes bulk transfers of dozens of cases are done for case load balancing - which also indicate the normal time frame for appeals that much of case backload can build up).

I know a lot of people make a big deal about where judges attended college or law school, but I don’t know of many (or any) cases of judges recusing themselves simply based on their alma mater appearing before the court. Particularly with state and local courts, you’re going to get a lot of judges that went to a specific set of schools. No judge wants to create a reputation or precedent that they have a conflict of interest simply because of alumni or fan status. Now, a Board of Trustee position or major donor status or another position of authority with a school is a true conflict of interest and there should be a recusal there. However, anyone thinking that judges that attended Texas Tech will recuse themselves solely based on that connection is fooling themselves.
The district judge did recuse himself. There are six district courts in Lubbock County, with three concentrating on civil matters. I don't know why they did not assign the case to one of the other two courts. Perhaps there was an issue of case loads, In any case, the administrative judge for the region assigned it to an outsider.

Experiences in Chicago may not translate to Lubbock. Lubbock is about as far from Fort Worth, as Des Moines is from Chicago. And Lubbock does not have other nearby cities that Des Moines has such as Minneapolis, Omaha, and Kansas City. There is going to be a stronger identification between Texas Tech and Lubbock, the South Plains, and West Texas than there is between Northwestern and Evanston, Chicagoland, and Illinois.

The 7th Court of Appeals judges grew up in Abilene, Brownwood, Littlefield, and Longview. They lived Friday Night Lights. Though the 7th Court of Appeals formally meet in Amarillo, three live in Lubbock. On those weeks when they hear cases in Amarillo, they may stay at a hotel, but it is not an impossible commute from Lubbock.

There are four 7th Court of Appeals justices. Cases are heard by 3-judge panels which rotate. It would not take one or two justices to recuse, to prevent a panel being formed.

The attorney of record for Sorsby is Dustin Burrows, House Speaker, who is from Lubbock, and a Texas Tech law school graduate. It would be weird if the justices did not know him. Judges in Texas are elected in partisan elections. Often, they are first appointed by the governor, so that they can then run as incumbents.

It is not a big deal if the case gets transferred to another appeals court. It may delay for a couple of days. No appeals court is going to try a case. They will at most either affirm, dissolve, or modify the injunction. They will have the same information that the district court had.
06-14-2026 06:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.