Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
Author Message
ken d Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,304
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #21
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-12-2026 07:23 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 07:15 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 05:47 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 05:21 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Its not that surprising, really. The whole country cares about the Super Bowl but attendance is limited in size to that of the stadium.

For reference:

~25,000 people run the Boston marathon each year (that's the cap)
~500,000 watch it in person
~1.5 million watch it on TV (most of that is in MA)

1/4 of the audience watches it in person, and that's why it's a huge economic boom. Unlike other marathons, it's not a loop. That's why it's an economic boom for multiple towns and cities.

How many watch the Super Bowl?

It seems you've missed the entire point of my post. This thread is about trying to replicate what marathons do in terms of impacts on local economies and comparing it to the super bowl. My post is showing that a substantial number of people who watch marathons do so in person as opposed to on TV, and that's why they generate more for local economies than the super bowl does, which has an almost negligible amount of people in person compared to the number that watches on TV.

I didn't miss the point of your post. I just made an observation about part of it. And if you read the OP, it doesn't say "impacts on local economies". It just says "more of an economic impact". The global economic impact of the Super Bowl dwarfs that of even the biggest marathon.

My observation in general is that numbers claimed by local Chambers of Commerce, like numbers generated by consultants hired to justify support for things like stadium building, are usually wildly optimistic and self-serving. In my experience in analyzing this sort of thing for decades is that if you cut these estimates in half you will be closer to the reality.

Using the data you have presented about specific aspects of the economic impact for the Boston Marathon, I calculated the local economic benefits to be closer to $200 million rather than $500 million, and the incremental labor income to be less than $100 million, not the $206 million claimed. Even if I underestimated some of these benefits and costs, the difference in the result would still not be enough to come close to the BAA numbers.

Most of the projected labor income comes from the cost of repaving the same 30 miles of the race route every year, which is not so much an economic benefit as it is a burden to the taxpayers of Boston and surrounding towns. I didn't try to estimate the economic cost of the months long annual disruption those paving projects would cause to businesses along the race route.

None of this suggests that the Boston Marathon, and marathons in other major world cities, aren't important events for those cities. I'm just saying they are great even without the hyperbole that accompanies them.
02-15-2026 03:30 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #22
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-15-2026 03:30 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 07:23 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 07:15 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 05:47 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 05:21 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Its not that surprising, really. The whole country cares about the Super Bowl but attendance is limited in size to that of the stadium.

For reference:

~25,000 people run the Boston marathon each year (that's the cap)
~500,000 watch it in person
~1.5 million watch it on TV (most of that is in MA)

1/4 of the audience watches it in person, and that's why it's a huge economic boom. Unlike other marathons, it's not a loop. That's why it's an economic boom for multiple towns and cities.

How many watch the Super Bowl?

It seems you've missed the entire point of my post. This thread is about trying to replicate what marathons do in terms of impacts on local economies and comparing it to the super bowl. My post is showing that a substantial number of people who watch marathons do so in person as opposed to on TV, and that's why they generate more for local economies than the super bowl does, which has an almost negligible amount of people in person compared to the number that watches on TV.

I didn't miss the point of your post. I just made an observation about part of it. And if you read the OP, it doesn't say "impacts on local economies". It just says "more of an economic impact". The global economic impact of the Super Bowl dwarfs that of even the biggest marathon.

My observation in general is that numbers claimed by local Chambers of Commerce, like numbers generated by consultants hired to justify support for things like stadium building, are usually wildly optimistic and self-serving. In my experience in analyzing this sort of thing for decades is that if you cut these estimates in half you will be closer to the reality.

Using the data you have presented about specific aspects of the economic impact for the Boston Marathon, I calculated the local economic benefits to be closer to $200 million rather than $500 million, and the incremental labor income to be less than $100 million, not the $206 million claimed. Even if I underestimated some of these benefits and costs, the difference in the result would still not be enough to come close to the BAA numbers.

Most of the projected labor income comes from the cost of repaving the same 30 miles of the race route every year, which is not so much an economic benefit as it is a burden to the taxpayers of Boston and surrounding towns. I didn't try to estimate the economic cost of the months long annual disruption those paving projects would cause to businesses along the race route.

None of this suggests that the Boston Marathon, and marathons in other major world cities, aren't important events for those cities. I'm just saying they are great even without the hyperbole that accompanies them.

You're once again changing the subject of the original post, which is about the data presented by the article linked in it, which is 100% about local economic impact. Just because the person who posted this thread described the data in the wrong way (by not including the word "local") doesn't mean the data is incorrect or that in now references a global impact.


To prove that you are barely reading the data presented, here's the intro to the article:

Quote:For decades, the Super Bowl has been the gold standard for sports-driven economic impact. One game, one weekend, hundreds of millions of dollars flowing into a host city.

But a deep dive into the data shows that major city marathons are no longer trailing behind. In cities like New York, Boston, and London, marathon weekend now delivers economic returns on par with, and in some cases greater than, the biggest game in American sports.


Now, please kindly explain why they would include the phrase I've underlined, "flowing into a host city," as part of the intro to the article if they're talking about a global impact? Why is all the data they're considering only pointed at the host cities?

Quote:This year’s Super Bowl, played at Levi’s Stadium in Santa Clara, California, is expected to generate between $370 million and $630 million in economic output for the Bay Area, according to a report commissioned by the Bay Area Host Committee.

Last year’s game in New Orleans drew about 115,000 visitors and produced $658 million in local spending. State officials reported more than $80 million in tax revenue tied to the event.

Spending spikes sharply around the stadium. Bank of America estimates a 77 percent jump in consumer spending in nearby areas on game day, driven largely by food, drinks, and parking.

Does any of that bother to check in with global impact of the super bowl? Or is it just about the impact to the local economy?


You also are just claiming the data to be incorrect without showing your work why, just that you did work (which so far has been incorrect, by assuming all 2700 jobs referenced were direct employees of the BAA, rather than what the data actually says, which is about all jobs created due to the marathon rather than just ones hired by the BAA).

You're also failing to state why you believe the local economic impact data for the super bowl while not believing it for the marathons. More people come in from out of town and stay for multiple days at the marathons than do people for the super bowl each year. These are surveys of the attendees that they're working from, not local chambers of commerce making estimates. It's the same way they estimate the impact of super bowls on host cities. Underlined above the data for the Super Bowl local impacts comes from Host Committees for the Super Bowl and State Officials. Those host cities also refer to jobs created (yes, even the temporary ones) when talking about the economic impact of super bowls. Hell, they even talk about increased tax revenues! If you're going to cut the numbers in half for these marathons for the reasons you've stated, you need to for the Super Bowls as well, because it's all collected the same way and by people in similar positions.


Again, working from the data in the article itself: 115,000 people visited New Orleans for the Super Bowl. That's less than HALF the number of people who stay multiple nights for the Boston Marathon each year. It less than a QUARTER the number of people who go to Boston in general.



As for paving the roads: we're happier for our tax dollars to fix those ****** roads every year. But it doesn't matter. The money referenced is money that goes into labor that then can be fed back into the economy. Road crews and police get paid money, they in turn spend money, economy goes up. Also roads are paved all over the state quite literally every time of the year where it's not snowing. Anyone who lives anywhere with yearly frequent snow can tell you that. It's not a disruption to the businesses because it's done so in a way that doesn't result in entire streets closing.

Also, that's not "most of the labor income" as you've stated in your post. It's part of the labor income. I just used it as an example of labor and jobs that are not directly managed or paid by the BAA.



If your argument is that the Marathons don't have the global impact of the Super Bowl: congrats on making a point no one cared about in this thread. It's accurate, but completely irrelevant to the topic at hand.
02-15-2026 04:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #23
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-15-2026 12:44 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(02-15-2026 12:29 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-14-2026 10:12 PM)rtist Wrote:  At the risk of going slightly off-topic, but remaining in the same general subject idea, I wonder if IRONMAN races (or IRONMAN 70.3 races) might draw in the same kind of revenues that Marathon races do. Or maybe more?

I would doubt it, at least not the big three in the US (and the majors outside the US).

It won't be easy to replicate what these marathons do. People need to remember that Boston is often called "The Mecca of Marathons" - it's the longest continually run marathon out there, going every year since 1897. NYC and Chicago were able to replicate the success, but not many others have. The big thing is the amount of people you get to come in, and not just runners, for a few days. There's just not that kind of audience in person for Ironman races.

It's like the conversations that have come up here before about how important the Parade of Roses is for the city of Pasadena. There are other parades out there, but most simply just pale in comparison to in terms of the impact they bring.

Your data is compelling, as a local economic impact. However, I would say that it should be "NYC, Boston and Chicago Marathons" instead of just "Marathons". As it is, you're talking about the Dodgers and implying that the Round Rock Express are also an equivalent "pro baseball team".

Perhaps you could call the Boston the Super Bowl of Marathons?

Not sure why everyone is calling it "my data" and such. This was all collected by an article linked in the first post that I had nothing to do with.

But yes, it really only refers to a specific few global marathons (3 in the US, and 3, maybe 4 outside of it) that can have this kind of impact. I never implied otherwise (in fact, in my first post in this thread I said "not sure how easy it would be to replicate" when referring to the success these specific marathons have), only the OP of the thread did by asking if it could be replicated for college championships.
02-15-2026 04:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #24
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-15-2026 03:30 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 07:23 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 07:15 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 05:47 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 05:21 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Its not that surprising, really. The whole country cares about the Super Bowl but attendance is limited in size to that of the stadium.

For reference:

~25,000 people run the Boston marathon each year (that's the cap)
~500,000 watch it in person
~1.5 million watch it on TV (most of that is in MA)

1/4 of the audience watches it in person, and that's why it's a huge economic boom. Unlike other marathons, it's not a loop. That's why it's an economic boom for multiple towns and cities.

How many watch the Super Bowl?

It seems you've missed the entire point of my post. This thread is about trying to replicate what marathons do in terms of impacts on local economies and comparing it to the super bowl. My post is showing that a substantial number of people who watch marathons do so in person as opposed to on TV, and that's why they generate more for local economies than the super bowl does, which has an almost negligible amount of people in person compared to the number that watches on TV.

I didn't miss the point of your post. I just made an observation about part of it. And if you read the OP, it doesn't say "impacts on local economies". It just says "more of an economic impact". The global economic impact of the Super Bowl dwarfs that of even the biggest marathon.

My observation in general is that numbers claimed by local Chambers of Commerce, like numbers generated by consultants hired to justify support for things like stadium building, are usually wildly optimistic and self-serving. In my experience in analyzing this sort of thing for decades is that if you cut these estimates in half you will be closer to the reality.

Using the data you have presented about specific aspects of the economic impact for the Boston Marathon, I calculated the local economic benefits to be closer to $200 million rather than $500 million, and the incremental labor income to be less than $100 million, not the $206 million claimed. Even if I underestimated some of these benefits and costs, the difference in the result would still not be enough to come close to the BAA numbers.

Most of the projected labor income comes from the cost of repaving the same 30 miles of the race route every year, which is not so much an economic benefit as it is a burden to the taxpayers of Boston and surrounding towns. I didn't try to estimate the economic cost of the months long annual disruption those paving projects would cause to businesses along the race route.

None of this suggests that the Boston Marathon, and marathons in other major world cities, aren't important events for those cities. I'm just saying they are great even without the hyperbole that accompanies them.

They've been running the marathon for a very long time, do they actually repave that same stretch of road every single year just b/c some people go running on it? Seems like an enormous waste of resources if so.

edit: ok so here's what my handy ai assistant spit out:

No, Boston does not repave the
entire 26.2-mile marathon route every single year.
However, crews from the eight cities and towns along the route do conduct extensive, targeted resurfacing and pothole repairs to ensure the road is safe for runners, particularly after harsh New England winters.
Here are the key details regarding the maintenance of the Boston Marathon route:

Targeted Repairs: Instead of a full, top-to-bottom repaving, road crews focus on "cosmetic surgery" to make the road smooth and safe, aiming to fix potholes and hazardous cracks.
Safety Focus: Town maintenance crews (such as in Wellesley or Framingham) actively fill potholes, as dangerous spots can cause runners to twist ankles.
Constant Maintenance: Because the race occurs in April, the roads often suffer from the effects of salt, freezing, and plows, leading to a "never-ending cycle" of repairs in the weeks leading up to the race.
City of Boston Resurfacing: The City of Boston does perform significant, year-round road improvements, often resurfacing more than 30 miles of roadway across the city annually, which may include parts of the final stretch of the course.
Painting/Markings: Ahead of the race, crews install the start line in Hopkinton and the finish line in Boston, and sometimes paint lines along the route to guide runners.

In summary, the route is not entirely repaved annually, but it is heavily patched and repaired to be in prime condition for Patriots' Day


I'd want to see some exact costs incurred by all cities on the route over a 5-10 year period before even allowing as much as half of his estimate.
(This post was last modified: 02-15-2026 05:51 PM by bryanw1995.)
02-15-2026 05:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,890
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #25
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-15-2026 04:51 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-15-2026 12:44 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(02-15-2026 12:29 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-14-2026 10:12 PM)rtist Wrote:  At the risk of going slightly off-topic, but remaining in the same general subject idea, I wonder if IRONMAN races (or IRONMAN 70.3 races) might draw in the same kind of revenues that Marathon races do. Or maybe more?

I would doubt it, at least not the big three in the US (and the majors outside the US).

It won't be easy to replicate what these marathons do. People need to remember that Boston is often called "The Mecca of Marathons" - it's the longest continually run marathon out there, going every year since 1897. NYC and Chicago were able to replicate the success, but not many others have. The big thing is the amount of people you get to come in, and not just runners, for a few days. There's just not that kind of audience in person for Ironman races.

It's like the conversations that have come up here before about how important the Parade of Roses is for the city of Pasadena. There are other parades out there, but most simply just pale in comparison to in terms of the impact they bring.

Your data is compelling, as a local economic impact. However, I would say that it should be "NYC, Boston and Chicago Marathons" instead of just "Marathons". As it is, you're talking about the Dodgers and implying that the Round Rock Express are also an equivalent "pro baseball team".

Perhaps you could call the Boston the Super Bowl of Marathons?

Not sure why everyone is calling it "my data" and such. This was all collected by an article linked in the first post that I had nothing to do with.

But yes, it really only refers to a specific few global marathons (3 in the US, and 3, maybe 4 outside of it) that can have this kind of impact. I never implied otherwise (in fact, in my first post in this thread I said "not sure how easy it would be to replicate" when referring to the success these specific marathons have), only the OP of the thread did by asking if it could be replicated for college championships.

I know they had a 5k associated with the championship game in LA a few years back. They might have something like that associated with the NCAA track and field championships. There could be other types of events beyond the simple fan zones that are pretty repititive if you've ever been to one.
02-15-2026 05:49 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #26
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-13-2026 10:13 AM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-13-2026 02:44 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 07:23 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 07:15 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 05:47 PM)e-parade Wrote:  For reference:

~25,000 people run the Boston marathon each year (that's the cap)
~500,000 watch it in person
~1.5 million watch it on TV (most of that is in MA)

1/4 of the audience watches it in person, and that's why it's a huge economic boom. Unlike other marathons, it's not a loop. That's why it's an economic boom for multiple towns and cities.

How many watch the Super Bowl?

It seems you've missed the entire point of my post. This thread is about trying to replicate what marathons do in terms of impacts on local economies and comparing it to the super bowl. My post is showing that a substantial number of people who watch marathons do so in person as opposed to on TV, and that's why they generate more for local economies than the super bowl does, which has an almost negligible amount of people in person compared to the number that watches on TV.

Yeah because a bunch of locals going to watch a marathon has the same economic impact as 60k people who can afford Super Bowl tickets flying into your city. But it’s not just the people going to the game, is it? I just googled it and got some interesting thoughts:

Based on data from recent Super Bowls, approximately 100,000 to 200,000 visitors typically travel to the host city for the week-long festivities, with a significant portion not attending the actual game. In some instances, estimates have shown that up to 50% of people who travel to a Super Bowl city do not attend the game itself, visiting instead for parties, corporate meetings, and related events.
Key statistics regarding travelers for events and meetings:
Total Visitors: Host cities generally see around 100,000–200,000+ visitors in town for the festivities (e.g., in New Orleans for 2025, or Atlanta for 2019).
Non-Ticket Holder Influx: In Atlanta (2019), 150,000 out-of-state visitors were estimated to have visited for events, with the stadium only holding ~70,000.
Event Participation: In San Francisco (2016), 1.1 million people (including locals) attended fan-focused events like "Super Bowl City".
Corporate & Network Activities: The week involves 100+ organized parties and events, drawing thousands of corporate professionals for meetings rather than just the game.
Key Takeaways:
Economic Impact: These visitors drive high-value tourism, contributing to an estimated $500+ million economic impact for the host city, heavily reliant on hotel and restaurant spending rather than just ticket sales.
Hospitality Trends: Sports tourism has seen a surge, with high demand for "experience" packages that focus on parties and activations over in-stadium viewing.
Activity Focus: For many, the trip is about the "Super Bowl Experience" rather than the 3-4 hours of the game itself.


How many of those 500k people watching the Boston’s marathon stay for a week and drop $10-20k at local hotels and restaurants?

Now, a better example might be a regular season NFL or College football game, which is what you’re really using as your comparison, right?

Are you guys not reading the original thing linked AT ALL when responding? Honestly, please take a second and read what's linked in the first post before throwing out assumptions that are proven entirely incorrect in what the thread was started for:

Quote:Boston offers a similar picture, scaled to a smaller city but with deep regional reach.

The Boston Marathon generates more than $509 million in state and local economic activity during marathon weekend, according to data from the Boston Athletic Association and regional tourism groups. The event supports roughly 2,900 jobs and produces more than $206 million in labor income.

More than two-thirds of participants travel from outside New England, and the median stay is three nights. Nearly 87 percent of visitors go out for food and drinks during their stay. EconomicImpact

Unlike the Super Bowl, which is concentrated in and around one stadium, Boston’s race spreads spending along the entire course, from Hopkinton to downtown Boston.

[Image: hgdxCwV.jpeg]


The big 3 marathons in the US generate as much, if not more, revenue for local economies as the super bowl.

Glossy Brochure Proving $509 Million impact of Boston Marathon (PDF)

It claims 34,000 runners, 69% fly to Boston, and spend 3 nights at $429 per night, plus spend $500. 77% have a friend.

So let's do 34,000 x 2 x ($429 x 3 + 500) = $121M.
02-16-2026 02:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,304
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #27
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-16-2026 02:28 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  Glossy Brochure Proving $509 Million impact of Boston Marathon (PDF)

It claims 34,000 runners, 69% fly to Boston, and spend 3 nights at $429 per night, plus spend $500. 77% have a friend.

So let's do 34,000 x 2 x ($429 x 3 + 500) = $121M.

The actual numbers in that brochure:

25,640 runners, 67% (or 17,180) of which stayed in hotels. It's likely that some of them stayed in hotels in the outskirts of Boston, so they would have paid less than $429 per night for their stay. Let's say the average room rate was about $375.

17,180 X 3 x375 = $19.3 million.

During a normal (non marathon) 3 day weekend, those hotels would have an expected occupancy of at least 60% (Chamber of Commerce data says in-city rates are about 75%) at prices about half of the race rates. So, "normal" revenue for three weekend days is about $5.3 million. That means the incremental hotel revenue attributable to the race is about $13.5 million. Meals at $500 per runner (though I doubt that runners are doing nearly that much wining and dining in the two days before the race) would add another $12.8 million.
(This post was last modified: 02-16-2026 10:06 AM by ken d.)
02-16-2026 09:39 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #28
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-16-2026 09:39 AM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 02:28 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  Glossy Brochure Proving $509 Million impact of Boston Marathon (PDF)

It claims 34,000 runners, 69% fly to Boston, and spend 3 nights at $429 per night, plus spend $500. 77% have a friend.

So let's do 34,000 x 2 x ($429 x 3 + 500) = $121M.

The actual numbers in that brochure:

25,640 runners, 67% (or 17,180) of which stayed in hotels. It's likely that some of them stayed in hotels in the outskirts of Boston, so they would have paid less than $429 per night for their stay. Let's say the average room rate was about $375.

17,180 X 3 x375 = $19.3 million.

During a normal (non marathon) 3 day weekend, those hotels would have an expected occupancy of at least 60% (Chamber of Commerce data says in-city rates are about 75%) at prices about half of the race rates. So, "normal" revenue for three weekend days is about $5.3 million. That means the incremental hotel revenue attributable to the race is about $13.5 million. Meals at $500 per runner (though I doubt that runners are doing nearly that much wining and dining in the two days before the race) would add another $12.8 million.
Someone posted this, which is the basis of the glossy brochure.

https://www.baa.org/wp-content/uploads/d...0FINAL.pdf

You are right about the Boston vs. outside Boston hotel rates (they come up with a blended rate of $380. The glossy brochure uses $429, but the study uses the in-Boston rate and outside Boston rates.

They come up with 1,800 worker-years for services for visitors. But much of that must be just for the race weekend (maids, waiters, etc.). So lets say 90,000 worker-weeks. But is that an increase or just shifted? Some might be overtime, but some would work that weekend and not the weekdays.

There could also be a negative effect, "that week is a bad week, its the Boston Marathon weekend, they jack up the hotel rates, Monday is a holiday, the airport will be a zoo, and Sal is actually running and will be a zombie the rest of the week."
02-16-2026 11:35 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #29
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-16-2026 09:39 AM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 02:28 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  Glossy Brochure Proving $509 Million impact of Boston Marathon (PDF)

It claims 34,000 runners, 69% fly to Boston, and spend 3 nights at $429 per night, plus spend $500. 77% have a friend.

So let's do 34,000 x 2 x ($429 x 3 + 500) = $121M.

The actual numbers in that brochure:

25,640 runners, 67% (or 17,180) of which stayed in hotels. It's likely that some of them stayed in hotels in the outskirts of Boston, so they would have paid less than $429 per night for their stay. Let's say the average room rate was about $375.

17,180 X 3 x375 = $19.3 million.

During a normal (non marathon) 3 day weekend, those hotels would have an expected occupancy of at least 60% (Chamber of Commerce data says in-city rates are about 75%) at prices about half of the race rates. So, "normal" revenue for three weekend days is about $5.3 million. That means the incremental hotel revenue attributable to the race is about $13.5 million. Meals at $500 per runner (though I doubt that runners are doing nearly that much wining and dining in the two days before the race) would add another $12.8 million.

You're ignoring the 50% of the non-runners who also stay in hotels. Non runners are a MUCH larger group of people. As stated earlier, it's 500,000 people who go to the marathon in person, with 50% of them staying in hotels or short term rentals (like Airbnbs) for a few days. The other 50% are local enough to do a day trip.

Quote:The B.A.A. estimates more than 34,000 people participated in at least one of the weekend’s races while conservative estimates for spectators are 500,000. Using surveys of both groups, we were able to learn more about them and their activities while in the area

Quote:There was additional spending from both spectators and participants on hotels or other accommodations during their stay. As mentioned earlier, spectators were more likely to be from the
region than participants, so many spectators were day-trippers and did not need overnight accommodations. Almost half of all spectator respondents (47%) said they did not stay overnight or said hat they live in the area so stayed at home. Nonetheless, a little more than half of the spectator respondents did stay overnight. Of the 53 percent that stayed overnight, most stayed at hotels, while some stayed at short-term rentals or with family and friends.


53% of the conservatively estimated 500,000 spectators stayed overnight at least one night (median was also 3 nights for them), 36% in hotels, 7% in short term rentals (Airbnb), and the other 10% at friends/relatives places.


Alao to be clear: 34000 participants in one of the BAA races that weekend. There are 5, the marathon has the most by far at the ~25000 number referenced, but there's also a 5K, 10K, a half marathon, and an invitational mile.
02-16-2026 12:07 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,304
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #30
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-16-2026 11:35 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 09:39 AM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 02:28 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  Glossy Brochure Proving $509 Million impact of Boston Marathon (PDF)

It claims 34,000 runners, 69% fly to Boston, and spend 3 nights at $429 per night, plus spend $500. 77% have a friend.

So let's do 34,000 x 2 x ($429 x 3 + 500) = $121M.

The actual numbers in that brochure:

25,640 runners, 67% (or 17,180) of which stayed in hotels. It's likely that some of them stayed in hotels in the outskirts of Boston, so they would have paid less than $429 per night for their stay. Let's say the average room rate was about $375.

17,180 X 3 x375 = $19.3 million.

During a normal (non marathon) 3 day weekend, those hotels would have an expected occupancy of at least 60% (Chamber of Commerce data says in-city rates are about 75%) at prices about half of the race rates. So, "normal" revenue for three weekend days is about $5.3 million. That means the incremental hotel revenue attributable to the race is about $13.5 million. Meals at $500 per runner (though I doubt that runners are doing nearly that much wining and dining in the two days before the race) would add another $12.8 million.
Someone posted this, which is the basis of the glossy brochure.

https://www.baa.org/wp-content/uploads/d...0FINAL.pdf

You are right about the Boston vs. outside Boston hotel rates (they come up with a blended rate of $380. The glossy brochure uses $429, but the study uses the in-Boston rate and outside Boston rates.

They come up with 1,800 worker-years for services for visitors. But much of that must be just for the race weekend (maids, waiters, etc.). So lets say 90,000 worker-weeks. But is that an increase or just shifted? Some might be overtime, but some would work that weekend and not the weekdays.

There could also be a negative effect, "that week is a bad week, its the Boston Marathon weekend, they jack up the hotel rates, Monday is a holiday, the airport will be a zoo, and Sal is actually running and will be a zombie the rest of the week."

In my initial analysis, I came up with a blended rate of about $340, and I assumed 330,000 room nights (although I suspect less than 100% of visitors stayed all three days). Using the $380 rate, that generates $125 million in revenue (if you assume that there should be no offset for the revenue they would have generated on any average 3 day weekend). If the 187,000 visitors who went out to eat or drink during their stay and spent $500 each, that would add $93.5 million.

As for labor income, the BAA employs 40 people. If you assume they earn on average $150K a year, that would add up to $6 million. But the BAA doesn't just sponsor the Boston Marathon. They also sponsor a 5K, 10K and half-marathon each year, as well as support for running programs for schools and clubs. So, I estimate that only 50% of those staffers time is spent on the Marathon.

If 1,000 cops patrol the race route 24 hours a day for the entire weekend, and earn $130 an hour (all at overtime rates), that would add about $9.4 million more cost. 1700 doctors for 3 days at $1200/day = another $6 million. 3,000 staffers to set up and tear down the race course, and supervise the actual race, for a total of 30 hours each at $25 an hour would add another $2.3 million. 10,000 additional food service workers working 3 ten hour shifts at $20 an hour comes to $6 million. That adds up to about $27 million labor income. If those estimates are too light, what would they have to be to add up to the $206 claimed by the BAA?
02-16-2026 12:24 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #31
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-16-2026 12:24 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 11:35 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 09:39 AM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 02:28 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  Glossy Brochure Proving $509 Million impact of Boston Marathon (PDF)

It claims 34,000 runners, 69% fly to Boston, and spend 3 nights at $429 per night, plus spend $500. 77% have a friend.

So let's do 34,000 x 2 x ($429 x 3 + 500) = $121M.

The actual numbers in that brochure:

25,640 runners, 67% (or 17,180) of which stayed in hotels. It's likely that some of them stayed in hotels in the outskirts of Boston, so they would have paid less than $429 per night for their stay. Let's say the average room rate was about $375.

17,180 X 3 x375 = $19.3 million.

During a normal (non marathon) 3 day weekend, those hotels would have an expected occupancy of at least 60% (Chamber of Commerce data says in-city rates are about 75%) at prices about half of the race rates. So, "normal" revenue for three weekend days is about $5.3 million. That means the incremental hotel revenue attributable to the race is about $13.5 million. Meals at $500 per runner (though I doubt that runners are doing nearly that much wining and dining in the two days before the race) would add another $12.8 million.
Someone posted this, which is the basis of the glossy brochure.

https://www.baa.org/wp-content/uploads/d...0FINAL.pdf

You are right about the Boston vs. outside Boston hotel rates (they come up with a blended rate of $380. The glossy brochure uses $429, but the study uses the in-Boston rate and outside Boston rates.

They come up with 1,800 worker-years for services for visitors. But much of that must be just for the race weekend (maids, waiters, etc.). So lets say 90,000 worker-weeks. But is that an increase or just shifted? Some might be overtime, but some would work that weekend and not the weekdays.

There could also be a negative effect, "that week is a bad week, its the Boston Marathon weekend, they jack up the hotel rates, Monday is a holiday, the airport will be a zoo, and Sal is actually running and will be a zombie the rest of the week."

In my initial analysis, I came up with a blended rate of about $340, and I assumed 330,000 room nights (although I suspect less than 100% of visitors stayed all three days). Using the $380 rate, that generates $125 million in revenue (if you assume that there should be no offset for the revenue they would have generated on any average 3 day weekend). If the 187,000 visitors who went out to eat or drink during their stay and spent $500 each, that would add $93.5 million.

As for labor income, the BAA employs 40 people. If you assume they earn on average $150K a year, that would add up to $6 million. But the BAA doesn't just sponsor the Boston Marathon. They also sponsor a 5K, 10K and half-marathon each year, as well as support for running programs for schools and clubs. So, I estimate that only 50% of those staffers time is spent on the Marathon.

If 1,000 cops patrol the race route 24 hours a day for the entire weekend, and earn $130 an hour (all at overtime rates), that would add about $9.4 million more cost. 1700 doctors for 3 days at $1200/day = another $6 million. 3,000 staffers to set up and tear down the race course, and supervise the actual race, for a total of 30 hours each at $25 an hour would add another $2.3 million. 10,000 additional food service workers working 3 ten hour shifts at $20 an hour comes to $6 million. That adds up to about $27 million labor income. If those estimates are too light, what would they have to be to add up to the $206 claimed by the BAA?

I had a whole thing I was going to type out, but at this point I'm instead curious: what's your aim here? Are you still trying to argue that the absolute top marathons do not have a similar local economic impact as a super bowl does (local only, obviously not global)? Or are you now just questioning how high the impact is in general?

I have to assume if you're questioning the numbers reported by the BAA that you would similarly question the ones brought up by the super bowl committees that put out the numbers (who are also local groups that do everything they can to show why they should support hosting these events).


So are you now just trying to figure out the actual impact by removing a potential fudge-factor or are you trying to apply a fudge-factor only to the marathons while letting the super bowl numbers stand as is? If it's to the point where you're now saying "it's possible they have the same local impacts but I don't think the impact for any of them is as high as they claim" then I don't have a problem with it at all.


The paper itself goes into more detail on jobs and other impacts, if you're curious. Not sure how much you've actually dug into the data. For instance, the $500 referenced is about all additional spending and not just food and beverage (they do lots of shopping, including for marathon specific swag), and many do other events locally (local bands, comedy troupes, and whatnot all get a lot more revenue during the weekend, for instance) and that number applies to everyone who stayed in Boston directly. It's closer to $200 for the people who stayed just outside of Boston. This would all be stuff that New Orleans and the Bay Area include in their numbers as well.

Day trippers also account for $125 of spending each. If that seems high to you...try having a dinner and going out to a bar in Boston. Yeesh. The people I know who went to college at one of the ones on the route (or nearby) also reminisce fondly of drinking all day both outside and at bars. Also that would count buying marathon swag, including random t-shirts and stuff being sold nearby.

[Image: DefLowY.png]

With the non-hotel spending breakdown being:
[Image: Gj93u7f.png]

So that $500 per person would break down to:
$250 for food/drink (very reasonable for 3 days)
$125 for miscellaneous shopping (not crazy at all, especially considering the Boston Marathon Celebration jacket itself costs $120 this year)
$125 for Other (a show, a tour, a car rental, anything else really)
02-16-2026 03:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,304
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #32
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-16-2026 03:47 PM)e-parade Wrote:  I have to assume if you're questioning the numbers reported by the BAA that you would similarly question the ones brought up by the super bowl committees that put out the numbers (who are also local groups that do everything they can to show why they should support hosting these events).

Not only would I question the numbers brought up by super bowl committees, I explicitly did. I said the real numbers would be about half of what they claim. And, as I have demonstrated, that's true also for the Boston Marathon.

What I don't get is why should the BAA claim those exaggerated numbers? It's not like the event wouldn't be held, or would be less important and iconic, if they only claimed $250 million in economic benefits instead of $500 million. Is it an ego thing?
02-16-2026 04:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #33
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-16-2026 04:45 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 03:47 PM)e-parade Wrote:  I have to assume if you're questioning the numbers reported by the BAA that you would similarly question the ones brought up by the super bowl committees that put out the numbers (who are also local groups that do everything they can to show why they should support hosting these events).

Not only would I question the numbers brought up by super bowl committees, I explicitly did. I said the real numbers would be about half of what they claim. And, as I have demonstrated, that's true also for the Boston Marathon.

What I don't get is why should the BAA claim those exaggerated numbers? It's not like the event wouldn't be held, or would be less important and iconic, if they only claimed $250 million in economic benefits instead of $500 million. Is it an ego thing?

Okay cool. Here's a long post along the lines for what I was doing to show my own calculations:

However your demonstration was only looking at 187,000 people as opposed to the full 500,000. 250,000 stayed overnight for an average of 3 days, and 250,000 were day trippers. The day trippers spent an average of $125 per person, which is $31 million in additional revenue.

The additional ~60000 who spent time overnight in and around Boston also spent money both staying there and buying other things.

Also, the median stay was 3 nights for all those who did stay, meaning half were less and half more, but no real number to say it the mean was higher or lower, so lets go with a flat 3. 53% of the spectators stayed overnight, with 43% of those being paid. So 10% didn't pay for lodging, but were included in the rest of the group for "additional spending." 55% who stayed did so in Boston itself.

137,000 stayed in Boston, average of $500 per person on non-lodging:
$68.75 million on non-lodging spending in Boston

113,000 stayed just outside of Boston, an average of $200 per person in non lodging spend: $22.6 million

Non-lodging spending across just the group of spectators (not runners and not day trippers) is about $90 million. (90.35)

I don't believe it breaks down where people stayed when they were staying with friends, so I split it evenly. So removing 25,000 (10% of the 250,000 who stayed stayed with friends) from the total number (12500 from each group) we get:

124,500 paid to stay in Boston
101,500 paid to stay outside of Boston

Average group size was 3 in each instance, but no idea if that means 3 to a room or some split of separate rooms, but lets just divide by 3.

41500 rooms in Boston
33833 rooms outside of Boston

41500*3 (number of nights stayed in Boston): 124500
32833*3 (number of nights stayed outside): 101500

124,500 * 429 (median nightly rate in Boston): $53.41 million
101500 * 250 (median nightly rate outside Boston): $25.38 million

Total lodging for spectators: $88.8 million

Total spend for spectators who stayed: $179.15 million

250,000 spectators who didn't spend the night reportedly spent $125 on average for the day trip: $31.25 million

34000 participants in one (or more) of the races.

68% stayed in Boston
20% stayed outside Boston
12% day trippers

23120 stayed in Boston for an average of 3 days ($429/night): $29.76 million

6800 stayed outside for an average of 3 days ($250/night): $5.1 million

Total lodging cost for participants: $34.86 million

They said the same spending patterns and whatnot happened for participants as well, so:

23120 * $500 = $11.56 million
6800 * $200 = $1.36 million

Total additional spending from participants: $47.78 million


Total spending across participants and spectators: $258.18 million



The reality is probably going to fall somewhere between the $218 million you calculated and this $258 million number. They raised it through "economic ripple effect" calculations, among other things (like BAA direct spending on advertising and such). The "ripple effect" likely has to do with calculations based on increased spending from the people who got increased wages from the increased labor spending.


For the labor spending numbers, you came up with $27 million. The BAA broke it down as:

BAA Specific:
Full time employees: $5.5 million (you were pretty close on this one actually)
Contractors & Consultants: $16 million
Office Space: $1.8 million
Advertising: $4.96 million
Payments to local governments for support: $6 million
Payments for warehouse, utilities, charitable support and other: $2.2 million.

So BAA specific labor costs are $36.46 million. This is apparently spread across 225 specific jobs in Suffolk county (where Boston is) and another 75 in the rest of the state.

They then mention an additional 1675 jobs (they count them as "Job years") within Suffolk county, and 925 outside of Suffolk county. I'm not sure what those jobs entail, because they don't go into much detail. But this is where I could agree with you on how to deal with the data. They mention, of the jobs created, 1800 are "direct" (meaning hired specifically and basically only for marathon purposes), and the rest are "indirect" or "induced" jobs.


But we know that the bare minimum is $34.46 million in labor costs for the BAA numbers that are spelled out. You estimated another $27 million. So if we add those together it gets to $61.46 million. Still a far way away, so I'm interested in seeing what else isn't being accounted for (police OT could be underestimated as well. There was a report that around 100 Boston police officers made at least $380K a year with some over half a million, for instance).



As for why fluff? It's the same kinds of people doing the same kinds of surveys everywhere. They use the same methods and will come up with the same added numbers on top. Don't think it's an ego thing so much as it's a "this is just how this industry works" thing. If you want to take all the given numbers and multiply by 0.6 to get what seems more right, that's fair for you to want to do. But I think we're on the same page overall here.
02-16-2026 05:56 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
owl at the moon Offline
Eastern Screech Owl
*

Posts: 21,694
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation: 3099
I Root For: rice,smu,uh,unt
Location: 23 mbps from csnbbs
Post: #34
Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-16-2026 02:28 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(02-13-2026 10:13 AM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-13-2026 02:44 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 07:23 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-12-2026 07:15 PM)ken d Wrote:  How many watch the Super Bowl?

It seems you've missed the entire point of my post. This thread is about trying to replicate what marathons do in terms of impacts on local economies and comparing it to the super bowl. My post is showing that a substantial number of people who watch marathons do so in person as opposed to on TV, and that's why they generate more for local economies than the super bowl does, which has an almost negligible amount of people in person compared to the number that watches on TV.

Yeah because a bunch of locals going to watch a marathon has the same economic impact as 60k people who can afford Super Bowl tickets flying into your city. But it’s not just the people going to the game, is it? I just googled it and got some interesting thoughts:

Based on data from recent Super Bowls, approximately 100,000 to 200,000 visitors typically travel to the host city for the week-long festivities, with a significant portion not attending the actual game. In some instances, estimates have shown that up to 50% of people who travel to a Super Bowl city do not attend the game itself, visiting instead for parties, corporate meetings, and related events.
Key statistics regarding travelers for events and meetings:
Total Visitors: Host cities generally see around 100,000–200,000+ visitors in town for the festivities (e.g., in New Orleans for 2025, or Atlanta for 2019).
Non-Ticket Holder Influx: In Atlanta (2019), 150,000 out-of-state visitors were estimated to have visited for events, with the stadium only holding ~70,000.
Event Participation: In San Francisco (2016), 1.1 million people (including locals) attended fan-focused events like "Super Bowl City".
Corporate & Network Activities: The week involves 100+ organized parties and events, drawing thousands of corporate professionals for meetings rather than just the game.
Key Takeaways:
Economic Impact: These visitors drive high-value tourism, contributing to an estimated $500+ million economic impact for the host city, heavily reliant on hotel and restaurant spending rather than just ticket sales.
Hospitality Trends: Sports tourism has seen a surge, with high demand for "experience" packages that focus on parties and activations over in-stadium viewing.
Activity Focus: For many, the trip is about the "Super Bowl Experience" rather than the 3-4 hours of the game itself.


How many of those 500k people watching the Boston’s marathon stay for a week and drop $10-20k at local hotels and restaurants?

Now, a better example might be a regular season NFL or College football game, which is what you’re really using as your comparison, right?

Are you guys not reading the original thing linked AT ALL when responding? Honestly, please take a second and read what's linked in the first post before throwing out assumptions that are proven entirely incorrect in what the thread was started for:

Quote:Boston offers a similar picture, scaled to a smaller city but with deep regional reach.

The Boston Marathon generates more than $509 million in state and local economic activity during marathon weekend, according to data from the Boston Athletic Association and regional tourism groups. The event supports roughly 2,900 jobs and produces more than $206 million in labor income.

More than two-thirds of participants travel from outside New England, and the median stay is three nights. Nearly 87 percent of visitors go out for food and drinks during their stay. EconomicImpact

Unlike the Super Bowl, which is concentrated in and around one stadium, Boston’s race spreads spending along the entire course, from Hopkinton to downtown Boston.

[Image: hgdxCwV.jpeg]


The big 3 marathons in the US generate as much, if not more, revenue for local economies as the super bowl.

Glossy Brochure Proving $509 Million impact of Boston Marathon (PDF)

It claims 34,000 runners, 69% fly to Boston, and spend 3 nights at $429 per night, plus spend $500. 77% have a friend.

So let's do 34,000 x 2 x ($429 x 3 + 500) = $121M.


“77% have a friend.”

I’m a runner myself. That sounds about right.

I’m one of the 77% who have at least one friend 03-wink
02-17-2026 07:07 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #35
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-16-2026 05:56 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 04:45 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 03:47 PM)e-parade Wrote:  I have to assume if you're questioning the numbers reported by the BAA that you would similarly question the ones brought up by the super bowl committees that put out the numbers (who are also local groups that do everything they can to show why they should support hosting these events).

Not only would I question the numbers brought up by super bowl committees, I explicitly did. I said the real numbers would be about half of what they claim. And, as I have demonstrated, that's true also for the Boston Marathon.

What I don't get is why should the BAA claim those exaggerated numbers? It's not like the event wouldn't be held, or would be less important and iconic, if they only claimed $250 million in economic benefits instead of $500 million. Is it an ego thing?

Okay cool. Here's a long post along the lines for what I was doing to show my own calculations:

However your demonstration was only looking at 187,000 people as opposed to the full 500,000. 250,000 stayed overnight for an average of 3 days, and 250,000 were day trippers. The day trippers spent an average of $125 per person, which is $31 million in additional revenue.

The additional ~60000 who spent time overnight in and around Boston also spent money both staying there and buying other things.

Also, the median stay was 3 nights for all those who did stay, meaning half were less and half more, but no real number to say it the mean was higher or lower, so lets go with a flat 3. 53% of the spectators stayed overnight, with 43% of those being paid. So 10% didn't pay for lodging, but were included in the rest of the group for "additional spending." 55% who stayed did so in Boston itself.

137,000 stayed in Boston, average of $500 per person on non-lodging:
$68.75 million on non-lodging spending in Boston

113,000 stayed just outside of Boston, an average of $200 per person in non lodging spend: $22.6 million

Non-lodging spending across just the group of spectators (not runners and not day trippers) is about $90 million. (90.35)

I don't believe it breaks down where people stayed when they were staying with friends, so I split it evenly. So removing 25,000 (10% of the 250,000 who stayed stayed with friends) from the total number (12500 from each group) we get:

124,500 paid to stay in Boston
101,500 paid to stay outside of Boston

Average group size was 3 in each instance, but no idea if that means 3 to a room or some split of separate rooms, but lets just divide by 3.

41500 rooms in Boston
33833 rooms outside of Boston

41500*3 (number of nights stayed in Boston): 124500
32833*3 (number of nights stayed outside): 101500

124,500 * 429 (median nightly rate in Boston): $53.41 million
101500 * 250 (median nightly rate outside Boston): $25.38 million

Total lodging for spectators: $88.8 million

Total spend for spectators who stayed: $179.15 million

250,000 spectators who didn't spend the night reportedly spent $125 on average for the day trip: $31.25 million

34000 participants in one (or more) of the races.

68% stayed in Boston
20% stayed outside Boston
12% day trippers

23120 stayed in Boston for an average of 3 days ($429/night): $29.76 million

6800 stayed outside for an average of 3 days ($250/night): $5.1 million

Total lodging cost for participants: $34.86 million

They said the same spending patterns and whatnot happened for participants as well, so:

23120 * $500 = $11.56 million
6800 * $200 = $1.36 million

Total additional spending from participants: $47.78 million


Total spending across participants and spectators: $258.18 million



The reality is probably going to fall somewhere between the $218 million you calculated and this $258 million number. They raised it through "economic ripple effect" calculations, among other things (like BAA direct spending on advertising and such). The "ripple effect" likely has to do with calculations based on increased spending from the people who got increased wages from the increased labor spending.


For the labor spending numbers, you came up with $27 million. The BAA broke it down as:

BAA Specific:
Full time employees: $5.5 million (you were pretty close on this one actually)
Contractors & Consultants: $16 million
Office Space: $1.8 million
Advertising: $4.96 million
Payments to local governments for support: $6 million
Payments for warehouse, utilities, charitable support and other: $2.2 million.

So BAA specific labor costs are $36.46 million. This is apparently spread across 225 specific jobs in Suffolk county (where Boston is) and another 75 in the rest of the state.

They then mention an additional 1675 jobs (they count them as "Job years") within Suffolk county, and 925 outside of Suffolk county. I'm not sure what those jobs entail, because they don't go into much detail. But this is where I could agree with you on how to deal with the data. They mention, of the jobs created, 1800 are "direct" (meaning hired specifically and basically only for marathon purposes), and the rest are "indirect" or "induced" jobs.


But we know that the bare minimum is $34.46 million in labor costs for the BAA numbers that are spelled out. You estimated another $27 million. So if we add those together it gets to $61.46 million. Still a far way away, so I'm interested in seeing what else isn't being accounted for (police OT could be underestimated as well. There was a report that around 100 Boston police officers made at least $380K a year with some over half a million, for instance).



As for why fluff? It's the same kinds of people doing the same kinds of surveys everywhere. They use the same methods and will come up with the same added numbers on top. Don't think it's an ego thing so much as it's a "this is just how this industry works" thing. If you want to take all the given numbers and multiply by 0.6 to get what seems more right, that's fair for you to want to do. But I think we're on the same page overall here.
Since Table 16 shows number of persons per party, is the spending per individual or per party? How were spectators selected for the spectator survey? How was the estimated 500,000 spectators determined?
02-17-2026 10:30 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #36
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-17-2026 10:30 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 05:56 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 04:45 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 03:47 PM)e-parade Wrote:  I have to assume if you're questioning the numbers reported by the BAA that you would similarly question the ones brought up by the super bowl committees that put out the numbers (who are also local groups that do everything they can to show why they should support hosting these events).

Not only would I question the numbers brought up by super bowl committees, I explicitly did. I said the real numbers would be about half of what they claim. And, as I have demonstrated, that's true also for the Boston Marathon.

What I don't get is why should the BAA claim those exaggerated numbers? It's not like the event wouldn't be held, or would be less important and iconic, if they only claimed $250 million in economic benefits instead of $500 million. Is it an ego thing?

Okay cool. Here's a long post along the lines for what I was doing to show my own calculations:

However your demonstration was only looking at 187,000 people as opposed to the full 500,000. 250,000 stayed overnight for an average of 3 days, and 250,000 were day trippers. The day trippers spent an average of $125 per person, which is $31 million in additional revenue.

The additional ~60000 who spent time overnight in and around Boston also spent money both staying there and buying other things.

Also, the median stay was 3 nights for all those who did stay, meaning half were less and half more, but no real number to say it the mean was higher or lower, so lets go with a flat 3. 53% of the spectators stayed overnight, with 43% of those being paid. So 10% didn't pay for lodging, but were included in the rest of the group for "additional spending." 55% who stayed did so in Boston itself.

137,000 stayed in Boston, average of $500 per person on non-lodging:
$68.75 million on non-lodging spending in Boston

113,000 stayed just outside of Boston, an average of $200 per person in non lodging spend: $22.6 million

Non-lodging spending across just the group of spectators (not runners and not day trippers) is about $90 million. (90.35)

I don't believe it breaks down where people stayed when they were staying with friends, so I split it evenly. So removing 25,000 (10% of the 250,000 who stayed stayed with friends) from the total number (12500 from each group) we get:

124,500 paid to stay in Boston
101,500 paid to stay outside of Boston

Average group size was 3 in each instance, but no idea if that means 3 to a room or some split of separate rooms, but lets just divide by 3.

41500 rooms in Boston
33833 rooms outside of Boston

41500*3 (number of nights stayed in Boston): 124500
32833*3 (number of nights stayed outside): 101500

124,500 * 429 (median nightly rate in Boston): $53.41 million
101500 * 250 (median nightly rate outside Boston): $25.38 million

Total lodging for spectators: $88.8 million

Total spend for spectators who stayed: $179.15 million

250,000 spectators who didn't spend the night reportedly spent $125 on average for the day trip: $31.25 million

34000 participants in one (or more) of the races.

68% stayed in Boston
20% stayed outside Boston
12% day trippers

23120 stayed in Boston for an average of 3 days ($429/night): $29.76 million

6800 stayed outside for an average of 3 days ($250/night): $5.1 million

Total lodging cost for participants: $34.86 million

They said the same spending patterns and whatnot happened for participants as well, so:

23120 * $500 = $11.56 million
6800 * $200 = $1.36 million

Total additional spending from participants: $47.78 million


Total spending across participants and spectators: $258.18 million



The reality is probably going to fall somewhere between the $218 million you calculated and this $258 million number. They raised it through "economic ripple effect" calculations, among other things (like BAA direct spending on advertising and such). The "ripple effect" likely has to do with calculations based on increased spending from the people who got increased wages from the increased labor spending.


For the labor spending numbers, you came up with $27 million. The BAA broke it down as:

BAA Specific:
Full time employees: $5.5 million (you were pretty close on this one actually)
Contractors & Consultants: $16 million
Office Space: $1.8 million
Advertising: $4.96 million
Payments to local governments for support: $6 million
Payments for warehouse, utilities, charitable support and other: $2.2 million.

So BAA specific labor costs are $36.46 million. This is apparently spread across 225 specific jobs in Suffolk county (where Boston is) and another 75 in the rest of the state.

They then mention an additional 1675 jobs (they count them as "Job years") within Suffolk county, and 925 outside of Suffolk county. I'm not sure what those jobs entail, because they don't go into much detail. But this is where I could agree with you on how to deal with the data. They mention, of the jobs created, 1800 are "direct" (meaning hired specifically and basically only for marathon purposes), and the rest are "indirect" or "induced" jobs.


But we know that the bare minimum is $34.46 million in labor costs for the BAA numbers that are spelled out. You estimated another $27 million. So if we add those together it gets to $61.46 million. Still a far way away, so I'm interested in seeing what else isn't being accounted for (police OT could be underestimated as well. There was a report that around 100 Boston police officers made at least $380K a year with some over half a million, for instance).



As for why fluff? It's the same kinds of people doing the same kinds of surveys everywhere. They use the same methods and will come up with the same added numbers on top. Don't think it's an ego thing so much as it's a "this is just how this industry works" thing. If you want to take all the given numbers and multiply by 0.6 to get what seems more right, that's fair for you to want to do. But I think we're on the same page overall here.
Since Table 16 shows number of persons per party, is the spending per individual or per party? How were spectators selected for the spectator survey? How was the estimated 500,000 spectators determined?

They said the additional (non-lodging) spending was per person, not per party. Lodging is likely the basis of "party size" there, which is why it's not several hundred million more (lodging would be the most expensive single item if everyone went on their own).

And as for how? Through the exact same method all surveys are done. For estimates on the number of people? The same way they estimate crowd sizes everywhere. Don't know what else to say other than "these are professionals at this and would come up with the same kinds of estimates as anyone else who is a professional at this." That's why ken_d is also saying to discount all of them - you never want to be the outlier if more than one group does surveys, it makes it look like you're worse at it if you are. So these estimates are going to be as accurate as any other large event.
02-17-2026 10:35 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ETSUfan#2 Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 297
Joined: Dec 2014
Reputation: 11
I Root For: ETSU, Tennessee, Vermont
Location:
Post: #37
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-14-2026 09:23 AM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-13-2026 11:08 AM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-13-2026 11:01 AM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-13-2026 10:13 AM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-13-2026 02:44 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Yeah because a bunch of locals going to watch a marathon has the same economic impact as 60k people who can afford Super Bowl tickets flying into your city. But it’s not just the people going to the game, is it? I just googled it and got some interesting thoughts:

Based on data from recent Super Bowls, approximately 100,000 to 200,000 visitors typically travel to the host city for the week-long festivities, with a significant portion not attending the actual game. In some instances, estimates have shown that up to 50% of people who travel to a Super Bowl city do not attend the game itself, visiting instead for parties, corporate meetings, and related events.
Key statistics regarding travelers for events and meetings:
Total Visitors: Host cities generally see around 100,000–200,000+ visitors in town for the festivities (e.g., in New Orleans for 2025, or Atlanta for 2019).
Non-Ticket Holder Influx: In Atlanta (2019), 150,000 out-of-state visitors were estimated to have visited for events, with the stadium only holding ~70,000.
Event Participation: In San Francisco (2016), 1.1 million people (including locals) attended fan-focused events like "Super Bowl City".
Corporate & Network Activities: The week involves 100+ organized parties and events, drawing thousands of corporate professionals for meetings rather than just the game.
Key Takeaways:
Economic Impact: These visitors drive high-value tourism, contributing to an estimated $500+ million economic impact for the host city, heavily reliant on hotel and restaurant spending rather than just ticket sales.
Hospitality Trends: Sports tourism has seen a surge, with high demand for "experience" packages that focus on parties and activations over in-stadium viewing.
Activity Focus: For many, the trip is about the "Super Bowl Experience" rather than the 3-4 hours of the game itself.


How many of those 500k people watching the Boston’s marathon stay for a week and drop $10-20k at local hotels and restaurants?

Now, a better example might be a regular season NFL or College football game, which is what you’re really using as your comparison, right?

Are you guys not reading the original thing linked AT ALL when responding? Honestly, please take a second and read what's linked in the first post before throwing out assumptions that are proven entirely incorrect in what the thread was started for:

Quote:Boston offers a similar picture, scaled to a smaller city but with deep regional reach.

The Boston Marathon generates more than $509 million in state and local economic activity during marathon weekend, according to data from the Boston Athletic Association and regional tourism groups. The event supports roughly 2,900 jobs and produces more than $206 million in labor income.

More than two-thirds of participants travel from outside New England, and the median stay is three nights. Nearly 87 percent of visitors go out for food and drinks during their stay. EconomicImpact

Unlike the Super Bowl, which is concentrated in and around one stadium, Boston’s race spreads spending along the entire course, from Hopkinton to downtown Boston.

[Image: hgdxCwV.jpeg]


The big 3 marathons in the US generate as much, if not more, revenue for local economies as the super bowl.

I can't speak for Bryan, but while I did see the supporting charts, I am simply skeptical about their validity. The groups providing that "data" have every incentive to exaggerate the economic benefits they claim.

That doesn't diminish the importance of those events. They don't need the hype.

Having lived in and around Boston my whole life, I can tell you that literally every bar and restaurant is PACKED the whole long weekend (again, the Monday is a state holiday here). The numbers are entirely believable to me. The race is also a huge event, so the jobs numbers make sense to me as well.

I suspect most of those 2,900 jobs are temporary (probably no more than a few weeks), not full time. But if they were full time (that is, they worked on the marathon 100% of their time for an entire year) that would mean their average salary was more than $70,000.

Let's say that there are 2,000 temps at $20 an hour, 3 weeks at 40 hours a week. The other 900 employees (and I find it hard to believe that there are that many permanent full time employees working exclusively on the Boston Marathon) would have to average $222,000 a year salary to get to $206 million.

How many year round full time employees does it take to organize and run the Boston Marathon once a year?

Not a lot but more then you'd think. It's not just the events in the Boston area either, there are dozens of smaller races across the country that serve as qualification races for Boston. Any place with a decent flat paved hiking or walking trail, or a downtown area that can be successfully closed off could technically serve this role, or if it is held on a college or university campus, you don't necessarily need one with a $1 Billion stadium or arena either, technically any place with a decent cross country course would probably count.

https://racecast.io/discover/boston-qualifying-races
02-21-2026 11:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,890
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #38
RE: Marathons bigger than Super Bowl
(02-17-2026 10:30 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 05:56 PM)e-parade Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 04:45 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 03:47 PM)e-parade Wrote:  I have to assume if you're questioning the numbers reported by the BAA that you would similarly question the ones brought up by the super bowl committees that put out the numbers (who are also local groups that do everything they can to show why they should support hosting these events).

Not only would I question the numbers brought up by super bowl committees, I explicitly did. I said the real numbers would be about half of what they claim. And, as I have demonstrated, that's true also for the Boston Marathon.

What I don't get is why should the BAA claim those exaggerated numbers? It's not like the event wouldn't be held, or would be less important and iconic, if they only claimed $250 million in economic benefits instead of $500 million. Is it an ego thing?

Okay cool. Here's a long post along the lines for what I was doing to show my own calculations:

However your demonstration was only looking at 187,000 people as opposed to the full 500,000. 250,000 stayed overnight for an average of 3 days, and 250,000 were day trippers. The day trippers spent an average of $125 per person, which is $31 million in additional revenue.

The additional ~60000 who spent time overnight in and around Boston also spent money both staying there and buying other things.

Also, the median stay was 3 nights for all those who did stay, meaning half were less and half more, but no real number to say it the mean was higher or lower, so lets go with a flat 3. 53% of the spectators stayed overnight, with 43% of those being paid. So 10% didn't pay for lodging, but were included in the rest of the group for "additional spending." 55% who stayed did so in Boston itself.

137,000 stayed in Boston, average of $500 per person on non-lodging:
$68.75 million on non-lodging spending in Boston

113,000 stayed just outside of Boston, an average of $200 per person in non lodging spend: $22.6 million

Non-lodging spending across just the group of spectators (not runners and not day trippers) is about $90 million. (90.35)

I don't believe it breaks down where people stayed when they were staying with friends, so I split it evenly. So removing 25,000 (10% of the 250,000 who stayed stayed with friends) from the total number (12500 from each group) we get:

124,500 paid to stay in Boston
101,500 paid to stay outside of Boston

Average group size was 3 in each instance, but no idea if that means 3 to a room or some split of separate rooms, but lets just divide by 3.

41500 rooms in Boston
33833 rooms outside of Boston

41500*3 (number of nights stayed in Boston): 124500
32833*3 (number of nights stayed outside): 101500

124,500 * 429 (median nightly rate in Boston): $53.41 million
101500 * 250 (median nightly rate outside Boston): $25.38 million

Total lodging for spectators: $88.8 million

Total spend for spectators who stayed: $179.15 million

250,000 spectators who didn't spend the night reportedly spent $125 on average for the day trip: $31.25 million

34000 participants in one (or more) of the races.

68% stayed in Boston
20% stayed outside Boston
12% day trippers

23120 stayed in Boston for an average of 3 days ($429/night): $29.76 million

6800 stayed outside for an average of 3 days ($250/night): $5.1 million

Total lodging cost for participants: $34.86 million

They said the same spending patterns and whatnot happened for participants as well, so:

23120 * $500 = $11.56 million
6800 * $200 = $1.36 million

Total additional spending from participants: $47.78 million


Total spending across participants and spectators: $258.18 million



The reality is probably going to fall somewhere between the $218 million you calculated and this $258 million number. They raised it through "economic ripple effect" calculations, among other things (like BAA direct spending on advertising and such). The "ripple effect" likely has to do with calculations based on increased spending from the people who got increased wages from the increased labor spending.


For the labor spending numbers, you came up with $27 million. The BAA broke it down as:

BAA Specific:
Full time employees: $5.5 million (you were pretty close on this one actually)
Contractors & Consultants: $16 million
Office Space: $1.8 million
Advertising: $4.96 million
Payments to local governments for support: $6 million
Payments for warehouse, utilities, charitable support and other: $2.2 million.

So BAA specific labor costs are $36.46 million. This is apparently spread across 225 specific jobs in Suffolk county (where Boston is) and another 75 in the rest of the state.

They then mention an additional 1675 jobs (they count them as "Job years") within Suffolk county, and 925 outside of Suffolk county. I'm not sure what those jobs entail, because they don't go into much detail. But this is where I could agree with you on how to deal with the data. They mention, of the jobs created, 1800 are "direct" (meaning hired specifically and basically only for marathon purposes), and the rest are "indirect" or "induced" jobs.


But we know that the bare minimum is $34.46 million in labor costs for the BAA numbers that are spelled out. You estimated another $27 million. So if we add those together it gets to $61.46 million. Still a far way away, so I'm interested in seeing what else isn't being accounted for (police OT could be underestimated as well. There was a report that around 100 Boston police officers made at least $380K a year with some over half a million, for instance).



As for why fluff? It's the same kinds of people doing the same kinds of surveys everywhere. They use the same methods and will come up with the same added numbers on top. Don't think it's an ego thing so much as it's a "this is just how this industry works" thing. If you want to take all the given numbers and multiply by 0.6 to get what seems more right, that's fair for you to want to do. But I think we're on the same page overall here.
Since Table 16 shows number of persons per party, is the spending per individual or per party? How were spectators selected for the spectator survey? How was the estimated 500,000 spectators determined?

When I went, I went with a tour group. There were about 15 of us. But I imagine most people did the trip on their own. The daughter of a friend ran it a couple of years ago and the two parents and the daughter went, so that was 3 for 1 runner.

And many people make it a trip. I stayed a few days afterwards in the area.
(This post was last modified: 02-23-2026 12:09 PM by bullet.)
02-23-2026 12:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.