(02-16-2026 04:45 PM)ken d Wrote: (02-16-2026 03:47 PM)e-parade Wrote: I have to assume if you're questioning the numbers reported by the BAA that you would similarly question the ones brought up by the super bowl committees that put out the numbers (who are also local groups that do everything they can to show why they should support hosting these events).
Not only would I question the numbers brought up by super bowl committees, I explicitly did. I said the real numbers would be about half of what they claim. And, as I have demonstrated, that's true also for the Boston Marathon.
What I don't get is why should the BAA claim those exaggerated numbers? It's not like the event wouldn't be held, or would be less important and iconic, if they only claimed $250 million in economic benefits instead of $500 million. Is it an ego thing?
Okay cool. Here's a long post along the lines for what I was doing to show my own calculations:
However your demonstration was only looking at 187,000 people as opposed to the full 500,000. 250,000 stayed overnight for an average of 3 days, and 250,000 were day trippers. The day trippers spent an average of $125 per person, which is $31 million in additional revenue.
The additional ~60000 who spent time overnight in and around Boston also spent money both staying there and buying other things.
Also, the median stay was 3 nights for all those who did stay, meaning half were less and half more, but no real number to say it the mean was higher or lower, so lets go with a flat 3. 53% of the spectators stayed overnight, with 43% of those being paid. So 10% didn't pay for lodging, but were included in the rest of the group for "additional spending." 55% who stayed did so in Boston itself.
137,000 stayed in Boston, average of $500 per person on non-lodging:
$68.75 million on non-lodging spending in Boston
113,000 stayed just outside of Boston, an average of $200 per person in non lodging spend: $22.6 million
Non-lodging spending across just the group of spectators (not runners and not day trippers) is about $90 million. (90.35)
I don't believe it breaks down where people stayed when they were staying with friends, so I split it evenly. So removing 25,000 (10% of the 250,000 who stayed stayed with friends) from the total number (12500 from each group) we get:
124,500 paid to stay in Boston
101,500 paid to stay outside of Boston
Average group size was 3 in each instance, but no idea if that means 3 to a room or some split of separate rooms, but lets just divide by 3.
41500 rooms in Boston
33833 rooms outside of Boston
41500*3 (number of nights stayed in Boston): 124500
32833*3 (number of nights stayed outside): 101500
124,500 * 429 (median nightly rate in Boston): $53.41 million
101500 * 250 (median nightly rate outside Boston): $25.38 million
Total lodging for spectators: $88.8 million
Total spend for spectators who stayed:
$179.15 million
250,000 spectators who didn't spend the night reportedly spent $125 on average for the day trip:
$31.25 million
34000 participants in one (or more) of the races.
68% stayed in Boston
20% stayed outside Boston
12% day trippers
23120 stayed in Boston for an average of 3 days ($429/night): $29.76 million
6800 stayed outside for an average of 3 days ($250/night): $5.1 million
Total lodging cost for participants:
$34.86 million
They said the same spending patterns and whatnot happened for participants as well, so:
23120 * $500 = $11.56 million
6800 * $200 = $1.36 million
Total additional spending from participants:
$47.78 million
Total spending across participants and spectators:
$258.18 million
The reality is probably going to fall somewhere between the $218 million you calculated and this $258 million number. They raised it through "economic ripple effect" calculations, among other things (like BAA direct spending on advertising and such). The "ripple effect" likely has to do with calculations based on increased spending from the people who got increased wages from the increased labor spending.
For the labor spending numbers, you came up with $27 million. The BAA broke it down as:
BAA Specific:
Full time employees: $5.5 million (you were pretty close on this one actually)
Contractors & Consultants: $16 million
Office Space: $1.8 million
Advertising: $4.96 million
Payments to local governments for support: $6 million
Payments for warehouse, utilities, charitable support and other: $2.2 million.
So BAA specific labor costs are $36.46 million. This is apparently spread across 225 specific jobs in Suffolk county (where Boston is) and another 75 in the rest of the state.
They then mention an additional 1675 jobs (they count them as "Job years") within Suffolk county, and 925 outside of Suffolk county. I'm not sure what those jobs entail, because they don't go into much detail. But this is where I could agree with you on how to deal with the data. They mention, of the jobs created, 1800 are "direct" (meaning hired specifically and basically only for marathon purposes), and the rest are "indirect" or "induced" jobs.
But we know that the bare minimum is $34.46 million in labor costs for the BAA numbers that are spelled out. You estimated another $27 million. So if we add those together it gets to
$61.46 million. Still a far way away, so I'm interested in seeing what else isn't being accounted for (police OT could be underestimated as well. There was a report that around 100 Boston police officers made at least $380K a year with some over half a million, for instance).
As for why fluff? It's the same kinds of people doing the same kinds of surveys everywhere. They use the same methods and will come up with the same added numbers on top. Don't think it's an ego thing so much as it's a "this is just how this industry works" thing. If you want to take all the given numbers and multiply by 0.6 to get what seems more right, that's fair for you to want to do. But I think we're on the same page overall here.