Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
Author Message
Scoochpooch1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,779
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 255
I Root For: P4
Location:
Post: #101
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-17-2026 01:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:25 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 11:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 10:19 AM)RUScarlets Wrote:  If a 13th game is added, it would explain starting the 1st round of the playoff week 2 instead of week 1. However, Army Navy would be in jeopardy.

I don't see a 13th game. They are adding playoff games that add more value and the players will start to balk at extra games. They really do need the two off weeks.

Then the first weekend isn't monetized, so I am just not sure what the solution is. I like moving the season deeper into January and playing the Rd of 16 all the way into NYD, but then you have to play cold weather games in the middle of Jan for QFs and SFs.

I am sure the SEC is receptive to the 23+1, but scheduling wise, it just doesn't work as cleanly as 16 with two play-ins.

I seriously doubt the SEC is receptive to the 23+1. Sankey hasn't indicated support for any model other than 16. How deep the season runs, byes, when the season starts, and protecting the regular season are all part of his agenda. The larger the playoff grows the less meaningful the regular season is and the SEC is winning the regular season ratings wise hands down. If December is used in a 16-team playoff model then the 16 will pared down to 8, and 8 to 4 before New Years. The Semis played on New Year's while only utilizing 2 Major Bowls and then another a week or so later for the finals the use of a third major bowl, would be an exclusive enough opportunity to raise the bids the bowls will place to carry those games.

16 is the Sweet Spot. It allows for a regular season without disruptions, allows for the CCG, and leaves two weekends the 2nd and 3rd in December for Rd 1 and 2 of the playoffs, and it leaves New Year's two meaningful games while finishing the season around the same time that it currently ends.

I don't see any possibility of the SEC agreeing to 23 +1. If the Big 10 wants to use Conference Semifinals to boost their revenue the winners would be helped by the extra games, the losers hurt by them, but they could do that if not attached to the NCAA which hasn't approved conference semis.

Hes right about the regular season but hasn't that ship sailed already? You can be 9-3 and make CFP now. Thats no different than 8-4, thats why I propose a giant playoff since Sept-Nov means nothing anymore.
In the 2 years of 12 teams, the true* higher seeds have been completely outmatched thus far. (* - true meaning Boise State, etc were given the wrong seeding in 2024).
02-18-2026 09:38 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13523
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #102
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-18-2026 09:38 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:25 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 11:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 10:19 AM)RUScarlets Wrote:  If a 13th game is added, it would explain starting the 1st round of the playoff week 2 instead of week 1. However, Army Navy would be in jeopardy.

I don't see a 13th game. They are adding playoff games that add more value and the players will start to balk at extra games. They really do need the two off weeks.

Then the first weekend isn't monetized, so I am just not sure what the solution is. I like moving the season deeper into January and playing the Rd of 16 all the way into NYD, but then you have to play cold weather games in the middle of Jan for QFs and SFs.

I am sure the SEC is receptive to the 23+1, but scheduling wise, it just doesn't work as cleanly as 16 with two play-ins.

I seriously doubt the SEC is receptive to the 23+1. Sankey hasn't indicated support for any model other than 16. How deep the season runs, byes, when the season starts, and protecting the regular season are all part of his agenda. The larger the playoff grows the less meaningful the regular season is and the SEC is winning the regular season ratings wise hands down. If December is used in a 16-team playoff model then the 16 will pared down to 8, and 8 to 4 before New Years. The Semis played on New Year's while only utilizing 2 Major Bowls and then another a week or so later for the finals the use of a third major bowl, would be an exclusive enough opportunity to raise the bids the bowls will place to carry those games.

16 is the Sweet Spot. It allows for a regular season without disruptions, allows for the CCG, and leaves two weekends the 2nd and 3rd in December for Rd 1 and 2 of the playoffs, and it leaves New Year's two meaningful games while finishing the season around the same time that it currently ends.

I don't see any possibility of the SEC agreeing to 23 +1. If the Big 10 wants to use Conference Semifinals to boost their revenue the winners would be helped by the extra games, the losers hurt by them, but they could do that if not attached to the NCAA which hasn't approved conference semis.

Hes right about the regular season but hasn't that ship sailed already? You can be 9-3 and make CFP now. Thats no different than 8-4, thats why I propose a giant playoff since Sept-Nov means nothing anymore.
In the 2 years of 12 teams, the true* higher seeds have been completely outmatched thus far. (* - true meaning Boise State, etc were given the wrong seeding in 2024).

The SEC won't be going for it. And they'll keep the CCG. The CCG keeps the conference play relevant for the SEC.

This is precisely why the commissioners have to be the guardians of the game and not networks execs. The network execs have no clue as to what the heartbeat of college football has been, what made it different from the NFL and what kept it great. And they haven't fully grasped that the overlap of fans between the NFL and College ball are not coincident and that the overlap is more 60/40 with the 60 being those who watch both and the 40 being those who watch only college football and the majority of those are in the Southeast and Southwest.

There's a reason why when the Big Ten the first year of its new contract earned 11 million more in media revenue, they earned 5.5 million less on average payouts for all sports revenue streams than did the SEC. And now that the SEC will be within 2 million of the Big 10 plus or minus in media revenue that advantage in all other revenue, primarily gate where the SEC averages 11,000 more per game than the Big 10 is going to be big, think around 15 million more in total revenue on average.

Sankey is not going to compromise the interest that drives regular season attendance. He has his regular season and CCG squared away and they produce annually, not sporadically. That's why 16 is his compromise. That week was already included with the first-round byes. To him there is no difference between 12 with 4 byes and 16 since both playout over the same period of time.

Furthermore, if the Big Ten can't or won't agree to the use of contracts and bargaining, he's been given presidential approval to breakaway and that 2 years ago.

The need of the Big Ten to jazz interest by keeping more schools relevant later in the season is a Big Ten issue and it's not pertinent to what is best for the SEC.
02-18-2026 10:00 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #103
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-18-2026 08:54 AM)RUScarlets Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 07:49 AM)Crayton Wrote:  It may have just been a fellow board member, but I feel like I remember a reporter saying the 4-team play-in round would not feature CCG teams. That is the way it ‘should’ be done, whether or not it actually is done that way.

I've advocated for such, but I don't know how that works in practice. Maybe a team ranked top 15 has a CFP spot secured even if it loses a CCG?

Maybe a team 16 or below must opt out of a CCG to play in a play-in game? Then what happens to that conference's CCG?

What if a #20 ACC team beats a #6 ACC team in a CCG? Then, you need to open a spot for the #20 ACC team.

So... the play-in games have to be seeded after all of the CCGs are played. Is it as simple as seeding the last four At-Larges that did not play a CCG? Maybe, but it is not clear cut to me, especially when involving schools ranked #16-20 that may have already played a CCG.

Right, you can’t set a rank threshold for CCG losers because the number of AQ teams above/below that line won’t always be the same. You either need to set the number of CG losers ‘or’ seed after the CCGs.

I think if there are only 2 play-in games you can just set the field to include 3 CG losers (conceivably, a 2nd G6 could qualify for one of these spots). I’d add a rule that would reduce it to 2 under certain pre-CCG conditions, but that begins to violate the KISS principle.

I think I was recalling our conversation. Just message board chatter I guess.
(This post was last modified: 02-18-2026 05:27 PM by Crayton.)
02-18-2026 05:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #104
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-18-2026 10:00 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 09:38 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:25 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 11:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  I don't see a 13th game. They are adding playoff games that add more value and the players will start to balk at extra games. They really do need the two off weeks.

Then the first weekend isn't monetized, so I am just not sure what the solution is. I like moving the season deeper into January and playing the Rd of 16 all the way into NYD, but then you have to play cold weather games in the middle of Jan for QFs and SFs.

I am sure the SEC is receptive to the 23+1, but scheduling wise, it just doesn't work as cleanly as 16 with two play-ins.

I seriously doubt the SEC is receptive to the 23+1. Sankey hasn't indicated support for any model other than 16. How deep the season runs, byes, when the season starts, and protecting the regular season are all part of his agenda. The larger the playoff grows the less meaningful the regular season is and the SEC is winning the regular season ratings wise hands down. If December is used in a 16-team playoff model then the 16 will pared down to 8, and 8 to 4 before New Years. The Semis played on New Year's while only utilizing 2 Major Bowls and then another a week or so later for the finals the use of a third major bowl, would be an exclusive enough opportunity to raise the bids the bowls will place to carry those games.

16 is the Sweet Spot. It allows for a regular season without disruptions, allows for the CCG, and leaves two weekends the 2nd and 3rd in December for Rd 1 and 2 of the playoffs, and it leaves New Year's two meaningful games while finishing the season around the same time that it currently ends.

I don't see any possibility of the SEC agreeing to 23 +1. If the Big 10 wants to use Conference Semifinals to boost their revenue the winners would be helped by the extra games, the losers hurt by them, but they could do that if not attached to the NCAA which hasn't approved conference semis.

Hes right about the regular season but hasn't that ship sailed already? You can be 9-3 and make CFP now. Thats no different than 8-4, thats why I propose a giant playoff since Sept-Nov means nothing anymore.
In the 2 years of 12 teams, the true* higher seeds have been completely outmatched thus far. (* - true meaning Boise State, etc were given the wrong seeding in 2024).

The SEC won't be going for it. And they'll keep the CCG. The CCG keeps the conference play relevant for the SEC.

This is precisely why the commissioners have to be the guardians of the game and not networks execs. The network execs have no clue as to what the heartbeat of college football has been, what made it different from the NFL and what kept it great. And they haven't fully grasped that the overlap of fans between the NFL and College ball are not coincident and that the overlap is more 60/40 with the 60 being those who watch both and the 40 being those who watch only college football and the majority of those are in the Southeast and Southwest.

There's a reason why when the Big Ten the first year of its new contract earned 11 million more in media revenue, they earned 5.5 million less on average payouts for all sports revenue streams than did the SEC. And now that the SEC will be within 2 million of the Big 10 plus or minus in media revenue that advantage in all other revenue, primarily gate where the SEC averages 11,000 more per game than the Big 10 is going to be big, think around 15 million more in total revenue on average.

Sankey is not going to compromise the interest that drives regular season attendance. He has his regular season and CCG squared away and they produce annually, not sporadically. That's why 16 is his compromise. That week was already included with the first-round byes. To him there is no difference between 12 with 4 byes and 16 since both playout over the same period of time.

Furthermore, if the Big Ten can't or won't agree to the use of contracts and bargaining, he's been given presidential approval to breakaway and that 2 years ago.

The need of the Big Ten to jazz interest by keeping more schools relevant later in the season is a Big Ten issue and it's not pertinent to what is best for the SEC.
The CFP should be converted to a Tournament of Champions, with the SEC and B1G champions entering in the semifinal. The SEC would control their playoffs, with either six or eight teams. SOS would not matter, since conference standings would solely determine who entered the playoffs. The SEC could even go to ten conference games.

The regular season would remain interesting, since it would determine the playoff seedings and home fields for the first couple of rounds. The championship could be played in the Sugar Bowl, Cotton Bowl, or Peach Bowl, with conference semifinals in New Orleans, Arlington, or Atlanta, or Nashville or Houston. The SEC could go back to divisions since ordinary fans will be able to understand the playoffs. It would not matter if the best two teams were in one division, since they could be seeded into opposite sides of the bracket.
02-19-2026 07:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #105
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-18-2026 10:00 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 09:38 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:25 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 11:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  I don't see a 13th game. They are adding playoff games that add more value and the players will start to balk at extra games. They really do need the two off weeks.

Then the first weekend isn't monetized, so I am just not sure what the solution is. I like moving the season deeper into January and playing the Rd of 16 all the way into NYD, but then you have to play cold weather games in the middle of Jan for QFs and SFs.

I am sure the SEC is receptive to the 23+1, but scheduling wise, it just doesn't work as cleanly as 16 with two play-ins.

I seriously doubt the SEC is receptive to the 23+1. Sankey hasn't indicated support for any model other than 16. How deep the season runs, byes, when the season starts, and protecting the regular season are all part of his agenda. The larger the playoff grows the less meaningful the regular season is and the SEC is winning the regular season ratings wise hands down. If December is used in a 16-team playoff model then the 16 will pared down to 8, and 8 to 4 before New Years. The Semis played on New Year's while only utilizing 2 Major Bowls and then another a week or so later for the finals the use of a third major bowl, would be an exclusive enough opportunity to raise the bids the bowls will place to carry those games.

16 is the Sweet Spot. It allows for a regular season without disruptions, allows for the CCG, and leaves two weekends the 2nd and 3rd in December for Rd 1 and 2 of the playoffs, and it leaves New Year's two meaningful games while finishing the season around the same time that it currently ends.

I don't see any possibility of the SEC agreeing to 23 +1. If the Big 10 wants to use Conference Semifinals to boost their revenue the winners would be helped by the extra games, the losers hurt by them, but they could do that if not attached to the NCAA which hasn't approved conference semis.

Hes right about the regular season but hasn't that ship sailed already? You can be 9-3 and make CFP now. Thats no different than 8-4, thats why I propose a giant playoff since Sept-Nov means nothing anymore.
In the 2 years of 12 teams, the true* higher seeds have been completely outmatched thus far. (* - true meaning Boise State, etc were given the wrong seeding in 2024).

The SEC won't be going for it. And they'll keep the CCG. The CCG keeps the conference play relevant for the SEC.

This is precisely why the commissioners have to be the guardians of the game and not networks execs. The network execs have no clue as to what the heartbeat of college football has been, what made it different from the NFL and what kept it great. And they haven't fully grasped that the overlap of fans between the NFL and College ball are not coincident and that the overlap is more 60/40 with the 60 being those who watch both and the 40 being those who watch only college football and the majority of those are in the Southeast and Southwest.

There's a reason why when the Big Ten the first year of its new contract earned 11 million more in media revenue, they earned 5.5 million less on average payouts for all sports revenue streams than did the SEC. And now that the SEC will be within 2 million of the Big 10 plus or minus in media revenue that advantage in all other revenue, primarily gate where the SEC averages 11,000 more per game than the Big 10 is going to be big, think around 15 million more in total revenue on average.

Sankey is not going to compromise the interest that drives regular season attendance. He has his regular season and CCG squared away and they produce annually, not sporadically. That's why 16 is his compromise. That week was already included with the first-round byes. To him there is no difference between 12 with 4 byes and 16 since both playout over the same period of time.

Furthermore, if the Big Ten can't or won't agree to the use of contracts and bargaining, he's been given presidential approval to breakaway and that 2 years ago.

The need of the Big Ten to jazz interest by keeping more schools relevant later in the season is a Big Ten issue and it's not pertinent to what is best for the SEC.

If the B1G doesn't get this way on this maybe they should add 8-10 teams from the SEC until they are the only ones making the decisions.

05-stirthepot
02-19-2026 09:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13523
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #106
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-19-2026 09:20 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 10:00 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 09:38 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:25 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  Then the first weekend isn't monetized, so I am just not sure what the solution is. I like moving the season deeper into January and playing the Rd of 16 all the way into NYD, but then you have to play cold weather games in the middle of Jan for QFs and SFs.

I am sure the SEC is receptive to the 23+1, but scheduling wise, it just doesn't work as cleanly as 16 with two play-ins.

I seriously doubt the SEC is receptive to the 23+1. Sankey hasn't indicated support for any model other than 16. How deep the season runs, byes, when the season starts, and protecting the regular season are all part of his agenda. The larger the playoff grows the less meaningful the regular season is and the SEC is winning the regular season ratings wise hands down. If December is used in a 16-team playoff model then the 16 will pared down to 8, and 8 to 4 before New Years. The Semis played on New Year's while only utilizing 2 Major Bowls and then another a week or so later for the finals the use of a third major bowl, would be an exclusive enough opportunity to raise the bids the bowls will place to carry those games.

16 is the Sweet Spot. It allows for a regular season without disruptions, allows for the CCG, and leaves two weekends the 2nd and 3rd in December for Rd 1 and 2 of the playoffs, and it leaves New Year's two meaningful games while finishing the season around the same time that it currently ends.

I don't see any possibility of the SEC agreeing to 23 +1. If the Big 10 wants to use Conference Semifinals to boost their revenue the winners would be helped by the extra games, the losers hurt by them, but they could do that if not attached to the NCAA which hasn't approved conference semis.

Hes right about the regular season but hasn't that ship sailed already? You can be 9-3 and make CFP now. Thats no different than 8-4, thats why I propose a giant playoff since Sept-Nov means nothing anymore.
In the 2 years of 12 teams, the true* higher seeds have been completely outmatched thus far. (* - true meaning Boise State, etc were given the wrong seeding in 2024).

The SEC won't be going for it. And they'll keep the CCG. The CCG keeps the conference play relevant for the SEC.

This is precisely why the commissioners have to be the guardians of the game and not networks execs. The network execs have no clue as to what the heartbeat of college football has been, what made it different from the NFL and what kept it great. And they haven't fully grasped that the overlap of fans between the NFL and College ball are not coincident and that the overlap is more 60/40 with the 60 being those who watch both and the 40 being those who watch only college football and the majority of those are in the Southeast and Southwest.

There's a reason why when the Big Ten the first year of its new contract earned 11 million more in media revenue, they earned 5.5 million less on average payouts for all sports revenue streams than did the SEC. And now that the SEC will be within 2 million of the Big 10 plus or minus in media revenue that advantage in all other revenue, primarily gate where the SEC averages 11,000 more per game than the Big 10 is going to be big, think around 15 million more in total revenue on average.

Sankey is not going to compromise the interest that drives regular season attendance. He has his regular season and CCG squared away and they produce annually, not sporadically. That's why 16 is his compromise. That week was already included with the first-round byes. To him there is no difference between 12 with 4 byes and 16 since both playout over the same period of time.

Furthermore, if the Big Ten can't or won't agree to the use of contracts and bargaining, he's been given presidential approval to breakaway and that 2 years ago.

The need of the Big Ten to jazz interest by keeping more schools relevant later in the season is a Big Ten issue and it's not pertinent to what is best for the SEC.

If the B1G doesn't get this way on this maybe they should add 8-10 teams from the SEC until they are the only ones making the decisions.

05-stirthepot

LOL! The SEC makes more revenue and is going to be very close to making more media money. I suspect both will do their own thing and the networks will keep upping the ante for a super league and then perhaps something happens that nobody likes. It seems more likely than anyone would like to think.
02-19-2026 10:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AllTideUp Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,744
Joined: Jul 2015
Reputation: 903
I Root For: Alabama & Cincinnati
Location:
Post: #107
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-18-2026 10:00 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 09:38 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:25 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 11:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  I don't see a 13th game. They are adding playoff games that add more value and the players will start to balk at extra games. They really do need the two off weeks.

Then the first weekend isn't monetized, so I am just not sure what the solution is. I like moving the season deeper into January and playing the Rd of 16 all the way into NYD, but then you have to play cold weather games in the middle of Jan for QFs and SFs.

I am sure the SEC is receptive to the 23+1, but scheduling wise, it just doesn't work as cleanly as 16 with two play-ins.

I seriously doubt the SEC is receptive to the 23+1. Sankey hasn't indicated support for any model other than 16. How deep the season runs, byes, when the season starts, and protecting the regular season are all part of his agenda. The larger the playoff grows the less meaningful the regular season is and the SEC is winning the regular season ratings wise hands down. If December is used in a 16-team playoff model then the 16 will pared down to 8, and 8 to 4 before New Years. The Semis played on New Year's while only utilizing 2 Major Bowls and then another a week or so later for the finals the use of a third major bowl, would be an exclusive enough opportunity to raise the bids the bowls will place to carry those games.

16 is the Sweet Spot. It allows for a regular season without disruptions, allows for the CCG, and leaves two weekends the 2nd and 3rd in December for Rd 1 and 2 of the playoffs, and it leaves New Year's two meaningful games while finishing the season around the same time that it currently ends.

I don't see any possibility of the SEC agreeing to 23 +1. If the Big 10 wants to use Conference Semifinals to boost their revenue the winners would be helped by the extra games, the losers hurt by them, but they could do that if not attached to the NCAA which hasn't approved conference semis.

Hes right about the regular season but hasn't that ship sailed already? You can be 9-3 and make CFP now. Thats no different than 8-4, thats why I propose a giant playoff since Sept-Nov means nothing anymore.
In the 2 years of 12 teams, the true* higher seeds have been completely outmatched thus far. (* - true meaning Boise State, etc were given the wrong seeding in 2024).

The SEC won't be going for it. And they'll keep the CCG. The CCG keeps the conference play relevant for the SEC.

This is precisely why the commissioners have to be the guardians of the game and not networks execs. The network execs have no clue as to what the heartbeat of college football has been, what made it different from the NFL and what kept it great. And they haven't fully grasped that the overlap of fans between the NFL and College ball are not coincident and that the overlap is more 60/40 with the 60 being those who watch both and the 40 being those who watch only college football and the majority of those are in the Southeast and Southwest.

There's a reason why when the Big Ten the first year of its new contract earned 11 million more in media revenue, they earned 5.5 million less on average payouts for all sports revenue streams than did the SEC. And now that the SEC will be within 2 million of the Big 10 plus or minus in media revenue that advantage in all other revenue, primarily gate where the SEC averages 11,000 more per game than the Big 10 is going to be big, think around 15 million more in total revenue on average.

Sankey is not going to compromise the interest that drives regular season attendance. He has his regular season and CCG squared away and they produce annually, not sporadically. That's why 16 is his compromise. That week was already included with the first-round byes. To him there is no difference between 12 with 4 byes and 16 since both playout over the same period of time.

Furthermore, if the Big Ten can't or won't agree to the use of contracts and bargaining, he's been given presidential approval to breakaway and that 2 years ago.

The need of the Big Ten to jazz interest by keeping more schools relevant later in the season is a Big Ten issue and it's not pertinent to what is best for the SEC.

The SEC Championship Game is a very special event. The SEC was the 1st league at the FBS level to create divisions and have a title game. It was a stroke of genius and helped define postseason play for all of FBS since 1992.

Add to that, it's also by far the most profitable conference championship game. It's always a hot ticket and there's a great deal of fanfare around the week of the game. You can't put a simple price tag on that. The SEC has no reason to give that up and increasing the playoff size only dilutes it further than it already has been. I believe Sankey has been pretty direct on this matter. The SEC title game is not on the table.

Even if it was on the table, the idea of a 24 team playoff replacing the SECCG revenue is a bit silly. The CFP doesn't need to replace the SECCG revenue, it would need to significantly exceed it. Otherwise, what is the motivation to move away from it?

It's a great event and an incredible showcase for the SEC. If the SEC becomes independent from the NCAA then I look forward to the SEC title game being an even more significant event.

There are numerous issues with the 24 team setup and relegating the conference title games to nothing more significant than your run of the mill conference basketball tournament is not the least.
02-20-2026 12:16 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
RUScarlets Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,717
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #108
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
What is clear is the SEC CCG is becoming the impediment that the Rose Bowl has been for decades in terms of blocking an expanded playoff. The SEC and ESPN want to control their little niche. The B1G eventually budged on the Rose Bowl, but it was like pulling teeth. 50% of Rose Bowl has since been democratized out for the rest of CFB and it has been relegated to a QF. The SEC will budge at some point, but it is just going to take a little while.
(This post was last modified: 02-20-2026 07:42 AM by RUScarlets.)
02-20-2026 07:37 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13523
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #109
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 12:16 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 10:00 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 09:38 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:25 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  Then the first weekend isn't monetized, so I am just not sure what the solution is. I like moving the season deeper into January and playing the Rd of 16 all the way into NYD, but then you have to play cold weather games in the middle of Jan for QFs and SFs.

I am sure the SEC is receptive to the 23+1, but scheduling wise, it just doesn't work as cleanly as 16 with two play-ins.

I seriously doubt the SEC is receptive to the 23+1. Sankey hasn't indicated support for any model other than 16. How deep the season runs, byes, when the season starts, and protecting the regular season are all part of his agenda. The larger the playoff grows the less meaningful the regular season is and the SEC is winning the regular season ratings wise hands down. If December is used in a 16-team playoff model then the 16 will pared down to 8, and 8 to 4 before New Years. The Semis played on New Year's while only utilizing 2 Major Bowls and then another a week or so later for the finals the use of a third major bowl, would be an exclusive enough opportunity to raise the bids the bowls will place to carry those games.

16 is the Sweet Spot. It allows for a regular season without disruptions, allows for the CCG, and leaves two weekends the 2nd and 3rd in December for Rd 1 and 2 of the playoffs, and it leaves New Year's two meaningful games while finishing the season around the same time that it currently ends.

I don't see any possibility of the SEC agreeing to 23 +1. If the Big 10 wants to use Conference Semifinals to boost their revenue the winners would be helped by the extra games, the losers hurt by them, but they could do that if not attached to the NCAA which hasn't approved conference semis.

Hes right about the regular season but hasn't that ship sailed already? You can be 9-3 and make CFP now. Thats no different than 8-4, thats why I propose a giant playoff since Sept-Nov means nothing anymore.
In the 2 years of 12 teams, the true* higher seeds have been completely outmatched thus far. (* - true meaning Boise State, etc were given the wrong seeding in 2024).

The SEC won't be going for it. And they'll keep the CCG. The CCG keeps the conference play relevant for the SEC.

This is precisely why the commissioners have to be the guardians of the game and not networks execs. The network execs have no clue as to what the heartbeat of college football has been, what made it different from the NFL and what kept it great. And they haven't fully grasped that the overlap of fans between the NFL and College ball are not coincident and that the overlap is more 60/40 with the 60 being those who watch both and the 40 being those who watch only college football and the majority of those are in the Southeast and Southwest.

There's a reason why when the Big Ten the first year of its new contract earned 11 million more in media revenue, they earned 5.5 million less on average payouts for all sports revenue streams than did the SEC. And now that the SEC will be within 2 million of the Big 10 plus or minus in media revenue that advantage in all other revenue, primarily gate where the SEC averages 11,000 more per game than the Big 10 is going to be big, think around 15 million more in total revenue on average.

Sankey is not going to compromise the interest that drives regular season attendance. He has his regular season and CCG squared away and they produce annually, not sporadically. That's why 16 is his compromise. That week was already included with the first-round byes. To him there is no difference between 12 with 4 byes and 16 since both playout over the same period of time.

Furthermore, if the Big Ten can't or won't agree to the use of contracts and bargaining, he's been given presidential approval to breakaway and that 2 years ago.

The need of the Big Ten to jazz interest by keeping more schools relevant later in the season is a Big Ten issue and it's not pertinent to what is best for the SEC.

The SEC Championship Game is a very special event. The SEC was the 1st league at the FBS level to create divisions and have a title game. It was a stroke of genius and helped define postseason play for all of FBS since 1992.

Add to that, it's also by far the most profitable conference championship game. It's always a hot ticket and there's a great deal of fanfare around the week of the game. You can't put a simple price tag on that. The SEC has no reason to give that up and increasing the playoff size only dilutes it further than it already has been. I believe Sankey has been pretty direct on this matter. The SEC title game is not on the table.

Even if it was on the table, the idea of a 24 team playoff replacing the SECCG revenue is a bit silly. The CFP doesn't need to replace the SECCG revenue, it would need to significantly exceed it. Otherwise, what is the motivation to move away from it?

It's a great event and an incredible showcase for the SEC. If the SEC becomes independent from the NCAA then I look forward to the SEC title game being an even more significant event.

There are numerous issues with the 24 team setup and relegating the conference title games to nothing more significant than your run of the mill conference basketball tournament is not the least.

If you grow the playoff to 24 then in 4 years time it will be 32, just like the damned NCAA basketball tournament it will be constant bracket creep.

All that happens at 24 is that the networks pay more for the semis and finals and pay the opening rounds like they would a T2 game on the regular schedule.

No thanks. Then realize that all of that revenue is split, and not equally and it's worse for all 4 conferences.

The Big Ten and SEC should breakaway (Big 12 and ACC should as well) and if the Big Ten wants play in games to the Big Ten Semis and CCG then so be it. If the SEC just wants conference semis and a CCG that's their business. Let the Big 12 and ACC do the same. Then let those 4 conferences' CCG game losers play the champs of the other conferences at their home venues for the Quarter finals. Re-seed after the Quarter Finals and play the semis and national championship game.

Each conference can maximize its revenue for its own championship by making it a play in affair with the quarter finals, and each conference will have 2 schools in the 8 team CFP with each champ getting a home game.

Trying to force all 4 into the same configuration outside of the Final 8 for the Title series is a fool's errand. They all have different needs and different circumstances. Let them use a system to determine their two representatives in the National Quarter Finals.
02-20-2026 09:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,900
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #110
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 07:37 AM)RUScarlets Wrote:  What is clear is the SEC CCG is becoming the impediment that the Rose Bowl has been for decades in terms of blocking an expanded playoff. The SEC and ESPN want to control their little niche. The B1G eventually budged on the Rose Bowl, but it was like pulling teeth. 50% of Rose Bowl has since been democratized out for the rest of CFB and it has been relegated to a QF. The SEC will budge at some point, but it is just going to take a little while.

The only impediments to an expanded playoff are the Big Ten and NFL.
02-20-2026 10:01 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,079
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #111
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 09:42 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-20-2026 12:16 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 10:00 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 09:38 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  I seriously doubt the SEC is receptive to the 23+1. Sankey hasn't indicated support for any model other than 16. How deep the season runs, byes, when the season starts, and protecting the regular season are all part of his agenda. The larger the playoff grows the less meaningful the regular season is and the SEC is winning the regular season ratings wise hands down. If December is used in a 16-team playoff model then the 16 will pared down to 8, and 8 to 4 before New Years. The Semis played on New Year's while only utilizing 2 Major Bowls and then another a week or so later for the finals the use of a third major bowl, would be an exclusive enough opportunity to raise the bids the bowls will place to carry those games.

16 is the Sweet Spot. It allows for a regular season without disruptions, allows for the CCG, and leaves two weekends the 2nd and 3rd in December for Rd 1 and 2 of the playoffs, and it leaves New Year's two meaningful games while finishing the season around the same time that it currently ends.

I don't see any possibility of the SEC agreeing to 23 +1. If the Big 10 wants to use Conference Semifinals to boost their revenue the winners would be helped by the extra games, the losers hurt by them, but they could do that if not attached to the NCAA which hasn't approved conference semis.

Hes right about the regular season but hasn't that ship sailed already? You can be 9-3 and make CFP now. Thats no different than 8-4, thats why I propose a giant playoff since Sept-Nov means nothing anymore.
In the 2 years of 12 teams, the true* higher seeds have been completely outmatched thus far. (* - true meaning Boise State, etc were given the wrong seeding in 2024).

The SEC won't be going for it. And they'll keep the CCG. The CCG keeps the conference play relevant for the SEC.

This is precisely why the commissioners have to be the guardians of the game and not networks execs. The network execs have no clue as to what the heartbeat of college football has been, what made it different from the NFL and what kept it great. And they haven't fully grasped that the overlap of fans between the NFL and College ball are not coincident and that the overlap is more 60/40 with the 60 being those who watch both and the 40 being those who watch only college football and the majority of those are in the Southeast and Southwest.

There's a reason why when the Big Ten the first year of its new contract earned 11 million more in media revenue, they earned 5.5 million less on average payouts for all sports revenue streams than did the SEC. And now that the SEC will be within 2 million of the Big 10 plus or minus in media revenue that advantage in all other revenue, primarily gate where the SEC averages 11,000 more per game than the Big 10 is going to be big, think around 15 million more in total revenue on average.

Sankey is not going to compromise the interest that drives regular season attendance. He has his regular season and CCG squared away and they produce annually, not sporadically. That's why 16 is his compromise. That week was already included with the first-round byes. To him there is no difference between 12 with 4 byes and 16 since both playout over the same period of time.

Furthermore, if the Big Ten can't or won't agree to the use of contracts and bargaining, he's been given presidential approval to breakaway and that 2 years ago.

The need of the Big Ten to jazz interest by keeping more schools relevant later in the season is a Big Ten issue and it's not pertinent to what is best for the SEC.

The SEC Championship Game is a very special event. The SEC was the 1st league at the FBS level to create divisions and have a title game. It was a stroke of genius and helped define postseason play for all of FBS since 1992.

Add to that, it's also by far the most profitable conference championship game. It's always a hot ticket and there's a great deal of fanfare around the week of the game. You can't put a simple price tag on that. The SEC has no reason to give that up and increasing the playoff size only dilutes it further than it already has been. I believe Sankey has been pretty direct on this matter. The SEC title game is not on the table.

Even if it was on the table, the idea of a 24 team playoff replacing the SECCG revenue is a bit silly. The CFP doesn't need to replace the SECCG revenue, it would need to significantly exceed it. Otherwise, what is the motivation to move away from it?

It's a great event and an incredible showcase for the SEC. If the SEC becomes independent from the NCAA then I look forward to the SEC title game being an even more significant event.

There are numerous issues with the 24 team setup and relegating the conference title games to nothing more significant than your run of the mill conference basketball tournament is not the least.

If you grow the playoff to 24 then in 4 years time it will be 32, just like the damned NCAA basketball tournament it will be constant bracket creep.

All that happens at 24 is that the networks pay more for the semis and finals and pay the opening rounds like they would a T2 game on the regular schedule.

No thanks. Then realize that all of that revenue is split, and not equally and it's worse for all 4 conferences.

The Big Ten and SEC should breakaway (Big 12 and ACC should as well) and if the Big Ten wants play in games to the Big Ten Semis and CCG then so be it. If the SEC just wants conference semis and a CCG that's their business. Let the Big 12 and ACC do the same. Then let those 4 conferences' CCG game losers play the champs of the other conferences at their home venues for the Quarter finals. Re-seed after the Quarter Finals and play the semis and national championship game.

Each conference can maximize its revenue for its own championship by making it a play in affair with the quarter finals, and each conference will have 2 schools in the 8 team CFP with each champ getting a home game.

Trying to force all 4 into the same configuration outside of the Final 8 for the Title series is a fool's errand. They all have different needs and different circumstances. Let them use a system to determine their two representatives in the National Quarter Finals.

Do you think the SEC would be okay with a conference tourney in FB followed by an 8 team national tournament where they can only get 2 teams? My guess is they'd demand it be a 4 champs + 4 at-large, which I think is reasonable, especially if ND is still operating as a quasi-Indy in this P4 breakaway. I think a 6 team conference tourney (maybe 7 teams depending on conference size) with the 4 champs guaranteed into an 8 team national tourney pretty decent. Having 4 at-large also incentivizes playing non-conference games within the P4 as there would be national seeding involved with the national tourney (keeps the committee involved) and structures the season like college basketball, but without the bloated tournaments.

Play a 12 game regular season schedule (maybe 13 with a G6 opponent to ensure 7 home games) with the regular season ending on Thanksgiving weekend. Conference tourney the first 3 weeks of December on campuses, except for maybe the CCG. The national tourney starts on New Years with the NY6 hosting the QFs and SFs (commissioners in charge want the bowls involved and they want QFs on New Years whether we agree with it or not). I'd say give the 4 conference champs their designated bowl (Orange, Sugar, Cotton, Rose), if that's possible. Maybe that results in seeding the champs 1-4 and the at-large 5-8 to perform and maybe reseed the semis based on rank to avoid the top 2 playing in the semis.

Bowl games can still be played between tourneys to help with the gap, but maybe have eligibility at 7 wins, use it based on conference standings, or just exclude conference tourney teams. Yeah, the calendar stays longer than it should and you may run into teams playing 18 or even 19 games (if 13 game RS) in a season, but maybe some organization of the postseason makes the length of the season more acceptable or tolerable with a 15 day conference tourney followed by the national tourney as opposed to the CFP lasting nearly 6 weeks by itself with additional 2 week layoff between CCGs and the first round of the CFP. Of course, the biggest hurdle of this format is can the P4 all agree with such a format as this? That, I do not know.
(This post was last modified: 02-20-2026 10:26 AM by GoBuckeyes1047.)
02-20-2026 10:26 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13523
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #112
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 10:26 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(02-20-2026 09:42 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-20-2026 12:16 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 10:00 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(02-18-2026 09:38 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  Hes right about the regular season but hasn't that ship sailed already? You can be 9-3 and make CFP now. Thats no different than 8-4, thats why I propose a giant playoff since Sept-Nov means nothing anymore.
In the 2 years of 12 teams, the true* higher seeds have been completely outmatched thus far. (* - true meaning Boise State, etc were given the wrong seeding in 2024).

The SEC won't be going for it. And they'll keep the CCG. The CCG keeps the conference play relevant for the SEC.

This is precisely why the commissioners have to be the guardians of the game and not networks execs. The network execs have no clue as to what the heartbeat of college football has been, what made it different from the NFL and what kept it great. And they haven't fully grasped that the overlap of fans between the NFL and College ball are not coincident and that the overlap is more 60/40 with the 60 being those who watch both and the 40 being those who watch only college football and the majority of those are in the Southeast and Southwest.

There's a reason why when the Big Ten the first year of its new contract earned 11 million more in media revenue, they earned 5.5 million less on average payouts for all sports revenue streams than did the SEC. And now that the SEC will be within 2 million of the Big 10 plus or minus in media revenue that advantage in all other revenue, primarily gate where the SEC averages 11,000 more per game than the Big 10 is going to be big, think around 15 million more in total revenue on average.

Sankey is not going to compromise the interest that drives regular season attendance. He has his regular season and CCG squared away and they produce annually, not sporadically. That's why 16 is his compromise. That week was already included with the first-round byes. To him there is no difference between 12 with 4 byes and 16 since both playout over the same period of time.

Furthermore, if the Big Ten can't or won't agree to the use of contracts and bargaining, he's been given presidential approval to breakaway and that 2 years ago.

The need of the Big Ten to jazz interest by keeping more schools relevant later in the season is a Big Ten issue and it's not pertinent to what is best for the SEC.

The SEC Championship Game is a very special event. The SEC was the 1st league at the FBS level to create divisions and have a title game. It was a stroke of genius and helped define postseason play for all of FBS since 1992.

Add to that, it's also by far the most profitable conference championship game. It's always a hot ticket and there's a great deal of fanfare around the week of the game. You can't put a simple price tag on that. The SEC has no reason to give that up and increasing the playoff size only dilutes it further than it already has been. I believe Sankey has been pretty direct on this matter. The SEC title game is not on the table.

Even if it was on the table, the idea of a 24 team playoff replacing the SECCG revenue is a bit silly. The CFP doesn't need to replace the SECCG revenue, it would need to significantly exceed it. Otherwise, what is the motivation to move away from it?

It's a great event and an incredible showcase for the SEC. If the SEC becomes independent from the NCAA then I look forward to the SEC title game being an even more significant event.

There are numerous issues with the 24 team setup and relegating the conference title games to nothing more significant than your run of the mill conference basketball tournament is not the least.

If you grow the playoff to 24 then in 4 years time it will be 32, just like the damned NCAA basketball tournament it will be constant bracket creep.

All that happens at 24 is that the networks pay more for the semis and finals and pay the opening rounds like they would a T2 game on the regular schedule.

No thanks. Then realize that all of that revenue is split, and not equally and it's worse for all 4 conferences.

The Big Ten and SEC should breakaway (Big 12 and ACC should as well) and if the Big Ten wants play in games to the Big Ten Semis and CCG then so be it. If the SEC just wants conference semis and a CCG that's their business. Let the Big 12 and ACC do the same. Then let those 4 conferences' CCG game losers play the champs of the other conferences at their home venues for the Quarter finals. Re-seed after the Quarter Finals and play the semis and national championship game.

Each conference can maximize its revenue for its own championship by making it a play in affair with the quarter finals, and each conference will have 2 schools in the 8 team CFP with each champ getting a home game.

Trying to force all 4 into the same configuration outside of the Final 8 for the Title series is a fool's errand. They all have different needs and different circumstances. Let them use a system to determine their two representatives in the National Quarter Finals.

Do you think the SEC would be okay with a conference tourney in FB followed by an 8 team national tournament where they can only get 2 teams? My guess is they'd demand it be a 4 champs + 4 at-large, which I think is reasonable, especially if ND is still operating as a quasi-Indy in this P4 breakaway. I think a 6 team conference tourney (maybe 7 teams depending on conference size) with the 4 champs guaranteed into an 8 team national tourney pretty decent. Having 4 at-large also incentivizes playing non-conference games within the P4 as there would be national seeding involved with the national tourney (keeps the committee involved) and structures the season like college basketball, but without the bloated tournaments.

Play a 12 game regular season schedule (maybe 13 with a G6 opponent to ensure 7 home games) with the regular season ending on Thanksgiving weekend. Conference tourney the first 3 weeks of December on campuses, except for maybe the CCG. The national tourney starts on New Years with the NY6 hosting the QFs and SFs (commissioners in charge want the bowls involved and they want QFs on New Years whether we agree with it or not). I'd say give the 4 conference champs their designated bowl (Orange, Sugar, Cotton, Rose), if that's possible. Maybe that results in seeding the champs 1-4 and the at-large 5-8 to perform and maybe reseed the semis based on rank to avoid the top 2 playing in the semis.

Bowl games can still be played between tourneys to help with the gap, but maybe have eligibility at 7 wins, use it based on conference standings, or just exclude conference tourney teams. Yeah, the calendar stays longer than it should and you may run into teams playing 18 or even 19 games (if 13 game RS) in a season, but maybe some organization of the postseason makes the length of the season more acceptable or tolerable with a 15 day conference tourney followed by the national tourney as opposed to the CFP lasting nearly 6 weeks by itself with additional 2 week layoff between CCGs and the first round of the CFP. Of course, the biggest hurdle of this format is can the P4 all agree with such a format as this? That, I do not know.

I believe if each conference does what is best for them marketing wise with their conference championship, that an 8 team CFP is all that is needed. I think the SEC and Big Ten could find common ground on 8 under those circumstances. Really why not make it a 4 team playoff with just conference champs. There's the leverage the Big Ten needs for its prize to consider joining. If our conferences wind up being 18 to 20 schools each there is plenty to be gleaned by the conference championship series and if those champs then play it off for a title the networks get their big event and no also rans are getting a doover and that would be good for the game.
02-20-2026 11:59 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
RUScarlets Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,717
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #113
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 10:01 AM)bullet Wrote:  The only impediments to an expanded playoff are the Big Ten and NFL.

It's whatever camp you are in and whatever you want to believe in. I am not a B1G guy like Frank or some of the other upper midwest homers. Just calling it like I see it, as are you.

The ultimate resolution doesn't matter to me, be it 16 or 24. I have yet to hear a proposal that works at every level, whether it is avoiding the NFL, minimizing player wear and tear, or maximizing revenue. There isn't a good solution that stands on its own merits. There are gaping holes with 16 or 24. Doesn't matter how many new threads on CFP formats we get, not one of them resolves the issues we've all discussed.

Some posters want to marginalize those issues, so be it. Why are all these PhDs and lawyers still stuck on the ground after all these months? Because, there are clearly issues with every format being proposed.
02-20-2026 12:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13523
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #114
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 12:58 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  
(02-20-2026 10:01 AM)bullet Wrote:  The only impediments to an expanded playoff are the Big Ten and NFL.

It's whatever camp you are in and whatever you want to believe in. I am not a B1G guy like Frank or some of the other upper midwest homers. Just calling it like I see it, as are you.

The ultimate resolution doesn't matter to me, be it 16 or 24. I have yet to hear a proposal that works at every level, whether it is avoiding the NFL, minimizing player wear and tear, or maximizing revenue. There isn't a good solution that stands on its own merits. There are gaping holes with 16 or 24. Doesn't matter how many new threads on CFP formats we get, not one of them resolves the issues we've all discussed.

Some posters want to marginalize those issues, so be it. Why are all these PhDs and lawyers still stuck on the ground after all these months? Because, there are clearly issues with every format being proposed.

There are solutions, but there are no solutions for intransigence. It is why if each conference held whatever internal playoff they desired and the 4 champs received AQ status the issues and the time it takes to play quarter finals and semifinals with a championship game in mid-January all become possible. When you are negotiating a deal and the parties become intransigent you simply leave it to them to do their own thing and bypass the details to attain the objective. Intransigence is not usually out of spite and in business is almost always related to an issue solely important to the party that fails to cooperate. Here you have an SEC agenda to protect their championship game and pocket the lion's share of profits perhaps from conference semifinals. With the Big Ten you have their need to make more of the regular season games relevant by simply having play ins. Well, those work at the conference level too if they aren't wanted in the CFP. Let them use them to keep interest later in the season for more schools, but use them at the conference level. Either way they are likely going to have to either start the season a week early or hold the CFP championship a week later because either proposal is already in a time crunch.
02-20-2026 03:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,438
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #115
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
Folks are underestimating the potential payout increases from expanding to 24 teams. In addition, the payout increases will disproportionately benefit the biggest football brands who will be hosting playoff games.

Over the past four years, look how the major brands would have dominated the CFP coverage:
- Georgia and Ohio State would have hosted a 2nd round playoff game each season
- Alabama would have hosted a playoff game each season (2nd round twice & 1st round twice)
- Michigan would have hosted two 2nd round CFP games and and been a visiting team in a third CFP.
- Texas would have hosted three CFP games (one 1st Rd and two 2nd Rd) and been a visiting team in the fourth CFP
- Notre Dame would have made all four CFPs and hosted games twice
- Penn State would have made three CFPs and hosted games three times
- Oregon would have made all four CFPs and always hosted a game
- Clemson, Ole Miss and Tennessee would have made three CFPs each
- FSU, LSU, Miami and Oklahoma would have hosted games in two CFPs each

On average, seven of the top eight CFP seeds are major football brands. The second round games are guaranteed to have strong ratings.

But what is underestimated is the brand strength in the 1st round games during the past four years. Clemson and Notre Dame would have been in three 1st round games each; Alabama, LSU, Miami and Texas would have been in two 1st round games each; FSU, Michigan, Tennessee, Oregon and Colorado would have played in one 1st round game. In all, about 50% of participants in 1st round games would have been a significant football brand.

Finally, if they clear up the calendar of the CCGs, media will have the opportunity to spread out the playoffs to maximize viewership across three Saturdays and weekday evenings.
02-20-2026 03:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #116
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 03:52 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Folks are underestimating the potential payout increases from expanding to 24 teams. In addition, the payout increases will disproportionately benefit the biggest football brands who will be hosting playoff games.

On average, seven of the top eight CFP seeds are major football brands. The second round games are guaranteed to have strong ratings.

But what is underestimated is the brand strength in the 1st round games during the past four years. Clemson and Notre Dame would have been in three 1st round games each; Alabama, LSU, Miami and Texas would have been in two 1st round games each; FSU, Michigan, Tennessee, Oregon and Colorado would have played in one 1st round game. In all, about 50% of participants in 1st round games would have been a significant football brand.

Finally, if they clear up the calendar of the CCGs, media will have the opportunity to spread out the playoffs to maximize viewership across three Saturdays and weekday evenings.

I know the ESPN article alluded to a 0-8-8 schedule across the first 3 weekends, but a 6-6-4 schedule would be better for TV revenue. Better even than the 5-2-6 of CCGs+16, though that schedule could be improved too.

I’m not sure there is much difference as far as TV is concerned whether Notre Dame and Alabama host or not. The argument for expansion has been getting them on TV, wherever the game is played.

But, are we really increasing their exposure by dumping CCGs? The teams that would play twice would be teams 9-16 and if any are matched against low-interest schools, they’ll probably be shunted to time slot #5 or #6 (whenever those are).

I would think 4-4-4 is the best distribution of games across the first three December weekends. Whether that is a 20-team playoff or CCGs+16, is a matter of politics.
02-20-2026 05:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
RUScarlets Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,717
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #117
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 03:37 PM)JRsec Wrote:  There are solutions, but there are no solutions for intransigence. It is why if each conference held whatever internal playoff they desired and the 4 champs received AQ status the issues and the time it takes to play quarter finals and semifinals with a championship game in mid-January all become possible. When you are negotiating a deal and the parties become intransigent you simply leave it to them to do their own thing and bypass the details to attain the objective. Intransigence is not usually out of spite and in business is almost always related to an issue solely important to the party that fails to cooperate. Here you have an SEC agenda to protect their championship game and pocket the lion's share of profits perhaps from conference semifinals. With the Big Ten you have their need to make more of the regular season games relevant by simply having play ins. Well, those work at the conference level too if they aren't wanted in the CFP. Let them use them to keep interest later in the season for more schools, but use them at the conference level. Either way they are likely going to have to either start the season a week early or hold the CFP championship a week later because either proposal is already in a time crunch.

Semifinals or even QFs where the Big 12 and ACC/ND champs have a beeline into is not a serious proposal. Or maybe I am reading your post wrong? I'm shocked you'd think the P2 would go for that, unless I am misunderstanding.
(This post was last modified: 02-21-2026 03:59 PM by RUScarlets.)
02-20-2026 05:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,438
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #118
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 05:05 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(02-20-2026 03:52 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Folks are underestimating the potential payout increases from expanding to 24 teams. In addition, the payout increases will disproportionately benefit the biggest football brands who will be hosting playoff games.

On average, seven of the top eight CFP seeds are major football brands. The second round games are guaranteed to have strong ratings.

But what is underestimated is the brand strength in the 1st round games during the past four years. Clemson and Notre Dame would have been in three 1st round games each; Alabama, LSU, Miami and Texas would have been in two 1st round games each; FSU, Michigan, Tennessee, Oregon and Colorado would have played in one 1st round game. In all, about 50% of participants in 1st round games would have been a significant football brand.

Finally, if they clear up the calendar of the CCGs, media will have the opportunity to spread out the playoffs to maximize viewership across three Saturdays and weekday evenings.

I know the ESPN article alluded to a 0-8-8 schedule across the first 3 weekends, but a 6-6-4 schedule would be better for TV revenue. Better even than the 5-2-6 of CCGs+16, though that schedule could be improved too.

I’m not sure there is much difference as far as TV is concerned whether Notre Dame and Alabama host or not. The argument for expansion has been getting them on TV, wherever the game is played.

But, are we really increasing their exposure by dumping CCGs? The teams that would play twice would be teams 9-16 and if any are matched against low-interest schools, they’ll probably be shunted to time slot #5 or #6 (whenever those are).

I would think 4-4-4 is the best distribution of games across the first three December weekends. Whether that is a 20-team playoff or CCGs+16, is a matter of politics.

Agree that TV is probably indifferent on whether Alabama or Notre Dame plays at home. Nevertheless, Alabama and Notre Dame (plus their stadium fans) really care. Home games are a big revenue boost and helps sell season tickets beforehand.

My point on scheduling, is that weekday evening games can draw large viewership. There’s more opportunities for weekday evening games when CCGs are eliminated. Using last December’s calendar as an example
1st Round
Sat 12/6 4 games
Tue 12/9 2 games
Wed 12/10 2 games

2nd Round
Sat 12/13 3 games
Tue 12/16 1 game
Wed 12/17 1 game
Fri 12/19 1 game
Sat 12/20 2 games

The CFP TV schedule doesn’t have to compete directly versus the NFL.
02-20-2026 06:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #119
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 06:04 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  My point on scheduling, is that weekday evening games can draw large viewership. There’s more opportunities for weekday evening games when CCGs are eliminated. Using last December’s calendar as an example
1st Round
Sat 12/6 4 games
Tue 12/9 2 games
Wed 12/10 2 games

2nd Round
Sat 12/13 3 games
Tue 12/16 1 game
Wed 12/17 1 game
Fri 12/19 1 game
Sat 12/20 2 games

The CFP TV schedule doesn’t have to compete directly versus the NFL.

Not a bad schedule, though doubling up on the first two Tue/Wed nights is sub-par. You might spread those games to Thur/Fri.

Perhaps my point is that, if that were the best schedule, it could be done with CCGs as those 4 first Saturday games and that that would INCREASE the value of those games, both by featuring “Top” teams and their “championship” nature.

EDIT: Establish a compromise. SEC Championship on second Saturday. Winner to NYD, loser plays third Saturday. If SEC teams would rather a championship game than a home game, let them make that choice.
(This post was last modified: 02-20-2026 07:03 PM by Crayton.)
02-20-2026 06:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,438
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #120
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-20-2026 06:59 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(02-20-2026 06:04 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  My point on scheduling, is that weekday evening games can draw large viewership. There’s more opportunities for weekday evening games when CCGs are eliminated. Using last December’s calendar as an example
1st Round
Sat 12/6 4 games
Tue 12/9 2 games
Wed 12/10 2 games

2nd Round
Sat 12/13 3 games
Tue 12/16 1 game
Wed 12/17 1 game
Fri 12/19 1 game
Sat 12/20 2 games

The CFP TV schedule doesn’t have to compete directly versus the NFL.

Not a bad schedule, though doubling up on the first two Tue/Wed nights is sub-par. You might spread those games to Thur/Fri.

Perhaps my point is that, if that were the best schedule, it could be done with CCGs as those 4 first Saturday games and that that would INCREASE the value of those games, both by featuring “Top” teams and their “championship” nature.

EDIT: Establish a compromise. SEC Championship on second Saturday. Winner to NYD, loser plays third Saturday. If SEC teams would rather a championship game than a home game, let them make that choice.

LOL. Expected SEC response (FWIW - B1G historically had the same intransigent approach vis-a-vis Rose Bowl and playoffs). You want your cake and eat it too - play the SEC CCG without any negative consequences to the SEC but hurt all the other conferences. Play the SEC CCG later in the calendar to increase SEC payouts. Regardless of whether SEC CCG teams win or lose they get to advance further than in the original CFP proposal. Next you’ll be proposing that SEC teams get to automatically advance in the CFP regardless of on-field results.

Sport was once about competition. Then serious money got involved. Now you’re making it about creating structural advantages.
02-21-2026 03:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.