JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Uh Oh! There's Talk of Abandoning Key OOC Games Because the Big Ten Reneged
(02-12-2026 12:50 PM)stechs02 Wrote: (02-12-2026 11:41 AM)JRsec Wrote: (02-12-2026 11:08 AM)stechs02 Wrote: (02-12-2026 10:10 AM)JRsec Wrote: (02-12-2026 09:23 AM)stechs02 Wrote: This is exactly the right take. What I find most interesting, despite the media narrative, is that the Big Ten actually has a cohesive strategy, and they’re sticking to their north star. They aren’t zigzagging or constantly changing direction; they’re executing against a long-term roadmap.
By contrast, the SEC is the conference that seems unable to make up its mind. They’ve zigzagged multiple times, which to me signals internal alignment issues, leadership and structural challenges, and a lack of clear long-term strategy and vision. Examples include: 8 vs 9 conference games flip-flopping, unclear CFP positioning over the past year, public disagreements between ADs, presidents, and the conference office, etc.
The media will continue to hammer the Big Ten and Petitti, because that’s what they do. But anyone with real business experience and an understanding of corporate America can see how differently these two conferences are being run right now. Honestly, I’m becoming more confident in Petitti despite him being raked over the coals. The private capital situation got out of hand, but outside of that, the conference appears largely aligned and committed to its strategic objectives.
We can debate all day whether those objectives are the right ones, but I respect the leadership approach. I like having a vision and not wavering from it. That’s leadership, staying the course when things get difficult, not bending the knee under pressure, and not changing direction every six months.
Please keep thinking that. The SEC's plan was simple. An upper tier away from the NCAA is inevitable by court ruling compliance if for no other reason. They preferred to make the move with the Big Ten because it won't cause a needless extra step in the process (that of both doing their own thing). But they'll go it alone if they must because they have the dominant product where it matters, in their expanded region where viewership is the highest, and where the most past champions reside.
That approach is what the Big Ten responded to with a flailing sprawling collection of DMAs where those on the West Coast have the least viewership per capita.
There is no flip flopping in the SEC. The presidents green lighted a breakaway prior to Sankey trying to cooperate for the breakaway. They were prepared to go it alone 2 years ago.
In the next expansion the essential markets and brands within the ACC will be covered either by a cooperative move with the SEC in total or through consolidation into the SEC. Making the move without the Big Ten was simply seen as delaying the final product, instead of implementing it with the move.
To see the viability of it one need only look at the map. Should the ACC become in full the partner of the SEC in such a move it locks the Big Ten out of the Southeast completely. Add their West Coast schools to that collective step and they have together the preponderance of top viewed schools and past champions, with Notre Dame in the mix holding their same relationship to the ACC, and with a coast to coast national audience. What the Big Ten will hold is second fiddle in a league still tied to the NCAA.
The SEC doesn't have to expand with anyone if they make that move, though adding Kansas, Colorado, and the Arizona schools might be something that interests ESPN which would still own rights to all of it until 2034.
What did you think got Stever's vehemence up? He knows that should the SEC/ACC do their own thing that the Big 12 will likely get picked apart and not included whole.
Now if Petitti was cooperative a different more equitable model could be had without going through this stage. But so be it. The backup plan has been in place for almost 3 years now and it simply means more fan angst over the games before all of the key players come to the table in earnest. And that's on the Big Ten and could result in only the top 10 to 12 Big Ten schools eventually being included, which likely suits ESPN, if not FOX's interests. They would love to see a deeper culling of the final product.
The SEC and ACC both grew out of the Old Southern Conference, both have expanded beyond that to varying degrees, and the only reason the Big Ten has had a resurgence is NIL allows you to recruit the South. A creation of a league of containing the SEC and ACC conferences is a more natural formation and one which will stress the importance of athletes remaining where their family and friends have the easiest time seeing them play, and apparently they can now play longer than 4 years and a redshirt season.
It is the lack of definitive rules regarding NIL and the Portal that have created the Big Ten's Indian Summer. Should the ACC and SEC form their own tier they'll create their own rules friendly to their situations. What you incorrectly view as the SEC flipflopping was simply a desire to move to the more profitable stage sooner because of the raised overhead. It was a strategic decision to attempt such a move. But it wasn't made without intent. Now the focus has changed. Stever is a smart poster who picks up on nuance. He read the tea leaves on this one well ahead of most of the board.
Help me understand how this changes the Big Ten’s “Indian Summer”? Right now, in the absence of definitive rules, every conference is operating with both arms and both legs in the fight.
If two of the four conferences band together and create their own rules, which will almost certainly be more restrictive, how does that suddenly change the balance of power? How does bringing only one arm to the fight improve your position? I don’t see how it does.
Unless those new rules meaningfully disadvantage the Big Ten, which the Big Ten isn't going to allow happen, I’m struggling to see how this materially changes the landscape at all. If anything, I could see if benefiting the Big Ten.
Each conference is trying to find a way to create its own standards. The necessity of that is to maintain internal cohesion as to how the entire subject is approached and, in an effort, not to curtail it, but define it in a way where there will be standardization of application, not a restriction upon remuneration. The Big Ten has had an advantage in raising funds corporately. I don't think that goes away. But the Big Ten is not in a hurry to see contracts in place either. Contracts are the only way, through the portal's application, that some semblance of order will be brought back to the process.
A breakaway allows the SEC to do that, and for the networks desirous of broadcasting the conference with the highest viewership, along with that move, they would find that sponsors desiring that added viewership would be more open to NIL contracts with their players.
A lack of standardization (defining what NIL is and isn't, distinguishing between booster money and advertising opportunities, and whether schools can be involved in NIL or is it going to be solely between players and companies) is going to not only continue to damage the sport by disconnecting personalities from their schools, but will be the catalyst for internal strife in conferences if it cannot be defined.
You don't have to control amounts of income going to players for NIL, you just need to define what is and isn't NIL.
And frankly, until the Big Ten and SEC come to an agreement on this matter any continued association is not in the SEC's interest. The issue boils down to two points: what kind of arrangement is NIL (just commercial or booster fed?) and will collective- bargaining and contracts put some controls on the portal. At least with contracts the school is compensated when a contract is bought out. It doesn't suffer the cost of player development being a total loss when the portal is used. Contracts return some consideration to the school losing an athlete they helped to develop.
Would the separation of the SEC into a different legal entity curtail the Big Ten's ability to land Southern players? No. But the definition of what is and isn't NIL will help the SEC organize itself in a way which keeps its cohesion intact, and by being a separate entity sets itself and its relationship with its own footprint into its own unique reality as it relates to athletes within that footprint.
It's an esoteric point with a real-life edge to it and while it doesn't prevent the Big Ten's recruitment of Southern athletes, it will strengthen the social connection between Southern players, Southern schools, and Southern Conferences culturally and that will help balance out what is currently happening. And in as much as the SEC is the leader in viewership already that only adds traction to such a move. And don't underestimate the strength of the athlete's ability to sell product if they remain attached to the region where their natural ties increase their popularity and name recognition.
Therefore, it strengthens the natural bond between the athlete and their native region, and it takes potential stressors out of the relationship between schools in a conference to have a uniform understanding of what does and does not constitute NIL. That some schools have larger purses than others has always been the reality so the amount offered is not the issue, the definition of what distinguishes and constitutes NIL is.
I agree NIL needs clearer definition. The current ambiguity between commercial endorsement and booster-funded inducement is destabilizing. Standardization would absolutely help restore internal order.
But internal order and competitive advantage are not the same thing.
The Big Ten’s edge is structural: high per-school media distributions, deeper corporate market access, and national alumni concentration in major economic hubs. A more commercially defined NIL environment doesn’t neutralize that, it likely reinforces it. If NIL becomes cleaner and more corporate-driven, that plays directly into conferences with the strongest institutional business ecosystems.
So the key question is mechanism:
What specifically about an SEC (or SEC/ACC) breakaway reduces the Big Ten’s structural revenue advantage? If media payouts, corporate scale, and playoff governance remain unchanged, where is the competitive swing actually coming from?
Fragmentation also cuts against leverage. In a consolidating media landscape, power concentrates around those who control the most valuable inventory and national governance structures. Splintering only works if you can dictate terms. Otherwise, you risk diluting collective negotiating power with networks, regulators, and eventually labor.
And the legal exposure isn’t theoretical. Coordinated contracts, buyouts, and portal controls move the model closer to employment classification and collective bargaining. That’s not necessarily strategic leverage, that could accelerate a shift conferences don’t fully control.
Defining NIL is about stabilizing the current system.
Gaining competitive leverage requires altering revenue control and governance power.
Unless separation meaningfully shifts CFP authority or redistributes media, economics, it doesn’t change the competitive landscape, it just reorganizes internal rules.
Standardization makes sense.
Assuming separation automatically creates advantage does not.
You conveniently miss the point of the SEC/ACC breaking away. Your media revenue advantage is down to 2.5 million tops, IOW, not enough to cover extra travel for multiple sports offerings per institution. Yes, you have a Big Ten footprint corporate HQ advantage. I acknowledged that. What I laugh at is the claim to be a national conference in light of the SEC overwhelming ratings advantage so I discount that claim and with the ACC the scope would be similar and the markets of the SEC/ACC increased.
The whole point of the separation is to be the distinct choice for what you don't have, Southern athletes coming out of Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Alabama, Mississippi, Texas, Oklahoma and South and North Carolina.
Missouri, Kentucky, and Virginia are not hotbeds of recruiting. The ACC's current presence in California is a better entrance to that market than the Big Ten has in any of the rest I listed. And Notre Dame's affiliation and subsequent scheduling agreements even erodes viewers in major Northern DMAs.
Separation doesn't take away advantages the Big Ten already has, it cements advantages the SEC/ACC already have while expanding market reach with the most watched product. Viewers and commercial interest go hand in hand and you know it. If the Big Ten refuses to build a new world with us, we will build one without them. Then the market will decide who succeeds and thus far the market is ours.
Your supply of home-grown athletes is why until NIL you weren't winning titles. Your supply was limited to Ohio, Pennsylvania, Indiana (only they weren't staying at home) and somewhat Iowa. USC and UCLA added access for athletes in Southern California. I wouldn't call Oregon and Washington a hotbed for high school recruits particularly in football.
By going it without the Big Ten the SEC positions itself to reclaim a much higher % of athletes from the greater South to remain home without losing as much in compensation.
Look we earn more and make the transition smoother if we work together, but it's the SEC which is best positioned to move forward without the Big Ten, not the other way around. But I don't expect you to admit it until after the separation the results make it indelible.
The sport is declining annually in high school participation, but it's holding its own in the deep South and deep Southwest, Southern California and the Northern States I listed. Time is not on your side. All indications are that football will live on in the South even if it becomes regional, and it will last longer regionally because this region of the nation is growing the fastest.
"Time is on our side, Yes it is!"
(This post was last modified: 02-12-2026 02:02 PM by JRsec.)
|
|