Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,078
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2771
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-07-2026 05:06 PM)ouflak Wrote: (02-07-2026 08:25 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-07-2026 07:08 AM)ouflak Wrote: (02-07-2026 01:51 AM)Gitanole Wrote: Labour law consists of Constitutional principles (can only be changed by amendment)
This is purely and historically correct. And I'm truly amazed at all of the, as far I can tell otherwise, seemingly intelligent people who suggest that you can just 'cap' NIL or force people to stay at one place and one place only, without either amending the 13th and 14th amendments of the Constituion to somehow exclude student athletes, or repealing those amendments altogether for everybody - and we just all live with consequences.
You can’t cap NIL, but I don’t think anyone is saying that. We’ve had this discussion and you’re still conflating NIL with revenue sharing. You were also upset about procedures qualifying NIL. Contracts don’t force people to stay in one place but they do introduce recourse if the person leaves.
I think you've got me confused with another poster. I've never cared about the revenue sharing thing. For me, that's completely irrelevant except perhaps for the 'they're not employees' argument - where yeah I guess that poses a problem. It's the third party NIL where the constitutional concerns are severe, not just for student athletes, but potentially for all of us. If we allow the fundamental right to earn whatever somebody is willing to pay you to be squashed, then you are all fools if you think corporations are just going to sit back and keep wasting billions of dollars in revenues by paying employees all of that money when they can just get a judge, or perhaps Congress, to declare those employees a special category and limit that profession's pay to whatever trivial amount is in their best interests. Hell, the corporations of this country would be fools not take advantage of that situation. *Nobody* should be fighting for a cap in third party NIL.
No, it was you. You were upset that NIL deals have to be legitimate. 3rd party NIL is not capped, it’s just vetted for legitimacy.
|
|
| 02-08-2026 08:51 PM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-08-2026 08:51 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-07-2026 05:06 PM)ouflak Wrote: (02-07-2026 08:25 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-07-2026 07:08 AM)ouflak Wrote: (02-07-2026 01:51 AM)Gitanole Wrote: Labour law consists of Constitutional principles (can only be changed by amendment)
This is purely and historically correct. And I'm truly amazed at all of the, as far I can tell otherwise, seemingly intelligent people who suggest that you can just 'cap' NIL or force people to stay at one place and one place only, without either amending the 13th and 14th amendments of the Constituion to somehow exclude student athletes, or repealing those amendments altogether for everybody - and we just all live with consequences.
You can’t cap NIL, but I don’t think anyone is saying that. We’ve had this discussion and you’re still conflating NIL with revenue sharing. You were also upset about procedures qualifying NIL. Contracts don’t force people to stay in one place but they do introduce recourse if the person leaves.
I think you've got me confused with another poster. I've never cared about the revenue sharing thing. For me, that's completely irrelevant except perhaps for the 'they're not employees' argument - where yeah I guess that poses a problem. It's the third party NIL where the constitutional concerns are severe, not just for student athletes, but potentially for all of us. If we allow the fundamental right to earn whatever somebody is willing to pay you to be squashed, then you are all fools if you think corporations are just going to sit back and keep wasting billions of dollars in revenues by paying employees all of that money when they can just get a judge, or perhaps Congress, to declare those employees a special category and limit that profession's pay to whatever trivial amount is in their best interests. Hell, the corporations of this country would be fools not take advantage of that situation. *Nobody* should be fighting for a cap in third party NIL.
No, it was you. You were upset that NIL deals have to be legitimate. 3rd party NIL is not capped, it’s just vetted for legitimacy.
It doesn’t affect this exchange but, for the sake of completeness, my full sentence was ‘Labour law consists of Constitutional principles (can only be changed by amendment), statutes (lawmakers enact), and case law (courts rule and create precedent).’
|
|
| 02-08-2026 10:49 PM |
|
ouflak
2nd String

Posts: 317
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation: 69
I Root For: University of Oklahoma
Location:
|
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-08-2026 08:51 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-07-2026 05:06 PM)ouflak Wrote: (02-07-2026 08:25 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-07-2026 07:08 AM)ouflak Wrote: (02-07-2026 01:51 AM)Gitanole Wrote: Labour law consists of Constitutional principles (can only be changed by amendment)
This is purely and historically correct. And I'm truly amazed at all of the, as far I can tell otherwise, seemingly intelligent people who suggest that you can just 'cap' NIL or force people to stay at one place and one place only, without either amending the 13th and 14th amendments of the Constituion to somehow exclude student athletes, or repealing those amendments altogether for everybody - and we just all live with consequences.
You can’t cap NIL, but I don’t think anyone is saying that. We’ve had this discussion and you’re still conflating NIL with revenue sharing. You were also upset about procedures qualifying NIL. Contracts don’t force people to stay in one place but they do introduce recourse if the person leaves.
I think you've got me confused with another poster. I've never cared about the revenue sharing thing. For me, that's completely irrelevant except perhaps for the 'they're not employees' argument - where yeah I guess that poses a problem. It's the third party NIL where the constitutional concerns are severe, not just for student athletes, but potentially for all of us. If we allow the fundamental right to earn whatever somebody is willing to pay you to be squashed, then you are all fools if you think corporations are just going to sit back and keep wasting billions of dollars in revenues by paying employees all of that money when they can just get a judge, or perhaps Congress, to declare those employees a special category and limit that profession's pay to whatever trivial amount is in their best interests. Hell, the corporations of this country would be fools not take advantage of that situation. *Nobody* should be fighting for a cap in third party NIL.
No, it was you. You were upset that NIL deals have to be legitimate. 3rd party NIL is not capped, it’s just vetted for legitimacy.
NIL deals don't have to be 'legitimate'. As long as these young men and women are fully emancipated citizens of the United States, they are allowed to make as much money as someone is willing to pay them for their services. This is guaranteed under the 14th amendment of the U.S. Constitution (right to pursue happiness) and all of the subsequent labor, trade, and anti-trust that's based on that premise.
This concept of 'vetting' pay to get around those legal and constitutional protections is not one that anyone here in their right mind should not be supporting. If these people can get away with a scheme like this, how long before the corporations stare with awe at the ungodly billions upon billions of dollars in revenues they could be saving in costly employee pay every year by getting a federal judge to put an identical scheme in place for them in the form of a settlement?
But all that said, no, I really don't care too much about the revenue sharing thing - I do think you've got me mixed up with someone else on that one.
(This post was last modified: 02-09-2026 07:08 AM by ouflak.)
|
|
| 02-09-2026 05:20 AM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,078
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2771
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-09-2026 05:20 AM)ouflak Wrote: (02-08-2026 08:51 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-07-2026 05:06 PM)ouflak Wrote: (02-07-2026 08:25 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-07-2026 07:08 AM)ouflak Wrote: This is purely and historically correct. And I'm truly amazed at all of the, as far I can tell otherwise, seemingly intelligent people who suggest that you can just 'cap' NIL or force people to stay at one place and one place only, without either amending the 13th and 14th amendments of the Constituion to somehow exclude student athletes, or repealing those amendments altogether for everybody - and we just all live with consequences.
You can’t cap NIL, but I don’t think anyone is saying that. We’ve had this discussion and you’re still conflating NIL with revenue sharing. You were also upset about procedures qualifying NIL. Contracts don’t force people to stay in one place but they do introduce recourse if the person leaves.
I think you've got me confused with another poster. I've never cared about the revenue sharing thing. For me, that's completely irrelevant except perhaps for the 'they're not employees' argument - where yeah I guess that poses a problem. It's the third party NIL where the constitutional concerns are severe, not just for student athletes, but potentially for all of us. If we allow the fundamental right to earn whatever somebody is willing to pay you to be squashed, then you are all fools if you think corporations are just going to sit back and keep wasting billions of dollars in revenues by paying employees all of that money when they can just get a judge, or perhaps Congress, to declare those employees a special category and limit that profession's pay to whatever trivial amount is in their best interests. Hell, the corporations of this country would be fools not take advantage of that situation. *Nobody* should be fighting for a cap in third party NIL.
No, it was you. You were upset that NIL deals have to be legitimate. 3rd party NIL is not capped, it’s just vetted for legitimacy.
NIL deals don't have to be 'legitimate'. As long as these young men and women are fully emancipated citizens of the United States, they are allowed to make as much money as someone is willing to pay them for their services. This is guaranteed under the 14th amendment of the U.S. Constitution (right to pursue happiness) and all of the subsequent labor, trade, and anti-trust that's based on that premise.
This concept of 'vetting' pay to get around those legal and constitutional protections is not one that anyone here in their right mind should not be supporting. If these people can get away with a scheme like this, how long before the corporations stare with awe at the ungodly billions upon billions of dollars in revenues they could be saving in costly employee pay every year by getting a federal judge to put an identical scheme in place for them in the form of a settlement?
But all that said, no, I really don't care too much about the revenue sharing thing - I do think you've got me mixed up with someone else on that one.
You are forgetting the unique circumstances of college athletes.
In this case, there are still recruiting violations although not enforced by the NCAA or called such, but in realty that's what they are. Paying someone outright to attend a school is essentially a recruiting violation according to the federal clearinghouse. An NIL collective paying someone to appear on a car wash commercial or do X amount of autograph signings fall under legitimate NIL deals.
IMO, the current situation is a stopgap until collective bargaining and scholarship contracts come into play. NIL will still be a factor, but currently it can be abused as a recruiting violation. People seem to forget those still exist under the current structure, just under a new overseer.
The NIL Clearinghouse Is Here
|
|
| 02-09-2026 10:16 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,883
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-09-2026 10:16 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-09-2026 05:20 AM)ouflak Wrote: (02-08-2026 08:51 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-07-2026 05:06 PM)ouflak Wrote: (02-07-2026 08:25 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: You can’t cap NIL, but I don’t think anyone is saying that. We’ve had this discussion and you’re still conflating NIL with revenue sharing. You were also upset about procedures qualifying NIL. Contracts don’t force people to stay in one place but they do introduce recourse if the person leaves.
I think you've got me confused with another poster. I've never cared about the revenue sharing thing. For me, that's completely irrelevant except perhaps for the 'they're not employees' argument - where yeah I guess that poses a problem. It's the third party NIL where the constitutional concerns are severe, not just for student athletes, but potentially for all of us. If we allow the fundamental right to earn whatever somebody is willing to pay you to be squashed, then you are all fools if you think corporations are just going to sit back and keep wasting billions of dollars in revenues by paying employees all of that money when they can just get a judge, or perhaps Congress, to declare those employees a special category and limit that profession's pay to whatever trivial amount is in their best interests. Hell, the corporations of this country would be fools not take advantage of that situation. *Nobody* should be fighting for a cap in third party NIL.
No, it was you. You were upset that NIL deals have to be legitimate. 3rd party NIL is not capped, it’s just vetted for legitimacy.
NIL deals don't have to be 'legitimate'. As long as these young men and women are fully emancipated citizens of the United States, they are allowed to make as much money as someone is willing to pay them for their services. This is guaranteed under the 14th amendment of the U.S. Constitution (right to pursue happiness) and all of the subsequent labor, trade, and anti-trust that's based on that premise.
This concept of 'vetting' pay to get around those legal and constitutional protections is not one that anyone here in their right mind should not be supporting. If these people can get away with a scheme like this, how long before the corporations stare with awe at the ungodly billions upon billions of dollars in revenues they could be saving in costly employee pay every year by getting a federal judge to put an identical scheme in place for them in the form of a settlement?
But all that said, no, I really don't care too much about the revenue sharing thing - I do think you've got me mixed up with someone else on that one.
You are forgetting the unique circumstances of college athletes.
In this case, there are still recruiting violations although not enforced by the NCAA or called such, but in realty that's what they are. Paying someone outright to attend a school is essentially a recruiting violation according to the federal clearinghouse. An NIL collective paying someone to appear on a car wash commercial or do X amount of autograph signings fall under legitimate NIL deals.
IMO, the current situation is a stopgap until collective bargaining and scholarship contracts come into play. NIL will still be a factor, but currently it can be abused as a recruiting violation. People seem to forget those still exist under the current structure, just under a new overseer.
The NIL Clearinghouse Is Here
Its also kind of a bribe in addition to a violation of the rules.
|
|
| 02-09-2026 10:22 AM |
|
mturn017
ODU Homer

Posts: 18,901
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 1828
I Root For: Old Dominion
Location: Roanoke, VA
|
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-09-2026 05:20 AM)ouflak Wrote: (02-08-2026 08:51 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-07-2026 05:06 PM)ouflak Wrote: (02-07-2026 08:25 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (02-07-2026 07:08 AM)ouflak Wrote: This is purely and historically correct. And I'm truly amazed at all of the, as far I can tell otherwise, seemingly intelligent people who suggest that you can just 'cap' NIL or force people to stay at one place and one place only, without either amending the 13th and 14th amendments of the Constituion to somehow exclude student athletes, or repealing those amendments altogether for everybody - and we just all live with consequences.
You can’t cap NIL, but I don’t think anyone is saying that. We’ve had this discussion and you’re still conflating NIL with revenue sharing. You were also upset about procedures qualifying NIL. Contracts don’t force people to stay in one place but they do introduce recourse if the person leaves.
I think you've got me confused with another poster. I've never cared about the revenue sharing thing. For me, that's completely irrelevant except perhaps for the 'they're not employees' argument - where yeah I guess that poses a problem. It's the third party NIL where the constitutional concerns are severe, not just for student athletes, but potentially for all of us. If we allow the fundamental right to earn whatever somebody is willing to pay you to be squashed, then you are all fools if you think corporations are just going to sit back and keep wasting billions of dollars in revenues by paying employees all of that money when they can just get a judge, or perhaps Congress, to declare those employees a special category and limit that profession's pay to whatever trivial amount is in their best interests. Hell, the corporations of this country would be fools not take advantage of that situation. *Nobody* should be fighting for a cap in third party NIL.
No, it was you. You were upset that NIL deals have to be legitimate. 3rd party NIL is not capped, it’s just vetted for legitimacy.
NIL deals don't have to be 'legitimate'. As long as these young men and women are fully emancipated citizens of the United States, they are allowed to make as much money as someone is willing to pay them for their services. This is guaranteed under the 14th amendment of the U.S. Constitution (right to pursue happiness) and all of the subsequent labor, trade, and anti-trust that's based on that premise.
This concept of 'vetting' pay to get around those legal and constitutional protections is not one that anyone here in their right mind should not be supporting. If these people can get away with a scheme like this, how long before the corporations stare with awe at the ungodly billions upon billions of dollars in revenues they could be saving in costly employee pay every year by getting a federal judge to put an identical scheme in place for them in the form of a settlement?
But all that said, no, I really don't care too much about the revenue sharing thing - I do think you've got me mixed up with someone else on that one.
So yeah, the NCAA can't stop them from receiving payments from boosters for doing nothing but signing with a certain school. It's a free country like you say. But they can stop them from being eligible to play if they do.
Vetting NIL deal for legitimacy is not sidestepping the constitution it's preventing cheating.
|
|
| 02-09-2026 11:22 AM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-09-2026 05:20 AM)ouflak Wrote: NIL deals don't have to be 'legitimate'. As long as these young men and women are fully emancipated citizens of the United States, they are allowed to make as much money as someone is willing to pay them for their services. This is guaranteed under the 14th amendment of the U.S. Constitution (right to pursue happiness) and all of the subsequent labor, trade, and anti-trust that's based on that premise.
This concept of 'vetting' pay to get around those legal and constitutional protections is not one that anyone here in their right mind should not be supporting. If these people can get away with a scheme like this, how long before the corporations stare with awe at the ungodly billions upon billions of dollars in revenues they could be saving in costly employee pay every year by getting a federal judge to put an identical scheme in place for them in the form of a settlement?
But all that said, no, I really don't care too much about the revenue sharing thing - I do think you've got me mixed up with someone else on that one.
The Fourteenth Amendment is not about ‘the right to pursue happiness.’ That phrase is drawn from the Preamble of the Declaration of Independence. The Fourteenth Amendment is mainly about citizenship rights and equal protection.
While it is generally true that US citizens are free to make as much money as they can persuade someone else to part with, it has never been the case that they are free to do so by any means imaginable. Profiteering and fraud, for example, remain crimes.
Regarding athletics, the legal situation has more nuance than your description acknowledges. The NFL, for example, does not place limits as such on individuals’ pay, but its franchises operate under salary caps that limit how much can be spent on players in the aggregate. This practice—designed in part to protect franchise competitiveness against a wide-open pay-what-you-will approach that would favour those franchises in the most lucrative markets—has stood.
We can leave rulings on the legitimacy of the clearing house idea, and other ideas popping up, to professional judges. All of this restructuring is happening now, after all, in an effort to comply with court rulings. (As it happens, NIL payments under $300 don’t need to be reported anyway.) We’ll see how things go.
___
(This post was last modified: 02-09-2026 03:54 PM by Gitanole.)
|
|
| 02-09-2026 03:45 PM |
|