Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
CFB's Philosopher's Stone (UPDATE 1/24, Full Draft w/Final Rankings)
Author Message
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #21
RE: CFB's Philosopher's Stone ("real" SOR rankings that fans can calculate o...
(01-07-2026 04:01 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Is this one of those formulas where a team is rewarded for losing to "good" teams?

Only in comparison to losing to “bad” teams… ideally, ha.

In a good SOR, beating UC San Diego should still be ever so slightly better than losing to Ohio State.

As this only approximates a good SOR, losing to Indiana or Ohio State actually does give a benefit over beating an FCS team. BUT, as the bottom 4 teams are excluded when determining SOS, you’d have to play 5 FCS teams (or FCS adjacent) for this to impact the formula.

Worthwhile question.
(This post was last modified: 01-07-2026 04:44 PM by Crayton.)
01-07-2026 04:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #22
RE: CFB's Philosopher's Stone ("real" SOR rankings that fans can calculate o...
(01-05-2026 06:09 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(01-05-2026 04:52 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(01-05-2026 04:12 PM)Crayton Wrote:  The takeaway is if something ‘like’ this could replace all those opaque computer formulas and media polls, making conference and national races more accessible to fans.

Teams’ SOS adjustments will be more-or-less “known” after 4 weeks, allowing fans to track which teams are on track for a CCG or playoff berth. In the ACC, for example, Georgia Tech and Pittsburgh fans will get the benefit of playing a stronger schedule and ‘know’ they’ll win the tiebreaker over Virginia if they finish with the same record.

Not all 10-2 records are created equal, even in the same conference, and right now we all wait until Sunday to find out which teams get postseason berths. Like the NFL and other sports, discrete standings would allow this information to be known beforehand.

How does anyone know what their team's SOS will be after only four weeks? And, even if they could know it, what good would it do them? Few teams have yet played a meaningful number of conference games, and teams that look like sure playoff bets after four weeks have been known to fade in the stretch. Just look at LSU this year.

Instead of Texas fans saying they need to beat A&M, hope for “some” upsets ahead of them, and enlist their coach to stump the media for enhanced standing, Texas fans should be able to say “we need to beat A&M and have 3 of the following 6 teams get upset.”

Can we know SOS after only 4 weeks?

That is a great question. I should run the OP standings at that point in the season and see how valid my presumption is. As you note, teams like LSU (and FSU) can see dramatic dips in fortunes after impressive season starts. There are a few mitigating factors though:

1) most teams ‘are’ as strong at the beginning of the year as they are at the end.

2) the teams which experience upsets after 4 weeks are generally upset by conference-mates, having a balancing affect on other conference teams’ SOS.

3) any unexpected result is ultimately only 1 of 12 games on a team’s schedule and only 1 of 144 when looking at another team’s SOS. Any unexpected results will generally balance.

But the proof is in the pudding. Either tonight or this weekend, I’ll look to see how SOS changes week-to-week. If it changes radically, my purpose may be defeated.

So, does a team's SOS stay the same after only 4 games? A note that I did not mention to ken earlier, but looking at ALL scheduled games (not just opponents played) helps reduce variance week-to-week. Texas doesn't play A&M until the end of the season, but if we want a metric that stays as consistent as possible, we should include A&M in the SOS calculation from the beginning.

Here are the SOS for the SEC each week of the past year. A couple observations:

1) My claim was not perfectly accurate. SOS is 'not' static after the first few weeks. Teams' relative SOS 'do' fluxuate week to week. BUT, most teams relative position only flxuates by a few positions. After the first few weeks we can see Florida, South Carolina, and Arkansas will have the toughest SOS; Ole Miss, Vandy, and A&M have the easiest. We 'do' see what ken is calling out when we look at Alabama: the Tide started with the #2 toughest SOS but saw it drop all the way to #10 as Florida State's early season strength crumbled.

2) There is a slight decline across the entire conference over time. This is mostly because there is no calibration to 'be' consistent from week to week. This offseason while I create a new hand-calculable Power metric, I will consider adding a modification that keeps these SOS numbers more flat over time.
[Image: attachment.php?aid=12287]
(12-31-2025 11:33 PM)Crayton Wrote:  Opportunities / Questions?

1) Because not all teams play 12 games (Army-Navy, CCG teams, mid-season standings), Win% would be more accurate than Win Count. On the other hand, "Wins" are more discrete and fan-accessible, I think. Would "adjusted Win %" still be as accessible as "Adjusted Wins"? Another option is to +/- half wins for CCGs and teams who play less than 12 games.

3) I threw the "-1" into the SOS calculation to balance the fact that I am only looking at the 8 most difficult opponents on a team's schedule. Is it nice to be able to see that Virginia, for example, has a pretty 'mid' schedule close to 0.0, or would it be better to save the extra subtraction step and only rarely come across teams with negative SOS adjustments?

Through the magic of algebra, these two "Opportunities" could be addressed through a single solution.

Rather than a -1, subtracting GamesOver10 divided by 1.5 would fix both. Most teams will play 2 games over 10. This amounts to -1.33, even closer to the actual -1.31. Teams that play 11 or 13 games will have a bonus/penalty of 0.66. This is roughly equivalent to a 10-3 team. 11-2 and 12-1 teams will experience a slight bonus; 8-3 and 9-4 teams will experience a slight penalty.

With the anticipated reworking of the SRS/Power rating, the exact factors are likely to change. Thank you everyone for asking good questions so that I can identify what needs to be addressed. If I like the product, I may have a thread tracking it next year.

Another "Opportunity" may be that Loss Count is more often what fans use to mentally sort teams rather than Win Count. Perhaps SOS-Losses would be more intuitive than SOS+Wins? I probably wouldn't use the -1 rule I just talked about (or its replacement) so that I can keep SOS-Losses in the positive for the Top 25/40 teams.

EDIT: yes, SOS-Losses would also allow a simpler SOS formula:

SOS = (AvgTop8SRS + GamesScheduled) / 8

Rather simple? It’d yield the same values as the OP, just -9.5. This means the Top 25 would still be > 0, which is aesthetically pleasing.


Attached File(s)
.png  sor sec.png (Size: 120.5 KB / Downloads: 71)
(This post was last modified: 01-08-2026 11:35 PM by Crayton.)
01-08-2026 07:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #23
RE: CFB's Philosopher's Stone (UPDATE 1/24, Full Draft w/Final Rankings)
After a few hours (spread over a few weeks), I have finalized an end-to-end SOR that can be calculated by hand.

(01-06-2026 10:22 AM)ken d Wrote:  As a starting point to develop an algorithm that gives a clear picture throughout the season, you must first have an algorithm that produces a logical result at the point in the season when you have all the data you are going to get. That's after the CCGs.

ken makes a fair point. Here is the output after CCGs:
[Image: attachment.php?aid=12300]

I'd say that is impressive. BYU at #8 is a known outlier when comparing humans to computers. No recency bias to put A&M beneath Ole Miss.

Dividing by 11 was slightly more accurate than 10, but 10 is a nice round number; plus dividing by 11 would have lessened the impact of SOS a smidge and the P2 want it heightened.

(01-06-2026 09:03 AM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Any particular reason why you’re only looking at the top 8 opponents for SOS? Ignoring [the bottom teams] rewards the cupcake eaters and I think the formula should punish teams for scheduling de facto wins.

This new formula for SOS now looks at only the Top 6 opponents. The rationale for the change is that the OP was calibrated for Top 25 + Top 5 in each conference. Now I only calibrated for Top 25. There is a chance I have “overfit”.

Does this encourage scheduling cupcakes? No. To get a high SOS a team needs more chances of having strong opponents. Every cupcake is 1 fewer chance for a Top 6 opponent. If Texas had scheduled Wyoming instead of Ohio State, their SOS would have (correctly) tanked almost a full point. And whether Texas played Wyoming or San Diego St would have (and should have) negligible impact... at least when it comes to evaluating a Top 25 team like Texas.

As of now, I am thinking of tracking this next season. SOS does stabilize after the first 3-5 weeks, so week-to-week should give us a clean picture of the playoff race, not necessarily which teams have the most human hype. A SOR of '3' may be a fine anticipated target for having a "playoff caliber" season.

For your own perusal, here are the ratings for every team, after CCGs. While the formula for calculating them is simple enough (Margin of Victory + 20 points for a win/loss + opponents' power), solving all 136 teams simultaneously still requires a computer. But as a human you can verify any team's rating.

Code:
Rec    Pow.    SOS    SOR    Team
13-0    63.4    5.97    5.97    Indiana
12-1    57.2    6.10    5.10    Ohio St
12-1    52.0    5.40    4.40    Texas Tech
10-2    51.4    5.46    3.46    Notre Dame
11-1    50.9    5.76    4.76    Oregon
12-1    43.8    5.90    4.90    Georgia
10-2    43.0    5.15    3.15    Miami
11-1    42.1    5.03    4.03    Texas A&M
10-2    41.5    4.84    2.84    Utah
9-3    41.3    5.95    2.95    USC
11-1    40.9    4.88    3.88    Ole Miss
11-2    40.8    6.14    4.14    BYU
10-3    40.0    6.18    3.18    Alabama
10-2    38.8    5.71    3.71    Oklahoma
10-2    37.7    5.04    3.04    Vanderbilt
9-3    34.8    5.68    2.68    Michigan
9-3    31.7    6.27    3.27    Texas
8-4    31.5    5.99    1.99    Iowa
8-4    29.7    5.51    1.51    Washington
9-3    28.9    4.45    1.45    Arizona
9-3    28.3    4.43    1.43    USF
8-4    27.6    6.09    2.09    Illinois
11-2    26.7    3.77    1.77    North Texas
8-4    26.5    5.45    1.45    Missouri
12-1    25.4    2.76    1.76    James Madison
8-4    24.4    5.45    1.45    Tennessee
8-4    23.9    5.24    1.24    Pittsburgh
10-3    23.7    4.30    1.30    Virginia
6-6    22.8    6.28    0.28    Penn State
8-4    22.7    4.30    0.30    SMU
7-5    21.8    5.96    0.96    LSU
11-2    21.5    4.64    2.64    Tulane
8-4    21.1    4.95    0.95    Louisville
9-3    21.0    4.56    1.56    Georgia Tech
8-4    20.2    4.98    0.98    Iowa St
8-4    18.8    5.35    1.35    Arizona St
8-4    18.0    4.66    0.66    TCU
7-5    17.7    5.40    0.40    NC State
8-5    17.0    4.85    -0.15    Duke
7-5    16.9    5.06    0.06    Nebraska
7-5    16.6    5.17    0.17    Cincinnati
9-3    16.3    4.46    1.46    Houston
5-7    16.1    5.11    -1.89    Florida St
9-2    15.5    3.78    1.78    Navy
7-5    14.4    4.39    -0.61    Clemson
5-7    14.1    6.21    -0.79    Auburn
8-4    13.7    3.89    -0.12    East Carolina
8-4    13.0    4.37    0.37    Wake Forest
9-4    12.9    4.32    0.32    Boise St
6-6    12.9    5.71    -0.29    Northwestern
4-8    12.5    6.23    -1.77    Florida
9-3    12.3    3.24    0.24    Old Dominion
7-5    12.1    5.38    0.38    Minnesota
8-4    11.5    3.64    -0.36    Memphis
5-7    10.5    5.89    -1.11    Mississippi St
6-6    10.1    5.21    -0.79    Kansas St
4-8    9.5    7.03    -0.97    Wisconsin
4-8    9.3    6.17    -1.83    South Carolina
9-3    8.0    2.75    -0.25    San Diego St
5-7    7.9    5.50    -1.51    Kansas
8-4    7.2    2.10    -1.90    Toledo
5-7    6.7    5.73    -1.27    Kentucky
5-7    6.7    6.06    -0.94    Rutgers
9-3    5.7    3.38    0.38    New Mexico
10-3    4.9    3.08    0.08    UNLV
5-7    4.6    4.84    -2.16    Baylor
6-6    3.9    4.97    -1.03    Washington St
10-3    3.6    3.14    0.14    Kennesaw St
2-10    3.1    6.02    -3.98    Arkansas
9-3    3.1    1.59    -1.41    UConn
6-6    2.5    4.52    -1.48    UTSA
5-7    1.3    4.79    -2.21    UCF
4-8    0.9    5.91    -2.09    Michigan St
7-5    0.6    4.14    -0.86    California
7-5    0.0    3.22    -1.78    Missouri St
3-9    -0.5    6.66    -2.34    UCLA
8-4    -0.9    2.62    -1.38    Fresno St
8-4    -1.0    3.01    -0.99    Hawaii
6-6    -1.1    4.11    -1.89    Utah St
9-4    -1.4    3.14    -0.86    Western Michigan
4-8    -2.3    5.43    -2.57    Maryland
4-8    -2.6    5.65    -2.35    West Virginia
4-8    -3.1    5.82    -2.18    Stanford
8-4    -3.7    2.44    -1.56    WKU
3-9    -4.2    5.14    -3.86    Virginia Tech
6-5    -4.8    3.31    -1.69    Army
7-5    -5.3    2.66    -2.34    La Tech
8-4    -5.4    2.84    -1.16    Ohio
2-10    -5.7    7.03    -2.97    Purdue
3-9    -6.2    5.25    -3.75    Colorado
6-6    -7.3    2.67    -3.33    Texas St
8-5    -7.4    3.37    -1.63    Troy
5-7    -8.1    4.69    -2.31    Temple
7-5    -9.4    2.63    -2.37    FIU
7-6    -9.6    3.03    -2.97    Miami(OH)
7-5    -9.8    1.82    -3.18    Southern Miss
4-8    -11.7    4.13    -3.87    North Carolina
8-5    -11.9    2.36    -2.64    Jacksonville St
3-9    -12.6    5.51    -3.49    Syracuse
2-10    -12.9    4.98    -5.02    Boston College
5-7    -13.2    3.41    -3.59    Marshall
6-6    -13.6    3.34    -2.66    Ga Southern
7-5    -13.8    2.60    -2.40    Central Michigan
4-8    -15.0    3.09    -4.91    Air Force
4-8    -15.8    3.96    -4.04    FAU
6-6    -16.0    2.44    -3.56    Arkansas St
6-6    -16.0    2.64    -3.36    Louisiana
5-7    -17.4    4.09    -2.91    Rice
6-6    -19.0    2.26    -3.74    Delaware
4-8    -19.7    2.84    -5.16    Liberty
6-6    -20.1    3.59    -2.41    Coastal Carolina
4-8    -21.1    3.22    -4.78    Tulsa
4-8    -21.1    4.22    -3.78    UAB
4-8    -22.0    3.03    -4.97    South Alabama
5-7    -22.0    2.63    -4.37    App St
4-8    -22.3    3.17    -4.83    Wyoming
5-7    -23.9    2.05    -4.95    Buffalo
1-11    -24.4    5.48    -5.52    OK State
2-10    -24.5    4.73    -5.27    Oregon St
4-8    -26.7    2.81    -5.19    New Mexico St
3-9    -27.2    3.29    -5.71    Nevada
2-10    -27.5    3.49    -6.51    Colorado St
3-9    -28.5    3.11    -5.89    San Jose St
4-8    -28.9    2.50    -5.50    Bowling Green
5-7    -29.4    3.67    -3.33    Kent St
4-8    -30.6    1.88    -6.12    Eastern Michigan
5-7    -31.2    1.69    -5.31    Akron
3-9    -33.9    2.68    -6.32    Northern Illinois
3-9    -34.6    2.20    -6.80    Middle Tennessee
4-8    -35.1    2.60    -5.40    Ball St
3-9    -35.3    3.08    -5.92    La Monroe
2-10    -35.3    2.68    -7.32    UTEP
1-11    -36.5    4.41    -6.59    Georgia St
1-11    -36.8    4.67    -6.33    Charlotte
2-10    -44.7    2.69    -7.31    Sam Houston
0-12    -61.6    2.89    -9.11    UMass
    -49.6            FCS


Attached File(s)
.png  sorfull1.png (Size: 50.22 KB / Downloads: 185)
(This post was last modified: 01-24-2026 06:47 PM by Crayton.)
01-24-2026 04:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,303
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #24
RE: CFB's Philosopher's Stone (UPDATE 1/24, Full Draft w/Final Rankings)
(01-24-2026 04:06 PM)Crayton Wrote:  After a few hours (spread over a few weeks), I have finalized an end-to-end SOR that can be calculated by hand.

(01-06-2026 10:22 AM)ken d Wrote:  As a starting point to develop an algorithm that gives a clear picture throughout the season, you must first have an algorithm that produces a logical result at the point in the season when you have all the data you are going to get. That's after the CCGs.

ken makes a fair point. Here is the output after CCGs:
[Image: attachment.php?aid=12300]

I'd say that is impressive. BYU at #8 is a known outlier when comparing humans to computers. No recency bias to put A&M beneath Ole Miss.

Dividing by 11 was slightly more accurate than 10, but 10 is a nice round number; plus dividing by 11 would have lessened the impact of SOS a smidge and the P2 want it heightened.

(01-06-2026 09:03 AM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Any particular reason why you’re only looking at the top 8 opponents for SOS? Ignoring [the bottom teams] rewards the cupcake eaters and I think the formula should punish teams for scheduling de facto wins.

This new formula for SOS now looks at only the Top 6 opponents. The rationale for the change is that the OP was calibrated for Top 25 + Top 5 in each conference. Now I only calibrated for Top 25. There is a chance I have “overfit”.

Does this encourage scheduling cupcakes? No. To get a high SOS a team needs more chances of having strong opponents. Every cupcake is 1 fewer chance for a Top 6 opponent. If Texas had scheduled Wyoming instead of Ohio State, their SOS would have (correctly) tanked almost a full point. And whether Texas played Wyoming or San Diego St would have (and should have) negligible impact... at least when it comes to evaluating a Top 25 team like Texas.

As of now, I am thinking of tracking this next season. SOS does stabilize after the first 3-5 weeks, so week-to-week should give us a clean picture of the playoff race, not necessarily which teams have the most human hype. A SOR of '3' may be a fine anticipated target for having a "playoff caliber" season.

For your own perusal, here are the ratings for every team, after CCGs. While the formula for calculating them is simple enough (Margin of Victory + 20 points for a win/loss + opponents' power), solving all 136 teams simultaneously still requires a computer. But as a human you can verify any team's rating.

Code:
Rec    Pow.    SOS    SOR    Team
13-0    63.4    5.97    5.97    Indiana
12-1    57.2    6.10    5.10    Ohio St
12-1    52.0    5.40    4.40    Texas Tech
10-2    51.4    5.46    3.46    Notre Dame
11-1    50.9    5.76    4.76    Oregon
12-1    43.8    5.90    4.90    Georgia
10-2    43.0    5.15    3.15    Miami
11-1    42.1    5.03    4.03    Texas A&M
10-2    41.5    4.84    2.84    Utah
9-3    41.3    5.95    2.95    USC
11-1    40.9    4.88    3.88    Ole Miss
11-2    40.8    6.14    4.14    BYU
10-3    40.0    6.18    3.18    Alabama
10-2    38.8    5.71    3.71    Oklahoma
10-2    37.7    5.04    3.04    Vanderbilt
9-3    34.8    5.68    2.68    Michigan
9-3    31.7    6.27    3.27    Texas
8-4    31.5    5.99    1.99    Iowa
8-4    29.7    5.51    1.51    Washington
9-3    28.9    4.45    1.45    Arizona
9-3    28.3    4.43    1.43    USF
8-4    27.6    6.09    2.09    Illinois
11-2    26.7    3.77    1.77    North Texas
8-4    26.5    5.45    1.45    Missouri
12-1    25.4    2.76    1.76    James Madison
8-4    24.4    5.45    1.45    Tennessee
8-4    23.9    5.24    1.24    Pittsburgh
10-3    23.7    4.30    1.30    Virginia
6-6    22.8    6.28    0.28    Penn State
8-4    22.7    4.30    0.30    SMU
7-5    21.8    5.96    0.96    LSU
11-2    21.5    4.64    2.64    Tulane
8-4    21.1    4.95    0.95    Louisville
9-3    21.0    4.56    1.56    Georgia Tech
8-4    20.2    4.98    0.98    Iowa St
8-4    18.8    5.35    1.35    Arizona St
8-4    18.0    4.66    0.66    TCU
7-5    17.7    5.40    0.40    NC State
8-5    17.0    4.85    -0.15    Duke
7-5    16.9    5.06    0.06    Nebraska
7-5    16.6    5.17    0.17    Cincinnati
9-3    16.3    4.46    1.46    Houston
5-7    16.1    5.11    -1.89    Florida St
9-2    15.5    3.78    1.78    Navy
7-5    14.4    4.39    -0.61    Clemson
5-7    14.1    6.21    -0.79    Auburn
8-4    13.7    3.89    -0.12    East Carolina
8-4    13.0    4.37    0.37    Wake Forest
9-4    12.9    4.32    0.32    Boise St
6-6    12.9    5.71    -0.29    Northwestern
4-8    12.5    6.23    -1.77    Florida
9-3    12.3    3.24    0.24    Old Dominion
7-5    12.1    5.38    0.38    Minnesota
8-4    11.5    3.64    -0.36    Memphis
5-7    10.5    5.89    -1.11    Mississippi St
6-6    10.1    5.21    -0.79    Kansas St
4-8    9.5    7.03    -0.97    Wisconsin
4-8    9.3    6.17    -1.83    South Carolina
9-3    8.0    2.75    -0.25    San Diego St
5-7    7.9    5.50    -1.51    Kansas
8-4    7.2    2.10    -1.90    Toledo
5-7    6.7    5.73    -1.27    Kentucky
5-7    6.7    6.06    -0.94    Rutgers
9-3    5.7    3.38    0.38    New Mexico
10-3    4.9    3.08    0.08    UNLV
5-7    4.6    4.84    -2.16    Baylor
6-6    3.9    4.97    -1.03    Washington St
10-3    3.6    3.14    0.14    Kennesaw St
2-10    3.1    6.02    -3.98    Arkansas
9-3    3.1    1.59    -1.41    UConn
6-6    2.5    4.52    -1.48    UTSA
5-7    1.3    4.79    -2.21    UCF
4-8    0.9    5.91    -2.09    Michigan St
7-5    0.6    4.14    -0.86    California
7-5    0.0    3.22    -1.78    Missouri St
3-9    -0.5    6.66    -2.34    UCLA
8-4    -0.9    2.62    -1.38    Fresno St
8-4    -1.0    3.01    -0.99    Hawaii
6-6    -1.1    4.11    -1.89    Utah St
9-4    -1.4    3.14    -0.86    Western Michigan
4-8    -2.3    5.43    -2.57    Maryland
4-8    -2.6    5.65    -2.35    West Virginia
4-8    -3.1    5.82    -2.18    Stanford
8-4    -3.7    2.44    -1.56    WKU
3-9    -4.2    5.14    -3.86    Virginia Tech
6-5    -4.8    3.31    -1.69    Army
7-5    -5.3    2.66    -2.34    La Tech
8-4    -5.4    2.84    -1.16    Ohio
2-10    -5.7    7.03    -2.97    Purdue
3-9    -6.2    5.25    -3.75    Colorado
6-6    -7.3    2.67    -3.33    Texas St
8-5    -7.4    3.37    -1.63    Troy
5-7    -8.1    4.69    -2.31    Temple
7-5    -9.4    2.63    -2.37    FIU
7-6    -9.6    3.03    -2.97    Miami(OH)
7-5    -9.8    1.82    -3.18    Southern Miss
4-8    -11.7    4.13    -3.87    North Carolina
8-5    -11.9    2.36    -2.64    Jacksonville St
3-9    -12.6    5.51    -3.49    Syracuse
2-10    -12.9    4.98    -5.02    Boston College
5-7    -13.2    3.41    -3.59    Marshall
6-6    -13.6    3.34    -2.66    Ga Southern
7-5    -13.8    2.60    -2.40    Central Michigan
4-8    -15.0    3.09    -4.91    Air Force
4-8    -15.8    3.96    -4.04    FAU
6-6    -16.0    2.44    -3.56    Arkansas St
6-6    -16.0    2.64    -3.36    Louisiana
5-7    -17.4    4.09    -2.91    Rice
6-6    -19.0    2.26    -3.74    Delaware
4-8    -19.7    2.84    -5.16    Liberty
6-6    -20.1    3.59    -2.41    Coastal Carolina
4-8    -21.1    3.22    -4.78    Tulsa
4-8    -21.1    4.22    -3.78    UAB
4-8    -22.0    3.03    -4.97    South Alabama
5-7    -22.0    2.63    -4.37    App St
4-8    -22.3    3.17    -4.83    Wyoming
5-7    -23.9    2.05    -4.95    Buffalo
1-11    -24.4    5.48    -5.52    OK State
2-10    -24.5    4.73    -5.27    Oregon St
4-8    -26.7    2.81    -5.19    New Mexico St
3-9    -27.2    3.29    -5.71    Nevada
2-10    -27.5    3.49    -6.51    Colorado St
3-9    -28.5    3.11    -5.89    San Jose St
4-8    -28.9    2.50    -5.50    Bowling Green
5-7    -29.4    3.67    -3.33    Kent St
4-8    -30.6    1.88    -6.12    Eastern Michigan
5-7    -31.2    1.69    -5.31    Akron
3-9    -33.9    2.68    -6.32    Northern Illinois
3-9    -34.6    2.20    -6.80    Middle Tennessee
4-8    -35.1    2.60    -5.40    Ball St
3-9    -35.3    3.08    -5.92    La Monroe
2-10    -35.3    2.68    -7.32    UTEP
1-11    -36.5    4.41    -6.59    Georgia St
1-11    -36.8    4.67    -6.33    Charlotte
2-10    -44.7    2.69    -7.31    Sam Houston
0-12    -61.6    2.89    -9.11    UMass
    -49.6            FCS

If I'm reading all that correctly, this year's CFP would have excluded both #9 Alabama (3.18) and #10 Miami (3.15), in favor of Notre Dame (3.46) and BYU (4.14).
01-25-2026 09:52 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #25
RE: CFB's Philosopher's Stone (UPDATE 1/24, Full Draft w/Final Rankings)
(01-25-2026 09:52 AM)ken d Wrote:  
(01-24-2026 04:06 PM)Crayton Wrote:  After a few hours (spread over a few weeks), I have finalized an end-to-end SOR that can be calculated by hand.

(01-06-2026 10:22 AM)ken d Wrote:  As a starting point to develop an algorithm that gives a clear picture throughout the season, you must first have an algorithm that produces a logical result at the point in the season when you have all the data you are going to get. That's after the CCGs.

ken makes a fair point. Here is the output after CCGs:
[Image: attachment.php?aid=12300]

I'd say that is impressive. BYU at #8 is a known outlier when comparing humans to computers. No recency bias to put A&M beneath Ole Miss.

If I'm reading all that correctly, this year's CFP would have excluded both #9 Alabama (3.18) and #10 Miami (3.15), in favor of Notre Dame (3.46) and BYU (4.14).

As shown, tiebreakers allow Miami to pass Alabama (combo better record & better power rating) as well as Notre Dame (head-to-head) to climb into the #10 spot. Tiebreakers are essential if any algorithm is to be used to rank teams, whether nationally or within conferences. All sports use them.

As far as the playoff field, the only difference is BYU instead of Alabama as the second CG loser. Oklahoma no longer has h2h to climb to #8, A&M no longer penalized for ending on a loss and secures #6.
(This post was last modified: 01-26-2026 09:08 AM by Crayton.)
01-25-2026 10:59 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.