(12-21-2025 06:37 PM)ericsrevenge76 Wrote: (12-21-2025 04:47 PM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote: (12-21-2025 01:16 PM)mapdude Wrote: OK, I will admit I am too lazy to do my own research.
So this team is made up of 100% new players, except for the return to the fold of Ashton. So, how many of these transfers came from winning programs last year? Or did they come for a paycheck?
So, in my opinion, it appears that some serious miscalculations were made in the abilities of these kids to perform at a high level on the court in game situations. The team appears to have some personality/skills issues similar to the team 2 years ago that imploded at the end of the season.
We traded point guards with Kansas State this year and I think we got the short end of the deal. Yeah, hindsight is 20/20, I know. I have some reservations about most of the players that ended up on the team. I guess I'm not seeing what the people who are getting paid to see are seeing.
But, the reality is, it appears this team is just a collection of kids only interested in $$. I still think CPH can prove he is a good coach, but this year, the kids he assembled on his team can only be characterized as "a swing and a miss". They are not "Memphis Good", whatever that actually means.
Knee jerk reactions are not advisable at this point, and I will advocate that any changes to the leadership of the program be postponed for a while. I personally would give CPH another couple of years to show that he is capable of identifying and developing talent that has the capability of competing at the highest level of college ball as it exists today. I know, what's the definition of insanity?
10 years of failure?? Fire his ass now or at the end of the year and get it over with. Find us a new coach who knows the game and knows how to teach schemes and design set plays.
You guys are living in a fantasy world imo. Or maybe it would be more accurate to say you are living in the past.
These kids today are hired guns looking to make money and move on next year to make even more money.
Its takes big time $$$ to win in college BB in 2025, and we don't have that. Coaching isn't going to change the fact that we lack real talent and recruiting is meaningless without untold millions to offer these kids. And we don't have that. There is not a coach in the nation that could get this program to where you guys imagine it should be in the modern game. Even if lighting stuck and you make the Sweet 16, that coach is gone a week later to a new team.
I wholeheartedly agree. Memphis is getting beat with bigger wallets. Compare Memphis to Ole Piss. SEC pays $52.5M/year and AAC paid Memphis $11M last year (most of any AAC school). This year Memphis put $5M toward basketball and Ole Miss put $11M toward basketball. And it’s apparent booster(s) have stepped back financially, while still sitting between scores table and coaching staff in the arena. Due to the gap in funds, there simply isn’t margin of error anywhere else: player assessment, recruiting, on court performance. We have to nail the assessment, allocate money in appropriate places and it has to pan out perfectly for us to compete. Throw in the greedy 24-hr sports network and the whole system becomes more biased. NCAA is not a level playing field, never has been, and it’s getting more unlevel by the day. It’s getting harder to be a smaller program and compete.
Penny didn’t take the job with Transfer Portal and NIL in play. He’s adapted well with the resources he has. We still end up fielding a new 15 player roster every year. I have previously mentioned Gregg Marshall. Terrific coach, but he’s also an authoritarian. Does that work in today’s climate? Would players hang around for tough-nosed coaching? I don’t know that they would. Who do you get? What happens after 2 years of success? They'd likely be poached by an SEC school.
Honestly, I’m kinda over the whole thing. Not knowing the names of players until Christmas is brutal. Players have zero pride in their university. Players are getting paid before producing. I have always been hyped for basketball. Right now, I'm less engaged. I don’t know our basketball schedule. I used to know the entire schedule by heart by November.
I love competing. I love sports. But I’m pretty over it all. Who are these players? Who are the current coaches? What is our on-court identity? Who will be the next 15 players to come in 6 months? Who's creating the rules? How are G-league players coming back to college, but Dain Dainja has no eligibility after 3 years + 3 games?It's hard to latch onto. It's certainly hard for casual fans to embrace it. Right now, it's hard for me to fight the apathy.
But to get to THE question, knowing Memphis’ largest obstacle is money, I don’t see a coaching change as the solution. If we run off Penny, we’d end up paying 2 coaches to HOPEFULLY marginally improve coaching. We’d have to spend more funds on a coach, as Penny does it at discount price. We’d also have to pay out Penny’s contract. All this while taking resources from NIL, facility improvement, P4 campaign, etc.
Do I think Penny is as good as we want him to be? No.
Do I think we move our basketball program forward by getting rid of him? Also no.
Sorry I didn't read more posts before posting. I've likely repeated others' thoughts.