(12-04-2025 10:19 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (12-04-2025 07:37 PM)toucansam123 Wrote: The problem is that there is a fixed number of playoff slots and a variable number of "worthy" teams. Ideally the number of slots would vary from year to year and the teams to qualify would be those that met a metric based on number of wins and strength of schedule (and conference championship would not factor).
Last year 12 was probably the right number of teams (sorry if you have three losses you have warts). BYU / Miami / Vandy probably deserve a shot (Utah maybe) this year.
That way one teams inclusion is not at the expense of another team...everyone earns their way in.
SEC wouldn't agree to that. When Vanderbilt is a threat, then every freaking game is either a trap game or a ranked opponent. Everybody else can coast in at least some of their conference games, even a team like Oregon that played an extremely difficult schedule overall.
That doesn't mean that a lot of 3 loss teams should get in, and we might go years before we even see one of them, but it's unreasonable to put an arbitrary "number of losses" cap on qualification. What do we do when the CFP inevitably expands? Keep the cap at 3? Bump it to 5? What if we do eventually have a set number of WCGs and bids per conference, would 3 loss teams be ineligible? What if all the game slots weren't filled b/c only 7 FBS teams had 2 or fewer losses? What if it's 7 P4 teams with 2 or fewer losses but there are 5 g5 teams that played bottom 30 schedules and have fewer than 3 losses? I wonder how ESPN, TNT, or a future network partner would feel about leaving a 3 loss Georgia at home in favor of a 3 loss NM St. Talk about encouraging change...
I offer 2017 Auburn. Lost by 8 at final CFP #1 Clemson. Lost at #17 LSU by 4. Beat then #1 UGA (final CFP 3) 40-17. Beat then #1 Alabama 26-14 (final CFP 4). Lost in CCG to UGA 28-7 after losing their RB. Record 10-3. They were rightfully ranked #7 ahead of every 2 loss team but Ohio St. Won every other game by at least 14.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Aubur...tball_team
Date Time Opponent Rank Site TV Result Attendance
September 2 6:30 p.m. Georgia Southern* No. 12
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL
SECN W 41–7 87,451
September 9 6:00 p.m. at No. 3 Clemson* No. 13
Memorial StadiumClemson, SC (rivalry)
ESPN L 6–14 81,799
September 16 3:00 p.m. Mercer*dagger No. 15
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL
SECN W 24–10 87,033
September 23 6:30 p.m. at Missouri No. 15
Faurot FieldColumbia, MO
ESPNU W 51–14 54,574
September 30 5:00 p.m. No. 24 Mississippi State No. 13
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL
ESPN W 49–10 86,901
October 7 11:00 a.m. Ole Miss No. 12
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL (rivalry)
SECN W 44–23 86,700
October 14 2:30 p.m. at LSU No. 10
Tiger StadiumBaton Rouge, LA (rivalry)
CBS L 23–27 101,601
October 21 6:30 p.m. at Arkansas No. 21
Donald W. Reynolds Razorback StadiumFayetteville, AR
SECN W 52–20 71,961
November 4 11:00 a.m. at Texas A&M No. 14
Kyle FieldCollege Station, TX
ESPN W 42–27 100,257
November 11 2:30 p.m. No. 1 Georgia No. 10
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL (Deep South's Oldest Rivalry, SEC Nation)
CBS W 40–17 87,451
November 18 11:00 a.m. Louisiana–Monroe* No. 6
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL
ESPN2 W 42–14 82,133
November 25 2:30 p.m. No. 1 Alabama No. 6
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL (Iron Bowl, College GameDay)
CBS W 26–14 87,451
December 2 3:00 p.m. vs. No. 6 Georgia No. 2
Mercedes–Benz StadiumAtlanta, GA (SEC Championship Game, SEC Nation)
CBS L 7–28 76,534