Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
Author Message
BePcr07 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,893
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 469
I Root For: Boise St & Zags
Location:
Post: #21
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
The question with Miami, Texas, Vanderbilt, and potentially BYU ends with a 16-school playoff. Yes, this has the same problem for the next few schools in line. However, 16 schools keeps the number of rounds the same and brings more to the table. Maintain the same bid structure with more at-large bids, obviously.

Here's how it could look assuming the following...
B1G: Ohio St over Indiana
SEC: Georgia over Alabama
XII: Texas Tech over BYU
ACC: Virginia over Duke
Non-Power: Tulane, James Madison, Boise St, Jacksonville St, Western Michigan

First Round

#16 Tulane @ #1 Ohio St
#15 Virginia @ #2 Georgia
#14 Vanderbilt @ #3 Indiana
#13 BYU @ #4 Texas Tech
#12 Texas @ #5 Oregon
#11 Miami @ #6 Mississippi
#10 Alabama @ #7 Texas A&M
#9 Notre Dame @ #8 Oklahoma

Quarterfinals - now projecting winners

Cotton Bowl: #4 Texas Tech vs #12 Texas
Orange Bowl: #11 Miami vs #14 Vanderbilt
Rose Bowl: #1 Ohio St vs #9 Notre Dame
Sugar Bowl: #2 Georgia vs #7 Texas A&M

Semifinals

Fiesta Bowl: #7 Texas A&M vs #14 Vanderbilt
Peach Bowl: #1 Ohio St vs #12 Texas

National Championship

Miami: #1 Ohio St vs #7 Texas A&M

National Champions: TEXAS A&M AGGIES
12-04-2025 05:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #22
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-04-2025 05:25 PM)BePcr07 Wrote:  The question with Miami, Texas, Vanderbilt, and potentially BYU ends with a 16-school playoff. Yes, this has the same problem for the next few schools in line. However, 16 schools keeps the number of rounds the same and brings more to the table. Maintain the same bid structure with more at-large bids, obviously.

Here's how it could look assuming the following...
B1G: Ohio St over Indiana
SEC: Georgia over Alabama
XII: Texas Tech over BYU
ACC: Virginia over Duke
Non-Power: Tulane, James Madison, Boise St, Jacksonville St, Western Michigan

First Round

#16 Tulane @ #1 Ohio St
#15 Virginia @ #2 Georgia
#14 Vanderbilt @ #3 Indiana
#13 BYU @ #4 Texas Tech
#12 Texas @ #5 Oregon
#11 Miami @ #6 Mississippi
#10 Alabama @ #7 Texas A&M
#9 Notre Dame @ #8 Oklahoma

I don’t think this addresses the question of teams near the bubble who are idle during CCGs wanting to improve their stock before the field is set.
12-04-2025 05:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
toucansam123 Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 24
Joined: Dec 2022
Reputation: 2
I Root For: CWRU
Location:
Post: #23
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
The problem is that there is a fixed number of playoff slots and a variable number of "worthy" teams. Ideally the number of slots would vary from year to year and the teams to qualify would be those that met a metric based on number of wins and strength of schedule (and conference championship would not factor).

Last year 12 was probably the right number of teams (sorry if you have three losses you have warts). BYU / Miami / Vandy probably deserve a shot (Utah maybe) this year.

That way one teams inclusion is not at the expense of another team...everyone earns their way in.
(This post was last modified: 12-04-2025 07:38 PM by toucansam123.)
12-04-2025 07:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jhjhanaway Offline
Banned

Posts: 147
Joined: Dec 2011
I Root For: UCM, Mizzou
Location:
Post: #24
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-04-2025 04:35 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(12-04-2025 04:25 PM)jhjhanaway Wrote:  If they lose the 13th game, they could schedule another game to try to put themselves back on the bubble. So then they could schedule another game to try to play their way in again. Never give up!

Wait. Are you Diego Pavia?

Lol you found the burner!
12-04-2025 09:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AuzGrams Offline
Banned

Posts: 2,229
Joined: May 2012
I Root For: Utah, UVU, North Dakota
Location: Colorado
Post: #25
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-04-2025 07:37 PM)toucansam123 Wrote:  The problem is that there is a fixed number of playoff slots and a variable number of "worthy" teams. Ideally the number of slots would vary from year to year and the teams to qualify would be those that met a metric based on number of wins and strength of schedule (and conference championship would not factor).

Last year 12 was probably the right number of teams (sorry if you have three losses you have warts). BYU / Miami / Vandy probably deserve a shot (Utah maybe) this year.

That way one teams inclusion is not at the expense of another team...everyone earns their way in.

Utah & Miami really don’t deserve a spot in the CFB unsanctioned tournament unless Alabama and/or Texas Tech lose.
12-04-2025 10:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #26
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-04-2025 07:37 PM)toucansam123 Wrote:  The problem is that there is a fixed number of playoff slots and a variable number of "worthy" teams. Ideally the number of slots would vary from year to year and the teams to qualify would be those that met a metric based on number of wins and strength of schedule (and conference championship would not factor).

Last year 12 was probably the right number of teams (sorry if you have three losses you have warts). BYU / Miami / Vandy probably deserve a shot (Utah maybe) this year.

That way one teams inclusion is not at the expense of another team...everyone earns their way in.

SEC wouldn't agree to that. When Vanderbilt is a threat, then every freaking game is either a trap game or a ranked opponent. Everybody else can coast in at least some of their conference games, even a team like Oregon that played an extremely difficult schedule overall.

That doesn't mean that a lot of 3 loss teams should get in, and we might go years before we even see one of them, but it's unreasonable to put an arbitrary "number of losses" cap on qualification. What do we do when the CFP inevitably expands? Keep the cap at 3? Bump it to 5? What if we do eventually have a set number of WCGs and bids per conference, would 3 loss teams be ineligible? What if all the game slots weren't filled b/c only 7 FBS teams had 2 or fewer losses? What if it's 7 P4 teams with 2 or fewer losses but there are 5 g5 teams that played bottom 30 schedules and have fewer than 3 losses? I wonder how ESPN, TNT, or a future network partner would feel about leaving a 3 loss Georgia at home in favor of a 3 loss NM St. Talk about encouraging change...
12-04-2025 10:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #27
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-04-2025 10:19 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-04-2025 07:37 PM)toucansam123 Wrote:  The problem is that there is a fixed number of playoff slots and a variable number of "worthy" teams. Ideally the number of slots would vary from year to year and the teams to qualify would be those that met a metric based on number of wins and strength of schedule (and conference championship would not factor).

Last year 12 was probably the right number of teams (sorry if you have three losses you have warts). BYU / Miami / Vandy probably deserve a shot (Utah maybe) this year.

That way one teams inclusion is not at the expense of another team...everyone earns their way in.

SEC wouldn't agree to that. When Vanderbilt is a threat, then every freaking game is either a trap game or a ranked opponent. Everybody else can coast in at least some of their conference games, even a team like Oregon that played an extremely difficult schedule overall.

That doesn't mean that a lot of 3 loss teams should get in, and we might go years before we even see one of them, but it's unreasonable to put an arbitrary "number of losses" cap on qualification. What do we do when the CFP inevitably expands? Keep the cap at 3? Bump it to 5? What if we do eventually have a set number of WCGs and bids per conference, would 3 loss teams be ineligible? What if all the game slots weren't filled b/c only 7 FBS teams had 2 or fewer losses? What if it's 7 P4 teams with 2 or fewer losses but there are 5 g5 teams that played bottom 30 schedules and have fewer than 3 losses? I wonder how ESPN, TNT, or a future network partner would feel about leaving a 3 loss Georgia at home in favor of a 3 loss NM St. Talk about encouraging change...
I offer 2017 Auburn. Lost by 8 at final CFP #1 Clemson. Lost at #17 LSU by 4. Beat then #1 UGA (final CFP 3) 40-17. Beat then #1 Alabama 26-14 (final CFP 4). Lost in CCG to UGA 28-7 after losing their RB. Record 10-3. They were rightfully ranked #7 ahead of every 2 loss team but Ohio St. Won every other game by at least 14.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Aubur...tball_team
Date Time Opponent Rank Site TV Result Attendance
September 2 6:30 p.m. Georgia Southern* No. 12
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL
SECN W 41–7 87,451
September 9 6:00 p.m. at No. 3 Clemson* No. 13
Memorial StadiumClemson, SC (rivalry)
ESPN L 6–14 81,799
September 16 3:00 p.m. Mercer*dagger No. 15
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL
SECN W 24–10 87,033
September 23 6:30 p.m. at Missouri No. 15
Faurot FieldColumbia, MO
ESPNU W 51–14 54,574
September 30 5:00 p.m. No. 24 Mississippi State No. 13
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL
ESPN W 49–10 86,901
October 7 11:00 a.m. Ole Miss No. 12
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL (rivalry)
SECN W 44–23 86,700
October 14 2:30 p.m. at LSU No. 10
Tiger StadiumBaton Rouge, LA (rivalry)
CBS L 23–27 101,601
October 21 6:30 p.m. at Arkansas No. 21
Donald W. Reynolds Razorback StadiumFayetteville, AR
SECN W 52–20 71,961
November 4 11:00 a.m. at Texas A&M No. 14
Kyle FieldCollege Station, TX
ESPN W 42–27 100,257
November 11 2:30 p.m. No. 1 Georgia No. 10
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL (Deep South's Oldest Rivalry, SEC Nation)
CBS W 40–17 87,451
November 18 11:00 a.m. Louisiana–Monroe* No. 6
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL
ESPN2 W 42–14 82,133
November 25 2:30 p.m. No. 1 Alabama No. 6
Jordan–Hare StadiumAuburn, AL (Iron Bowl, College GameDay)
CBS W 26–14 87,451
December 2 3:00 p.m. vs. No. 6 Georgia No. 2
Mercedes–Benz StadiumAtlanta, GA (SEC Championship Game, SEC Nation)
CBS L 7–28 76,534
12-04-2025 10:49 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #28
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
Any 13th game probably needs planned prior to the season rather than on the fly. I'm a strong supporter of 4/4/3/3/1+3 as an 18 team CFP because of the conference WCGs we can have that I believe would be fair for the P4.

B1G
#23 Iowa vs. #5 Oregon
#19 Michigan vs. #16 USC
SEC
#8 Oklahoma vs. #6 Ole Miss
#13 Texas vs. #7 Texas A&M
ACC
#22 Georgia Tech v. #12 Miami
B12
#21 Houston vs. #15 Utah

I will say that the SEC may push back against this some as their 2 WCGs may not mean much in the sense of 18 teams looking at this year's example with both lossers in or Vandy at home sneaking in over an SEC WCG loser.


Another possibility that may be more enticing to the SEC is 2/2/2/2/1+9 where you have the B1G and SEC 3rd and 4th place teams along with the 3rd place ACC and B12 teams hosting a WCG against the next 6 highest ranked teams (may need the CFP committee to meet on Sunday a couple weekends or use a bunch of rankings methods and averaging them out in place of committee for selecting those 6 teams). The 6 winners are in with 2 or 3 at-large spots still available for WCG losers, depending on ND. Maybe ND would chose participate if they have the opportunity to host with a 7th game or play their way in, but my guess is they'd stick with in if Top X. Conference media partners get their games, particularly the B1G, while SEC has 5 teams playing for bids. It's a lower floor, but higher ceiling. ACC and B12 can also earn it on the field how they desire.

WCGs
#21 Houston @ #5 Oregon
#19 Michigan @ #6 Ole Miss
#18 Arizona @ #7 Texas A&M
#14 Vanderbilt @ #12 Miami
#13 Texas @ #15 Utah
#8 Oklahoma @ #16 USC
If ND plays and 7th game played, Oklahoma hosts as top at-large, ND plays @ USC. AZ @ Okla, Mich @ A&M, Hou @ Miss, GT @ Ore


One other alternative with 2/2/2/2/1+9 could be what I think is similar to Crayton's perfect playoff. Top 2 in P4 are in. Top 2 At-large are in and avoid a WCG, but with no buffer for WCG losers, it's win and IN. Lose and go home.

IN: #5 Oregon, #6 Ole Miss, #10 Notre Dame
#23 Iowa @ #7 Texas A&M
#22 Georgia Tech @ #13 Texas/#8 Oklahoma
#21 Houston @ #12 Miami
#18 Arizona @ #15 Utah
#14 Vanderbilt @ #16 USC
#8 Oklahoma/#13 Texas @ #19 Michigan

OR

#23 Iowa @ #7 Texas A&M
#22 Georgia Tech @ #8 Oklahoma
#21 Houston @ #12 Miami
#19 Michigan @ #13 Texas
#18 Arizona @ #15 Utah
#14 Vanderbilt @ #16 USC

My biggest questions with this are would we try to preserve keeping 2 B1G, 2 SEC, and 2 M2 teams each hosting to satisfy media partners, would ND be willing to play for a 7th game (as presented above), and would we intentionally avoid conference matchups or RS rematches?

I think conference media partners would want that 2nd game guaranteed and we would see, in this case, Michigan and either Texas or Oklahoma elevated to host a WCG unless a B1G media partner picks up a B1G road game for their 2nd game to replace Oregon avoiding the WCG. Again, as above, I think ND sticks within Top X and they're in, but would like to see them play adding a 7th WCG and, in this case, probably gives Tennessee a chance (GT @ ND, Iowa @ Okla, Tenn @ A&M). I think the SEC would definitely want to avoid conference matchups to give themselves the best opportunity to get as many bids as possible. Not sure if the rest of the P4 would or not, but may desire more regional matchups when possible. As for RS rematches, I think we wouldn't avoid this and we let them play again.
12-05-2025 06:33 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #29
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-05-2025 06:33 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  Any 13th game probably needs planned prior to the season rather than on the fly. I'm a strong supporter of 4/4/3/3/1+3 as an 18 team CFP because of the conference WCGs we can have that I believe would be fair for the P4.

B1G
#23 Iowa vs. #5 Oregon
#19 Michigan vs. #16 USC
SEC
#8 Oklahoma vs. #6 Ole Miss
#13 Texas vs. #7 Texas A&M
ACC
#22 Georgia Tech v. #12 Miami
B12
#21 Houston vs. #15 Utah

I will say that the SEC may push back against this some as their 2 WCGs may not mean much in the sense of 18 teams looking at this year's example with both lossers in or Vandy at home sneaking in over an SEC WCG loser.


Another possibility that may be more enticing to the SEC is 2/2/2/2/1+9 where you have the B1G and SEC 3rd and 4th place teams along with the 3rd place ACC and B12 teams hosting a WCG against the next 6 highest ranked teams (may need the CFP committee to meet on Sunday a couple weekends or use a bunch of rankings methods and averaging them out in place of committee for selecting those 6 teams). The 6 winners are in with 2 or 3 at-large spots still available for WCG losers, depending on ND. Maybe ND would chose participate if they have the opportunity to host with a 7th game or play their way in, but my guess is they'd stick with in if Top X. Conference media partners get their games, particularly the B1G, while SEC has 5 teams playing for bids. It's a lower floor, but higher ceiling. ACC and B12 can also earn it on the field how they desire.

WCGs
#21 Houston @ #5 Oregon
#19 Michigan @ #6 Ole Miss
#18 Arizona @ #7 Texas A&M
#14 Vanderbilt @ #12 Miami
#13 Texas @ #15 Utah
#8 Oklahoma @ #16 USC
If ND plays and 7th game played, Oklahoma hosts as top at-large, ND plays @ USC. AZ @ Okla, Mich @ A&M, Hou @ Miss, GT @ Ore


One other alternative with 2/2/2/2/1+9 could be what I think is similar to Crayton's perfect playoff. Top 2 in P4 are in. Top 2 At-large are in and avoid a WCG, but with no buffer for WCG losers, it's win and IN. Lose and go home.

IN: #5 Oregon, #6 Ole Miss, #10 Notre Dame
#23 Iowa @ #7 Texas A&M
#22 Georgia Tech @ #13 Texas/#8 Oklahoma
#21 Houston @ #12 Miami
#18 Arizona @ #15 Utah
#14 Vanderbilt @ #16 USC
#8 Oklahoma/#13 Texas @ #19 Michigan

OR

#23 Iowa @ #7 Texas A&M
#22 Georgia Tech @ #8 Oklahoma
#21 Houston @ #12 Miami
#19 Michigan @ #13 Texas
#18 Arizona @ #15 Utah
#14 Vanderbilt @ #16 USC

My biggest questions with this are would we try to preserve keeping 2 B1G, 2 SEC, and 2 M2 teams each hosting to satisfy media partners, would ND be willing to play for a 7th game (as presented above), and would we intentionally avoid conference matchups or RS rematches?

I think conference media partners would want that 2nd game guaranteed and we would see, in this case, Michigan and either Texas or Oklahoma elevated to host a WCG unless a B1G media partner picks up a B1G road game for their 2nd game to replace Oregon avoiding the WCG. Again, as above, I think ND sticks within Top X and they're in, but would like to see them play adding a 7th WCG and, in this case, probably gives Tennessee a chance (GT @ ND, Iowa @ Okla, Tenn @ A&M). I think the SEC would definitely want to avoid conference matchups to give themselves the best opportunity to get as many bids as possible. Not sure if the rest of the P4 would or not, but may desire more regional matchups when possible. As for RS rematches, I think we wouldn't avoid this and we let them play again.

And this doesn't have to be 18 teams, this is just a way to look at 3 options for WCGs that the P4 conferences could consider if they went multi-AQ for the expanded CFP.
12-05-2025 07:08 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
owl at the moon Offline
Eastern Screech Owl
*

Posts: 21,692
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation: 3099
I Root For: rice,smu,uh,unt
Location: 23 mbps from csnbbs
Post: #30
Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-04-2025 07:37 PM)toucansam123 Wrote:  The problem is that there is a fixed number of playoff slots and a variable number of "worthy" teams. Ideally the number of slots would vary from year to year and the teams to qualify would be those that met a metric based on number of wins and strength of schedule (and conference championship would not factor).

Last year 12 was probably the right number of teams (sorry if you have three losses you have warts). BYU / Miami / Vandy probably deserve a shot (Utah maybe) this year.

That way one teams inclusion is not at the expense of another team...everyone earns their way in.


THIS IS THE WAY

committee has discretion to select 11-16 teams each year.

First round can be anywhere between 3 and 8 on-campus sites.

This year maybe the right number would be 14. Kind of depends on how the CCGs all play out.
12-05-2025 09:01 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jhjhanaway Offline
Banned

Posts: 147
Joined: Dec 2011
I Root For: UCM, Mizzou
Location:
Post: #31
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-05-2025 09:01 AM)owl at the moon Wrote:  
(12-04-2025 07:37 PM)toucansam123 Wrote:  The problem is that there is a fixed number of playoff slots and a variable number of "worthy" teams. Ideally the number of slots would vary from year to year and the teams to qualify would be those that met a metric based on number of wins and strength of schedule (and conference championship would not factor).

Last year 12 was probably the right number of teams (sorry if you have three losses you have warts). BYU / Miami / Vandy probably deserve a shot (Utah maybe) this year.

That way one teams inclusion is not at the expense of another team...everyone earns their way in.


THIS IS THE WAY

committee has discretion to select 11-16 teams each year.

First round can be anywhere between 3 and 8 on-campus sites.

This year maybe the right number would be 14. Kind of depends on how the CCGs all play out.

The last thing the CFP committee needs is to be making more judgement calls. The reality is, it doesn't matter if it's 2, 4, 12, or 64 teams that make the playoffs. The first couple teams out will have an argument why they got cheated. You have over 130 schools fighting for 12 spots and only playing 12 games to figure it out. This ain't it at all.
12-05-2025 10:38 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UpStreamRedTeam Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,320
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 234
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #32
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
I guess this gives us something for podcasters to yell about, but at some point it just boils down to win one more game next time.
12-05-2025 11:24 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #33
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-05-2025 09:01 AM)owl at the moon Wrote:  
(12-04-2025 07:37 PM)toucansam123 Wrote:  The problem is that there is a fixed number of playoff slots and a variable number of "worthy" teams. Ideally the number of slots would vary from year to year and the teams to qualify would be those that met a metric based on number of wins and strength of schedule (and conference championship would not factor).

Last year 12 was probably the right number of teams (sorry if you have three losses you have warts). BYU / Miami / Vandy probably deserve a shot (Utah maybe) this year.

That way one teams inclusion is not at the expense of another team...everyone earns their way in.

THIS IS THE WAY

committee has discretion to select 11-16 teams each year.

First round can be anywhere between 3 and 8 on-campus sites.

This year maybe the right number would be 14. Kind of depends on how the CCGs all play out.

Always always ALWAYS remember that there is one single reason why the CFP exists in the first place: TV money, TV money, and even more TV money.

“Flexibility in the number of teams and games” is completely at odds with TV money. These networks are signing contracts for multiple years and they require X number of guaranteed games every single year. Deciding at the last second to add or subtract a game or two is a complete non-starter.
These networks are selling ad inventory months or even a year in advance for the CFP games.

This ain’t about what’s “fair”. It’s about 100% guaranteed TV money and we shouldn’t ever forget that point.
12-05-2025 12:33 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
YNot Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,082
Joined: May 2014
Reputation: 388
I Root For: BYU
Location:
Post: #34
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-04-2025 04:29 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  I mean if you’ve had WC games as a play ins then we’d just debate who should be in those. Not against expanding the playoffs but realistically you’re always going to have people upset about the field. I’d personally just expand to 16 and do one round of 8 home games. Leave it alone after that.

You could eliminate or reduce the debate if you decide playoff and wild-card participation based on something other than a beauty pageant and committee deliberations.

We can argue and debate all day long about Oregon's, BYU's, Miami's, and Texas' merits and beauty and rankings....but there is ZERO debate about whether:

- Ohio State and Indiana finished in the Big Ten top-2;
- Oregon finished in the third spot in the Big Ten behind Ohio State and Indiana and ahead of USC and Michigan;
- Texas Tech is in the first spot in the Big 12, ahead of BYU;
- BYU finished in the second spot in the Big 12 behind Texas Tech and ahead of Utah;
- Virginia is in the first spot in the ACC, ahead of all the 6-2 teams;
- Miami finished in at least the second spot in the ACC behind Virginia;
- Texas finished in at least the fifth spot in the SEC behind Alabama, Georgia, Ole Miss, and Texas A&M.

Win-loss records and Standings get you there. Then, some fairly simple tie-breaker rules can help you sort out the rest:
- Indiana or Ohio State as #1-2 in the Big Ten
- USC or Michigan in Big Ten fourth place
- Alabama, Georgia, Ole Miss, or Texas A&M in #1-4 in the SEC
- Miami, SMU, Pitt, Georgia Tech, or Duke in in second place in the ACC

Heck, even Notre Dame has a 10-2 record that supports some sort of win-loss record-based eligibility or qualification process. If you want to avoid criteria that could unintentionally give 'the wrong' access to 11-1 JMU or 10-2 UNLV, you can even look at Notre Dame's 8-2 win-loss record v. P4 opponents and use that as your eligibility or qualification criteria.

There is debate and controversy simply because the system has chosen a beauty pageant instead of a more straightforward process.
12-05-2025 02:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
toucansam123 Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 24
Joined: Dec 2022
Reputation: 2
I Root For: CWRU
Location:
Post: #35
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-05-2025 12:33 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-05-2025 09:01 AM)owl at the moon Wrote:  
(12-04-2025 07:37 PM)toucansam123 Wrote:  The problem is that there is a fixed number of playoff slots and a variable number of "worthy" teams. Ideally the number of slots would vary from year to year and the teams to qualify would be those that met a metric based on number of wins and strength of schedule (and conference championship would not factor).

Last year 12 was probably the right number of teams (sorry if you have three losses you have warts). BYU / Miami / Vandy probably deserve a shot (Utah maybe) this year.

That way one teams inclusion is not at the expense of another team...everyone earns their way in.

THIS IS THE WAY

committee has discretion to select 11-16 teams each year.

First round can be anywhere between 3 and 8 on-campus sites.

This year maybe the right number would be 14. Kind of depends on how the CCGs all play out.

Always always ALWAYS remember that there is one single reason why the CFP exists in the first place: TV money, TV money, and even more TV money.

“Flexibility in the number of teams and games” is completely at odds with TV money. These networks are signing contracts for multiple years and they require X number of guaranteed games every single year. Deciding at the last second to add or subtract a game or two is a complete non-starter.
These networks are selling ad inventory months or even a year in advance for the CFP games.

This ain’t about what’s “fair”. It’s about 100% guaranteed TV money and we shouldn’t ever forget that point.

I would agree on a certain level...bear in mind this though. What is the World Series and NBA Finals (let alone the rest of the playoffs. Best 4 out of 7 series. You set a certain minimum and maximum threshold and you establish a historical rate of qualifying teams. 11 to 16 teams with all conferences playing relatively equivalent schedules allows the cream to rise. And the field is set ahead of championship week. Teams should not get credit (or dinged) for playing an extra game against a quality opponent...though seeding may change. I would cap this at 16 so as to avoid any further lengthening of the season.

I find it ludicrous that D3 has 40 teams playoffs and a 10 game regular season. Really? 6 possible playoff games represents a 60% season extension.

I realize that my idea will never see the light of day. We have a completely irrational way of determining quality whereby most every team wastes 2 or 3 games against guaranteed wins. Time to end games agains the MAC and FCS. Nobody cares whether Kentucky gets to 6-6 to make the Pop-Tart Bowl. Everyone hates those games and you are left with teams only playing half their league in any given year.
12-05-2025 08:30 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #36
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-05-2025 06:33 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  Any 13th game probably needs planned prior to the season rather than on the fly. I'm a strong supporter of 4/4/3/3/1+3 as an 18 team CFP because of the conference WCGs we can have that I believe would be fair for the P4.

B1G
#23 Iowa vs. #5 Oregon
#19 Michigan vs. #16 USC
SEC
#8 Oklahoma vs. #6 Ole Miss
#13 Texas vs. #7 Texas A&M
ACC
#22 Georgia Tech v. #12 Miami
B12
#21 Houston vs. #15 Utah

I will say that the SEC may push back against this some as their 2 WCGs may not mean much in the sense of 18 teams looking at this year's example with both lossers in or Vandy at home sneaking in over an SEC WCG loser.


Another possibility that may be more enticing to the SEC is 2/2/2/2/1+9 where you have the B1G and SEC 3rd and 4th place teams along with the 3rd place ACC and B12 teams hosting a WCG against the next 6 highest ranked teams (may need the CFP committee to meet on Sunday a couple weekends or use a bunch of rankings methods and averaging them out in place of committee for selecting those 6 teams). The 6 winners are in with 2 or 3 at-large spots still available for WCG losers, depending on ND. Maybe ND would chose participate if they have the opportunity to host with a 7th game or play their way in, but my guess is they'd stick with in if Top X. Conference media partners get their games, particularly the B1G, while SEC has 5 teams playing for bids. It's a lower floor, but higher ceiling. ACC and B12 can also earn it on the field how they desire.

WCGs
#21 Houston @ #5 Oregon
#19 Michigan @ #6 Ole Miss
#18 Arizona @ #7 Texas A&M
#14 Vanderbilt @ #12 Miami
#13 Texas @ #15 Utah
#8 Oklahoma @ #16 USC
If ND plays and 7th game played, Oklahoma hosts as top at-large, ND plays @ USC. AZ @ Okla, Mich @ A&M, Hou @ Miss, GT @ Ore


One other alternative with 2/2/2/2/1+9 could be what I think is similar to Crayton's perfect playoff. Top 2 in P4 are in. Top 2 At-large are in and avoid a WCG, but with no buffer for WCG losers, it's win and IN. Lose and go home.

IN: #5 Oregon, #6 Ole Miss, #10 Notre Dame
#23 Iowa @ #7 Texas A&M
#22 Georgia Tech @ #13 Texas/#8 Oklahoma
#21 Houston @ #12 Miami
#18 Arizona @ #15 Utah
#14 Vanderbilt @ #16 USC
#8 Oklahoma/#13 Texas @ #19 Michigan

OR

#23 Iowa @ #7 Texas A&M
#22 Georgia Tech @ #8 Oklahoma
#21 Houston @ #12 Miami
#19 Michigan @ #13 Texas
#18 Arizona @ #15 Utah
#14 Vanderbilt @ #16 USC

My biggest questions with this are would we try to preserve keeping 2 B1G, 2 SEC, and 2 M2 teams each hosting to satisfy media partners, would ND be willing to play for a 7th game (as presented above), and would we intentionally avoid conference matchups or RS rematches?

I think conference media partners would want that 2nd game guaranteed and we would see, in this case, Michigan and either Texas or Oklahoma elevated to host a WCG unless a B1G media partner picks up a B1G road game for their 2nd game to replace Oregon avoiding the WCG. Again, as above, I think ND sticks within Top X and they're in, but would like to see them play adding a 7th WCG and, in this case, probably gives Tennessee a chance (GT @ ND, Iowa @ Okla, Tenn @ A&M). I think the SEC would definitely want to avoid conference matchups to give themselves the best opportunity to get as many bids as possible. Not sure if the rest of the P4 would or not, but may desire more regional matchups when possible. As for RS rematches, I think we wouldn't avoid this and we let them play again.

Various scenarios can work.

I will say that I'm super stoked at the idea of hosting a CFP game in College Station. I think that the atmosphere will be amazing.
12-05-2025 08:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #37
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-05-2025 12:33 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-05-2025 09:01 AM)owl at the moon Wrote:  
(12-04-2025 07:37 PM)toucansam123 Wrote:  The problem is that there is a fixed number of playoff slots and a variable number of "worthy" teams. Ideally the number of slots would vary from year to year and the teams to qualify would be those that met a metric based on number of wins and strength of schedule (and conference championship would not factor).

Last year 12 was probably the right number of teams (sorry if you have three losses you have warts). BYU / Miami / Vandy probably deserve a shot (Utah maybe) this year.

That way one teams inclusion is not at the expense of another team...everyone earns their way in.

THIS IS THE WAY

committee has discretion to select 11-16 teams each year.

First round can be anywhere between 3 and 8 on-campus sites.

This year maybe the right number would be 14. Kind of depends on how the CCGs all play out.

Always always ALWAYS remember that there is one single reason why the CFP exists in the first place: TV money, TV money, and even more TV money.

“Flexibility in the number of teams and games” is completely at odds with TV money. These networks are signing contracts for multiple years and they require X number of guaranteed games every single year. Deciding at the last second to add or subtract a game or two is a complete non-starter.
These networks are selling ad inventory months or even a year in advance for the CFP games.

This ain’t about what’s “fair”. It’s about 100% guaranteed TV money and we shouldn’t ever forget that point.

Yep. 4 teams? 24 teams? Something in between? Any format makes more money if we know ahead of time how many games there will be.
12-05-2025 08:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #38
RE: Thamel: Vandy examined scheduling 13th game in attempt to earn CFP at-large slot
(12-05-2025 02:22 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(12-04-2025 04:29 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  I mean if you’ve had WC games as a play ins then we’d just debate who should be in those. Not against expanding the playoffs but realistically you’re always going to have people upset about the field. I’d personally just expand to 16 and do one round of 8 home games. Leave it alone after that.

You could eliminate or reduce the debate if you decide playoff and wild-card participation based on something other than a beauty pageant and committee deliberations.

We can argue and debate all day long about Oregon's, BYU's, Miami's, and Texas' merits and beauty and rankings....but there is ZERO debate about whether:

- Ohio State and Indiana finished in the Big Ten top-2;
- Oregon finished in the third spot in the Big Ten behind Ohio State and Indiana and ahead of USC and Michigan;
- Texas Tech is in the first spot in the Big 12, ahead of BYU;
- BYU finished in the second spot in the Big 12 behind Texas Tech and ahead of Utah;
- Virginia is in the first spot in the ACC, ahead of all the 6-2 teams;
- Miami finished in at least the second spot in the ACC behind Virginia;
- Texas finished in at least the fifth spot in the SEC behind Alabama, Georgia, Ole Miss, and Texas A&M.

Win-loss records and Standings get you there. Then, some fairly simple tie-breaker rules can help you sort out the rest:
- Indiana or Ohio State as #1-2 in the Big Ten
- USC or Michigan in Big Ten fourth place
- Alabama, Georgia, Ole Miss, or Texas A&M in #1-4 in the SEC
- Miami, SMU, Pitt, Georgia Tech, or Duke in in second place in the ACC

Heck, even Notre Dame has a 10-2 record that supports some sort of win-loss record-based eligibility or qualification process. If you want to avoid criteria that could unintentionally give 'the wrong' access to 11-1 JMU or 10-2 UNLV, you can even look at Notre Dame's 8-2 win-loss record v. P4 opponents and use that as your eligibility or qualification criteria.

There is debate and controversy simply because the system has chosen a beauty pageant instead of a more straightforward process.

A more straightforward process is tough to implement when you have schools from both the SEC and the SBC competing for a limited number of slots. As big as the gap is between Ohio St and Iowa St, imagine how big it is between Alabama and Marshall. Then tack on the fact that the CFP is mostly about money and only tangentially about creating clarity with the national title picture, and we're stuck with a Committee for now.
12-05-2025 08:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.