Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Big 12 alternate history
Author Message
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #21
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-01-2025 12:07 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 11:04 AM)Sicembear11 Wrote:  The hierarchical power wasn't as established in 2010 as it was in 2023.

No, it was. People just didn't know it yet because the public only finds out when programs jump.

SEC>Big Ten>Pac 10>ACC>Big XII>Big East

It was there all along, we just didn't notice and inertia was enough to keep a few schools in their leagues temporarily.

I’m going to disagree with you here. Competitively, the Big 12 was probably top 2 in terms of football strength. The league just wasn’t as cohesive a unit as some of the others because it was a chimera of the Big 8 and top SWC schools.
12-01-2025 12:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,343
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #22
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-01-2025 12:52 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 12:07 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 11:04 AM)Sicembear11 Wrote:  The hierarchical power wasn't as established in 2010 as it was in 2023.

No, it was. People just didn't know it yet because the public only finds out when programs jump.

SEC>Big Ten>Pac 10>ACC>Big XII>Big East

It was there all along, we just didn't notice and inertia was enough to keep a few schools in their leagues temporarily.

I’m going to disagree with you here. Competitively, the Big 12 was probably top 2 in terms of football strength. The league just wasn’t as cohesive a unit as some of the others because it was a chimera of the Big 8 and top SWC schools.
I'm not talking on the field competitiveness, I'm talking attractiveness for joining, which had more to do with tv sets and fan interest han winning national championships, though the two are of course related.
12-01-2025 01:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Attackcoog Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 49,241
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3527
I Root For: Houston
Location:
Post: #23
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(11-30-2025 06:46 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  The Big 12, as originally assembled, was built to be a beast. It’s a shame that the infighting and egos caused it to crumble.

Hell---the old SWC would still be pretty darn good. You'd have Texas---Texas A&M---Tech---along with SMU, Houston, Arkansas, Baylor, TCU providing solid depth. That old league would boast pretty darn good basketball as well. Only Rice would be a bit of an athletic anchor within the original group. Could that league appeal to much of an audience outside of Texas---idk--maybe? Regardless---the athletics quality of the old SWC grouping would be quite solid.
(This post was last modified: 12-01-2025 02:16 PM by Attackcoog.)
12-01-2025 02:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #24
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-01-2025 02:14 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  
(11-30-2025 06:46 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  The Big 12, as originally assembled, was built to be a beast. It’s a shame that the infighting and egos caused it to crumble.

Hell---the old SWC would still be pretty darn good. You'd have Texas---Texas A&M---Tech---along with SMU, Houston, Arkansas, Baylor, TCU providing solid depth. That old league would boast pretty darn good basketball as well. Only Rice would be a bit of an athletic anchor within the original group. Could that league appeal to much of an audience outside of Texas---idk--maybe? Regardless---the athletics quality of the old SWC grouping would be quite solid.

Texas went from 17m population in 1990 to 31.5m in 2025. That makes it look a whole lot more desirable today than it was back in the SWC days. However, what is the change with the entire rest of the Big 12 States, 1990 to today?

Ok: 3.17m 1990, 4.12m = + .95m
Kansas: 2.48m 1990, 2.97m 2025 = + .49m
Colorado: 3.30m 1990, 6.01m 2025 = + 2.71m
Nebraska: 1.58m 1990, 2.00m 2025 = + .42m
Missouri: 5.12m 1990, 6.16m 2025 = + 1.04m
Iowa: 2.78m 1990, 3.24m 2025 = + .46m

3.36m growth over 35 years for all of OK, Kansas, Ne, MS and Iowa combined
2.71m for Colorado
14.5m for Texas

Total footprint population 1990:
17+3.17+2.48+3.3+1.58+5.12+2.78 = 35.43m

Total footprint population 2025:
35.43m + 3.36 +2.71 +14.5 = 55.5m

US population grew by 38% during that time period, so the old Big 12 footprint did continue to grow, but it was at a distinct disadvantage when compared to the SEC, Pac 12 and Big 10. People pretended that losing Colorado wasn't all that important in 2010, but these numbers tell a different story. Nebraska hurt b/c they were NEBRASKA, but Colorado had a proud history, too, and their State was good-sized and growing like gang busters. If we were all still in the Big 12 today, we'd be comparatively better off than we used to be, but the conference would be even more slanted towards a State of Texas focus, too. Louisville and BYU would have helped tremendously with expanding the footprint, but we have the benefit of hindsight on those moves today. The discussion back in the 90s was BYU + UNM, Louisville was considered too distant or too weak, perhaps both. If the Louisville of today had been available back then, however, I do think that we'd have started with BYU and Louisville in the conference, and it would have had more stability for that. Thank goodness that didn't happen, we might still be in the Big 12!

Looking at how rapidly both Utah and Colorado are growing today, it's hard to blame the Pac for adding them back in 2010. Too bad for them that they didn't strike while the iron was hot with OUT, too.
(This post was last modified: 12-01-2025 02:41 PM by bryanw1995.)
12-01-2025 02:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
CFBLurker Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 464
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 60
I Root For: Tulsa,Oklahoma
Location:
Post: #25
RE: Big 12 alternate history
The Big 12 was always a marriage of convenience. It was a reactionary response to the rise of cable tv and the introduction of conference championship games.
12-01-2025 04:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #26
RE: Big 12 alternate history
As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.
(This post was last modified: 12-01-2025 05:51 PM by Fighting Muskie.)
12-01-2025 05:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
andybible1995 Offline
Banned

Posts: 14,847
Joined: Apr 2022
I Root For: TN, MTSU, MD, Army
Location:
Post: #27
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

If Texas A&M joining the SEC doomed the system, what would you call the moves that happened afterwards, at least at the Power conference level?
12-01-2025 07:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #28
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-01-2025 07:41 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

If Texas A&M joining the SEC doomed the system, what would you call the moves that happened afterwards, at least at the Power conference level?

Everything after TAMU’s move to the SEC was an effort to survive in a climate where the SEC was well overpowered. In terms of competitiveness and market share, adding TAMU ensured that only the Big 10 could be a potential rival to the SEC in dominance. The Big East, ACC, Big 12, and PAC 12 were in no position to compete and would be slowly left behind.

The ACC and Big 10 both moved to 14 to emulate the size of the SEC and to gain new markets and try to bridge the financial gap. (The Big 12 held at 10 because by their own math, there wasn’t anyone who could help them compete).

Texas and Oklahoma joining the SEC was the acquiescence that they couldn’t stay on the same financial footing in the Big 12 and it was finally economical to jump ship.

The Big 10’s acquisitions from the Pac 12 were a mutual conclusion that the PAC 12 was already way way behind and the only chance for anyone to be on the same tier as the 16-member SEC was for the Big 10 to absorb either the Pac 12 or ACC’s best programs.

The Big 12 and ACC jumping at the remnants of the Pac 12 demonstrated that they were well aware of the precariousness of their situations and merely trying to survive. Even ND, chief architect of the ACC’s expansion, was scared about their future.
(This post was last modified: 12-01-2025 09:38 PM by Fighting Muskie.)
12-01-2025 09:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #29
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

The B1G straight up raided the Big XII for Nebraska, a blue blood football program with rich Big 8/Big XII history. THAT was the most "pivotal"—or should we say "destructive"—move. aTm left over a year after that.

Before people clamor about Miami—a renegade, hired-gun program which never belonged in the Big East anyway—let's revisit why the Northeast never had a viable conference and relied on Southern mercenaries. Wait for it...oh, that's right the B1G brought in Penn State!

The B1G and their lackey the Pac 10 also held up a college football playoff, (of course this was before the B1G Fredo'd the Pac) and now they are holding up sensible CFP expansion with their multi-bid nonsense.

The NYT recently shared an article titled "The Big Ten got too big, and fighting ensued. What’s next for a conference losing its identity?"

Couldn't have happened to a better bunch of fellers. 07-coffee3
(This post was last modified: 12-02-2025 07:13 AM by Dr Dawgma III.)
12-02-2025 07:12 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
andybible1995 Offline
Banned

Posts: 14,847
Joined: Apr 2022
I Root For: TN, MTSU, MD, Army
Location:
Post: #30
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-02-2025 07:12 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

The B1G straight up raided the Big XII for Nebraska, a blue blood football program with rich Big 8/Big XII history. THAT was the most "pivotal"—or should we say "destructive"—move. aTm left over a year after that.

Before people clamor about Miami—a renegade, hired-gun program which never belonged in the Big East anyway—let's revisit why the Northeast never had a viable conference and relied on Southern mercenaries. Wait for it...oh, that's right the B1G brought in Penn State!

The B1G and their lackey the Pac 10 also held up a college football playoff, (of course this was before the B1G Fredo'd the Pac) and now they are holding up sensible CFP expansion with their multi-bid nonsense.

The NYT recently shared an article titled "The Big Ten got too big, and fighting ensued. What’s next for a conference losing its identity?"

Couldn't have happened to a better bunch of fellers. 07-coffee3

"The BIG Fredo'd the PAC"

03-lmfao
12-02-2025 07:25 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
andybible1995 Offline
Banned

Posts: 14,847
Joined: Apr 2022
I Root For: TN, MTSU, MD, Army
Location:
Post: #31
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

FM,

I would to take your perfect world scenario, and take it a step further.

Suppose that the Power 6 conferences look like this:

ACC

Atlantic

Boston College
Florida State
Maryland
Miami (FL)
Virginia
Virginia Tech

Coastal

Clemson
Duke
Georgia Tech
NC State
North Carolina
Wake Forest

Big East

North

Cincinnati
Pittsburgh
Rutgers
Syracuse
UConn
West Virginia

South

Houston
Louisville
Memphis
SMU
South Florida
UCF

BIG

East

Indiana
Michigan
Michigan State
Ohio State
Penn State
Purdue

West

Illinois
Iowa
Minnesota
Nebraska
Northwestern
Wisconsin

Big XII

North

Iowa State
Kansas
Kansas State
Missouri
Oklahoma
Oklahoma State

South

Baylor
BYU
TCU
Texas
Texas A&M
Texas Tech

PAC-12

North

Colorado
Oregon
Oregon State
Utah
Washington
Washington State

South

Arizona
Arizona State
California
Stanford
UCLA
USC

SEC

East

Florida
Georgia
Kentucky
South Carolina
Tennessee
Vanderbilt

West

Alabama
Arkansas
Auburn
LSU
Mississippi State
Ole Miss

Does that mean that the Group of 5 Conferences (CUSA, MAC, MWC, SBC, and WAC) are forced to be more selective of who they add, especially from the ranks of the FCS?

In this scenario, I could see the CUSA making a move for Temple as a full member, but I'm not sure what would happen next.
(This post was last modified: 12-02-2025 02:10 PM by andybible1995.)
12-02-2025 02:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #32
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-02-2025 07:12 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

The B1G straight up raided the Big XII for Nebraska, a blue blood football program with rich Big 8/Big XII history. THAT was the most "pivotal"—or should we say "destructive"—move. aTm left over a year after that.

Before people clamor about Miami—a renegade, hired-gun program which never belonged in the Big East anyway—let's revisit why the Northeast never had a viable conference and relied on Southern mercenaries. Wait for it...oh, that's right the B1G brought in Penn State!

The B1G and their lackey the Pac 10 also held up a college football playoff, (of course this was before the B1G Fredo'd the Pac) and now they are holding up sensible CFP expansion with their multi-bid nonsense.

The NYT recently shared an article titled "The Big Ten got too big, and fighting ensued. What’s next for a conference losing its identity?"

Couldn't have happened to a better bunch of fellers. 07-coffee3

Stop acting dense and clueless. Your anti-Big 10 bias is on full display.

Nebraska panicked and sought out the Big 10, agreeing to unfavorable terms, because it looked like half the Big 12 was headed for the Pac 16. Their conference was on the verge of getting wrecked; they needed a lifeboat; the Big 10 was an exceptionally attractive lifeboat. Texas and TAMU called off the Pac 16 at the last minute. Grabbing a 12th member and gaining a CCG a full 2 decades after the SEC got theirs is hardly the evil, landscape altering move that the TAMU add was.

Penn St joined the Big 10 because they got tired of the rest of the northeast thinking small, focusing on basketball, and leaving them out. They wanted an all-sports league but BC, Cuse, and Pitt didn’t.

As to delaying the playoff—the Big 10, ACC, and PAC 12 were all infuriated with the SEC for their duplicitousness in courting Texas and Oklahoma while sitting on the playoff working group and building a plan that assumed there’d be a P5 when in reality the kneecapping of the Big 12 was already set into motion. The weakened Big 12 and the G5 were going to chew up 2 autobids while the Big 10/ACC/Pac 12 would have to compete with an absolutely stacked SEC. And before you go blaming the Big 10 for killing the Pac 12, the SEC OUT additions made it a competitive necessity.

Just own it— your league is the realignment bad guy.
12-02-2025 05:57 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #33
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-02-2025 02:04 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

FM,

I would to take your perfect world scenario, and take it a step further.

Suppose that the Power 6 conferences look like this:

ACC

Atlantic

Boston College
Florida State
Maryland
Miami (FL)
Virginia
Virginia Tech

Coastal

Clemson
Duke
Georgia Tech
NC State
North Carolina
Wake Forest

Big East

North

Cincinnati
Pittsburgh
Rutgers
Syracuse
UConn
West Virginia

South

Houston
Louisville
Memphis
SMU
South Florida
UCF

BIG

East

Indiana
Michigan
Michigan State
Ohio State
Penn State
Purdue

West

Illinois
Iowa
Minnesota
Nebraska
Northwestern
Wisconsin

Big XII

North

Iowa State
Kansas
Kansas State
Missouri
Oklahoma
Oklahoma State

South

Baylor
BYU
TCU
Texas
Texas A&M
Texas Tech

PAC-12

North

Colorado
Oregon
Oregon State
Utah
Washington
Washington State

South

Arizona
Arizona State
California
Stanford
UCLA
USC

SEC

East

Florida
Georgia
Kentucky
South Carolina
Tennessee
Vanderbilt

West

Alabama
Arkansas
Auburn
LSU
Mississippi State
Ole Miss

Does that mean that the Group of 5 Conferences (CUSA, MAC, MWC, SBC, and WAC) are forced to be more selective of who they add, especially from the ranks of the FCS?

In this scenario, I could see the CUSA making a move for Temple as a full member, but I'm not sure what would happen next.

That’s all the right schools—the only alteration I’d made is that I’d keep the Leaders/Legends B10 divisions but find better names—American & National?

As for everyone else—

The MAC stays intact with Temple and UMass as football only members.

The MWC (SDSU, UNLV, WYO, AFA, Colo St, UNM) adds Boise State, Fresno State, Nevada, Hawaii, Utah State, and San Jose St for 12 (look familiar?)

C-USA adds a few schools (4?) and so does the SBC (enough to be at a min of 9, but potentially 10 or 12).
12-02-2025 06:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #34
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-02-2025 05:57 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 07:12 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

The B1G straight up raided the Big XII for Nebraska, a blue blood football program with rich Big 8/Big XII history. THAT was the most "pivotal"—or should we say "destructive"—move. aTm left over a year after that.

Before people clamor about Miami—a renegade, hired-gun program which never belonged in the Big East anyway—let's revisit why the Northeast never had a viable conference and relied on Southern mercenaries. Wait for it...oh, that's right the B1G brought in Penn State!

The B1G and their lackey the Pac 10 also held up a college football playoff, (of course this was before the B1G Fredo'd the Pac) and now they are holding up sensible CFP expansion with their multi-bid nonsense.

The NYT recently shared an article titled "The Big Ten got too big, and fighting ensued. What’s next for a conference losing its identity?"

Couldn't have happened to a better bunch of fellers. 07-coffee3

Stop acting dense and clueless. Your anti-Big 10 bias is on full display.

Nebraska panicked and sought out the Big 10, agreeing to unfavorable terms, because it looked like half the Big 12 was headed for the Pac 16. Their conference was on the verge of getting wrecked; they needed a lifeboat; the Big 10 was an exceptionally attractive lifeboat. Texas and TAMU called off the Pac 16 at the last minute. Grabbing a 12th member and gaining a CCG a full 2 decades after the SEC got theirs is hardly the evil, landscape altering move that the TAMU add was.

Penn St joined the Big 10 because they got tired of the rest of the northeast thinking small, focusing on basketball, and leaving them out. They wanted an all-sports league but BC, Cuse, and Pitt didn’t.

As to delaying the playoff—the Big 10, ACC, and PAC 12 were all infuriated with the SEC for their duplicitousness in courting Texas and Oklahoma while sitting on the playoff working group and building a plan that assumed there’d be a P5 when in reality the kneecapping of the Big 12 was already set into motion. The weakened Big 12 and the G5 were going to chew up 2 autobids while the Big 10/ACC/Pac 12 would have to compete with an absolutely stacked SEC. And before you go blaming the Big 10 for killing the Pac 12, the SEC OUT additions made it a competitive necessity.

Just own it— your league is the realignment bad guy.

I won't report you for the thinly veiled name calling and simply point out not much of what you say is accurate.

Nebraska wasn't panicking, and your entire timeline is off. The Oklahoma/Texas Pac 10 scuttlebutt ramped up because Nebraska left:

"A Big 12 football coach, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, told ESPN.com's Mark Schlabach on Wednesday night if Nebraska left the Big 12 the conference would dissolve, according to his athletic director and university president. The coach said Texas, Texas A&M;, Texas Tech, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State and Colorado would join the Pac-10, leaving Baylor, Kansas, Kansas State, Missouri and Iowa State behind."

Do you really believe the B1G didn't pursue Penn State and Nebraska? They just showed up in Chicago simply orphans in search of a warm bed? 03-lmfao

The B1G and Fredo delayed any form of postseason expansion (including a playoff) as early as the 90's (most likely 80's, but I'd need to confirm) when they shot it down due to the precious Rose Bowl.

If anything, the ACC has been reactionary—slow to conform—while the B1G has been an apex predator, poaching every flavor of power league and sometimes devouring them along the way. And now they've overextended themselves and nobody is crying for them.
12-02-2025 10:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,343
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #35
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-02-2025 10:11 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 05:57 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 07:12 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

The B1G straight up raided the Big XII for Nebraska, a blue blood football program with rich Big 8/Big XII history. THAT was the most "pivotal"—or should we say "destructive"—move. aTm left over a year after that.

Before people clamor about Miami—a renegade, hired-gun program which never belonged in the Big East anyway—let's revisit why the Northeast never had a viable conference and relied on Southern mercenaries. Wait for it...oh, that's right the B1G brought in Penn State!

The B1G and their lackey the Pac 10 also held up a college football playoff, (of course this was before the B1G Fredo'd the Pac) and now they are holding up sensible CFP expansion with their multi-bid nonsense.

The NYT recently shared an article titled "The Big Ten got too big, and fighting ensued. What’s next for a conference losing its identity?"

Couldn't have happened to a better bunch of fellers. 07-coffee3

Stop acting dense and clueless. Your anti-Big 10 bias is on full display.

Nebraska panicked and sought out the Big 10, agreeing to unfavorable terms, because it looked like half the Big 12 was headed for the Pac 16. Their conference was on the verge of getting wrecked; they needed a lifeboat; the Big 10 was an exceptionally attractive lifeboat. Texas and TAMU called off the Pac 16 at the last minute. Grabbing a 12th member and gaining a CCG a full 2 decades after the SEC got theirs is hardly the evil, landscape altering move that the TAMU add was.

Penn St joined the Big 10 because they got tired of the rest of the northeast thinking small, focusing on basketball, and leaving them out. They wanted an all-sports league but BC, Cuse, and Pitt didn’t.

As to delaying the playoff—the Big 10, ACC, and PAC 12 were all infuriated with the SEC for their duplicitousness in courting Texas and Oklahoma while sitting on the playoff working group and building a plan that assumed there’d be a P5 when in reality the kneecapping of the Big 12 was already set into motion. The weakened Big 12 and the G5 were going to chew up 2 autobids while the Big 10/ACC/Pac 12 would have to compete with an absolutely stacked SEC. And before you go blaming the Big 10 for killing the Pac 12, the SEC OUT additions made it a competitive necessity.

Just own it— your league is the realignment bad guy.

I won't report you for the thinly veiled name calling and simply point out not much of what you say is accurate.

Nebraska wasn't panicking, and your entire timeline is off. The Oklahoma/Texas Pac 10 scuttlebutt ramped up because Nebraska left:

"A Big 12 football coach, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, told ESPN.com's Mark Schlabach on Wednesday night if Nebraska left the Big 12 the conference would dissolve, according to his athletic director and university president. The coach said Texas, Texas A&M;, Texas Tech, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State and Colorado would join the Pac-10, leaving Baylor, Kansas, Kansas State, Missouri and Iowa State behind."

Do you really believe the B1G didn't pursue Penn State and Nebraska? They just showed up in Chicago simply orphans in search of a warm bed? 03-lmfao

The B1G and Fredo delayed any form of postseason expansion (including a playoff) as early as the 90's (most likely 80's, but I'd need to confirm) when they shot it down due to the precious Rose Bowl.

If anything, the ACC has been reactionary—slow to conform—while the B1G has been an apex predator, poaching every flavor of power league and sometimes devouring them along the way. And now they've overextended themselves and nobody is crying for them.
Your league has 7 poached former Big East/AAC members. 8 if you count Notre Dame.

And will be taking even more in two years after its next hair cut.
12-02-2025 10:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
billybobby777 Offline
The REAL BillyBobby
*

Posts: 14,623
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 755
I Root For: ECU, Army
Location: Houston dont sleepon
Post: #36
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-02-2025 07:25 AM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 07:12 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

The B1G straight up raided the Big XII for Nebraska, a blue blood football program with rich Big 8/Big XII history. THAT was the most "pivotal"—or should we say "destructive"—move. aTm left over a year after that.

Before people clamor about Miami—a renegade, hired-gun program which never belonged in the Big East anyway—let's revisit why the Northeast never had a viable conference and relied on Southern mercenaries. Wait for it...oh, that's right the B1G brought in Penn State!

The B1G and their lackey the Pac 10 also held up a college football playoff, (of course this was before the B1G Fredo'd the Pac) and now they are holding up sensible CFP expansion with their multi-bid nonsense.

The NYT recently shared an article titled "The Big Ten got too big, and fighting ensued. What’s next for a conference losing its identity?"

Couldn't have happened to a better bunch of fellers. 07-coffee3

"The BIG Fredo'd the PAC"

03-lmfao

Before that though the SEC “Ned Beaty’d the SWC by yanking the oinking hog of Arkansas.
12-02-2025 10:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #37
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-02-2025 10:36 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 10:11 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 05:57 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 07:12 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

The B1G straight up raided the Big XII for Nebraska, a blue blood football program with rich Big 8/Big XII history. THAT was the most "pivotal"—or should we say "destructive"—move. aTm left over a year after that.

Before people clamor about Miami—a renegade, hired-gun program which never belonged in the Big East anyway—let's revisit why the Northeast never had a viable conference and relied on Southern mercenaries. Wait for it...oh, that's right the B1G brought in Penn State!

The B1G and their lackey the Pac 10 also held up a college football playoff, (of course this was before the B1G Fredo'd the Pac) and now they are holding up sensible CFP expansion with their multi-bid nonsense.

The NYT recently shared an article titled "The Big Ten got too big, and fighting ensued. What’s next for a conference losing its identity?"

Couldn't have happened to a better bunch of fellers. 07-coffee3

Stop acting dense and clueless. Your anti-Big 10 bias is on full display.

Nebraska panicked and sought out the Big 10, agreeing to unfavorable terms, because it looked like half the Big 12 was headed for the Pac 16. Their conference was on the verge of getting wrecked; they needed a lifeboat; the Big 10 was an exceptionally attractive lifeboat. Texas and TAMU called off the Pac 16 at the last minute. Grabbing a 12th member and gaining a CCG a full 2 decades after the SEC got theirs is hardly the evil, landscape altering move that the TAMU add was.

Penn St joined the Big 10 because they got tired of the rest of the northeast thinking small, focusing on basketball, and leaving them out. They wanted an all-sports league but BC, Cuse, and Pitt didn’t.

As to delaying the playoff—the Big 10, ACC, and PAC 12 were all infuriated with the SEC for their duplicitousness in courting Texas and Oklahoma while sitting on the playoff working group and building a plan that assumed there’d be a P5 when in reality the kneecapping of the Big 12 was already set into motion. The weakened Big 12 and the G5 were going to chew up 2 autobids while the Big 10/ACC/Pac 12 would have to compete with an absolutely stacked SEC. And before you go blaming the Big 10 for killing the Pac 12, the SEC OUT additions made it a competitive necessity.

Just own it— your league is the realignment bad guy.

I won't report you for the thinly veiled name calling and simply point out not much of what you say is accurate.

Nebraska wasn't panicking, and your entire timeline is off. The Oklahoma/Texas Pac 10 scuttlebutt ramped up because Nebraska left:

"A Big 12 football coach, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, told ESPN.com's Mark Schlabach on Wednesday night if Nebraska left the Big 12 the conference would dissolve, according to his athletic director and university president. The coach said Texas, Texas A&M;, Texas Tech, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State and Colorado would join the Pac-10, leaving Baylor, Kansas, Kansas State, Missouri and Iowa State behind."

Do you really believe the B1G didn't pursue Penn State and Nebraska? They just showed up in Chicago simply orphans in search of a warm bed? 03-lmfao

The B1G and Fredo delayed any form of postseason expansion (including a playoff) as early as the 90's (most likely 80's, but I'd need to confirm) when they shot it down due to the precious Rose Bowl.

If anything, the ACC has been reactionary—slow to conform—while the B1G has been an apex predator, poaching every flavor of power league and sometimes devouring them along the way. And now they've overextended themselves and nobody is crying for them.
Your league has 7 poached former Big East/AAC members. 8 if you count Notre Dame.

And will be taking even more in two years after its next hair cut.

...and your school joining the B1G is why the Big East should have never even tried to play football, especially with Miami as they were very open about their designs to join the ACC.
12-02-2025 11:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
andybible1995 Offline
Banned

Posts: 14,847
Joined: Apr 2022
I Root For: TN, MTSU, MD, Army
Location:
Post: #38
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(12-02-2025 06:09 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 02:04 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:50 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As Wahoowa points out, Texas A&M to the SEC was the most pivotal conference realignment history and depending on your perspective, could have doomed the system.

I wish the Pac 10 would have been less ambitious at the time and not shot for the moon. The Pac 16 dream conference brought to a head the very worst of the Big 12’s infighting—Nebraska’s insecurities with the power shift to the south, TAMU’s shoulder chip as the #2 Texas team and their pining to move east, and Texas’s shear ego in their attempt to impose their will and financially disadvantage their conference mates.

What needed to happen in 2010 was for the Big 10 to add a member and the Pac 10 to add 2, putting them on equal standing with the other BCS (sans Big East) leagues. Lack of a title game was causing them to leave revenue on the table and disadvantaging their champs in the BCS standings.

In a perfect world:

Big 10 adds Nebraska
PAC 10 adds Colorado & Utah
Big 12 adds BYU & TCU

We maintain the harmony of the BCS 6 and hopefully adopt an 8 team playoff soon after.

Cherry-picking the MWC would have created greater separation between the G-leagues and P-leagues, negating the need for a guaranteed autoberth—a conditional one based on reaching a certain threshold in the rankings would have been fine. The Big East could still potentially add UCF, Memphis, SMU, and Houston to bolster their football side.

FM,

I would to take your perfect world scenario, and take it a step further.

Suppose that the Power 6 conferences look like this:

ACC

Atlantic

Boston College
Florida State
Maryland
Miami (FL)
Virginia
Virginia Tech

Coastal

Clemson
Duke
Georgia Tech
NC State
North Carolina
Wake Forest

Big East

North

Cincinnati
Pittsburgh
Rutgers
Syracuse
UConn
West Virginia

South

Houston
Louisville
Memphis
SMU
South Florida
UCF

BIG

East

Indiana
Michigan
Michigan State
Ohio State
Penn State
Purdue

West

Illinois
Iowa
Minnesota
Nebraska
Northwestern
Wisconsin

Big XII

North

Iowa State
Kansas
Kansas State
Missouri
Oklahoma
Oklahoma State

South

Baylor
BYU
TCU
Texas
Texas A&M
Texas Tech

PAC-12

North

Colorado
Oregon
Oregon State
Utah
Washington
Washington State

South

Arizona
Arizona State
California
Stanford
UCLA
USC

SEC

East

Florida
Georgia
Kentucky
South Carolina
Tennessee
Vanderbilt

West

Alabama
Arkansas
Auburn
LSU
Mississippi State
Ole Miss

Does that mean that the Group of 5 Conferences (CUSA, MAC, MWC, SBC, and WAC) are forced to be more selective of who they add, especially from the ranks of the FCS?

In this scenario, I could see the CUSA making a move for Temple as a full member, but I'm not sure what would happen next.

That’s all the right schools—the only alteration I’d made is that I’d keep the Leaders/Legends B10 divisions but find better names—American & National?

As for everyone else—

The MAC stays intact with Temple and UMass as football only members.

The MWC (SDSU, UNLV, WYO, AFA, Colo St, UNM) adds Boise State, Fresno State, Nevada, Hawaii, Utah State, and San Jose St for 12 (look familiar?)

C-USA adds a few schools (4?) and so does the SBC (enough to be at a min of 9, but potentially 10 or 12).

Well, my questions about the MAC and MWC were answered. All that's left is the CUSA, SBC and WAC.

Here's what those three would look like after the moves:

CUSA

East Carolina
Marshall
Rice
Southern Miss
Tulsa
Tulane
UAB
UTEP

SBC

Arkansas State
Florida Atlantic
FIU
Louisiana
Louisiana Monroe
Middle Tennessee
North Texas
Troy
Western Kentucky

WAC

Idaho
Louisiana Tech
New Mexico State
Texas State
UTSA

IMO, I see the CUSA picking up Florida Atlantic, FIU, Middle Tennessee and North Texas, and the SBC and WAC football schools merge under the SBC umbrella. Idaho and New Mexico State are football-only members while Georgia State and South Alabama are brought in as full members when they start their football programs.
12-03-2025 07:33 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #39
RE: Big 12 alternate history
(11-30-2025 05:14 PM)mike012779 Wrote:  Seeing Texas , Texas A&M , Oklahoma and all those old Big12 teams. Why wasn’t the Big 12 more aggressive long ago. Go after the Pac12 teams or even pry an Arkansas or Lsu from the Sec when it was in its prime? If football is king, they had solid football programs.

Back to this topic.

The Big XII never had the leverage to pull from anyone else that was of equal to greater strength.

When the Big XII formed, there were essentially two other options on the table which clearly indicate their standing on the grand totem pole of realignment:

1) A full merger with the SWC which would have resulted in Houston, Rice, SMU, and TCU also being brought in.

2) Bringing in BYU and New Mexico as the thirteenth and fourteenth members.

It was only in Jerry Jones' mind where Arkansas would return to Texas, awaiting with open arms. Instead, we ended up with some of the original SWC core in the SEC: Texas, aTm, Arkansas, Oklahoma, plus a couple schools who were invited to the SWC, but declined in LSU and Ole Miss.
12-03-2025 09:56 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #40
RE: Big 12 alternate history
@Andy

In real life we encountered a similar situation with C-USA and the SBC—only it was somewhat protracted over a couple of years.

C-USA added 6 all at once: Charlotte, ODU, UNT, FIU, LA Tech, and UTSA to C-USA, and the later MTSU and FAU got a call and after that, WKU. I’m guessing if C-USA had found themselves in this similar predicament, they add 4-6 of the first group.

Pick your option—either C-USA @ 12 or at 16.
The SBC added Texas St and Georgia St. Their next 2 adds after that were App St and Georgia St.

ALTERNATIVELY— I think the 6 member MWC might have merged with the 8 member C-USA. (UTEP moves to the West division with the MWC schools). Adding 6 from the WAC is more probable
12-03-2025 10:24 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.