CFB Harbin Rankings - 2025
If you see my experiment from the offseason, you're probably somewhat familiar with this. It's a method used for determining OHSAA playoff teams. Top 12 teams (down from 16 teams) for 18-27 team regions. 4 regions each in 7 divisions each, based on boys 9-11th grade enrollment with a competitive balance.
How it works is teams get points from winning games (L1 points). Then they get extra points from the teams they beat winning games (L2 points), which rewards teams who beat stronger teams and play stronger schedules. It also has the added benefit of comparing over 700 teams with unbalanced and uneven schedules with success for over 50 season in Ohio HS Football.
Formula: L1 Points/# of Games played + L2 Points/# of opponents games to be played*10
- Note that I will have a 2nd total Points multiplied by 10 Points based on previous feedback
Example: OSU - L1: 54/10 = 5.4, L2: 224/144*10 = 15.556; Total: 5.4 + 15.556 = 20.956
- Total Points * 10 = 209.56 (by request from previous feedback)
Points per Wins
B1G/SEC/ND - 6 Points
ACC/B12 - 5 Points
G6/UCONN - 4 Points
FCS - 2 Points
Non-D1 - 1 Point
- Note, I plan to do a 2nd version with ACC and B12 getting 6 points each, but it won't be until the regular season is complete. I did all of FBS and it took about 24 hours to make this and while I can copy paste, I would rather update 1 spreadsheet weekly for all 136 FBS teams during the season and create new spreadsheets afterwards that will be easy to modify.
Something this method doesn't take into account is CCGs so I plan to have a pre-CCG list and a post-CCG list. Then take the higher points total from the 2 list into a final list to not to punish teams from CCGs losses, but allow teams opportunities to improve if they win their CCG or beat a team(s) who won their CCG (or in Ohio State's case, got points from Marshall winning, but lost more points from Oregon beating Penn State).
This won't be the exact format as I had to modify it to better fit college football, but I think is interesting to compare to the AP, Coaches, BCS, and CFP Rankings. The farther down the list we go, I think it becomes less reliable, but I think at the top and maybe in the middle, it has worth. This also won't take into account of H2H results and record. It just looks at your entire schedule to this point and is updated as more games are played (probably could've started this a few weeks ago with the CFP Rankings, but didn't have the time until this weekend). I will not be including FCS playoff results for teams playing FCS playoff opponents, just FCS regular season games. Army-Navy will also not be included.
I can also at some point separate just conference schedule data and compare teams in conferences, but as I found out before, this would better serve as a tiebreaker as H2H results and conference record aren't considered (last year, OSU was #2 in B1G because of a stronger SoS at 7-2 and H2H wins was above 8-1 PSU and Indiana; UM at 5-4 was #5 ahead of 6-3 Iowa and Illinois because stronger SoS).
Worth noting that the top 6 teams going into this past Saturday were Indiana, Alabama, Ohio St. Texas A&M, Georgia, and Texas Tech (I thought I took a screenshot of the P4 + PAC2 & UCONN, but I guess I forgot to take it prior to starting the G5 conferences and updating the P4, PAC2, and UCONN and I couldn't remember beyond the top 6).
|