(12-02-2025 06:35 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: [quote='chrisd11' pid='20450729' dateline='1764717765']
I never said it was a trend and I don't want to hire him. But some folks are running him down like he's a bum. He's obviously a good football coach. One dude was criticizing him for not winning by enough points, at Kennesaw St.
And again, I don't want Memphis to hire him. I want them to fully vet Mike Shanahan and if he's as good as he seems on paper, that's who I want them to hire.
I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
[/quote
Do not be surprised if this is our coach. Maybe, we will see.
So our AD considered this a "splash" hire? We really are headed down hill, SMH.
If the new coach fails, doctor scott goes with him
(12-02-2025 06:35 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: [quote='chrisd11' pid='20450729' dateline='1764717765']
I never said it was a trend and I don't want to hire him. But some folks are running him down like he's a bum. He's obviously a good football coach. One dude was criticizing him for not winning by enough points, at Kennesaw St.
And again, I don't want Memphis to hire him. I want them to fully vet Mike Shanahan and if he's as good as he seems on paper, that's who I want them to hire.
I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
[/quote
Do not be surprised if this is our coach. Maybe, we will see.
So our AD considered this a "splash" hire? We really are headed down hill, SMH.
If the new coach fails, doctor scott goes with him
Ed is not calling the shots but he will get the heat.
(12-02-2025 06:22 PM)chrisd11 Wrote: I never said it was a trend and I don't want to hire him. But some folks are running him down like he's a bum. He's obviously a good football coach. One dude was criticizing him for not winning by enough points, at Kennesaw St.
And again, I don't want Memphis to hire him. I want them to fully vet Mike Shanahan and if he's as good as he seems on paper, that's who I want them to hire.
I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
Plus a knat could have farted and changed the outcome of some of those kennesaw state games. I'd rather have a coordinator from a successful P4 myself.
True. They only had one easy win and the rest were close. Liberty was awful this year but took Kennesaw to double OT.
We can do better.
In our Cotton Bowl year, we had to sweat out a bad Tulsa team's chipshot fg miss to win that game. (jump tp 4:44)
(This post was last modified: 12-02-2025 09:46 PM by EarthBoundMisfit.)
(12-02-2025 06:35 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: [quote='chrisd11' pid='20450729' dateline='1764717765']
I never said it was a trend and I don't want to hire him. But some folks are running him down like he's a bum. He's obviously a good football coach. One dude was criticizing him for not winning by enough points, at Kennesaw St.
And again, I don't want Memphis to hire him. I want them to fully vet Mike Shanahan and if he's as good as he seems on paper, that's who I want them to hire.
I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
[/quote
Do not be surprised if this is our coach. Maybe, we will see.
So our AD considered this a "splash" hire? We really are headed down hill, SMH.
If the new coach fails, doctor scott goes with him
(12-02-2025 06:35 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: [quote='chrisd11' pid='20450729' dateline='1764717765']
I never said it was a trend and I don't want to hire him. But some folks are running him down like he's a bum. He's obviously a good football coach. One dude was criticizing him for not winning by enough points, at Kennesaw St.
And again, I don't want Memphis to hire him. I want them to fully vet Mike Shanahan and if he's as good as he seems on paper, that's who I want them to hire.
I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
[/quote
Do not be surprised if this is our coach. Maybe, we will see.
So our AD considered this a "splash" hire? We really are headed down hill, SMH.
If the new coach fails, doctor scott goes with him
Why wait, just let the guy go now
We haven't fired anyone since Tubby. Hope our FB hire is a great success & everyone concerned gets hero status.
(12-02-2025 06:39 PM)griffin Wrote: I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
[/quote
Do not be surprised if this is our coach. Maybe, we will see.
So our AD considered this a "splash" hire? We really are headed down hill, SMH.
If the new coach fails, doctor scott goes with him
Why wait, just let the guy go now
We haven't fired anyone since Tubby. Hope our FB hire is a great success & everyone concerned gets hero status.
meh
We've fired softball, baseball, womens basketball coaches in the last few years.
The hire that would make more sense but I know number of you would reject him as a retread is Dan Mullen.
If Memphis’s administration and boosters are serious about elevating the program — improving recruiting, upgrading facilities, maybe re-positioning for a higher-tier conference — then Dan Mullen offers the highest upside. He’s the kind of coach who can bring credibility, recruit talent, develop players (especially QBs), and build sustained success.
If they prefer stability and a lower-risk path, then Tim Cramsey makes sense — but only if expectations remain modest (i.e., steady competitiveness, not necessarily contending for major bowls or Power-Conference status).
(12-02-2025 06:35 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: [quote='chrisd11' pid='20450729' dateline='1764717765']
I never said it was a trend and I don't want to hire him. But some folks are running him down like he's a bum. He's obviously a good football coach. One dude was criticizing him for not winning by enough points, at Kennesaw St.
And again, I don't want Memphis to hire him. I want them to fully vet Mike Shanahan and if he's as good as he seems on paper, that's who I want them to hire.
I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
[/quote
Do not be surprised if this is our coach. Maybe, we will see.
Nothing surprises me these days. I really hope we aim higher.
(12-03-2025 09:42 AM)hartlessnhere Wrote: The hire that would make more sense but I know number of you would reject him as a retread is Dan Mullen.
If Memphis’s administration and boosters are serious about elevating the program — improving recruiting, upgrading facilities, maybe re-positioning for a higher-tier conference — then Dan Mullen offers the highest upside. He’s the kind of coach who can bring credibility, recruit talent, develop players (especially QBs), and build sustained success.
If they prefer stability and a lower-risk path, then Tim Cramsey makes sense — but only if expectations remain modest (i.e., steady competitiveness, not necessarily contending for major bowls or Power-Conference status).
Cramsey would be the TOUGHEST sell of all the candidates.
A continuation of the regime that most of us were tired of?
The same thing we did last time?
A coach that is not being mentioned for ANY other hires out of all the openings around the country?
(12-02-2025 06:35 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: [quote='chrisd11' pid='20450729' dateline='1764717765']
I never said it was a trend and I don't want to hire him. But some folks are running him down like he's a bum. He's obviously a good football coach. One dude was criticizing him for not winning by enough points, at Kennesaw St.
And again, I don't want Memphis to hire him. I want them to fully vet Mike Shanahan and if he's as good as he seems on paper, that's who I want them to hire.
I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
[/quote
Do not be surprised if this is our coach. Maybe, we will see.
So our AD considered this a "splash" hire? We really are headed down hill, SMH.
If the new coach fails, doctor scott goes with him
(12-02-2025 06:39 PM)griffin Wrote: I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
[/quote
Do not be surprised if this is our coach. Maybe, we will see.
So our AD considered this a "splash" hire? We really are headed down hill, SMH.
If the new coach fails, doctor scott goes with him
Why wait, just let the guy go now
Is accountability "mean?"
ADs who are as popular as roofing nails on a concrete driveway and as arrogant as any individual who has ever drawn breath, should absolutely be held accountable.
(12-03-2025 09:42 AM)hartlessnhere Wrote: The hire that would make more sense but I know number of you would reject him as a retread is Dan Mullen.
If Memphis’s administration and boosters are serious about elevating the program — improving recruiting, upgrading facilities, maybe re-positioning for a higher-tier conference — then Dan Mullen offers the highest upside. He’s the kind of coach who can bring credibility, recruit talent, develop players (especially QBs), and build sustained success.
If they prefer stability and a lower-risk path, then Tim Cramsey makes sense — but only if expectations remain modest (i.e., steady competitiveness, not necessarily contending for major bowls or Power-Conference status).
Cramsey would be the TOUGHEST sell of all the candidates.
A continuation of the regime that most of us were tired of?
The same thing we did last time?
A coach that is not being mentioned for ANY other hires out of all the openings around the country?
now that you mention it...he has 'Memphis hire' written ALL over him....
(12-02-2025 06:22 PM)chrisd11 Wrote: I never said it was a trend and I don't want to hire him. But some folks are running him down like he's a bum. He's obviously a good football coach. One dude was criticizing him for not winning by enough points, at Kennesaw St.
And again, I don't want Memphis to hire him. I want them to fully vet Mike Shanahan and if he's as good as he seems on paper, that's who I want them to hire.
I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
Plus a knat could have farted and changed the outcome of some of those kennesaw state games. I'd rather have a coordinator from a successful P4 myself.
True. They only had one easy win and the rest were close. Liberty was awful this year but took Kennesaw to double OT.
We can do better.
In our Cotton Bowl year, we had to sweat out a bad Tulsa team's chipshot fg miss to win that game. (jump tp 4:44)
What most forget is that Tulsa got the ball, down 1, with about 4:30 left in the game and marched the ball easily down the field. Then, when they got near the goal line, got super conservative and basically played for the FG attempt. But, it's Tulsa so...
This is closest thing to a specific name that those around the program say they like. This article is from yesterday but he updated his tweet about Helton
(12-03-2025 09:16 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: meh
We've fired softball, baseball, womens basketball coaches in the last few years.
Insignificant/irrelevant compared to our FB & MBB programs
Oh, I agree with that. But your post seemed to indicate an unwillingness to fire anyone - which is not factual.
I'm sure we've fired other AD staff too but not HCs of our major sports since Tubby & he essentially fired himself.
So what point are you trying to make? That we haven't fired a fb or mens bb coach in 5-6 years? Ok? Not sure what that means.
Let me make it clear for you, I'm hoping we hire the RIGHT guy because we have a tendency to keep a mediocre coach around rather than fire him, i.e., RS. And it has brought major damage to our program - attendance & ticket sales, playing for conference championships. Clear enough?
(12-02-2025 06:22 PM)chrisd11 Wrote: I never said it was a trend and I don't want to hire him. But some folks are running him down like he's a bum. He's obviously a good football coach. One dude was criticizing him for not winning by enough points, at Kennesaw St.
And again, I don't want Memphis to hire him. I want them to fully vet Mike Shanahan and if he's as good as he seems on paper, that's who I want them to hire.
I don’t want to disparage the guy, but there just isn’t enough data to consider him a viable candidate. He may be incredible and we missed out on a diamond here, but this hire needs to be a good one. One bad hire and we become irrelevant.. fast.
Plus a knat could have farted and changed the outcome of some of those kennesaw state games. I'd rather have a coordinator from a successful P4 myself.
True. They only had one easy win and the rest were close. Liberty was awful this year but took Kennesaw to double OT.
We can do better.
He would be a good hire for UAB, not here. If this is the guy I'm starting to change my opinion of our AD hire as well.