AdoptedMonarch
Heisman

Posts: 8,949
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 3093
I Root For: Old Dominion
Location: Norfolk, Va.
|
RE: Top 1% of earners pay 46% of all taxes. Bottom 50% pay 2%.
(06-20-2025 10:50 PM)ODUsmitty Wrote: Certainly not in the top 1% and certainly not in bottom 50%, either. Make decent money and have earned that right through my hard work and dedication to my craft. The top 1% pays plenty, and it is enough by my standards. They fund many lives that live beneath their level. The bottom 50% is where I have real problems, as you have the working poor and the dependent poor. The working poor deserve every opportunity to improve their economic status, and I support some of my tax dollars supporting them to do just that. The dependent poor are nothing more than human tapeworms that feed off of the rest of us. I care nothing for them and wish their existence was harder, not easier. It should be painful to be lazy or unreliable, and their existence should be right at the level that they can survive on basic foodstuffs and crappy housing. Want to live better, than be better. But there are literally generations of his human scum that are completely dependent on the government (and many are obese). Get off your arse, get a f'ing skill and job, and take care of yourselves
In my mind this is similar to homeless in colder cities during the winter. If one feeds and shelters them, they will gladly take your charity. If you choose to not help them, the problem will resolve itself in the first couple of freezes. Harsh but true. My father grew up growing crops on a Methodist orphanage. He asked for nothing as an adult, served in the Air Force, and his offspring are doing quite well. I have zero sympathy for generational dependence and would rather have my taxes support those working to improve their situation, vice just sucking off the government teat.
This is a solid a post. And a properly functioning tax system would be able to distinguish between the “working poor” and the “dependent poor”. We, unfortunately, do not have a functioning tax system. What we have instead is a discombobulated mess that (purposely, I think) invites resentment. And we find ourselves endlessly arguing about the unfairness of it all, but with no realistic fix to our current system.
The solution? A FairTax system. Scrap our current income/wealth-based revenue methods and instead install an across-the-board arrangement tied to spending, with a fixed percentage charged to sales of both goods and services. In order to support the “working poor”, which we absolutely should do, provide that support via a prebate.
I don’t know, and am not qualified to suggest, the right numbers - - neither the percentage charged nor the amount of the prebate. But whatever the numbers, a FairTax system would do a better job of incentivizing every American to behave in a manner that is in everyone’s best interest. And it would minimize the need to point fingers at others who are perceived (whether justifiably or not) as “not paying their fair share” - - whether because they are viewed as being too wealthy or too lazy.
The reality, I understand, is that this will never happen. The FairTax proposal has been floated for at least two generations. As sensible as it is in theory, we seem as a society to get some weird enjoyment from the resentment that is inevitable under our current system. And so on and on we go.
|
|
| 06-21-2025 07:28 AM |
|