Bull
Heisman
Posts: 5,374
Joined: Mar 2011
Reputation: 397
I Root For: USF and the AAC!
Location:
|
RE: Colley Matrix Revokes UCF’s National Title
(05-12-2019 01:33 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote: (05-12-2019 11:54 AM)Bull Wrote: It's quite simple... we don't have a legitimate NC. We had a 2, and now 4, team tournament. So long as 'selection' is involved, and not everyone has a pathway, it's ridiculously subjective. You can't 'select' in teams for a playoff. By definition, that is not what a playoff is...
If the P5 distill down to 4 and separate, it can be a playoff. If they expand it to all FBS conference champs, it's a playoff. Just look at how MLB, NFL, etc playoffs happen... the regular season is actually the first part of the playoff. You don't have that in NCAAFB, when a team can be undefeated for 2 seasons and still not be 'selected'.
Given we don't have a real playoff, leading to a situation where an undefeated UCF could beat Auburn in a NY6 bowl, and Auburn beat BOTH 'playoff' teams... yeah, you have a real strong argument that UCF was the best team in the country. Relying on the fact that some committee kept them off the field is a real weak argument.
And this is coming from a USF fan...
So you want a 130 team tournament? Makes sense to anyone who hasn't watched or played one second of football.
Don't put words in my mouth, I didn't say that. But everyone knows how to easily make this a real playoff, give everyone a pathway. Making the arbitrary selectees to the tourn from 2 to 4 schools did NOTHING to make it a real playoff. 5 'P5' champs, 1 bid for the G5, 2 at large. Done. Everyone has a pathway and no more nonsense. Didn't take 130 teams did it?
|
|
05-12-2019 02:32 PM |
|