(02-09-2019 01:01 PM)esayem Wrote: The Mountain West grew too quickly when Utah left.
No, they didn't. Here's what happened:
June 2010 -- Utah accepts invitation from Pac-10. Boise State accepts invitation from MWC.
August 2010 -- BYU agrees to Karl Benson's idiotic scheme that ended up destroying the WAC. The plan was to have BYU leave the MWC, become indy in FB, and join the WAC for all other sports, and part of the plan was to lure UNLV and SDSU to move back to the WAC as well. The MWC blew up the plan by getting Nevada and Fresno State to leave the WAC for the MWC. (BYU didn't get burned, they left the MWC anyway, as we know.)
November 2010 -- TCU accepts invitation from Big East. (Of course TCU ended up moving to the Big 12 and not the Big East.)
December 2010 -- Hawai'i accepts football-only invitation from MWC.
December 2011 -- Boise State and SDSU announce they will join Big "East". That leaves the MWC with 7 full members, 8 for football.
May 2012 -- SJSU and Utah State accept invitations from MWC.
December 2012 -- Boise State tells the Big East to forget it and remains in the MWC.
January 2013 -- SDSU finally decides to remain in the MWC.
The MWC invited Boise when Utah left. They invited Nevada and Fresno to blow up Benson's scheme to raid the MWC. They invited Hawai'i to get a 10th football team after TCU left. They invited SJSU and USU because they were down to 7 full members after Boise and SDSU announced they were leaving. I suppose we could second guess choosing SJSU instead of UTEP, but I don't see what's wrong with any of the other moves.