(10-10-2017 11:12 AM)Doggone Wrote:  

(10-10-2017 11:07 AM)Djud Wrote:  

(10-10-2017 10:33 AM)7 Wrote:  The one play away narrative needs to stop. He’s thrown 3 picks in his last 5 pass attempts. He didn’t get benched because of one play. He got benched because he makes bad decisions, just as he did in practice.

It may not fit your narrative but the 3rd pick never happens if the pass is completed. Your good points get clouded by you ignoring information that doesn't support your opinions. Your point on Santa is all that he did prior to the last 2 min of the SDSU game gets negated. You look for only the data to support your initial stance; the same one where you said Childers gives you "the least good and the most bad".

I think Carey is on the same track as you; he starts Graham when he is healthy, which he won't be this week, and he starts Childers against Buffalo. My hope is that he doesn't yank Childers if he starts to screw up. Pick a lane, believe in your choice and have the kids back. Thank God Harnish was allowed to develop and grow through mistakes. That would have been a complete waste of talent.

Was Harnish? He was benched for Grady. Grady didn't perform so they went back to Harnish.

Right, and there was never a realistic alternative to Harnish.

Let’s be honest, Harnish was the exception to the norm. It’s very rare to see a QB make the big of a jump in the middle of a career. That’s not to say guys don’t improve, because they do, but usually not from fringe starter to MAC MVP.