(01-23-2020 02:13 PM)AllTideUp Wrote:  There really shouldn't be a committee in the first place, but it seems the formula should be pretty simple.

- One active AD from each of the Power 5
- One person with a significant administrative background from each of the Power 5
- One former coach from each of the Power 5
- Five former players, regardless of affiliation, who spent at least 4 years at the FBS level
- One active AD, one administrator, and one former coach from the G5 level.

That's 23 members and basically every potential interest is represented.

The Big 10 and Pac 12 have historically been over-represented (ties in with JR's comments about a little club). Big 12 and ACC ADs have often had previous experience with Big 10 and Pac 12 schools.

Hasn't really helped the Pac 12.

I remember the Big 12 complaining when Archie Manning left that nobody left on the committee but the one Big 12 AD knew anything about the Big 12.