What credibility am I losing? More people voted for Gore. It's a fact.
The electoral college is the system. Yes.
And... I don't like it. I admit it. The electoral college is outdated. It distorts the will of the people. And it ought to be replaced. In fact, if the electoral college wasn't in the constitution, it would have been declared unconstitutional by now.
Why? The electoral college defies the principle of one person, one vote. Small states are overrepresented in the college. Large states are underrepresented. In fact, Wyoming only has as many people as metropolitan Dayton. Yet it still gets three electoral college votes, which is close to triple the clout metropolitan Dayton has in presidental elections.
In order for the college to reflect the balance of population among the states, two electors would have to be subtracted from each state and the District of Columbia. Had that been the case, Gore would have won.
Essentially our Constitution forces this country unnaturally rightward. It does so with the electoral college. And it does so in the Senate, where a state about as siginficant as metropolitan Dayton gets as many senators as the entire state of New York.
The constitution favors small states. And these small states tend to be rural, conservative and -- as we can see on the maps above -- red.
I understand the constitutional compromise that produced our bicameral system. But I also recognize what many fail to see -- that the framers were not infalliable. We need look no further than the fact that our framers made a royal mess the first time they tried to draw up a constitution. Remember the Articles of Confederation? It was a disaster.
Essentially, our constitution is a second effort -- a second effort drawn up in an era of slavery, an era when people from Virginia called themselves Virginians and few people any where in these united states called themselves Americans.
It's a hell of a document. But it isn't perfect. (If it were, our Founding Fathers might have made a bit more clear what they had in mind with Amendment No. 2, for instance).
We live in a different age. In this day and age, an urban and suburban age, giving Wyoming as large a senate delegation as California makes only marginally more sense than giving Sault Sainte Marie the same clout as Detroit in the Michigan legislature. (And that, my friends, would be unconstitutional).
This is the reality: 50,996,582 voted for Al Gore and 50,456,062 voted for George Bush. It was close -- but Al Gore represented the will of the people, not George Bush.
Our constitution prevented the will of the people from being heard.
I have a problem with that, yes.
<!--EDIT|RochesterFalcon|Apr 16 2003, 11:00 PM-->
|