CSNbbs
[NEWS] Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: The Spin Room (/forum-540.html)
+---- Thread: [NEWS] Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC (/thread-989207.html)

Pages: 1 2


Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - UofMstateU - 04-02-2024 05:56 PM




RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - stinkfist - 04-02-2024 06:05 PM

again, I can't begin to define how the gubernatorial races now matter more than EVER YA STUPID ARSE MOTEHRTRUCKKKERS...

it's starin' ya right in the fk'n face...

/rant


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - MileHighBronco - 04-02-2024 06:52 PM

This push is because DJT could flip Arizona, Nevada and Georgia and still lose by 1 Electoral vote.

Now, you understand why this scheme has been pushed by the dems and especially in red states, although it is pushed also in blue states.

Winner - take - all is the way it should be. When this scheme was first introduced, one of the arguments for it was that it would help negate the effect that big (blue) cities have on vote totals in states. Like all dem proposals, it sounded good. But that was not the reason the left wanted this in all states.

I hope that the politicians in Nebraska send this to the trash heap.


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - rath v2.0 - 04-02-2024 07:01 PM

Yep. Without Michigan or PA his ceiling with all the swing states and keeping every state he won in 2020 is only 268. That 1 EV could be really important.


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - green - 04-02-2024 07:06 PM

(04-02-2024 06:52 PM)MileHighBronco Wrote:  This push is because DJT could flip Arizona, Nevada and Georgia and still lose by 1 Electoral vote.

Now, you understand why this scheme has been pushed by the dems and especially in red states, although it is pushed also in blue states.

Winner - take - all is the way it should be. When this scheme was first introduced, one of the arguments for it was that it would help negate the effect that big (blue) cities have on vote totals in states. Like all dem proposals, it sounded good. But that was not the reason the left wanted this in all states.

I hope that the politicians in Nebraska send this to the trash heap.

[Image: JdlPB.png]

TIE GOES TO THE RUNNER


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - green - 04-02-2024 07:29 PM

(04-02-2024 06:52 PM)MileHighBronco Wrote:  This push is because DJT could flip Arizona, Nevada and Georgia and still lose by 1 Electoral vote.

Now, you understand why this scheme has been pushed by the dems and especially in red states, although it is pushed also in blue states.

Winner - take - all is the way it should be. When this scheme was first introduced, one of the arguments for it was that it would help negate the effect that big (blue) cities have on vote totals in states. Like all dem proposals, it sounded good. But that was not the reason the left wanted this in all states.

I hope that the politicians in Nebraska send this to the trash heap.

[Image: Z2eNQ.png]

MEMORIES OF THE WAY WE WERE


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - Native Georgian - 04-03-2024 05:26 AM

(04-02-2024 06:52 PM)MileHighBronco Wrote:  Now, you understand why this scheme has been pushed by the dems and especially in red states, although it is pushed also in blue states.
Where else besides Maine?


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - Native Georgian - 04-03-2024 05:30 AM

(04-02-2024 07:29 PM)green Wrote:  [Image: Z2eNQ.png]

MEMORIES OF THE WAY WE WERE
Obviously WI, MI, PA all flip before Maine does, and probably NH and Minnesota, too.


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - stinkfist - 04-03-2024 05:32 AM

(04-03-2024 05:30 AM)Native Georgian Wrote:  
(04-02-2024 07:29 PM)green Wrote:  [Image: Z2eNQ.png]

MEMORIES OF THE WAY WE WERE
Obviously WI, MI, PA all flip before Maine does, and probably NH and Minnesota, too.

MN ... that ain' gonna happen on my best day hangin' out in any parallel universe ... 03-wink 03-lmfao 04-cheers


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - Native Georgian - 04-03-2024 05:39 AM

(04-03-2024 05:32 AM)stinkfist Wrote:  
(04-03-2024 05:30 AM)Native Georgian Wrote:  Obviously WI, MI, PA all flip before Maine does, and probably NH and Minnesota, too.

MN ... that ain' gonna happen on my best day hangin' out in any parallel universe ... 03-wink 03-lmfao 04-cheers
Hasn't happened in over 50 years (Nixon/Agnew vs McGovern) and only 3 times (Ike/Nixon 2x) in last 95 years. And yet the margin really isn’t that bad. Just 1.5% for Hillary. And just 7% for Biden, even with the mail-in-ballots.

Edit: by the way, the thing where electoral votes are awarded by district is something I could be okay with if every state did it. Nixon would have beaten Kennedy under that system.


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - green - 04-03-2024 07:21 AM

Quote:According to the U.S. Census Bureau, Maine’s population is predominantly white, with 93.9% of the population identifying as White alone. While Maine remains the whitest state in the nation ...

AS PURE AS THE DRIVEN SNOW


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - Native Georgian - 04-03-2024 08:49 AM

(04-03-2024 07:21 AM)green Wrote:  
Quote:According to the U.S. Census Bureau, Maine’s population is predominantly white, with 93.9% of the population identifying as White alone. While Maine remains the whitest state in the nation ...

AS PURE AS THE DRIVEN SNOW
Relevant but not decisive.


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - solohawks - 04-03-2024 08:51 AM

(04-03-2024 05:39 AM)Native Georgian Wrote:  
(04-03-2024 05:32 AM)stinkfist Wrote:  
(04-03-2024 05:30 AM)Native Georgian Wrote:  Obviously WI, MI, PA all flip before Maine does, and probably NH and Minnesota, too.

MN ... that ain' gonna happen on my best day hangin' out in any parallel universe ... ;) :lmfao: :cheers:
Hasn't happened in over 50 years (Nixon/Agnew vs McGovern) and only 3 times (Ike/Nixon 2x) in last 95 years. And yet the margin really isn’t that bad. Just 1.5% for Hillary. And just 7% for Biden, even with the mail-in-ballots.

Edit: by the way, the thing where electoral votes are awarded by district is something I could be okay with if every state did it. Nixon would have beaten Kennedy under that system.

I too would be in support of every congressional district having 1 vote and every state having two votes

You want to eliminate swing states that is the best way to do it


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - rath v2.0 - 04-03-2024 09:22 AM

(04-03-2024 05:30 AM)Native Georgian Wrote:  
(04-02-2024 07:29 PM)green Wrote:  [Image: Z2eNQ.png]

MEMORIES OF THE WAY WE WERE
Obviously WI, MI, PA all flip before Maine does, and probably NH and Minnesota, too.

Maine is a cultural thing. Anyone who has spent time there knows what I mean. Nearly impossible to change other than generationally.

Those states you listed are where most of these campaigns are going to be focused.

Trump wins every single swing state, defends all red states, and he is still stuck below 270 without one or more of those.


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - CrimsonPhantom - 04-03-2024 09:28 AM




RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - solohawks - 04-03-2024 12:32 PM

This thing might have legs

The Governor of Nebraska came out for it, now a Nebraska Dem switches to team Red giving team Red enough to overcome a cloture vote
https://omaha.com/news/local/government-politics/state-sen-mike-mcdonnell-changes-party-registration-to-republican/article_fa2f43ce-f1d7-11ee-81fc-bb5689121b26.html

He says he is not going to vote for the EC change, but i wouldnt be surprised if he got sick the day of the vote


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - MileHighBronco - 04-03-2024 02:08 PM

Well, Semafor, a left leaning publication, sounds a bit concerned by this.

Quote:Trump and Nebraska governor push to deny Biden a crucial electoral vote

Donald Trump and Nebraska Gov. Jim Pillen endorsed legislation that would take Omaha’s potentially decisive electoral vote out of play for Democrats, hours after conservative activist Charlie Kirk’s Tuesday X post suggesting it.

In just 200 words, Kirk urged Republicans to repeal the state’s 1991 law that assigned two electors to the winner of the state, and one for each of its three congressional districts. Republicans easily carried Nebraska in every subsequent election, but in 2008 and 2020, the Omaha-based 2nd District voted Democratic.

“Nebraskans should call their legislators and their governor to demand their state stop pointlessly giving strength to their political enemies,” wrote Kirk.

Five hours and 10 minutes later, Pillen put out a statement supporting a bill that would convert the state to a winner-take all system in November. Donald Trump weighed in early Tuesday evening, praising Pillen’s “very smart letter” in a Truth Social post.

The district has drawn special attention from election observers this year because of the unusually high chance of it playing tiebreaker in a close race between Trump and President Biden.

If Biden lost only Arizona, Georgia, and Nevada from his 2020 column, he would win the electoral college 270-268; if Nebraska gave all five electors to Trump, the tied 269-269 election would be decided by the incoming House’s state delegations, where Republicans currently hold an advantage.

Pillen’s statement drew some immediate murmurs of concern from Democrats, some of whom speculated that Maine’s Democratic government could respond by consolidating their own divided electoral votes, where Trump won the 2nd District in 2020. No other states award their electoral votes this way.

https://www.semafor.com/article/04/02/2024/trump-and-nebraska-governor-push-to-deny-biden-a-crucial-electoral-vote


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - MileHighBronco - 04-03-2024 02:23 PM

[Image: calling-marc-elias.jpg]


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - Bronco'14 - 04-03-2024 02:49 PM

Maine or some other blue state will counter. Democrats fight back x2


RE: Nebraska looks to go back to winner take all for the EC - UofMstateU - 04-03-2024 05:41 PM

Full on panic as republicans now have the votes to pass this.