CSNbbs
With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… (/thread-975733.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - RamblinRedWolf - 08-24-2023 07:48 AM

Will we see the temporary conclusion of realignment or will it continue to trinkle down to the G5 level?

I think Chris Vannini made a very interesting comment yesterday when he said about the possibility of MAC eventually could add Umass, Deleware (maybe Uconn in football only) Texas State goes American and Sunbelt adds Mo. State (something our own Matty Brown has reported for a while)


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - Owls9878 - 08-24-2023 07:53 AM

I don’t think this would impact the MAC.

Assuming the PAC2 merge with MWC, I wouldn’t expect anything further with the MWC.

As for the American, for me, it would be Army FB only and an olympic sports add (VCU) or just remain at 13. Texas State does absolutely nothing for the AAC.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - PeteTheChop - 08-24-2023 08:03 AM

(08-24-2023 07:48 AM)RamblinRedWolf Wrote:  With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC…

Is this a done deal, like officially?

I went to bed last night thinking it was a smoke screen to nudge WSU and OSU to the Mountain West so Cal and Stanford would be free and clear to leave for the Big Ten


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - CliftonAve - 08-24-2023 08:04 AM

Conference shifts have been going on since the advent of college football. It just occasionally takes a pause for a couple years. It’s never done.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - arkstfan - 08-24-2023 08:06 AM

(08-24-2023 07:48 AM)RamblinRedWolf Wrote:  Will we see the temporary conclusion of realignment or will it continue to trinkle down to the G5 level?

I think Chris Vannini made a very interesting comment yesterday when he said about the possibility of MAC eventually could add Umass, Deleware (maybe Uconn in football only) Texas State goes American and Sunbelt adds Mo. State (something our own Matty Brown has reported for a while)

I can't see such a nice neat conclusion. Just doesn't happen that way.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - ThreeifbyLightning - 08-24-2023 08:13 AM

Two near term questions.

1. It would seem now that OSU and WSU join the MWC or conduct some sort of merger to protect the NCAA tourney credits due to the PAC, so perhaps the question here is do they attempt to add another school to get to an even 14?

2. Does the AAC backfill SMU or stay at 13?


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - Frank the Tank - 08-24-2023 08:16 AM

There will be a trickle down, but it’s an open question about the scale.

If the Pac-2 can somehow take the best of the rest from the MWC and AAC, then that would obviously have a massive impact on the G5.

If it’s a matter of the Pac-2 just heading to or merging with the MWC, then that’s a lot more mitigated, but moved at the G5 level will still happen.

I think ESPN is going to insist on the AAC replacing SMU with someone (e.g. Texas State) if SMU leaves in order for the league to keep its full payout. ESPN wants the AAC for pure game tonnage for ESPN+, which is why they pushed the AAC to expand to 14 schools in the first place.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - ThreeifbyLightning - 08-24-2023 08:20 AM

(08-24-2023 08:16 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  There will be a trickle down, but it’s an open question about the scale.

If the Pac-2 can somehow take the best of the rest from the MWC and AAC, then that would obviously have a massive impact on the G5.

If it’s a matter of the Pac-2 just heading to or merging with the MWC, then that’s a lot more mitigated, but moved at the G5 level will still happen.

I think ESPN is going to insist on the AAC replacing SMU with someone (e.g. Texas State) if SMU leaves in order for the league to keep its full payout. ESPN wants the AAC for pure game tonnage for ESPN+, which is why they pushed the AAC to expand to 14 schools in the first place.

The problem for Texas St is that SBC and AAC are both ESPN properties and as we have seen ESPN has largely refused to tap into content it already has. It's more likely that if AAC backfills it will be someone from C-USA. And we might get to see that GOR tested right away.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - loki_the_bubba - 08-24-2023 08:23 AM

(08-24-2023 08:16 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  There will be a trickle down, but it’s an open question about the scale.

If the Pac-2 can somehow take the best of the rest from the MWC and AAC, then that would obviously have a massive impact on the G5.

If it’s a matter of the Pac-2 just heading to or merging with the MWC, then that’s a lot more mitigated, but moved at the G5 level will still happen.

I think ESPN is going to insist on the AAC replacing SMU with someone (e.g. Texas State) if SMU leaves in order for the league to keep its full payout. ESPN wants the AAC for pure game tonnage for ESPN+, which is why they pushed the AAC to expand to 14 schools in the first place.

I don't get the interest in Texas State. They're sandwiched between Texas and a growing UTSA. They've not been successful (40-92 in FBS). San Marcos doesn't add any televisions not already covered by UTSA. Other teams will grumble when conferences get too 'Texas-centric'.

There has to be a better choice somewhere.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - PeteTheChop - 08-24-2023 08:26 AM

(08-24-2023 08:06 AM)arkstfan Wrote:  I think Chris Vannini made a very interesting comment yesterday when he said about the possibility of MAC eventually could add Umass, Deleware (maybe Uconn in football only)

But then student-athletes in non-revenue sports would have to endure plane rides, which would lead to falling grades and mental health problems.

Source: Stewart Mandel and his staff at the Athletic


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - Michael in Raleigh - 08-24-2023 08:27 AM

(08-24-2023 08:23 AM)loki_the_bubba Wrote:  
(08-24-2023 08:16 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  There will be a trickle down, but it’s an open question about the scale.

If the Pac-2 can somehow take the best of the rest from the MWC and AAC, then that would obviously have a massive impact on the G5.

If it’s a matter of the Pac-2 just heading to or merging with the MWC, then that’s a lot more mitigated, but moved at the G5 level will still happen.

I think ESPN is going to insist on the AAC replacing SMU with someone (e.g. Texas State) if SMU leaves in order for the league to keep its full payout. ESPN wants the AAC for pure game tonnage for ESPN+, which is why they pushed the AAC to expand to 14 schools in the first place.

I don't get the interest in Texas State. They're sandwiched between Texas and a growing UTSA. They've not been successful (40-92 in FBS). San Marcos doesn't add any televisions not already covered by UTSA. Other teams will grumble when conferences get too 'Texas-centric'.

There has to be a better choice somewhere.

Who might you prefer?


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - PeteTheChop - 08-24-2023 08:30 AM

(08-24-2023 08:23 AM)loki_the_bubba Wrote:  I don't get the interest in Texas State. They're sandwiched between Texas and a growing UTSA. They've not been successful (40-92 in FBS). San Marcos doesn't add any televisions not already covered by UTSA. Other teams will grumble when conferences get too 'Texas-centric'.

There has to be a better choice somewhere.

LOL

"The farther you're away, the better something looks"


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - Garden_KC - 08-24-2023 08:30 AM

(08-24-2023 07:48 AM)RamblinRedWolf Wrote:  I think Chris Vannini made a very interesting comment yesterday when he said about the possibility of MAC eventually could add Umass, Deleware (maybe Uconn in football only) Texas State goes American and Sunbelt adds Mo. State (something our own Matty Brown has reported for a while)

MAC fans have been talking about Umass and Delaware forever as possibilities, probably since Buffalo joined the conference.

Delaware was thought to be too good for the MAC as an elite FCS program back in the day. Decline of the CAA along with increased CFP money has changed the equation somewhat. Academics aside however it doesn't seem like a sports school which would fit in with a lot of existing MAC members but it doesn't uplift the conference.

UMass is different with its huge size and has more of an overall athletic rep, though in basketball and hockey. They've been in the MAC before as a FB member too.

I will say though the MAC had a standing invite for JMU if UMass was willing to go all-sports back in 2014 so the idea of accepting Delaware as a 14th plausible. They feel more like an academic add than an athletic add.

Its also getting to the point where the MAC could pull in A10 schools since they have 15 members and only 1 bid. A MAC with Loyola, SLU, Dayton, Duquense would be 16 in basketball but less travel costs for those additions.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - msu35 - 08-24-2023 08:31 AM

(08-24-2023 08:03 AM)PeteTheChop Wrote:  
(08-24-2023 07:48 AM)RamblinRedWolf Wrote:  With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC…

Is this a done deal, like officially?

I went to bed last night thinking it was a smoke screen to nudge WSU and OSU to the Mountain West so Cal and Stanford would be free and clear to leave for the Big Ten

Nothing is official and it's all speculation thus far.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - loki_the_bubba - 08-24-2023 08:32 AM

(08-24-2023 08:27 AM)Michael in Raleigh Wrote:  
(08-24-2023 08:23 AM)loki_the_bubba Wrote:  
(08-24-2023 08:16 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  There will be a trickle down, but it’s an open question about the scale.

If the Pac-2 can somehow take the best of the rest from the MWC and AAC, then that would obviously have a massive impact on the G5.

If it’s a matter of the Pac-2 just heading to or merging with the MWC, then that’s a lot more mitigated, but moved at the G5 level will still happen.

I think ESPN is going to insist on the AAC replacing SMU with someone (e.g. Texas State) if SMU leaves in order for the league to keep its full payout. ESPN wants the AAC for pure game tonnage for ESPN+, which is why they pushed the AAC to expand to 14 schools in the first place.

I don't get the interest in Texas State. They're sandwiched between Texas and a growing UTSA. They've not been successful (40-92 in FBS). San Marcos doesn't add any televisions not already covered by UTSA. Other teams will grumble when conferences get too 'Texas-centric'.

There has to be a better choice somewhere.

Who might you prefer?

I'm not one, like some here, to run all the numbers. It's my local instinct that Texas State bring almost zero. My gut would also tell me to look at schools like Southern Miss, La Tech, or Marshall first. They may not want, or be able to, come. But they're better known programs with better hsitory.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - Frank the Tank - 08-24-2023 08:32 AM

(08-24-2023 08:23 AM)loki_the_bubba Wrote:  
(08-24-2023 08:16 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  There will be a trickle down, but it’s an open question about the scale.

If the Pac-2 can somehow take the best of the rest from the MWC and AAC, then that would obviously have a massive impact on the G5.

If it’s a matter of the Pac-2 just heading to or merging with the MWC, then that’s a lot more mitigated, but moved at the G5 level will still happen.

I think ESPN is going to insist on the AAC replacing SMU with someone (e.g. Texas State) if SMU leaves in order for the league to keep its full payout. ESPN wants the AAC for pure game tonnage for ESPN+, which is why they pushed the AAC to expand to 14 schools in the first place.

I don't get the interest in Texas State. They're sandwiched between Texas and a growing UTSA. They've not been successful (40-92 in FBS). San Marcos doesn't add any televisions not already covered by UTSA. Other teams will grumble when conferences get too 'Texas-centric'.

There has to be a better choice somewhere.

Maybe a school like Georgia State - to the extent that the AAC has any guiding institutional congruity, it’s schools located directly in large markets (with a couple of exceptions like ECU).

UMass is always out there and willing - they’d join as a full member of the AAC in a way that they would only want a football-only membership in the other G5 leagues.

Army’s temperature for conference membership should be taken again - they’d be the clear #1 option if they’re willing to join (but I wouldn’t bank on them).

UConn is out there as a possible football-only option, but they probably like their independent schedules even more now compared to the AAC lineup that doesn’t have Houston, Cincinnati, UCF or SMU.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - PeteTheChop - 08-24-2023 08:33 AM

(08-24-2023 08:20 AM)ThreeifbyLightning Wrote:  The problem for Texas St is that SBC and AAC are both ESPN properties and as we have seen ESPN has largely refused to tap into content it already has.

Are you referring to the SEC-ACC-Ironclad GoR thingie? Or something else?


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - TDenverFan - 08-24-2023 08:33 AM

The AAC would be at 13 members without SMU, so I wouldn't be surprised if they made a move.

Also, I think it would depend on what WSU/OSU do. If they try to rebuild the PAC by inviting the top few MWC/AAC schools, there will be a ton of ripple effects. If they join/merge with the MWC, things might slow down for a bit.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - Garden_KC - 08-24-2023 08:35 AM

(08-24-2023 08:20 AM)ThreeifbyLightning Wrote:  
(08-24-2023 08:16 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  There will be a trickle down, but it’s an open question about the scale.

If the Pac-2 can somehow take the best of the rest from the MWC and AAC, then that would obviously have a massive impact on the G5.

If it’s a matter of the Pac-2 just heading to or merging with the MWC, then that’s a lot more mitigated, but moved at the G5 level will still happen.

I think ESPN is going to insist on the AAC replacing SMU with someone (e.g. Texas State) if SMU leaves in order for the league to keep its full payout. ESPN wants the AAC for pure game tonnage for ESPN+, which is why they pushed the AAC to expand to 14 schools in the first place.

The problem for Texas St is that SBC and AAC are both ESPN properties and as we have seen ESPN has largely refused to tap into content it already has. It's more likely that if AAC backfills it will be someone from C-USA. And we might get to see that GOR tested right away.

Yeah and the AAC would be sitting with 3 Texas schools already.

The west schools in this situation probably have the vote so it could be Louisiana Tech as they played with them before in CUSA 3.0.


RE: With the addition of Cal, Stanford & SMU to ACC… - msu35 - 08-24-2023 08:36 AM

(08-24-2023 08:33 AM)TDenverFan Wrote:  I think it would depend on what WSU/OSU do. If they try to rebuild the PAC by inviting the top few MWC/AAC schools, there will be a ton of ripple effects. If they join/merge with the MWC, things might slow down for a bit.

Is a best of the rest scenario feasible? Two isolated schools in the PNW with no media deal trying to attract schools with hefty fees? How will the PAC2 secure a media contract with numbers that could entice schools to jump, when they have no schools to base a contract on?