CSNbbs
Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl (/thread-961904.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - DFW HOYA - 12-18-2022 11:49 PM

The Frisco Bowl, the misfit toy in ESPN's box of bowls, drew an announced crowd of 12,211 despite one of the schools being located 23 miles away. See the photo linked below.

https://twitter.com/JessicaM_Hall/status/1604336554532634624/photo/2

At some point, these low-tier bowls do not serve a purpose for the G5 other than schedule filler for the network. Per the Dallas Morning News, they could not even draw high school crowds:

"The South Oak Cliff vs. Port Neches-Groves Class 5A Division II title game, played Friday night, drew 32,098. SOC had been hoping to break the state’s all-time single-game attendance record of 54,347, and while it fell well short of that, the game was the first of three state finals that drew more than 30,000.

There were 28,160 on hand for Aledo’s 52-14 rout of College Station in the 5A Division I final, and Saturday afternoon’s 6A Division II title game between DeSoto and Austin Vandegrift had a crowd of 34,891. Finally, Duncanville’s 28-21 win over Galena Park North Shore in a dramatic 6A Division I final Saturday night had a crowd of 40,056.

Since the UIL state championship games returned to AT&T Stadium in 2016, there have been eight state finals that had a crowd of more than 40,000. Duncanville and North Shore have met in a state final in four of the last five years, and all drew over 40,000, including 47,818 in 2019."

https://www.dallasnews.com/high-school-sports/football/2022/12/17/attendance-for-2022-uil-state-championships-trumps-college-bowl-games/


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - Frank the Tank - 12-19-2022 12:06 AM

I’ll repeat the same thing that I stated on the Fenway Bowl thread: “[F]ans in general need to get over the attendance numbers for many (all?) of these bowls. They are ESPN television events first and foremost. It has been that way for a very long time.”


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - johnintx - 12-19-2022 12:27 AM

(12-18-2022 11:49 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  The Frisco Bowl, the misfit toy in ESPN's box of bowls, drew an announced crowd of 12,211 despite one of the schools being located 23 miles away. See the photo linked below.

https://twitter.com/JessicaM_Hall/status/1604336554532634624/photo/2

Per the Dallas Morning News, they could not even draw high school crowds:

"The South Oak Cliff vs. Port Neches-Groves Class 5A Division II title game, played Friday night, drew 32,098. SOC had been hoping to break the state’s all-time single-game attendance record of 54,347, and while it fell well short of that, the game was the first of three state finals that drew more than 30,000.

There were 28,160 on hand for Aledo’s 52-14 rout of College Station in the 5A Division I final, and Saturday afternoon’s 6A Division II title game between DeSoto and Austin Vandegrift had a crowd of 34,891. Finally, Duncanville’s 28-21 win over Galena Park North Shore in a dramatic 6A Division I final Saturday night had a crowd of 40,056.

Since the UIL state championship games returned to AT&T Stadium in 2016, there have been eight state finals that had a crowd of more than 40,000. Duncanville and North Shore have met in a state final in four of the last five years, and all drew over 40,000, including 47,818 in 2019."

https://www.dallasnews.com/high-school-sports/football/2022/12/17/attendance-for-2022-uil-state-championships-trumps-college-bowl-games/

Wow, that's embarrassing for the Frisco Bowl. I know North Texas had a mediocre season and fired their coach, but they barely move the needle in DFW. I'm not sure about the ticket price, and the prices had to be dirt cheap on the secondary market. Still, ESPN wants to have a bowl game for programming purposes, and Frisco is willing to host it, so they'll keep the bowl. Last year, Frisco even hosted a second bowl on the spur of the moment because there were two extra bowl-eligible teams, another bowl was canceled, and ESPN wanted to create a matchup. The bowl is the TV show, and the Frisco soccer stadium is the stage.

But, for those not from Texas: The UIL state championships are a different animal, especially now that all state championship games are played at one site. It draws from all over the state, but attendance is usually better when there are nearby teams involved. The ticket price is $20 for all 3 games in the same day (not sure about parking costs). This year, there were local DFW teams in the two class 6A and the two class 5A state championship games. In particular, Duncanville and DeSoto are located next to each other, and South Oak Cliff is not far away.

Also, Port Neches-Groves, located near Beaumont, travels extremely well, even from 5 hours away. PNG was involved in the state attendance record for a one-game state championship event in 1977, when they and Plano drew over 49,000 for a game at old Texas Stadium (This was prior to the UIL moving the state championships to one site...the two games that have surpassed it were part of tripleheaders). The pictures and tweets I saw from the game sounded as if PNG drew better than the local team South Oak Cliff. It's a situation where fans from nearby schools jumped on the PNG bandwagon and traveled with them through later rounds in the playoffs. The same thing happened in 2018, when Longview (2 1/2 hours away) played Beaumont West Brook (5 hours away) at Jerry World, drawing over 48,000. Fans from throughout southeast Texas followed West Brook, while fans from throughout east Texas followed Longview.
https://www.pngindians.com/football/texas-high-school-football-all-time-highest-attendance/

Imagine driving five hours to follow a high school that neither you nor your children attended. That's what some people in Texas will do.

So, yes, in Texas, the priority is: Favorite P5 school > high school > local G5 school. High school football is a really big deal here. As I tell people: Friday Night Lights is real.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - Poster - 12-19-2022 12:41 AM

(12-19-2022 12:06 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I’ll repeat the same thing that I stated on the Fenway Bowl thread: “[F]ans in general need to get over the attendance numbers for many (all?) of these bowls. They are ESPN television events first and foremost. It has been that way for a very long time.”

I'm not sure I totally buy into the idea of all these bowls being good for ESPN. I always wonder if bowls like the Frisco Bowl simply demean the meaning of bowls as a whole, and make people less willing to watch better bowl games.

There's the new trend where star players will sit out for any bowl game except for a playoff game, including a Big Six bowl. Probably not coincidentally, this trend didn't begin until there were over 40 bowls. I suspect this trend wouldn't have occurred if there were even 25 bowl games like there were roughly 20 years ago. (Let alone less than 10 bowl games like there was 50 years ago.) There's come to be a perception that bowls are a joke and should not be taken seriously.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - AuzGrams - 12-19-2022 12:42 AM

To be honest, I’m a fan of slight contraction of a few bowls such as the Pinstripe Bowl, Fenway Bowl, Frisco Bowl. Those are baseball & American soccer stadiums.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - Poster - 12-19-2022 12:46 AM

(12-19-2022 12:42 AM)AuzGrams Wrote:  To be honest, I’m a fan of slight contraction of a few bowls such as the Pinstripe Bowl, Fenway Bowl, Frisco Bowl. Those are baseball & American soccer stadiums.


Honestly, this is probably the only website on the internet where there's not a 100% consensus in favor of a contraction of bowls.

I have no idea why the NCAA got rid of the moratorium on new bowl games it created after 2015. (The first year that 5-7 teams made bowls). And frankly that moratorium was barely the tip of the iceberg when it came to solving the bowl problem. I think the minimum for bowl eligibility should be either 7-5 or 8-4, and there should be at most 25 bowl games.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - johnintx - 12-19-2022 12:54 AM

And if I still lived in DFW, given the choice of attending the Frisco Bowl (spare bowl game involving local team, played outside, for bowl game ticket price) or the Class 6A Division I state championship game (two undefeated teams playing for the fourth time in five years, with the local team not having won yet, for $20, indoors), I'd go to the state championship game. In a heartbeat.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - DFW HOYA - 12-19-2022 01:26 AM

An extreme but provocative approach: if your bowl game is not (or was never) played in a namesake stadium, cancel it.

There is (or was) a Rose Bowl, Cotton Bowl, Sugar Bowl (sort of), Orange Bowl, Sun Bowl, Gator Bowl, Alamo Bowl (sort of), and Liberty Bowl as stadiums. There was not and will never be a Cheez-It, Cure, Potato, Jimmy Kimmel LA, Frisco, Bahamas, Lending Tree, Myrtle Beach, Boca Raton, Gasparilla, First Responder, Military, Fenway, Pinstripe or Las Vegas Bowl structure to play in. Start with these as the first cut.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - Troy_Fan_15 - 12-19-2022 01:55 AM

(12-19-2022 12:41 AM)Poster Wrote:  
(12-19-2022 12:06 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I’ll repeat the same thing that I stated on the Fenway Bowl thread: “[F]ans in general need to get over the attendance numbers for many (all?) of these bowls. They are ESPN television events first and foremost. It has been that way for a very long time.”

I'm not sure I totally buy into the idea of all these bowls being good for ESPN. I always wonder if bowls like the Frisco Bowl simply demean the meaning of bowls as a whole, and make people less willing to watch better bowl games.

There's the new trend where star players will sit out for any bowl game except for a playoff game, including a Big Six bowl. Probably not coincidentally, this trend didn't begin until there were over 40 bowls. I suspect this trend wouldn't have occurred if there were even 25 bowl games like there were roughly 20 years ago. (Let alone less than 10 bowl games like there was 50 years ago.) There's come to be a perception that bowls are a joke and should not be taken seriously.

Keep whining. Players are not opting out from the Sugar Bowl or Orange Bowl because the Frisco Bowl exists lol. The only perception that I’ve come to a conclusion of is your takes regarding non-P5 related matters should not be taken seriously.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - schmolik - 12-19-2022 07:27 AM

Well in the Frisco Bowl's case, scheduling it at the same time as state playoff games in the same area has got to be idiotic when it comes to attendance. I'm sure ESPN will take that into account next year.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - inutech - 12-19-2022 07:31 AM

(12-19-2022 12:41 AM)Poster Wrote:  
(12-19-2022 12:06 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I’ll repeat the same thing that I stated on the Fenway Bowl thread: “[F]ans in general need to get over the attendance numbers for many (all?) of these bowls. They are ESPN television events first and foremost. It has been that way for a very long time.”

I'm not sure I totally buy into the idea of all these bowls being good for ESPN. I always wonder if bowls like the Frisco Bowl simply demean the meaning of bowls as a whole, and make people less willing to watch better bowl games.

There's the new trend where star players will sit out for any bowl game except for a playoff game, including a Big Six bowl. Probably not coincidentally, this trend didn't begin until there were over 40 bowls. I suspect this trend wouldn't have occurred if there were even 25 bowl games like there were roughly 20 years ago. (Let alone less than 10 bowl games like there was 50 years ago.) There's come to be a perception that bowls are a joke and should not be taken seriously.

I've given you the solution. If you don't like to watch football on tv, that's why they made the Hallmark channel.

Your tv isn't stuck on espn is it?


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - Frank the Tank - 12-19-2022 08:00 AM

(12-19-2022 07:31 AM)inutech Wrote:  
(12-19-2022 12:41 AM)Poster Wrote:  
(12-19-2022 12:06 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I’ll repeat the same thing that I stated on the Fenway Bowl thread: “[F]ans in general need to get over the attendance numbers for many (all?) of these bowls. They are ESPN television events first and foremost. It has been that way for a very long time.”

I'm not sure I totally buy into the idea of all these bowls being good for ESPN. I always wonder if bowls like the Frisco Bowl simply demean the meaning of bowls as a whole, and make people less willing to watch better bowl games.

There's the new trend where star players will sit out for any bowl game except for a playoff game, including a Big Six bowl. Probably not coincidentally, this trend didn't begin until there were over 40 bowls. I suspect this trend wouldn't have occurred if there were even 25 bowl games like there were roughly 20 years ago. (Let alone less than 10 bowl games like there was 50 years ago.) There's come to be a perception that bowls are a joke and should not be taken seriously.

I've given you the solution. If you don't like to watch football on tv, that's why they made the Hallmark channel.

Your tv isn't stuck on espn is it?

Yes, we seem to have this same discussion every year.

If someone doesn’t want to watch more football, then don’t watch it. There’s no need to get *rid* of it when the market otherwise supports it.

I’m the total opposite where I think EVERY school (even if they went 0-12) should be able to play another game after the regular season (whether you call it a bowl or not). The more the merrier. If the market supports it, then I don’t understand the problem with as many bowls as possible. Even the Frisco Bowl got over 1.15 million viewers last year, which is still more viewers than virtually anything else ESPN could have put into that time slot short of an NFL game.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - Side.Show.Joe - 12-19-2022 08:04 AM

I went to the fake Frisco Bowl last year when UNT faced Miami OH, and it sucked big donkey balls. I swore I'd never return to that POS and I meant it. This year, I watched the game on ESPN like everyone else.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - Frank the Tank - 12-19-2022 08:25 AM

By the way, all of the opt outs in bowl games have nothing to do with whether games like the Frisco Bowl make the whole bowl system less prestigious. What has happened is the College Football Playoff where there’s a stark contrast between the games that matter (the playoff) and everything else that doesn’t matter (the rest of the bowls). And frankly, that’s OK. The bowls were originally created to be pure exhibitions and that’s truly how they were looked at for most of the history of college football. That’s why the AP Poll named their national champion *before* the bowls until the 1960s and the Coaches’ Poll didn’t name their champion after the bowls until the 1970s. Non-playoff bowls are simply going back to their original roots of being pure exhibitions. My brain has a hard time comprehending people actually complaining about having football games on every night for 3 weeks straight.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - SkullyMaroo - 12-19-2022 08:31 AM

Less bowls would just hurt G5 teams. Let’s look at 2013. The Sun Belt only had 8 teams that year following a raid from CUSA and the new teams came to the league in 2014. Here are the final standings

7-5 Arkansas State (won Sun Belt and went to Go Daddy Bowl - now Lending Tree Bowl)
8-4 Louisiana (went to New Orleans Bowl)
8-4 Western Kentucky (No bowl, not enough tie-ins)
6-6 South Alabama (No bowl, not enough tie-ins)
6-6 Troy (No bowl, not enough tie-ins)
6-6 ULM (No bowl, not enough tie-ins)
6-6 Texas State (No bowl, not enough tie-ins)
0-12 Georgia State

So 7 of 8 teams were bowl eligible and only 2 went bowling.

Meanwhile 6-6 P5 teams that went bowling:
Washington State
Oregon State
Pittsburgh
Syracuse
Rutgers
North Carolina
Mississippi State

P5 6-6 teams that did not go bowling:


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - Dr Dawgma III - 12-19-2022 08:33 AM

(12-19-2022 08:04 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:  I went to the fake Frisco Bowl last year when UNT faced Miami OH, and it sucked big donkey balls. I swore I'd never return to that POS and I meant it. This year, I watched the game on ESPN like everyone else.

Why do you call it fake?


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - RUScarlets - 12-19-2022 08:42 AM

The NFL would have gutted these bowls alive despite the mediocre matchups featured last Saturday had they been on the main networks. I can't find NFL Network on my listings and won't plan to any time soon.

The Jackson State game was the most compelling but that was about it. How can I get up for these games as a fan when the atmosphere is completely dead and all you get are the faint sounds on the field under the voices of the commentators? The TV product definitely suffers.

Nonetheless, the Bowls are dying. Younger people just don't take exotic vacations to see their college football team, especially after their alma maters milked them for every penny for a degree that is not even applicable to their career. 25' is really the last year of an era. I mean Florida rested, two dozen players? Absolute joke.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - Frank the Tank - 12-19-2022 09:10 AM

(12-19-2022 08:42 AM)RUScarlets Wrote:  The NFL would have gutted these bowls alive despite the mediocre matchups featured last Saturday had they been on the main networks. I can't find NFL Network on my listings and won't plan to any time soon.

The Jackson State game was the most compelling but that was about it. How can I get up for these games as a fan when the atmosphere is completely dead and all you get are the faint sounds on the field under the voices of the commentators? The TV product definitely suffers.

Nonetheless, the Bowls are dying. Younger people just don't take exotic vacations to see their college football team, especially after their alma maters milked them for every penny for a degree that is not even applicable to their career. 25' is really the last year of an era. I mean Florida rested, two dozen players? Absolute joke.

The NFL games actually were pretty great on Saturday. The Vikings comeback against the Colts was a literal historic all-time classic. Those were the games that I watched and undoubtedly that's what most of America watched, too.

However, everything going up against the NFL is going to lose. That has happened to even the most marquee events like the World Series. So, whether something can compete with the NFL shouldn't ever be the standard because *nothing* can compete with the NFL. That's why they're the largest juggernaut in the entire entertainment industry (not just sports).

Instead, it's about whether a college football bowl game is going to get a better ROI for ESPN than the random college basketball or NHL game that would have taken its place instead. As long as that bowl game has such higher ROI, they'll continue to exist. We also shouldn't discount the value that ESPN has a well-tuned circular promotion machine perfected from its parent company Disney (who invented "synergy") - all of these warm-up bowl games are feeding a constant promotion of the main event of the playoff games over the next two weeks.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - inutech - 12-19-2022 09:15 AM

(12-19-2022 08:04 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:  I went to the fake Frisco Bowl last year when UNT faced Miami OH, and it sucked big donkey balls. I swore I'd never return to that POS and I meant it. This year, I watched the game on ESPN like everyone else.

I went to the first one (not the first of the two last season, the first one ever) and had a great time. The local team's fans mostly filled their half of the stadium (until around halftime) and the visiting team's fans pretty much filled their half (for the whole game). Atmosphere was good, game was fun, end result was great.

It looks like the Toyota Stadium seats 25,000 for (American) football, but I think that first year it was quite a bit less because of renovations. 14,000 people in a stadium that holds 25,000 (or I honestly think it was just 15,000 that year) is a better atmosphere than 31,000 in the 92,000 capacity Cotton Bowl for the First Responders Bowl a couple of years earlier.


RE: Poor Attendance At Frisco Bowl - inutech - 12-19-2022 09:23 AM

(12-19-2022 09:10 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Instead, it's about whether a college football bowl game is going to get a better ROI for ESPN than the random college basketball or NHL game that would have taken its place instead.

For the mid-day ones, it wouldn't even be that. It'd be some awful fake debate show or card games or something.