CSNbbs
An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: The Spin Room (/forum-540.html)
+---- Thread: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare (/thread-600728.html)



An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - mixduptransistor - 11-20-2012 08:47 AM

So my local paper had a story about Hobby Lobby (a crafts store, not a Catholic hospital) being required to cover contraception under Obamacare, and not being eligible for the religious exception because it's a business, not a religious organization. Courts ruled against them, which was the genesis for the story this morning: http://blog.al.com/spotnews/2012/11/hobby_lobby_must_cover_morning.html#incart_flyout_business

One of the commenters had a very interesting point that I thought I'd throw out here:

Lots of people think that even private businesses shouldn't be required to provide contraception if the managers/owners of the business have a religious aversion to doing so. Lots of people think that owners of businesses don't have any business imposing their religious views on their employees.

This came up as a dust-up with contraception, but what about other medical procedures that are religiously questionable in some circles? What if your boss was a Jehovah's Witness and refused to cover any procedure that resulted in a blood transfusion? What if your boss was a Scientologist and didn't believe in psychiatry and you had a child with Schizophrenia or some other disease? What if your boss thought vaccines were a government conspiracy/caused autism/was otherwise crazy and refused to cover them in his health plan?

If you support a company's right to deny contraceptive coverage on religious grounds, do you also support a company's right to deny live saving procedures? And please, for purposes of this discussion let's not argue whether or not employers should be forced to provide coverage at all, because Hobby Lobby was providing insurance before Obamacare. This is simply them being held to a certain standard of coverage. This isn't meant to be a provocative, attack style discussion. Try to keep it civil.


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - DrTorch - 11-20-2012 08:53 AM

(11-20-2012 08:47 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  So my local paper had a story about Hobby Lobby (a crafts store, not a Catholic hospital) being required to cover contraception under Obamacare, and not being eligible for the religious exception because it's a business, not a religious organization. Courts ruled against them, which was the genesis for the story this morning: http://blog.al.com/spotnews/2012/11/hobby_lobby_must_cover_morning.html#incart_flyout_business

One of the commenters had a very interesting point that I thought I'd throw out here:

Lots of people think that even private businesses shouldn't be required to provide contraception if the managers/owners of the business have a religious aversion to doing so. Lots of people think that owners of businesses don't have any business imposing their religious views on their employees.

This came up as a dust-up with contraception, but what about other medical procedures that are religiously questionable in some circles? What if your boss was a Jehovah's Witness and refused to cover any procedure that resulted in a blood transfusion? What if your boss was a Scientologist and didn't believe in psychiatry and you had a child with Schizophrenia or some other disease? What if your boss thought vaccines were a government conspiracy/caused autism/was otherwise crazy and refused to cover them in his health plan?

If you support a company's right to deny contraceptive coverage on religious grounds, do you also support a company's right to deny live saving procedures?

Absolutely. I have no problem with that. I might or might not work there, but I'd respect that person's right to religious expression.

In the end, one mistake people are making is accepting the original error and trying to work solutions with that in place.

Health insurance shouldn't be tied to your job. I don't get homeowners insurance or car insurance thru my job.


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - dcCid - 11-20-2012 09:06 AM

(11-20-2012 08:53 AM)DrTorch Wrote:  
(11-20-2012 08:47 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  So my local paper had a story about Hobby Lobby (a crafts store, not a Catholic hospital) being required to cover contraception under Obamacare, and not being eligible for the religious exception because it's a business, not a religious organization. Courts ruled against them, which was the genesis for the story this morning: http://blog.al.com/spotnews/2012/11/hobby_lobby_must_cover_morning.html#incart_flyout_business

One of the commenters had a very interesting point that I thought I'd throw out here:

Lots of people think that even private businesses shouldn't be required to provide contraception if the managers/owners of the business have a religious aversion to doing so. Lots of people think that owners of businesses don't have any business imposing their religious views on their employees.

This came up as a dust-up with contraception, but what about other medical procedures that are religiously questionable in some circles? What if your boss was a Jehovah's Witness and refused to cover any procedure that resulted in a blood transfusion? What if your boss was a Scientologist and didn't believe in psychiatry and you had a child with Schizophrenia or some other disease? What if your boss thought vaccines were a government conspiracy/caused autism/was otherwise crazy and refused to cover them in his health plan?

If you support a company's right to deny contraceptive coverage on religious grounds, do you also support a company's right to deny live saving procedures?

Absolutely. I have no problem with that. I might or might not work there, but I'd respect that person's right to religious expression.

In the end, one mistake people are making is accepting the original error and trying to work solutions with that in place.

Health insurance shouldn't be tied to your job. I don't get homeowners insurance or car insurance thru my job.

I agree that health insurance should not be tied to your job, but I think it will be while before we get there (if we ever do).

But other than a Church, I think all health care policies should have some minimum standards regardless of the provider.

The courts ruled in the attached case that some types of birth control can be excluded for a christian publishing company. (Plan B pills and IUD's).

http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/judge-grants-company-injunction-against-health-care-law-contraception-efforts/2012/11/18/efdabcf8-31a1-11e2-9cfa-e41bac906cc9_story.html


Re: RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - I'mMoreAwesomeThanYou - 11-20-2012 10:00 AM

(11-20-2012 09:06 AM)dcCid Wrote:  
(11-20-2012 08:53 AM)DrTorch Wrote:  
(11-20-2012 08:47 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  So my local paper had a story about Hobby Lobby (a crafts store, not a Catholic hospital) being required to cover contraception under Obamacare, and not being eligible for the religious exception because it's a business, not a religious organization. Courts ruled against them, which was the genesis for the story this morning: http://blog.al.com/spotnews/2012/11/hobby_lobby_must_cover_morning.html#incart_flyout_business

One of the commenters had a very interesting point that I thought I'd throw out here:

Lots of people think that even private businesses shouldn't be required to provide contraception if the managers/owners of the business have a religious aversion to doing so. Lots of people think that owners of businesses don't have any business imposing their religious views on their employees.

This came up as a dust-up with contraception, but what about other medical procedures that are religiously questionable in some circles? What if your boss was a Jehovah's Witness and refused to cover any procedure that resulted in a blood transfusion? What if your boss was a Scientologist and didn't believe in psychiatry and you had a child with Schizophrenia or some other disease? What if your boss thought vaccines were a government conspiracy/caused autism/was otherwise crazy and refused to cover them in his health plan?

If you support a company's right to deny contraceptive coverage on religious grounds, do you also support a company's right to deny live saving procedures?

Absolutely. I have no problem with that. I might or might not work there, but I'd respect that person's right to religious expression.

In the end, one mistake people are making is accepting the original error and trying to work solutions with that in place.

Health insurance shouldn't be tied to your job. I don't get homeowners insurance or car insurance thru my job.

I agree that health insurance should not be tied to your job, but I think it will be while before we get there (if we ever do).

But other than a Church, I think all health care policies should have some minimum standards regardless of the provider.

The courts ruled in the attached case that some types of birth control can be excluded for a christian publishing company. (Plan B pills and IUD's).

http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/judge-grants-company-injunction-against-health-care-law-contraception-efforts/2012/11/18/efdabcf8-31a1-11e2-9cfa-e41bac906cc9_story.html

If Hobby Lobby is a private organization they should be able to offer as much or as little as they want by way of coverage.

BY READING THIS POST YOU RECOGNIZE THAT IMATY IS THE LAST GREAT CRUSADER FOR TRUTH AND JUSTICE SO HELP YOU GOD.


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - Bull_In_Exile - 11-20-2012 10:14 AM

(11-20-2012 08:47 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  This came up as a dust-up with contraception, but what about other medical procedures that are religiously questionable in some circles? What if your boss was a Jehovah's Witness and refused to cover any procedure that resulted in a blood transfusion? What if your boss was a Scientologist and didn't believe in psychiatry and you had a child with Schizophrenia or some other disease? What if your boss thought vaccines were a government conspiracy/caused autism/was otherwise crazy and refused to cover them in his health plan?

Stupid comparisons. Blood transfusions after surgery and psychiatry treat illness.. Contraceptives do not. two of the three are actual medicine the third not so much.

Quote:If you support a company's right to deny contraceptive coverage on religious grounds, do you also support a company's right to deny live saving procedures?

Yes.

I don't think companies should have to provide any coverage for anything. In the end they will not get the best workers and will go down in flames.

Quote:And please, for purposes of this discussion let's not argue whether or not employers should be forced to provide coverage at all

Why not... It's stupid on it face to say "because they provided something they have to provide everything".

Its not stupid to say "They should be able to pick and choose any or all of the benefits they want to provide.

I know it helps to ignore that point, that people who own business should be able to pick and choose. But just because it's inconvenient does not mean it should be ignored.


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - mixduptransistor - 11-20-2012 10:15 AM

(11-20-2012 08:53 AM)DrTorch Wrote:  Health insurance shouldn't be tied to your job. I don't get homeowners insurance or car insurance thru my job.

I completely agree with you here. We probably disagree on what should replace it (I think a single, public payer with a privatized delivery system) but if employers weren't in the healthcare business, they could simply pay higher wages (in the case of everyone buying private insurance on their own) or shift the money into higher taxes to pay for a public system.

(11-20-2012 10:00 AM)ImMoreAwesomeThanYou Wrote:  If Hobby Lobby is a private organization they should be able to offer as much or as little as they want by way of coverage.

The problem I have with this, however, is that in most circumstances you more or less have to go with the healthcare your employer provides. A job like Hobby Lobby isn't going to pay enough for you to buy individual coverage on the open market. The other thing is that health insurance is considered a benefit, like part of your salary. Should my boss be able to tell me how to spend my salary? Why should health coverage be treated any different?


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - mixduptransistor - 11-20-2012 10:16 AM

(11-20-2012 10:14 AM)Bull_In_Exile Wrote:  Stupid comparisons. Blood transfusions after surgery and psychiatry treat illness.. Contraceptives do not. two of the three are actual medicine the third not so much.

In what way are contraceptives not "actual medicine"? We're not talking about abortion here, we're talking about contraception, which prevents a pregnancy from taking place in the first place. This isn't something you have to go to Planned Parenthood for. This is stuff that every OB/GYN in America is prescribing.

(11-20-2012 10:14 AM)Bull_In_Exile Wrote:  Why not... It's stupid on it face to say "because they provided something they have to provide everything".

Its not stupid to say "They should be able to pick and choose any or all of the benefits they want to provide.

I know it helps to ignore that point, that people who own business should be able to pick and choose. But just because it's inconvenient does not mean it should be ignored.

I wanted to limit it to this specific issue instead of mandated coverage overall because I didn't really want the discussion to devolve into Obamacare is socialism blah blah blah. That has been argued ad infinitum


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - BlazerFan11 - 11-20-2012 10:26 AM

(11-20-2012 10:15 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  The problem I have with this, however, is that in most circumstances you more or less have to go with the healthcare your employer provides. A job like Hobby Lobby isn't going to pay enough for you to buy individual coverage on the open market. The other thing is that health insurance is considered a benefit, like part of your salary. Should my boss be able to tell me how to spend my salary? Why should health coverage be treated any different?

That's a poor analogy. They aren't telling you how you have to spend your health coverage, just the extent of what they'll cover - just like they set the extent of your salary. You aren't prohibited from seeking any health care by your employer.


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - Bull_In_Exile - 11-20-2012 10:29 AM

(11-20-2012 10:15 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  The other thing is that health insurance is considered a benefit, like part of your salary. Should my boss be able to tell me how to spend my salary? Why should health coverage be treated any different?

No they can't tell you how to spend your money but they get to say how much they pay you! Just like they can decided what level of insurance to provide..

And BTW birth control adds a lot more to the cost of an insurance plan than people think because it's guaranteed to be used every day.


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - mixduptransistor - 11-20-2012 10:29 AM

(11-20-2012 10:26 AM)BlazerFan11 Wrote:  
(11-20-2012 10:15 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  The problem I have with this, however, is that in most circumstances you more or less have to go with the healthcare your employer provides. A job like Hobby Lobby isn't going to pay enough for you to buy individual coverage on the open market. The other thing is that health insurance is considered a benefit, like part of your salary. Should my boss be able to tell me how to spend my salary? Why should health coverage be treated any different?

That's a poor analogy. They aren't telling you how you have to spend your health coverage, just the extent of what they'll cover - just like they set the extent of your salary. You aren't prohibited from seeking any health care by your employer.

I am willing to bet that the employee contributes to part of the cost of the insurance


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - Bull_In_Exile - 11-20-2012 10:38 AM

(11-20-2012 10:16 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  In what way are contraceptives not "actual medicine"? We're not talking about abortion here, we're talking about contraception, which prevents a pregnancy from taking place in the first place.

Medicine is the applied science or practice of the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of disease.

Pregnancy != Disease

(11-20-2012 10:16 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  I wanted to limit it to this specific issue instead of mandated coverage overall because I didn't really want the discussion to devolve into Obamacare is socialism blah blah blah. That has been argued ad infinitum

Did I mention socialism anywhere? I merely pointed out that it's wrong to mandate employers provide *anything* but if an emplyer does decide to provide something that does not mean they should have to give everything.


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - Bull_In_Exile - 11-20-2012 10:39 AM

(11-20-2012 10:29 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  
(11-20-2012 10:26 AM)BlazerFan11 Wrote:  
(11-20-2012 10:15 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  The problem I have with this, however, is that in most circumstances you more or less have to go with the healthcare your employer provides. A job like Hobby Lobby isn't going to pay enough for you to buy individual coverage on the open market. The other thing is that health insurance is considered a benefit, like part of your salary. Should my boss be able to tell me how to spend my salary? Why should health coverage be treated any different?

That's a poor analogy. They aren't telling you how you have to spend your health coverage, just the extent of what they'll cover - just like they set the extent of your salary. You aren't prohibited from seeking any health care by your employer.

I am willing to bet that the employee contributes to part of the cost of the insurance

I am willing to be that the employer contributes as well..


RE: An interesting thought regarding "religious freedom" and Obamacare - BlazerFan11 - 11-20-2012 11:02 AM

(11-20-2012 10:29 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  
(11-20-2012 10:26 AM)BlazerFan11 Wrote:  
(11-20-2012 10:15 AM)mixduptransistor Wrote:  The problem I have with this, however, is that in most circumstances you more or less have to go with the healthcare your employer provides. A job like Hobby Lobby isn't going to pay enough for you to buy individual coverage on the open market. The other thing is that health insurance is considered a benefit, like part of your salary. Should my boss be able to tell me how to spend my salary? Why should health coverage be treated any different?

That's a poor analogy. They aren't telling you how you have to spend your health coverage, just the extent of what they'll cover - just like they set the extent of your salary. You aren't prohibited from seeking any health care by your employer.

I am willing to bet that the employee contributes to part of the cost of the insurance

What does that have to do with anything? The employees contribute to the costs in a lot of areas.

Company cars are a benefit for some. If a business decides the company cars shouldn't have leather seats, does that mean they're telling you how to spend your money? Not sure what you're getting at with the whole "health insurance is a benefit, so they shouldn't be able to tell me what is covered" argument.