CSNbbs
North Korea... - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: The Spin Room (/forum-540.html)
+---- Thread: North Korea... (/thread-466192.html)



North Korea... - GrayBeard - 11-28-2010 10:22 PM

Was there any response to NK's attack on South Korea, or did we just give Kim Jong Crazy Ill the right to do whatever he wants with impunity?


RE: North Korea... - smn1256 - 11-28-2010 10:48 PM

1. We've all been bitching that the affairs of the world should be their affairs and not ours. But that doesn't explain our troops that are over there.

2. What can we do that won't piss China off?

3. What has NK got to lose? Like a spoiled kid they want someone (the USA) to talk to them about giving them aid in return for dropping their nuke program.

4. Have you forgotten who our president is?


RE: North Korea... - Cardiff - 11-28-2010 10:49 PM

the latter, with a caveat -- we gave beijing the right to decide what the norks can and can't do. so far china has let them run with a very long leash.

since mao, china's leaders have always taken a pretty cold-blooded view of these things. but the idea of a nuclear bomb(s) going off so close to their own centers of population, you would think they would step in and do what they have to do to prevent that. but then again, maybe not. we'll just have to wait and see.

i can understand why, back in 1950, truman and most other people didn't want to deal with this the hard way, like macarthur advised. but with 60 years perspective, we now see the 2 choices were whether we wanted to deal with it back then, when the other side didn't have nukes, or take our chances later, when they do. we chose door #2, and here it is, right up in our face. god know how it will all turn out.

i'll say one thing -- if the norks drop a bomb or whatever that kills a bunch of americans stationed in korea/japan, and then if america does not retaliate with nukes of our own, it will be 100 years before the bad guys around the world take us seriously again. we'll be just a bigger version of france or great britain.


RE: North Korea... - T-Monay820 - 11-28-2010 11:56 PM

No affirmative response by the US or SK. Just a bunch of saber rattling. This is SOP though for the US. We have no intention of starting a war (technicalities aside), and neither does SK. Naturally I expect the WH to be on the phone essentially nonstop with Beijing, and whether this has any impact will be interesting. I can foresee a breakout of violence in only a handful of situations:

1) All out invasion/attack by the North,
2) US military personnel are injured/killed,
3) Continuous "random" attacks by the North for at least 10 days,
4) SK initiates the offensive.


RE: North Korea... - Bull_In_Exile - 11-29-2010 01:05 PM

(11-28-2010 10:48 PM)smn1256 Wrote:  1. We've all been bitching that the affairs of the world should be their affairs and not ours. But that doesn't explain our troops that are over there.

2. What can we do that won't piss China off?

3. What has NK got to lose? Like a spoiled kid they want someone (the USA) to talk to them about giving them aid in return for dropping their nuke program.

4. Have you forgotten who our president is?

1. The Korean presence is one of the few in the world that I would consider critical. The nation is an alley, the nation exist in part due to our earlier intervention, and their neighbor is bat5#!7 crazy... It also puts a regional presence near China which is nice to have.

2. Nothing China is in 100% sabre rattling mode. WE have a tiger by the tail and lord help us if we let go.

3. Nothing. There is *zero* chance of a ground incursion into N. Korea and any other action (cruise missiles etc) will do nothing to harm the iron grip that the Kim family has on NK. Those people are nuts from cradle to grave and anyone not that crazy is living in a place that makes Stallinist gulags look like a spa.

4. There is a fair chance S. Korea will force even "the one's" hand eventually. They are just as passionate as the north except they offer their people freedom and not oppression..


RE: North Korea... - Cardiff - 11-29-2010 01:37 PM

for people who forgot or never knew what the 'cold war' was all about: it was about trying to prevent the sort of people who control north korea -- and used to control soviet russia, east germany, albania, maoist china, etc., etc. etc. -- from taking over the world.

it was tragic enough that so many free-people in the west were unable to grasp that basic reality while it was happening. the fact that so many people still don't grasp it even now, in retrospect, suggests the tragedy will have to be re-lived someday by future generations.


RE: North Korea... - SumOfAllFears - 11-30-2010 10:31 AM

(11-29-2010 01:37 PM)Cardiff Wrote:  for people who forgot or never knew what the 'cold war' was all about: it was about trying to prevent the sort of people who control north korea -- and used to control soviet russia, east germany, albania, maoist china, etc., etc. etc. -- from taking over the world.

it was tragic enough that so many free-people in the west were unable to grasp that basic reality while it was happening. the fact that so many people still don't grasp it even now, in retrospect, suggests the tragedy will have to be re-lived someday by future generations.

True, there is no shortage of tyranny in the world, or at home for that matter. For sure, only democracy has a chance to and attempts to eliminate the tools of tyranny.