Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - Gitanole - 11-18-2026 12:05 PM
The ever-present Ross Dellenger:
A proposal from the SEC to impose financial penalties on schools for exceeding the athlete revenue-share cap is gaining traction not only within the conference but across the four power leagues, those with knowledge of the discussion tell Yahoo Sports.
According to the proposal—reported in detail last week—schools spending more than the $21.6 million revenue-share cap stand to be assessed millions in penalties in a concept most similar to pro sports-style luxury tax structures.
....
While the plan originated from the SEC, leaders in the other power conferences—the Big Ten, ACC, and Big 12—are coalescing around the concept to the point of adopting it soon and, perhaps, communicating their plans with the co-lead plaintiff attorneys in the House settlement, Jeffrey Kessler and Steve Berman.
Both attorneys have suggested that such a cap policy may unnecessarily restrict athlete pay and have expressed doubt that it is legal without their approval under the House settlement—the NCAA’s multi-billion dollar agreement that governs the industry's new athlete compensation system.
Anil Gollahalli, the Big Ten’s chief legal officer and general counsel, discussed the Big Ten’s own cap policy—passed last month—and the one circulated from the SEC. He said the two are “distinctly different.” The Big Ten’s rule only applies to those within the league, while the SEC’s proposal—possibly now embraced by all power conferences and administered by the College Sports Commission—may necessitate crossing other legal hurdles.
“You have to draw a distinction about what conferences can do by themselves versus what leagues can do collectively and perhaps in connection with [House plaintiff attorneys],” Gollahalli told Yahoo Sports. “I can’t comment on what the right mechanisms are because I don’t know what the contours of the proposal will finally end up being.”
....
Ivy League commissioner Robin Harris made a somewhat bold and revolutionary statement: Perhaps those rich football powers should go do their own thing.
“Call a spade a spade,” Harris told Yahoo Sports. “They are operating as revenue-producing entities for profit. And they are paying athletes a lot of money and paying coaches a lot of money. It should be a standalone, but yet affiliated, for-profit venture. They are operated as taxable entities but are still affiliated with the institutions. You have to have a different structure and rules. What that looks like, I don’t know.”
She is perhaps referencing the long-discussed split of the power leagues, or perhaps even a smaller group of high-revenue producing football programs. A split into a “semi-pro model” would bring “reality and rational choices” to the schools outside of those leagues that are “overspending and can’t afford it,” she said.
“They are chasing something that they cannot obtain,” Harris said. “Now they would free up dollars to be put to the greater good.”
....
https://sports.yahoo.com/college-football/article/our-industry-right-now-is-laundering-money--with-college-sports-in-chaos-is-a-rev-share-cap-solution-on-the-way-152548146.html
Original report, SEC proposal
https://sports.yahoo.com/college-football/article/secs-proposed-cap-policy-would-penalize-big-spending-schools-7-million-this-year-232342944.html
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - bullet - 11-18-2026 12:31 PM
(11-18-2026 12:05 PM)Gitanole Wrote: The ever-present Ross Dellenger:
A proposal from the SEC to impose financial penalties on schools for exceeding the athlete revenue-share cap is gaining traction not only within the conference but across the four power leagues, those with knowledge of the discussion tell Yahoo Sports.
According to the proposal—reported in detail last week—schools spending more than the $21.6 million revenue-share cap stand to be assessed millions in penalties in a concept most similar to pro sports-style luxury tax structures.
....
While the plan originated from the SEC, leaders in the other power conferences—the Big Ten, ACC, and Big 12—are coalescing around the concept to the point of adopting it soon and, perhaps, communicating their plans with the co-lead plaintiff attorneys in the House settlement, Jeffrey Kessler and Steve Berman.
Both attorneys have suggested that such a cap policy may unnecessarily restrict athlete pay and have expressed doubt that it is legal without their approval under the House settlement—the NCAA’s multi-billion dollar agreement that governs the industry's new athlete compensation system.
Anil Gollahalli, the Big Ten’s chief legal officer and general counsel, discussed the Big Ten’s own cap policy—passed last month—and the one circulated from the SEC. He said the two are “distinctly different.” The Big Ten’s rule only applies to those within the league, while the SEC’s proposal—possibly now embraced by all power conferences and administered by the College Sports Commission—may necessitate crossing other legal hurdles.
“You have to draw a distinction about what conferences can do by themselves versus what leagues can do collectively and perhaps in connection with [House plaintiff attorneys],” Gollahalli told Yahoo Sports. “I can’t comment on what the right mechanisms are because I don’t know what the contours of the proposal will finally end up being.”
....
Ivy League commissioner Robin Harris made a somewhat bold and revolutionary statement: Perhaps those rich football powers should go do their own thing.
“Call a spade a spade,” Harris told Yahoo Sports. “They are operating as revenue-producing entities for profit. And they are paying athletes a lot of money and paying coaches a lot of money. It should be a standalone, but yet affiliated, for-profit venture. They are operated as taxable entities but are still affiliated with the institutions. You have to have a different structure and rules. What that looks like, I don’t know.”
She is perhaps referencing the long-discussed split of the power leagues, or perhaps even a smaller group of high-revenue producing football programs. A split into a “semi-pro model” would bring “reality and rational choices” to the schools outside of those leagues that are “overspending and can’t afford it,” she said.
“They are chasing something that they cannot obtain,” Harris said. “Now they would free up dollars to be put to the greater good.”
....
https://sports.yahoo.com/college-football/article/our-industry-right-now-is-laundering-money--with-college-sports-in-chaos-is-a-rev-share-cap-solution-on-the-way-152548146.html
Original report, SEC proposal
https://sports.yahoo.com/college-football/article/secs-proposed-cap-policy-would-penalize-big-spending-schools-7-million-this-year-232342944.html
She's in her ivy tower. A for profit entity is a lose-lose.
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - Gitanole - 11-18-2026 12:38 PM
(11-18-2026 12:31 PM)bullet Wrote: She's in her ivy tower. A for profit entity is a lose-lose.
Robin Harris (JD, Duke) addresses a basic matter of clarity.
College sport is a revenue-generating venture, as running a shop on campus is.
She reminds all that calling a spade a spade results in better law than calling a spade an ivory tower.
Interestingly, she is also recommending formation of a Super League.
___
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - SFLFB - 11-18-2026 12:43 PM
So from my POV we have 3 pieces of the pie when it comes to athletes being paid:
1. Institutional revenue share of ~$21MM/year
2. Corporate NIL contracts (athletes signing direct deals with Nike and Adidas, for example, regardless of school unless dictated in contract)
3. Fan-funded "collectives" for NIL contracts (Sign with us? Get paid by us)
This is only regarding #1, correct? Isn't that already limited/regulated by the CSC as determined by the House settlement? I guess I might have missed the memo on conferences being the authority if a member school breaks the rules, but why would any conference care? Or is this like when Pablo Escobar built his own prison? "We're definitely going to punish ourselves *wink* *wink*".
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - otown - 11-18-2026 12:45 PM
What about the auto dealership money that is outside of the school's control?
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - Gitanole - 11-18-2026 12:56 PM
(11-18-2026 12:45 PM)otown Wrote: What about the auto dealership money that is outside of the school's control?
There’s a lot to read at those two links. Let me know your take.
Revshare and NIL are a bit different. Or at least they’re supposed to be.
It’s noteworthy how often individuals at the center of discussions still end their observations with ‘I am not sure what that would look like’ or ‘I don’t know what shape that would take.’
If the people directly involved don’t know every detail of what a solution would be, it’s OK for us not to know. Plenty of open questions exist, obviously.
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - bullet - 11-18-2026 02:53 PM
(11-18-2026 12:38 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 12:31 PM)bullet Wrote: She's in her ivy tower. A for profit entity is a lose-lose.
Robin Harris (JD, Duke) addresses a basic matter of clarity.
College sport is a revenue-generating venture, as running a shop on campus is.
She reminds all that calling a spade a spade results in better law than calling a spade an ivory tower.
Interestingly, she is also recommending formation of a Super League.
___
Like I said, she's clueless.
For profit means taxes. It means donations are not tax deductible. It means a whole host of regulations. Everyone loses except DC.
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - Gitanole - 11-18-2026 03:22 PM
(11-18-2026 02:53 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-18-2026 12:38 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 12:31 PM)bullet Wrote: She's in her ivy tower. A for profit entity is a lose-lose.
Robin Harris (JD, Duke) addresses a basic matter of clarity.
College sport is a revenue-generating venture, as running a shop on campus is.
She reminds all that calling a spade a spade results in better law than calling a spade an ivory tower.
Interestingly, she is also recommending formation of a Super League.
Like I said, she's clueless.
For profit means taxes. It means donations are not tax deductible. It means a whole host of regulations. Everyone loses except DC.
I get that something about Robin Harris, JD, conference commissioner of the Ivy League, triggers the bullet. As I say, though: these are detailed articles. Many individuals are quoted, many legal ramifications are suggested and considered.
I encourage all to take a look. If this new SEC proposal keeps gaining ground it could be big.

Those excerpts and links again...
Quote:A proposal from the SEC to impose financial penalties on schools for exceeding the athlete revenue-share cap is gaining traction not only within the conference but across the four power leagues, those with knowledge of the discussion tell Yahoo Sports.
According to the proposal—reported in detail last week—schools spending more than the $21.6 million revenue-share cap stand to be assessed millions in penalties in a concept most similar to pro sports-style luxury tax structures.
....
While the plan originated from the SEC, leaders in the other power conferences—the Big Ten, ACC, and Big 12—are coalescing around the concept to the point of adopting it soon and, perhaps, communicating their plans with the co-lead plaintiff attorneys in the House settlement, Jeffrey Kessler and Steve Berman.
Both attorneys have suggested that such a cap policy may unnecessarily restrict athlete pay and have expressed doubt that it is legal without their approval under the House settlement—the NCAA’s multi-billion dollar agreement that governs the industry's new athlete compensation system.
Anil Gollahalli, the Big Ten’s chief legal officer and general counsel, discussed the Big Ten’s own cap policy—passed last month—and the one circulated from the SEC. He said the two are “distinctly different.” The Big Ten’s rule only applies to those within the league, while the SEC’s proposal—possibly now embraced by all power conferences and administered by the College Sports Commission—may necessitate crossing other legal hurdles.
“You have to draw a distinction about what conferences can do by themselves versus what leagues can do collectively and perhaps in connection with [House plaintiff attorneys],” Gollahalli told Yahoo Sports. “I can’t comment on what the right mechanisms are because I don’t know what the contours of the proposal will finally end up being.”
....
Ivy League commissioner Robin Harris made a somewhat bold and revolutionary statement: Perhaps those rich football powers should go do their own thing.
“Call a spade a spade,” Harris told Yahoo Sports. “They are operating as revenue-producing entities for profit. And they are paying athletes a lot of money and paying coaches a lot of money. It should be a standalone, but yet affiliated, for-profit venture. They are operated as taxable entities but are still affiliated with the institutions. You have to have a different structure and rules. What that looks like, I don’t know.”
She is perhaps referencing the long-discussed split of the power leagues, or perhaps even a smaller group of high-revenue producing football programs. A split into a “semi-pro model” would bring “reality and rational choices” to the schools outside of those leagues that are “overspending and can’t afford it,” she said.
“They are chasing something that they cannot obtain,” Harris said. “Now they would free up dollars to be put to the greater good.”
....
https://sports.yahoo.com/college-football/article/our-industry-right-now-is-laundering-money--with-college-sports-in-chaos-is-a-rev-share-cap-solution-on-the-way-152548146.html
Original report, SEC proposal
https://sports.yahoo.com/college-football/article/secs-proposed-cap-policy-would-penalize-big-spending-schools-7-million-this-year-232342944.html
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - The Beaver - 11-18-2026 05:01 PM
(11-18-2026 12:38 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 12:31 PM)bullet Wrote: She's in her ivy tower. A for profit entity is a lose-lose.
Robin Harris (JD, Duke) addresses a basic matter of clarity.
College sport is a revenue-generating venture, as running a shop on campus is.
She reminds all that calling a spade a spade results in better law than calling a spade an ivory tower.
Interestingly, she is also recommending formation of a Super League.
___
Pizza enjoyer wants burger enjoyers to piss off. Too bad, she gets no say. Being minor league sports is clearly entirely destructive to the branding of the big schools and will not be done.
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - bryanw1995 - 11-18-2026 05:14 PM
(11-18-2026 12:05 PM)Gitanole Wrote: The ever-present Ross Dellenger:
A proposal from the SEC to impose financial penalties on schools for exceeding the athlete revenue-share cap is gaining traction not only within the conference but across the four power leagues, those with knowledge of the discussion tell Yahoo Sports.
According to the proposal—reported in detail last week—schools spending more than the $21.6 million revenue-share cap stand to be assessed millions in penalties in a concept most similar to pro sports-style luxury tax structures.
....
While the plan originated from the SEC, leaders in the other power conferences—the Big Ten, ACC, and Big 12—are coalescing around the concept to the point of adopting it soon and, perhaps, communicating their plans with the co-lead plaintiff attorneys in the House settlement, Jeffrey Kessler and Steve Berman.
Both attorneys have suggested that such a cap policy may unnecessarily restrict athlete pay and have expressed doubt that it is legal without their approval under the House settlement—the NCAA’s multi-billion dollar agreement that governs the industry's new athlete compensation system.
Anil Gollahalli, the Big Ten’s chief legal officer and general counsel, discussed the Big Ten’s own cap policy—passed last month—and the one circulated from the SEC. He said the two are “distinctly different.” The Big Ten’s rule only applies to those within the league, while the SEC’s proposal—possibly now embraced by all power conferences and administered by the College Sports Commission—may necessitate crossing other legal hurdles.
“You have to draw a distinction about what conferences can do by themselves versus what leagues can do collectively and perhaps in connection with [House plaintiff attorneys],” Gollahalli told Yahoo Sports. “I can’t comment on what the right mechanisms are because I don’t know what the contours of the proposal will finally end up being.”
....
Ivy League commissioner Robin Harris made a somewhat bold and revolutionary statement: Perhaps those rich football powers should go do their own thing.
“Call a spade a spade,” Harris told Yahoo Sports. “They are operating as revenue-producing entities for profit. And they are paying athletes a lot of money and paying coaches a lot of money. It should be a standalone, but yet affiliated, for-profit venture. They are operated as taxable entities but are still affiliated with the institutions. You have to have a different structure and rules. What that looks like, I don’t know.”
She is perhaps referencing the long-discussed split of the power leagues, or perhaps even a smaller group of high-revenue producing football programs. A split into a “semi-pro model” would bring “reality and rational choices” to the schools outside of those leagues that are “overspending and can’t afford it,” she said.
“They are chasing something that they cannot obtain,” Harris said. “Now they would free up dollars to be put to the greater good.”
....
https://sports.yahoo.com/college-football/article/our-industry-right-now-is-laundering-money--with-college-sports-in-chaos-is-a-rev-share-cap-solution-on-the-way-152548146.html
Original report, SEC proposal
https://sports.yahoo.com/college-football/article/secs-proposed-cap-policy-would-penalize-big-spending-schools-7-million-this-year-232342944.html
Very interesting discussion, not surprising since Dellinger offers us lots of those, although I’m not sure that the Ivy League Commissioner is the right person to weigh in on a P4 breakaway. The Ivy, more than any other D1Conference, would be almost completely unaffected if the P4 moved football or even all sports elsewhere. What’s a million or 2 per year to your school when your average endowment is $25b and you don’t even offer athletics scholarships? Instead of the Ivory Tower, we might as well call it the Ivy Tower. I’d be more interested to see the Commissioner of the PAC 12, Patriot, MVC, etc etc etc weigh in on the topic. Not saying that they might not agree with Harris, but they’d certainly have a much stronger incentive to be right.
To put it in perspective:
Ivy endowments ~ $25b give or take
P4 endowment ~ $2.5b give or take, with a handful of notable exceptions that are more Ivy-like
G5 endowment ~ $250m give or take, again with some exceptions that are more similar to P4 schools
Ivy literally 10x the wealth of the massively wealthy P4, which are in turn 10x the g6, and on and on. It doesn’t take long to get to programs with 1/4 of their annual athletics budget funded by the NCAA, which is itself almost completely funded by the value of the P4.
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - Stugray2 - 11-18-2026 05:17 PM
Good ideas, except they require buy-in from the players to pass legal muster, let alone the House settlement. In other words these require a CBA.
PCSA (congressional action) was the only way they could ever get around that.
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - ken d - 11-18-2026 05:19 PM
(11-18-2026 02:53 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-18-2026 12:38 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 12:31 PM)bullet Wrote: She's in her ivy tower. A for profit entity is a lose-lose.
Robin Harris (JD, Duke) addresses a basic matter of clarity.
College sport is a revenue-generating venture, as running a shop on campus is.
She reminds all that calling a spade a spade results in better law than calling a spade an ivory tower.
Interestingly, she is also recommending formation of a Super League.
___
Like I said, she's clueless.
For profit means taxes. It means donations are not tax deductible. It means a whole host of regulations. Everyone loses except DC.
"For profit" only means taxes if there is, in fact, profit. How many P4 schools would actually make a profit if not subsidized by the school? I assume schools would charge their revenue sport teams a rental fee for the facilities which those teams use, which were paid for by the school and in many cases are still being paid for.
As for "donations", by which I assume you mean payments by collectives or NIL in excess of fair market value, those should already be non-deductible under existing tax law.
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - bullet - 11-18-2026 05:35 PM
(11-18-2026 05:19 PM)ken d Wrote: (11-18-2026 02:53 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-18-2026 12:38 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 12:31 PM)bullet Wrote: She's in her ivy tower. A for profit entity is a lose-lose.
Robin Harris (JD, Duke) addresses a basic matter of clarity.
College sport is a revenue-generating venture, as running a shop on campus is.
She reminds all that calling a spade a spade results in better law than calling a spade an ivory tower.
Interestingly, she is also recommending formation of a Super League.
___
Like I said, she's clueless.
For profit means taxes. It means donations are not tax deductible. It means a whole host of regulations. Everyone loses except DC.
"For profit" only means taxes if there is, in fact, profit. How many P4 schools would actually make a profit if not subsidized by the school? I assume schools would charge their revenue sport teams a rental fee for the facilities which those teams use, which were paid for by the school and in many cases are still being paid for.
As for "donations", by which I assume you mean payments by collectives or NIL in excess of fair market value, those should already be non-deductible under existing tax law.
Have you never heard of donations to athletic departments? How do you think stadium renovations happen?
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - DFW HOYA - 11-18-2026 05:40 PM
(11-18-2026 12:38 PM)Gitanole Wrote: Robin Harris (JD, Duke) addresses a basic matter of clarity.
College sport is a revenue-generating venture, as running a shop on campus is.
___
Two Division I sports generate revenue, out of anywhere from 14 to 43 different sports, depending on the school. Texas A&M golf or Bradley swimming or Boston College field hockey does not produce revenues.
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - Just Joe - 11-18-2026 05:43 PM
The commissioner of a league that doesn't offer athletic scholarships and includes the most of the wealthiest and most prestigious schools in the country is fine with a split. Ok.
RE: Revshare Cap proposals, PCSA alternatives - ken d - 11-18-2026 09:24 PM
(11-18-2026 05:35 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-18-2026 05:19 PM)ken d Wrote: (11-18-2026 02:53 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-18-2026 12:38 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 12:31 PM)bullet Wrote: She's in her ivy tower. A for profit entity is a lose-lose.
Robin Harris (JD, Duke) addresses a basic matter of clarity.
College sport is a revenue-generating venture, as running a shop on campus is.
She reminds all that calling a spade a spade results in better law than calling a spade an ivory tower.
Interestingly, she is also recommending formation of a Super League.
___
Like I said, she's clueless.
For profit means taxes. It means donations are not tax deductible. It means a whole host of regulations. Everyone loses except DC.
"For profit" only means taxes if there is, in fact, profit. How many P4 schools would actually make a profit if not subsidized by the school? I assume schools would charge their revenue sport teams a rental fee for the facilities which those teams use, which were paid for by the school and in many cases are still being paid for.
As for "donations", by which I assume you mean payments by collectives or NIL in excess of fair market value, those should already be non-deductible under existing tax law.
Have you never heard of donations to athletic departments? How do you think stadium renovations happen?
If those are donations to the university, I assume they are tax-deductible. Athletic departments aren't a separate entity at present, and if they were to become one in the future donors could simply give them to the tax exempt entity - the university. If they were to subsequently use that money to pay for stadium renovations it's not clear if that would retroactively make the donation non-deductible. We're plowing new legal ground here. That possibility could generate new legislation to clarify this point.
|