CSNbbs
Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: MACbbs (/forum-513.html)
+---- Forum: ☠️ Jolly Rogers ☠️ (/forum-463.html)
+----- Forum: Western Michigan (/forum-469.html)
+------ Forum: The Dan Burgardt Memorial Bronco Football Forum (/forum-489.html)
+------ Thread: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion (/thread-1035681.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Motown Bronco - 11-13-2026 02:32 PM

Tuesday, 6 pm on ESPN2.

Broncos are 13.5 favorites. Same line we opened at for Akron. Although EMU will be a much tougher opponent, and they tend to get extra "up" when they play us. EMU hung very tough with Ohio, but got destroyed by CMU last week. The starting QB is questionable at this point. I'm not familiar with their backups, but I don't think I want to face Noah Kim again.

Currently, EMU is ranked 10th in the MAC for both Offense and Defense.

Weather continues to cooperate well for mid-November: Sunny, high 55, low 30.

There is no scenario where we clinch a MACC berth with a win. Although the rooting guide would be to cheer for Kent State (vs. Miami), Ball State (at Ohio), CMU (at Buffalo) and BGSU (at Toledo). Any of those would be moderate upsets.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - toddjnsn - 11-16-2026 01:47 AM

Broncos are now -14.5 favorites against EMU, in Kzoo. Yeah, EMU should step up, but they seem odd at QB.

Their 1st main starter was Noah Kim -- not too impressive looking at his last games:
21/30, 2TD, 0INT - @UMass (this one's good/solid)
26/46, 1TD, 1INT - @Akron (not impressive; it's Akron who you can expect not-that-great against them on O sometimes, but not that bad)
16/36, 2TD, 0INT - Toledo (bad pass %; and Toledo doesn't have a tough D; apparently Noah got injured in latter section of the game)

Then two backups played in latter part of Toledo game + fully in Central game but skipping in-between against @Ohio with a Nick Poulos.
20/30, 2TD, 0INT - @Ohio (not bad, but didn't play in next game against CMU at home)

The other two guys....
Brogan McCaughey: 2/4, 0TD, 0INT - Toledo
Brogan McCaughey: 12/17, 0TD, 1INT - CMU
Jace Stuckey: 2/2, 0TD, 0INT - @Wisconsin
Jace Stuckey: 2/3, 0TD, 0INT - Toledo
Jace Stuckey: 5/6, 1TD, 0INT - CMU

I don't fear Noah Kim given our decently solid D, as he can be unimpressive sometimes. And not playing for a couple weeks, especially if not 100.0% better, I don't expect him to be grand or anything, even fired up against us. I would instead expect him to not make any big mistakes, keep things in the not-poor realm for himself, and for him to be motivated.

I imagine they're seeing if said Nick Poulos is ready, who oddly only played this year in their game against @Ohio, for the full game, that was a close one (24-20). I fear him more coming in.

My thoughts? I'd say EMU capitalizes on some mistakes of ours, it's at home for us, so we don't let it get too out of control, and hold on to comfortably win it in the (late?) 4th Q, winning by 10-17 pts.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Boca Rocket - 11-16-2026 09:22 AM

(11-16-2026 01:47 AM)toddjnsn Wrote:  Broncos are now -14.5 favorites against EMU, in Kzoo. Yeah, EMU should step up, but they seem odd at QB.

Their 1st main starter was Noah Kim -- not too impressive looking at his last games:
21/30, 2TD, 0INT - @UMass (this one's good/solid)
26/46, 1TD, 1INT - @Akron (not impressive; it's Akron who you can expect not-that-great against them on O sometimes, but not that bad)
16/36, 2TD, 0INT - Toledo (bad pass %; and Toledo doesn't have a tough D; apparently Noah got injured in latter section of the game)

Then two backups played in latter part of Toledo game + fully in Central game but skipping in-between against @Ohio with a Nick Poulos.
20/30, 2TD, 0INT - @Ohio (not bad, but didn't play in next game against CMU at home)

The other two guys....
Brogan McCaughey: 2/4, 0TD, 0INT - Toledo
Brogan McCaughey: 12/17, 0TD, 1INT - CMU
Jace Stuckey: 2/2, 0TD, 0INT - @Wisconsin
Jace Stuckey: 2/3, 0TD, 0INT - Toledo
Jace Stuckey: 5/6, 1TD, 0INT - CMU

I don't fear Noah Kim given our decently solid D, as he can be unimpressive sometimes. And not playing for a couple weeks, especially if not 100.0% better, I don't expect him to be grand or anything, even fired up against us. I would instead expect him to not make any big mistakes, keep things in the not-poor realm for himself, and for him to be motivated.

I imagine they're seeing if said Nick Poulos is ready, who oddly only played this year in their game against @Ohio, for the full game, that was a close one (24-20). I fear him more coming in.

My thoughts? I'd say EMU capitalizes on some mistakes of ours, it's at home for us, so we don't let it get too out of control, and hold on to comfortably win it in the (late?) 4th Q, winning by 10-17 pts.

Toledo Defense(National Ranking/MAC) thru 11/14/26:
Total Defense 21/1
Scoring Defense 46/2
Rushing Defense 25/2
Pass Efficiency Defense 11/1
Defensive TDs 16/1
Team Sacks 7/1
Tackles for Loss 14/1


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Motown Bronco - 11-16-2026 10:14 AM

^ WMU and Toledo are the MAC Top 2 in scoring defense, which certainly makes that high-scoring shootout feel odd.

Anyhow, back to EMU...


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - wmubroncopilot - 11-16-2026 11:55 AM

So here's the MAC tiebreaker list

Two or More Teams
I. Head-to-Head result among tied teams
II. If not all common opponents, whoever defeated all other tied teams
III. If n/a, eliminate any team that lost to all other tied teams
IV. Combined win % of conference opponents
V. SportSource Analytics Team Rating Score
VI. Commissioner Draw / Coin Toss

Notable: As teams are eliminated, cycle back to the top and work through the tiebreaker for all remaining teams.

This is my best analysis of the possibilities, assuming WMU wins out.

The 2 way 7-1 ties don't matter except to designate a "home team" (meaningless for a neutral site game). So there are two possible three way ties.

First, the "easy" one.

WMU-Ohio-Buffalo
I. H2H among tied teams: This is ill-defined for a three-way tie. If it's taken literally and doesn't require all teams playing each other, then WMU's win over Buffalo eliminates Buffalo and WMU plays Ohio in Detroit. If not (and I don't think it does, because of tiebreaker 2's language)..
II. Does not apply. Not all common opponents.
III. Does not apply.
IV. Combined win % of conference opponents. Current numbers of each team's opponents:
WMU: 25-23
Buffalo: 24-24
Ohio: 19-30

Ohio is eliminated in this scenario. There is no scenario left where their opponent record catches up to either other team. In other words, WMU-Buffalo is the guaranteed matchup here.

WMU-Toledo-Buffalo
I. H2H among tied teams: Does not resolve. All teams played each other and finished 1-1.
II. Does not apply.
III. Does not apply.
IV. Combined win % of conference opponents. Here's where things get complicated. Current numbers of each team's opponents:
WMU: 25-23
Toledo: 26-24
Buffalo: 24-24

Here I will defer to this twitter post (second picture). I can't promise it's 100% accurate, but according to them there are no scenarios that eliminate WMU outright based on tiebreaker 4. There is at least one that ends up with the computer tiebreaker. If that even vaguely tracks other analytics rankings, both WMU and Toledo are well above Buffalo.

TL;DR: I think (without 100% certainty) that WMU actually controls their own destiny. If not, they are very close.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - thewoodennickel - 11-16-2026 06:15 PM

(11-16-2026 01:47 AM)toddjnsn Wrote:  Broncos are now -14.5 favorites against EMU, in Kzoo. Yeah, EMU should step up, but they seem odd at QB.

Their 1st main starter was Noah Kim -- not too impressive looking at his last games:
21/30, 2TD, 0INT - @UMass (this one's good/solid)
26/46, 1TD, 1INT - @Akron (not impressive; it's Akron who you can expect not-that-great against them on O sometimes, but not that bad)
16/36, 2TD, 0INT - Toledo (bad pass %; and Toledo doesn't have a tough D; apparently Noah got injured in latter section of the game)

Then two backups played in latter part of Toledo game + fully in Central game but skipping in-between against @Ohio with a Nick Poulos.
20/30, 2TD, 0INT - @Ohio (not bad, but didn't play in next game against CMU at home)

The other two guys....
Brogan McCaughey: 2/4, 0TD, 0INT - Toledo
Brogan McCaughey: 12/17, 0TD, 1INT - CMU
Jace Stuckey: 2/2, 0TD, 0INT - @Wisconsin
Jace Stuckey: 2/3, 0TD, 0INT - Toledo
Jace Stuckey: 5/6, 1TD, 0INT - CMU

I don't fear Noah Kim given our decently solid D, as he can be unimpressive sometimes. And not playing for a couple weeks, especially if not 100.0% better, I don't expect him to be grand or anything, even fired up against us. I would instead expect him to not make any big mistakes, keep things in the not-poor realm for himself, and for him to be motivated.

I imagine they're seeing if said Nick Poulos is ready, who oddly only played this year in their game against @Ohio, for the full game, that was a close one (24-20). I fear him more coming in.

My thoughts? I'd say EMU capitalizes on some mistakes of ours, it's at home for us, so we don't let it get too out of control, and hold on to comfortably win it in the (late?) 4th Q, winning by 10-17 pts.
Kim did not play against Ohio. McCaughey played that game. Kim hasn't played since Toledo.

We EMU folks are hoping the soph Stuckey plays. McCaughey was brutal against CMU and is not a D1 QB.

We're also hoping for a new coach next year.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Nacho - 11-16-2026 06:35 PM

I think EMU puts up more of a fight than Akron did against us as this is their Super Bowl but we win 38-14 or something like that.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - sdsly - Yesterday 09:55 AM

You can't really ask for better weather for a night game in November. My buddy and I will be there. Hope there is at least a decent crowd.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Motown Bronco - Yesterday 10:07 AM

(11-16-2026 06:35 PM)Nacho Wrote:  I think EMU puts up more of a fight than Akron did against us as this is their Super Bowl but we win 38-14 or something like that.

Yeah, and EMU knows if they pull off a win tonight, their likelihood to get bowl eligible goes up significantly (they host Kent State in the finale).

Putting aside EMU's tendency to play 'up' for us, this should - on paper - be a solid victory for us. EMU's wins are over Sacramento State, Lindenwood, UMass and Akron. And they just got clobbered by CMU.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - SilentStryk09 - Yesterday 10:21 AM

(Yesterday 10:07 AM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  
(11-16-2026 06:35 PM)Nacho Wrote:  I think EMU puts up more of a fight than Akron did against us as this is their Super Bowl but we win 38-14 or something like that.

Yeah, and EMU knows if they pull off a win tonight, their likelihood to get bowl eligible goes up significantly (they host Kent State in the finale).

Putting aside EMU's tendency to play 'up' for us, this should - on paper - be a solid victory for us. EMU's wins are over Sacramento State, Lindenwood, UMass and Akron. And they just got clobbered by CMU.

i believe they're already considered ineligible since their FCS win came against a school not giving enough scholarships, so even at 6-6 they'd be in the backlog, but would be first in the list.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - ColinApocalypse - Yesterday 11:32 AM

Frankly, Eastern has not looked great. They barely beat Akron and got crushed by Central at Ford Field. This seems to be Eastern's thing every year though, very up and down throughout the season. This year has been mostly down.

Being at home and in contention for the MACC, I think our guys will be plenty motivated. I would hope so at least.

Run game should go wild like they did against Akron. Just pound the Hurons into submission and collect the W. Don't get cute with the offensive playcalling, cuz EMU treats this game like their Super Bowl and even their bad teams have made us pay in the past.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Broncos1983 - Yesterday 11:41 AM

(Yesterday 11:32 AM)ColinApocalypse Wrote:  Frankly, Eastern has not looked great. They barely beat Akron and got crushed by Central Ford Field. This seems to be Eastern's thing every year though, very up and down throughout the season. This year has been mostly down.

Being at home and in contention for the MACC, I think our guys will be plenty motivated. I would hope so at least.

Run game should go wild like they did against Akron. Just pound the Hurons into submission and collect the W. Don't get cute with the offensive playcalling, cuz EMU treats this game like their Super Bowl and even their bad teams have made us pay in the past.

FYI, the Akron and CMU games in which EMU played poorly were played with a backup QB. If starter Noah Kim (former MSU QB) is back tonight (as most suspect), I suspect EMU will play much better. Also read that EMU is getting 2 P4 transfer O-Linemen back tonight (one from MSU and one from Oklahoma State). I would be surprised if this game isn’t close. We need to play our ball control game, get turnovers and not turn the ball over.

Go Broncos!


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - sdsly - Yesterday 02:23 PM

(Yesterday 11:32 AM)ColinApocalypse Wrote:  Frankly, Eastern has not looked great. They barely beat Akron and got crushed by Central Ford Field. This seems to be Eastern's thing every year though, very up an

Run game should go wild like they did against Akron. Just pound the Hurons into submission and collect the W. Don't get cute with the offensive playcalling, cuz EMU treats this game like their Super Bowl and even their bad teams have made us pay in the past.

I put some money on Buckley to go over 100 yards tonight at +102. I also think he is going to run wild tonight.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Motown Bronco - Yesterday 03:46 PM

(Yesterday 02:23 PM)sdsly Wrote:  
(Yesterday 11:32 AM)ColinApocalypse Wrote:  Frankly, Eastern has not looked great. They barely beat Akron and got crushed by Central Ford Field. This seems to be Eastern's thing every year though, very up an

Run game should go wild like they did against Akron. Just pound the Hurons into submission and collect the W. Don't get cute with the offensive playcalling, cuz EMU treats this game like their Super Bowl and even their bad teams have made us pay in the past.

I put some money on Buckley to go over 100 yards tonight at +102. I also think he is going to run wild tonight.

A bit risky as they've been mixing in Cabana more lately.

In terms of MACtion, I only partook on Miami -7.5 at Kent State. (it's since shifted to Miami -9.5 so I guess I wasn't alone, lol)


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Johny - Yesterday 03:58 PM

(11-13-2026 02:32 PM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  Tuesday, 6 pm on ESPN2.

Broncos are 13.5 favorites. Same line we opened at for Akron. Although EMU will be a much tougher opponent, and they tend to get extra "up" when they play us. EMU hung very tough with Ohio, but got destroyed by CMU last week. The starting QB is questionable at this point. I'm not familiar with their backups, but I don't think I want to face Noah Kim again.

Currently, EMU is ranked 10th in the MAC for both Offense and Defense.

Weather continues to cooperate well for mid-November: Sunny, high 55, low 30.

There is no scenario where we clinch a MACC berth with a win. Although the rooting guide would be to cheer for Kent State (vs. Miami), Ball State (at Ohio), CMU (at Buffalo) and BGSU (at Toledo). Any of those would be moderate upsets.



RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Johny - Yesterday 03:59 PM

(11-13-2026 02:32 PM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  Tuesday, 6 pm on ESPN2.

Broncos are 13.5 favorites. Same line we opened at for Akron. Although EMU will be a much tougher opponent, and they tend to get extra "up" when they play us. EMU hung very tough with Ohio, but got destroyed by CMU last week. The starting QB is questionable at this point. I'm not familiar with their backups, but I don't think I want to face Noah Kim again.

Currently, EMU is ranked 10th in the MAC for both Offense and Defense.

Weather continues to cooperate well for mid-November: Sunny, high 55, low 30.

There is no scenario where we clinch a MACC berth with a win. Although the rooting guide would be to cheer for Kent State (vs. Miami), Ball State (at Ohio), CMU (at Buffalo) and BGSU (at Toledo). Any of those would be moderate upsets.



RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Johny - Yesterday 04:02 PM

MAC football is hard to predict, so 13 point in our favor is nice, but let them play the game.


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Johny - Yesterday 04:10 PM

(11-13-2026 02:32 PM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  Tuesday, 6 pm on ESPN2.

Broncos are 13.5 favorites. Same line we opened at for Akron. Although EMU will be a much tougher opponent, and they tend to get extra "up" when they play us. EMU hung very tough with Ohio, but got destroyed by CMU last week. The starting QB is questionable at this point. I'm not familiar with their backups, but I don't think I want to face Noah Kim again.

Currently, EMU is ranked 10th in the MAC for both Offense and Defense.

Weather continues to cooperate well for mid-November: Sunny, high 55, low 30.

There is no scenario where we clinch a MACC berth with a win. Although the rooting guide would be to cheer for Kent State (vs. Miami), Ball State (at Ohio), CMU (at Buffalo) and BGSU (at Toledo). Any of those would be moderate upsets.



RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Broncos1983 - Yesterday 05:11 PM

(Yesterday 11:41 AM)Broncos1983 Wrote:  
(Yesterday 11:32 AM)ColinApocalypse Wrote:  Frankly, Eastern has not looked great. They barely beat Akron and got crushed by Central Ford Field. This seems to be Eastern's thing every year though, very up and down throughout the season. This year has been mostly down.

Being at home and in contention for the MACC, I think our guys will be plenty motivated. I would hope so at least.

Run game should go wild like they did against Akron. Just pound the Hurons into submission and collect the W. Don't get cute with the offensive playcalling, cuz EMU treats this game like their Super Bowl and even their bad teams have made us pay in the past.

FYI, the Akron and CMU games in which EMU played poorly were played with a backup QB. If starter Noah Kim (former MSU QB) is back tonight (as most suspect), I suspect EMU will play much better. Also read that EMU is getting 2 P4 transfer O-Linemen back tonight (one from MSU and one from Oklahoma State). I would be surprised if this game isn’t close. We need to play our ball control game, get turnovers and not turn the ball over.

Go Broncos!

Noah Kim is listed as “Out” per the just released MAC Availability Report. Not sure who their starting QB will be. I still remember back a few years ago when EMU went with a surprise backup against us in Ypsi and the guy just tore us apart. Some on the EMU board are speculating their current 3rd stringer could get his first start instead of the guy that played QB last game vs. CMU. I guess we’ll see soon enough…


RE: Game #11: WMU vs. EMU MACtion - Broncodan - Yesterday 05:59 PM

(Yesterday 05:11 PM)Broncos1983 Wrote:  
(Yesterday 11:41 AM)Broncos1983 Wrote:  
(Yesterday 11:32 AM)ColinApocalypse Wrote:  Frankly, Eastern has not looked great. They barely beat Akron and got crushed by Central Ford Field. This seems to be Eastern's thing every year though, very up and down throughout the season. This year has been mostly down.

Being at home and in contention for the MACC, I think our guys will be plenty motivated. I would hope so at least.

Run game should go wild like they did against Akron. Just pound the Hurons into submission and collect the W. Don't get cute with the offensive playcalling, cuz EMU treats this game like their Super Bowl and even their bad teams have made us pay in the past.

FYI, the Akron and CMU games in which EMU played poorly were played with a backup QB. If starter Noah Kim (former MSU QB) is back tonight (as most suspect), I suspect EMU will play much better. Also read that EMU is getting 2 P4 transfer O-Linemen back tonight (one from MSU and one from Oklahoma State). I would be surprised if this game isn’t close. We need to play our ball control game, get turnovers and not turn the ball over.

Go Broncos!

Noah Kim is listed as “Out” per the just released MAC Availability Report. Not sure who their starting QB will be. I still remember back a few years ago when EMU went with a surprise backup against us in Ypsi and the guy just tore us apart. Some on the EMU board are speculating their current 3rd stringer could get his first start instead of the guy that played QB last game vs. CMU. I guess we’ll see soon enough…

I’m not worried with lance Taylor, Tim Lester could never make adjustments.