Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - msu35 - 11-07-2026 10:08 PM
Tier 1
Memphis
UNT
Tier 2
FAU
UTSA
Army
Tier 3
Tulsa
UAB
ECU
Tier 4
USF
Charlotte
Navy
Tier 5
Tulane
Temple
Rice
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - Frank Grimes - 11-07-2026 11:26 PM
Pretty accurate and close to what I’d have. I’d probably put Tulane in the 4th tier, but given what they did today, they probably deserve the 5th tier, at least for this week lol. I’d probably move USF to the 3rd tier.
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - Ned Low - 11-07-2026 11:33 PM
1. Memphis: off this weekend but have earned the top spot.
2. North Texas: convincing win over Rice. They’ve earned the #2 ranking.
3. (Tie) FAU: convincing win over UTSA… but UTSA has some issues with defense.
3. (Tie) UTSA: Destroyed by FAU. Next week’s game vs UNT could be a lot of fun. I’m picking the Runners in this one.
3. (Tie) Army: Tough loss today against a solid Air Force squad.
4. Tulsa: I am struggling to figure them out. They demolished Tulane today and deserve this spot.
5. ECU: We beat a USF team by a FG in a game that we should have won by a TD. This same USF team beat a UAB team by 20 last week. That same UAB beat us in OT.
6. UAB: Well coached. Struggled against an improving Charlotte squad, however.
7. USF: the talent is there but they have clearly taken a step back.
8. Navy: They’ve dropped off this season but remain well-coached. Memphis best not overlook them in two weeks.
9. (Tie) Temple: Better than their record indicates. Well-coached.
9. (Tie) Charlotte: impressively, they have not given up. Albin deserves some credit for this fact. I expect them to play ECU tough next week.
10. Rice: They aren’t winning but would beat…
11. Tulane: What’s developing in New Orleans is partly due to a terrible HC… but my hunch is that more is going on behind the scenes.
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - Ned Low - 11-07-2026 11:35 PM
(11-07-2026 11:26 PM)Frank Grimes Wrote: Pretty accurate and close to what I’d have. I’d probably put Tulane in the 4th tier, but given what they did today, they probably deserve the 5th tier, at least for this week lol. I’d probably move USF to the 3rd tier.
Agreed. You make some good points.
Y’all certainly have a good coach, btw.
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - Frank Grimes - 11-07-2026 11:38 PM
(11-07-2026 11:35 PM)Ned Low Wrote: (11-07-2026 11:26 PM)Frank Grimes Wrote: Pretty accurate and close to what I’d have. I’d probably put Tulane in the 4th tier, but given what they did today, they probably deserve the 5th tier, at least for this week lol. I’d probably move USF to the 3rd tier.
Agreed. You make some good points.
Y’all certainly have a good coach, btw.
I’ve gone back and forth on him, but he’s obviously a step up from Dilhole. I like that we’re typically a better second half team, which signals quality coaching, and the defense is very good. But something with the offense (which is his baby) is just… off. The O-Line sucks for sure, but there doesn’t seem to be any adjustment to account for that. If he can win next week at Temple to get us to bowl eligibility, that’d go a long way for me.
Also hoping we can hold on to Grantham as our DC. He’s been huge for us.
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - msu35 - 11-08-2026 10:56 AM
(11-07-2026 11:26 PM)Frank Grimes Wrote: Pretty accurate and close to what I’d have. I’d probably put Tulane in the 4th tier, but given what they did today, they probably deserve the 5th tier, at least for this week lol. I’d probably move USF to the 3rd tier.
Those are all fair points, but I had to demerit Tulane for the skull dragging and USF for outspending everyone yet leading the way in how to do it wrong.
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - msu35 - 11-08-2026 11:00 AM
(11-07-2026 11:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote: 1. Memphis: off this weekend but have earned the top spot.
2. North Texas: convincing win over Rice. They’ve earned the #2 ranking.
3. (Tie) FAU: convincing win over UTSA… but UTSA has some issues with defense.
3. (Tie) UTSA: Destroyed by FAU. Next week’s game vs UNT could be a lot of fun. I’m picking the Runners in this one.
3. (Tie) Army: Tough loss today against a solid Air Force squad.
4. Tulsa: I am struggling to figure them out. They demolished Tulane today and deserve this spot.
5. ECU: We beat a USF team by a FG in a game that we should have won by a TD. This same USF team beat a UAB team by 20 last week. That same UAB beat us in OT.
6. UAB: Well coached. Struggled against an improving Charlotte squad, however.
7. USF: the talent is there but they have clearly taken a step back.
8. Navy: They’ve dropped off this season but remain well-coached. Memphis best not overlook them in two weeks.
9. (Tie) Temple: Better than their record indicates. Well-coached.
9. (Tie) Charlotte: impressively, they have not given up. Albin deserves some credit for this fact. I expect them to play ECU tough next week.
10. Rice: They aren’t winning but would beat…
11. Tulane: What’s developing in New Orleans is partly due to a terrible HC… but my hunch is that more is going on behind the scenes.
Yeah, my tiers are more or less fluid within the tier -- easiest way to represent degrees of uncertainty. I can also see the argument that ECU may be a stronger team than UAB currently. I also can't push back on Tulane being relegated to the bottom, but I did let conference standing carry a bit of weight in my rankings for this week. Still, you make valid points and I appreciate your contribution.
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - tigerfan39 - 11-08-2026 11:14 AM
If memphis wins out and UTSA beats UNT we will mostly likely have a 3 way tie.
how will that work out?
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - msu35 - 11-08-2026 11:18 AM
(11-08-2026 11:14 AM)tigerfan39 Wrote: If memphis wins out and UTSA beats UNT we will mostly likely have a 3 way tie.
how will that work out?
If Memphis wins out and UTSA beats UNT, Memphis plays UTSA for the championship -- this assumes UTSA wins out of course.
(11-07-2026 02:13 PM)msu35 Wrote: I provided a simplified version for the Tigers board. I'll post it here too:
TWO-TEAM TIES
- First Place Tie: Both teams automatically play in the championship game.
- Second Place Tie:
- Head-To-Head: Winner of the regular-season matchup advances.
- CFP Rankings and Final Weekend: If they did not play each other:
- One Team Ranked: If the ranked team doesn't lose on the final weekend, they advance. If they lose, computer metrics decide.
- Both Teams Ranked: The higher-ranked team that wins on the final weekend advances. If neither wins, computer metrics decide.
- Neither Team Ranked: Computer metrics decide.
- Fallback Tiebreakers: If still tied, look at win percentage against common conference opponents, overall winning percentage (excluding exempt games), and finally a coin toss by the commissioner.
MULTI-TEAM TIES (3+ Teams)
- Reduction: Narrow the tied teams down to the top two. If a step reduces the tie to two teams, use the two-team rules above.
- Tiebreaking Steps:
- Mini Round-Robin: Compare head-to-head records among the tied group. If one team beat all other tied opponents, they advance. Otherwise, proceed to rankings.
- CFP Rankings and Final Weekend:
- Highest-Ranked Team: If the highest-ranked team doesn't lose on the final weekend, they advance. If they lose, computer metrics are used for all spots.
- Multiple Ranked Teams: The highest-ranked team(s) that win on the final weekend advance.
- No Ranked Teams / None Win: If no teams are ranked or none win on the final weekend, computer metrics decide.
- Fallback Tiebreakers: If still tied, use win percentage against common conference opponents, overall winning percentage (excluding exempt games), and finally a drawing by the commissioner.
Computer metrics refer to the composite average of Connolly SP+, SportSource TR116, ESPN SOR, and KPI.
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - Tiger1983 - 11-08-2026 11:36 AM
(11-08-2026 11:14 AM)tigerfan39 Wrote: If memphis wins out and UTSA beats UNT we will mostly likely have a 3 way tie.
how will that work out?
According to Daily Memphian
Assumptions
Memphis wins out
NT beats Rice, Tulane, and Temple
UTSA beats UAB and Tulsa:
If North Texas beats UTSA, Memphis is 2nd place and goes to NT for championship game.
If UTSA beats NT, the most likely tiebreaker would come down to the composite average of selected computer metrics (Connolly SP+, SportSource TR116 Team Strength Ranking, ESPN SOR, KPI).
https://dailymemphian.com/subscriber/section/sportsmemphis-tigers-football/article/68368/memphis-tigers-football-american-conference-standings-tiebreaker
Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - owl at the moon - 11-08-2026 02:48 PM
T1. FAU 60
T1. Tulsa 60
3. UNT 52
4. Memphis 49
5. Navy 42
6. Temple 35
7. UTSA 29
T8. Rice 23
T8. UAB 23
10. Army 21
11. ECU 20
12. USF 17
13. CLT 12
14. Tulane 10
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - virgosports - 11-08-2026 04:06 PM
Here is my take
1. North Texas: undefeated and more so, starting to look solid. Next week is almost make or break for the championship.
2. Memphis: if not for that stupid Tulane giveaway, we could be ranked. Next two are tricky.
3. UTSA: lost chance to catch up to the top g6 teams for playoff. Next week can move them back in the convo for at least the championship game.
4. FAU: beat the leader to get in the conversation but need utsa and Memphis to slip.
5. Army: Tries to be a strong team but uneven season.
6. ECU: winning two straight has to be a confidence builder, right? ECU can win or lose the last three and it would not be surprising including Charlotte. I personally thought ECU would be at the leaderboard before start of season.
7. Tulsa:won 2 of last three and the next two are at home to build momentum.
8. UAB: I think future is better for UAB, however for the present, they need to beat Temple as the last two are difficult. I struggled with them as they could be ahead of Tulsa and ECU.
9. USF: the talent is there but with new coach, let’s hope with time they get better. Next season. Interesting last three games to end season with two of three at home but two of three overall tough games.
10. Navy: They’ve dropped off this season but remain well-coached. Memphis best not overlook them in two weeks.< this…
11. Charlotte: the first part of the season, they looked terrible, however since then have improved without the Ws showing up. With the next two at home, they can double their season W total.
12. Temple: The way season started, specially first 5 games, they looked like a tough out but seems to have regressed as season has progressed.
13. Tulane: Not the best team but did beat Memphis.
14. Rice: They aren’t winning but would could have with some close games that did not go their way
Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - owl at the moon - 11-08-2026 04:09 PM
(11-08-2026 04:06 PM)virgosports Wrote: Here is my take
1. North Texas: undefeated and more so, starting to look solid. Next week is almost make or break for the championship.
2. Memphis: if not for that stupid Tulane giveaway, we could be ranked. Next two are tricky.
3. UTSA: lost chance to catch up to the top g6 teams for playoff. Next week can move them back in the convo for at least the championship game.
4. FAU: beat the leader to get in the conversation but need utsa and Memphis to slip.
5. Army: Tries to be a strong team but uneven season.
6. ECU: winning two straight has to be a confidence builder, right? ECU can win or lose the last three and it would not be surprising including Charlotte. I personally thought ECU would be at the leaderboard before start of season.
7. Tulsa:won 2 of last three and the next two are at home to build momentum.
8. UAB: I think future is better for UAB, however for the present, they need to beat Temple as the last two are difficult. I struggled with them as they could be ahead of Tulsa and ECU.
9. USF: the talent is there but with new coach, let’s hope with time they get better. Next season. Interesting last three games to end season with two of three at home but two of three overall tough games.
10. Navy: They’ve dropped off this season but remain well-coached. Memphis best not overlook them in two weeks.< this…
11. Charlotte: the first part of the season, they looked terrible, however since then have improved without the Ws showing up. With the next two at home, they can double their season W total.
12. Temple: The way season started, specially first 5 games, they looked like a tough out but seems to have regressed as season has progressed.
13. Tulane: Not the best team but did beat Memphis.
14. Rice: They aren’t winning but would could have with some close games that did not go their way
Telephone game:
I heard UTSA can’t get the Alamodome so would have to host in The Convo
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - Volkmar - 11-08-2026 04:41 PM
(11-08-2026 04:09 PM)owl at the moon Wrote: (11-08-2026 04:06 PM)virgosports Wrote: Here is my take
1. North Texas: undefeated and more so, starting to look solid. Next week is almost make or break for the championship.
2. Memphis: if not for that stupid Tulane giveaway, we could be ranked. Next two are tricky.
3. UTSA: lost chance to catch up to the top g6 teams for playoff. Next week can move them back in the convo for at least the championship game.
4. FAU: beat the leader to get in the conversation but need utsa and Memphis to slip.
5. Army: Tries to be a strong team but uneven season.
6. ECU: winning two straight has to be a confidence builder, right? ECU can win or lose the last three and it would not be surprising including Charlotte. I personally thought ECU would be at the leaderboard before start of season.
7. Tulsa:won 2 of last three and the next two are at home to build momentum.
8. UAB: I think future is better for UAB, however for the present, they need to beat Temple as the last two are difficult. I struggled with them as they could be ahead of Tulsa and ECU.
9. USF: the talent is there but with new coach, let’s hope with time they get better. Next season. Interesting last three games to end season with two of three at home but two of three overall tough games.
10. Navy: They’ve dropped off this season but remain well-coached. Memphis best not overlook them in two weeks.< this…
11. Charlotte: the first part of the season, they looked terrible, however since then have improved without the Ws showing up. With the next two at home, they can double their season W total.
12. Temple: The way season started, specially first 5 games, they looked like a tough out but seems to have regressed as season has progressed.
13. Tulane: Not the best team but did beat Memphis.
14. Rice: They aren’t winning but would could have with some close games that did not go their way
Telephone game:
I heard UTSA can’t get the Alamodome so would have to host in The Convo
You’re in no position to talk football smack.
Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - owl at the moon - 11-08-2026 05:15 PM
(11-08-2026 04:41 PM)Volkmar Wrote: (11-08-2026 04:09 PM)owl at the moon Wrote: (11-08-2026 04:06 PM)virgosports Wrote: Here is my take
1. North Texas: undefeated and more so, starting to look solid. Next week is almost make or break for the championship.
2. Memphis: if not for that stupid Tulane giveaway, we could be ranked. Next two are tricky.
3. UTSA: lost chance to catch up to the top g6 teams for playoff. Next week can move them back in the convo for at least the championship game.
4. FAU: beat the leader to get in the conversation but need utsa and Memphis to slip.
5. Army: Tries to be a strong team but uneven season.
6. ECU: winning two straight has to be a confidence builder, right? ECU can win or lose the last three and it would not be surprising including Charlotte. I personally thought ECU would be at the leaderboard before start of season.
7. Tulsa:won 2 of last three and the next two are at home to build momentum.
8. UAB: I think future is better for UAB, however for the present, they need to beat Temple as the last two are difficult. I struggled with them as they could be ahead of Tulsa and ECU.
9. USF: the talent is there but with new coach, let’s hope with time they get better. Next season. Interesting last three games to end season with two of three at home but two of three overall tough games.
10. Navy: They’ve dropped off this season but remain well-coached. Memphis best not overlook them in two weeks.< this…
11. Charlotte: the first part of the season, they looked terrible, however since then have improved without the Ws showing up. With the next two at home, they can double their season W total.
12. Temple: The way season started, specially first 5 games, they looked like a tough out but seems to have regressed as season has progressed.
13. Tulane: Not the best team but did beat Memphis.
14. Rice: They aren’t winning but would could have with some close games that did not go their way
Telephone game:
I heard UTSA can’t get the Alamodome so would have to host in The Convo
You’re in no position to talk football smack.
Rice and UTSA have the exact same record in fútbol this year (4-4-2) and we are going to settle this in about five minutes in Bradenton.
Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - owl at the moon - 11-08-2026 05:17 PM
Entschuldigung, I meant Fußball
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - msu35 - 11-09-2026 10:25 AM
(11-08-2026 04:06 PM)virgosports Wrote: Here is my take
1. North Texas: undefeated and more so, starting to look solid. Next week is almost make or break for the championship.
2. Memphis: if not for that stupid Tulane giveaway, we could be ranked. Next two are tricky.
3. UTSA: lost chance to catch up to the top g6 teams for playoff. Next week can move them back in the convo for at least the championship game.
4. FAU: beat the leader to get in the conversation but need utsa and Memphis to slip.
5. Army: Tries to be a strong team but uneven season.
6. ECU: winning two straight has to be a confidence builder, right? ECU can win or lose the last three and it would not be surprising including Charlotte. I personally thought ECU would be at the leaderboard before start of season.
7. Tulsa:won 2 of last three and the next two are at home to build momentum.
8. UAB: I think future is better for UAB, however for the present, they need to beat Temple as the last two are difficult. I struggled with them as they could be ahead of Tulsa and ECU.
9. USF: the talent is there but with new coach, let’s hope with time they get better. Next season. Interesting last three games to end season with two of three at home but two of three overall tough games.
10. Navy: They’ve dropped off this season but remain well-coached. Memphis best not overlook them in two weeks.< this…
11. Charlotte: the first part of the season, they looked terrible, however since then have improved without the Ws showing up. With the next two at home, they can double their season W total.
12. Temple: The way season started, specially first 5 games, they looked like a tough out but seems to have regressed as season has progressed.
13. Tulane: Not the best team but did beat Memphis.
14. Rice: They aren’t winning but would could have with some close games that did not go their way
That UTSA at FAU game was a head scratcher, but UTSA has advantages in the 'dome. This is going to be a very interesting week.
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - Ourland - 11-09-2026 05:46 PM
North Texas
Memphis
UT - San Antonio
Florida Atlantic
Army
Tulsa
South Florida
UAB
East Carolina
Navy
Rice
Tulane
Temple
Charlotte
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - panicstricken - 11-09-2026 09:48 PM
1: Tulsa
2: UNT
12: Tulane
13: Memphis
RE: Rank the American -- Week 11 Edition - panicstricken - 11-09-2026 10:16 PM
1: Tulsa
2: UNT
12: Tulane
13: Memphis
|