![]() |
|
Coaches vote on G6 playoff - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: Coaches vote on G6 playoff (/thread-1035199.html) Pages: 1 2 |
Coaches vote on G6 playoff - b2b - 11-03-2026 09:02 PM I'm sorry if this has already been posted. .... Group of Six coaches want their own College Football Playoff. Here's why originally appeared on The Sporting News. Add The Sporting News as a Preferred Source by clicking here. Pete Nakos and Brett McMurphy from On3 surveyed every Group of Six coach in the country. The results shed light on the schools left out to dry. 40 of 61 coaches favor a separate playoff outside the College Football Playoff. This is not breathtaking because of the newly expanded 24-team playoff coming in 2027. The CFP format is 19 at-large bids and 5 automatic bids: the 4 Power 4 champions and the top Group of Six champion. That's 1 guaranteed spot for the whole Group of Six. "There's no ability for any of us to realistically win the national title. That's the truth," a Group of Six coach said. Sent from my Pixel 7 using CSNbbs mobile app RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - DavidSt - 11-04-2026 02:08 AM On3 said at first all the G6 coaches, but it seems they left off PAC 12, MWC and American schools from or excluded from the vote. Boise State, New Mexico, Oregon State, NDSU, Air Force, UTSA, Memphis, USF and others said they were never asked about the playoffs, so there is push back from the schools and conferences. If you give them a playoffs? No G6 teams get to play the P4 in the playoffs. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - Stugray2 - 11-04-2026 05:33 AM Side note: DavidSt, 61 of 69 coaches were surveyed, nearly 90% of G6. That includes most Pac-12, American and Mountain West coaches. It is obvious that you simply made that list up. While it is true some schools, like Boise State, are attempting to become the "Gonzaga" of G6, the one team invited to the CFP every year, and also true that ten others are focused on somehow crossing the divide to get into A4 and think anything less than pretending to be A4 will doom them, two thirds of the coaches know the reality, they are playing for nothing, which is destroying all G6. They need to play for something. It must be said the G6 schools won't voluntarily give up their CFP access, nor the money. They need it to stay in FBS. But they are very serious about getting an NIT type tournament together for the other 5 conference champions who do not get the one reserved CFP slot per Chris Vannini reporting. This report from On3 is what Vannini was responding to and clarifying the position of the G6, and what they are actually negotiating. (Vannini also notes that the consensus opinion is the CCGs are going away, which will cost the top seed in each G6 conference a home game and the conferences revenue) IMHO, they will likely settle on an 8-team playoff with the top 4 of the 5 non-CFP G6 conference regular season champions hosting the first round, and the highest winning seeds hosting the second round, then a bowl game for the "conference champions playoff series" championship game. This is because G6 fan bases are relatively small and cannot be asked to travel to multiple rounds of bowls. (Even the A4 reserve bowls to the New Years four, semifinals and Championship, having schools host the first rounds for the fan travel issue.) Basically 5 champions, 4 hosting, and three at-large or "best of the rest" second place teams. That is small enough to pull off, with a New Year's championship and with the first two rounds in ESPN TV windows not occupied by the CFP. It also creates six home games that should have full stands without the overhead or hassle of bowls (meaning they'll actually make teams money instead of costing them money, as most G6 bowls are financial losses for participants). Maybe they pool together a couple of their better bowls for the conference runner ups not in their "NIT" as consolation. The collapse of the bowl system and near exclusion from the CFP (69 of 70 non-autonomy schools will not participate) doesn't leave them many options. I think the G6 "NIT" is the most realistic option to try and fill the void. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - b2b - 11-04-2026 10:33 AM ECU's coach is on record being against it. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - Akiraptor - 11-04-2026 11:44 AM What would be the point of this tournament? Is it to determine who's the second best G6 team? Does the victor get a "Congrats on almost making the real playoffs! You're the first loser!" trophy? Out of every idea I've heard being seriously proposed, this one is no doubt the worst. I'd rather have a conference championship game and no postseason at all than this farce. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - dbackjon - 11-04-2026 02:27 PM Can you imagine the opt-outs from this? RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - GoBuckeyes1047 - 11-04-2026 03:00 PM My proposal for the G6 is a 10 team, but the 1-2 CFP participants from the G6 get a bye to the semis after New Years (1st round played the 2nd weekend, QFs on 3rd weekend). If 1 team in the CFP, 5-7 hosts 8-10 in the 1st round, 3 winners play @ 2-4 in the QFs, then those 3 winners join the 1st seeded team sometime after New Years, ideally at a time to give the G6 CFP team a chance to make the QFs. If 2 teams make the CFP from the G6, 3-6 host 7-10 in the 1st round, the 4 winners play in the QFs with the higher seeds hosting, then those 2 winners play the 2 CFP teams in the semis. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - goofus - 11-04-2026 03:11 PM I could see the appeal of maybe getting rid of G6 CCG's and have an 8-team G6 NIT type tourney instead. Invite the best team available from each G6 conference plus 2 more at large teams. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - Just Joe - 11-04-2026 03:17 PM So... Expanding the playoff to 24 for the Eli Drinkwitz's of the P4 to get playoff bids accelerates the death of the bowls and now G6 coaches see their season's ending in November and being without a postseason at all. Got it. Well FCS would gladly take anyone in that wants to drop. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - goofus - 11-04-2026 03:21 PM (11-04-2026 03:00 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: My proposal for the G6 is a 10 team, but the 1-2 CFP participants from the G6 get a bye to the semis after New Years (1st round played the 2nd weekend, QFs on 3rd weekend). If 1 team in the CFP, 5-7 hosts 8-10 in the 1st round, 3 winners play @ 2-4 in the QFs, then those 3 winners join the 1st seeded team sometime after New Years, ideally at a time to give the G6 CFP team a chance to make the QFs. If 2 teams make the CFP from the G6, 3-6 host 7-10 in the 1st round, the 4 winners play in the QFs with the higher seeds hosting, then those 2 winners play the 2 CFP teams in the semis. Wait, what? I am.having a hard time following this. So what happens if the G6 team keeps winning in the CFP? This is too confusing. Just pick a tourney. Once you lose in the CFP, you are done. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - Stugray2 - 11-04-2026 05:32 PM (11-04-2026 11:44 AM)Akiraptor Wrote: What would be the point of this tournament? Is it to determine who's the second best G6 team? Does the victor get a "Congrats on almost making the real playoffs! You're the first loser!" trophy? Out of every idea I've heard being seriously proposed, this one is no doubt the worst. I'd rather have a conference championship game and no postseason at all than this farce. Replace the CCGs and give conference champs not in the CFP something to play for. That's important for recruiting. Remember, 69 of 70 schools wind up playing for nothing under the current system. They are losing their best players in the portal and struggle to raise money for NIL. Who is going to donate to an NIL collective for USM or Missouri State or UAB or Miami U or Colorado State or Nevada if they never participate in the CFP and are eliminated from consideration every year by the end of October? Schools need something to show, something to raise money, something to sell recruits. Boise State, as the potential Gonzaga of G6 football and a few others may have stories to sell donors and recruits. But easily 60 schools have nothing to sell. G6 Bowls lose money, they tend to cost participants more than they make back in revenue. We have all been asked to donate for our G6 schools playing in some rinky dink bowl causing a budget shortfall. CCGs were revenue generating, but going away, they need replacing. I think when we look at these things we tend to focus only on the conference or TV money, but forget the school's own athletic department's donors demands. We fans are not the drivers behind either the expanded CFP or the G6 NIT proposal. I think it will be interesting to look at how things are perceived and shake out in three years where UNLV is playing App State on December 30th for the G6 champions trophy, while Boise State or Tulane is sitting at home after getting blown out by Georgia or Michigan three weeks prior in a CFP road playoff game, as the Gonzaga of the G6. Which one did more for their program? RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - BearcatJerry - 11-04-2026 06:19 PM They can call it...wait for it... The Football Championship Subdivision" or FCS for short. Catchy, right? RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - AlwaysSunny - 11-04-2026 06:33 PM It's probably because they see the inevitable writing on the wall. When 12 more of the better P4 teams are in the playoffs and some of the better bowls realize that they'll only be able to get G6 teams which will tank their ratings, then what? 6 conferences fighting for 1 CFP spot and bowls that will likely cut their payouts due to not getting P4 schools is only gonna last for so long. You think P4 opt outs from bowls was a thing before, just wait until there's 23 spots for the CFP when a football school doesn't make it and gets relegated to a bowl game against Louisiana Tech. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - Fresno Fanatic - 11-04-2026 06:38 PM (11-04-2026 05:32 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:(11-04-2026 11:44 AM)Akiraptor Wrote: What would be the point of this tournament? Is it to determine who's the second best G6 team? Does the victor get a "Congrats on almost making the real playoffs! You're the first loser!" trophy? Out of every idea I've heard being seriously proposed, this one is no doubt the worst. I'd rather have a conference championship game and no postseason at all than this farce. I like your words. I also have another idea for the G6 that allows more “access” to something more meaningful. And it has to do with the rumbling of around 10 major bowls not part of the CFP wanting to survive when/if a 24 team CFP does move forward. And that is this…so say 10 bowls. Each bowl location will have a mini 4-team playoff. That would be 40 teams total on top of the 24 that goes to the CFP24. Of the 40 teams in these 10 “bowl series”, most will be p4 with reps from the 4 or 5 or ? G6 conferences that didn’t get a team into the CFP. Surely these bowl locations would dole out more prize money if 4 fan-bases are there around their respective semifinals, and then 2 fan-bases for their series’ championship game. Also tv would pay more money for these 10 4-team BCS’s. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - Frank the Tank - 11-04-2026 06:47 PM (11-04-2026 06:38 PM)Fresno Fanatic Wrote:(11-04-2026 05:32 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:(11-04-2026 11:44 AM)Akiraptor Wrote: What would be the point of this tournament? Is it to determine who's the second best G6 team? Does the victor get a "Congrats on almost making the real playoffs! You're the first loser!" trophy? Out of every idea I've heard being seriously proposed, this one is no doubt the worst. I'd rather have a conference championship game and no postseason at all than this farce. I’m willing to be proven wrong… but why is there this assumption that TV would magically pay more for any multi-game G6 consolation tournament? My strong belief is that a G6 vs. G6 game is going to be worth the same in the marketplace whether it’s a single bowl game or part of a consolation bracket. Plus, why wouldn’t the American and Pac-12 simply have a deal where their respective champs (or top teams that aren’t in the CFP) play each other directly in a bowl and/or series of bowls and cut out all of the lower value G6 leagues? That seems far more likely to me. The not-so-hidden secret in college sports is that the G6 are less aligned and try to one-up each other even more than the P4. Heck, that’s why the Pac-12 still exists as it looked at the other MWC schools as riff-raff. Meanwhile, the American has positioned itself as the top G6 league for conference realignment value. Those two leagues are less likely to agree to a structural setup where they are treated as equal to the other G6 leagues than even the Big Ten and SEC as compared to the ACC and Big 12. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - Schadenfreude - 11-04-2026 07:14 PM The MAC's commissioner has spoken of this concept before. It would be like the NIT. A key question has always been whether networks would pay more for it than they now pay for bowl games. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - JMURocks - 11-04-2026 07:26 PM (11-04-2026 06:47 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:(11-04-2026 06:38 PM)Fresno Fanatic Wrote:(11-04-2026 05:32 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:(11-04-2026 11:44 AM)Akiraptor Wrote: What would be the point of this tournament? Is it to determine who's the second best G6 team? Does the victor get a "Congrats on almost making the real playoffs! You're the first loser!" trophy? Out of every idea I've heard being seriously proposed, this one is no doubt the worst. I'd rather have a conference championship game and no postseason at all than this farce. Don't like these G6 only proposals, your thoughts make sense to me. Could see American and PAC holding their own contest or looking at alternatives. The question is what structure makes sense. Postseason games vs P4 opponents are still desirable, even if outside the CFP. Would rather play a 7-5 or 8-4 Wake, Duke or Pitt that misses the CFP than a MAC or CUSA conference winner. Not yet convinced all the remaining bowls fold, though perhaps smaller ones do. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - DavidSt - 11-04-2026 08:00 PM Some years, you may have 2 to 3 G6 inside the top 24. If it is the top 24 teams? We get the top G6 in and two of them get an at large. BCS did had two G5 teams at the time and the Big East schools that seemed not full P6 at the time had several schools in the Top 25. 2009 season rankings before the bowl games. AP #3 TCU MWC #5 Cincinnati Big East #7 Boise State WAC #16 BYU MWC #18 Pittsburgh Big East #19 West Virginia Big East #24 Utah MWC #25 Central Michigan Houston CUSA dropped out. Coaches Poll #3 TCU #4 Cincinnati #6 Boise State #14 BYU #16 Pittsburgh #17 West Virginia Big East #24 Utah #25 Houston BCS had Cincinnati at 3, TCU 4,Boise State 6, BYU 14, West Virginia 16, Pittsburgh 17 and Utah at 23. If it was the 24 team playoffs back then? 7 G6 teams. Big East was like a combined P5 and G5 teams. We need to treat each school equally again. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - Scoochpooch1 - 11-04-2026 08:14 PM (11-04-2026 11:44 AM)Akiraptor Wrote: What would be the point of this tournament? Is it to determine who's the second best G6 team? Does the victor get a "Congrats on almost making the real playoffs! You're the first loser!" trophy? Out of every idea I've heard being seriously proposed, this one is no doubt the worst. I'd rather have a conference championship game and no postseason at all than this farce. Using that logic, now explain bowl games. RE: Coaches vote on G6 playoff - bullet - 11-04-2026 08:34 PM (11-04-2026 06:47 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:(11-04-2026 06:38 PM)Fresno Fanatic Wrote:(11-04-2026 05:32 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:(11-04-2026 11:44 AM)Akiraptor Wrote: What would be the point of this tournament? Is it to determine who's the second best G6 team? Does the victor get a "Congrats on almost making the real playoffs! You're the first loser!" trophy? Out of every idea I've heard being seriously proposed, this one is no doubt the worst. I'd rather have a conference championship game and no postseason at all than this farce. That makes more sense. American vs. Pac other two will have more regional pairings: Sun Belt vs. MAC CUSA vs. MWC |