CSNbbs
W-L + Sagarin - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: W-L + Sagarin (/thread-1035084.html)



W-L + Sagarin - SouthEastAlaska - 11-01-2026 03:41 PM

Alright it's that time of year again, with the first CFP rankings coming out this Tuesday I am releasing my second annual W-L + Sagarin rankings. This rankings is just for fun, so try not to take it too seriously.

In my rankings teams Win/Loss records trump all, so you will see significant differences here in comparison to the AP top 25 and the upcoming CFP rankings. I hate the phrase "They pass the eye test". With so much subjectivity in the sport wins and losses should mean more than eye tests and my rankings reflect that alternate universe. Unfortunately, with so many schools competing for only 12 spots I have to use a ranking system to differentiate the schools with the same record, I choose to use the Sagarin rankings. I use Sagarin because I like the use of the Recent ranking, this gives schools the ability to improve and not be completely sunk based off early season lackluster play.

So below you will see the top 20 P4 schools (including ND) and the top 5 from the G6. I will attempt to update the rankings every week for the rest of the season. I hope the rankings are at least mildly thought provoking Lol. 04-cheers

http://sagarin.com/sports/cfsend.htm

P-4

1- Miami (8-0)
2- Utah (8-0)
3- UCLA (8-0)

4- Notre Dame (7-1)
5- Georgia (7-1)
6- Indiana (7-1)
7- Wake Forest (7-1)
8- Kentucky (7-1)
9- Texas Tech (7-1)
10- BYU (7-1)

11- LSU (6-2)
12- Ohio State (6-2)
13- Texas (6-2)
14- Alabama (6-2)
15- Ole Miss (6-2)
16- Tennessee (6-2)
17- Iowa (6-2)
18- Missouri (6-2)
19- USC (6-2)
20- Houston (6-2)

G-6

1- Boise State (7-1)
2- New Mexico (7-1)
3- Liberty (7-1)
4- UTSA (7-1)
5- Memphis (7-2)


RE: W-L + Sagarin - bullet - 11-01-2026 05:09 PM

I would argue that Strength of Record is much more important than pure W/L.

I don't really think ESPN's are great, but they are easy to find:
1. Miami 8-0
2. Kentucky 7-1
3. UCLA 8-0
4. Indiana 8-1
5. Utah 8-0
6. Georgia 7-1
7. Ole Miss 6-2
8. Alabama 6-2
9. Ohio St. 6-2
10. Texas 6-2
11. Wake Forest 7-1
12. BYU 7-1
13. Notre Dame 7-1
14. USC 7-2
15. Florida 5-3
16. LSU 6-2
17. Texas Tech 7-1
18. Tennessee 6-2
19. Boise St. 7-1
20. Missouri 6-2


RE: W-L + Sagarin - DavidSt - 11-01-2026 07:18 PM

Winning is more important than SOS because it skews more in favor of lousy teams than how they perform on the field.


RE: W-L + Sagarin - Crayton - 11-01-2026 07:32 PM

(11-01-2026 07:18 PM)DavidSt Wrote:  Winning is more important than SOS because it skews more in favor of lousy teams than how they perform on the field.

Bullet is referencing SOR which combines winning ‘and’ SOS.


RE: W-L + Sagarin - bullet - 11-01-2026 08:28 PM

(11-01-2026 07:32 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 07:18 PM)DavidSt Wrote:  Winning is more important than SOS because it skews more in favor of lousy teams than how they perform on the field.

Bullet is referencing SOR which combines winning ‘and’ SOS.

Sagarin used his ELO-Chess system for the BCS. To use an example from chess:

If you play 12 opponents rated 1600 and go 9-3, that is an equal result to playing 12 opponents rated 1800 and going 6-6. You should beat someone rated 200 points lower 75% of the time.

So if Boise goes 9-3, that is not the same as an SEC team going 9-3. And within the P4, IU went 11-1 with a really weak schedule in 2024. Their SOR may have been less than Alabama at 9-3. It was definitely less than a number of 10-2 teams.


RE: W-L + Sagarin - Wahoowa84 - 11-01-2026 08:43 PM

(11-01-2026 05:09 PM)bullet Wrote:  I would argue that Strength of Record is much more important than pure W/L.

I don't really think ESPN's are great, but they are easy to find:
1. Miami 8-0
2. Kentucky 7-1
3. UCLA 8-0
4. Indiana 8-1
5. Utah 8-0
6. Georgia 7-1
7. Ole Miss 6-2
8. Alabama 6-2
9. Ohio St. 6-2
10. Texas 6-2
11. Wake Forest 7-1
12. BYU 7-1
13. Notre Dame 7-1
14. USC 7-2
15. Florida 5-3
16. LSU 6-2
17. Texas Tech 7-1
18. Tennessee 6-2
19. Boise St. 7-1
20. Missouri 6-2

In theory, strength-of-record (SOR) should be better, but ESPN is too overt in their bias when creating advanced metrics.

5-3 Florida with a better SOR than 7-1 Texas Tech seems like the most questionable ranking. ESPN must overweight their biased SOS metric to get their desired result. Media needs lots of brand-on-brand games for their regular season ratings. Florida has a monster schedule this year, they beat a couple of strong teams while losing convincingly to three teams.