CSNbbs
Week 10 polls - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Week 10 polls (/thread-1035075.html)

Pages: 1 2


Week 10 polls - bullet - 11-01-2026 02:11 PM

Coaches poll is out.

I suspect the committe will continue to follow the polls and look at W/L to the exclusion of strenght of record.

Boise is 7-1 and ranked 21st. Their loss was to Oregon. New Mexico is 7-1 and ranked 25th. Their loss was to Oklahoma. Boise's best win is Memphis. New Mexico's is North Dakota St. Oregon meanwhile had the 31st most votes with a 5-3 record. They have wins over #17 USC, #21 Boise and #23 Northwestern along with 5-3 Nebraska. Their losses are to #5 UCLA and to Oklahoma St. 5-3 and ranked last week (now 33rd) and to Illinois 5-3. Oklahoma is 4-4 and got no votes.

Its hard to think about the schedules and actually rate Boise and New Mexico ahead of Oregon. But the pollsters do. And I suspect the CFP will as well. That is a real problem for the SEC and Big Ten going forward.

Poll: https://www.espn.com/college-football/rankings

Top 10
1 Miami 8-0 1818
2 Georgia 7-1 1719
3 Indiana 8-1 1597
4 Utah 8-0 1590
5 UCLA 8-0 1501
6 Notre Dame 7-1 1498
7 Kentucky 7-1 1344
8 BYU 7-1 1278
9 Alabama 6-2 1131
10 Ohio State 6-2 1101


RE: Week 10 polls - schmolik - 11-01-2026 02:21 PM

Picture Form:

AP:

[Image: HWD8QzbakAAtIYx?format=jpg&name=large]

Coaches:

[Image: HWDvwdibgAArwJ1?format=jpg&name=large]

Playoff:

9 Alabama (9 both polls) at 8 Kentucky (AP 8, Coaches 7) vs. 1 Miami (Peach)

12 Boise State (AP 20, Coaches 21) at 5 Notre Dame (AP 4, Coaches 6) vs. 4 Indiana (AP 6, Coaches 3) (Rose)

10 Texas (AP 10, Coaches 11) at 7 BYU (AP 7, Coaches 8) vs. 2 Georgia (Cotton)

11 Ohio State (AP 11, Coaches 10) at 6 UCLA (5 both polls) vs. 3 (AP 3, Coaches 4) Utah (Fiesta)


RE: Week 10 polls - bullet - 11-01-2026 02:35 PM

Both polls have New Mexico and Boise outside the P4 plus Notre Dame and 5 Big 12 schools (Utah, BYU, Texas Tech, Houston, Arizona). The coaches have 8 SEC, 6 Big Ten and 3 ACC. The writers have 10 SEC, 5 Big Ten and 2 ACC. AP has 5-3 South Carolina and Florida while coaches has 6-2 Northwestern and SMU.


RE: Week 10 polls - Just Joe - 11-01-2026 02:36 PM

The MW is giving New Mexico a lot more to work with than the Pac 12 is to Boise.

MW has 5 decent teams; New Mexico has a win over one and closes with the other three. Pretty good chance that if they win out (not a guarantee) they’ll play at worst a 9-3 team in a rematch of one of those.

The Pac 12 might literally have only two teams that even make a bowl (Boise & OSU). Boise giving OSU a 4th loss isn’t going to impress nor is beating them in a rematch for the conference championship. And the Pac 12 flex game isn’t going to do them any favors either.

So Boise has a much easier road but if UNM wins out it’s theirs for the taking IMO.


RE: Week 10 polls - Kittonhead - 11-01-2026 02:45 PM

(11-01-2026 02:36 PM)Just Joe Wrote:  The MW is giving New Mexico a lot more to work with than the Pac 12 is to Boise.

MW has 5 decent teams; New Mexico has a win over one and closes with the other three. Pretty good chance that if they win out (not a guarantee) they’ll play at worst a 9-3 team in a rematch of one of those.

The Pac 12 might literally have only two teams that even make a bowl (Boise & OSU). Boise giving OSU a 4th loss isn’t going to impress nor is beating them in a rematch for the conference championship. And the Pac 12 flex game isn’t going to do them any favors either.

So Boise has a much easier road but if UNM wins out it’s theirs for the taking IMO.

No.


RE: Week 10 polls - bryanw1995 - 11-01-2026 02:48 PM

(11-01-2026 02:45 PM)Kittonhead Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 02:36 PM)Just Joe Wrote:  The MW is giving New Mexico a lot more to work with than the Pac 12 is to Boise.

MW has 5 decent teams; New Mexico has a win over one and closes with the other three. Pretty good chance that if they win out (not a guarantee) they’ll play at worst a 9-3 team in a rematch of one of those.

The Pac 12 might literally have only two teams that even make a bowl (Boise & OSU). Boise giving OSU a 4th loss isn’t going to impress nor is beating them in a rematch for the conference championship. And the Pac 12 flex game isn’t going to do them any favors either.

So Boise has a much easier road but if UNM wins out it’s theirs for the taking IMO.

No.

Strong argument. Um, care to expand on that? Just Joe was pretty persuasive there.


RE: Week 10 polls - Just Joe - 11-01-2026 02:52 PM

Worth noting this is UNM’s first appearance in the AP poll since… EVER. I knew it had been awhile but wouldn’t have guessed that.

First Coaches Poll appearance since Franchione’s last season in 1997 btw.


RE: Week 10 polls - bryanw1995 - 11-01-2026 02:57 PM

Worth noting that Big 12 and B1G have nearly identical polls this week. I wonder if the CFP Committee will agree?


RE: Week 10 polls - Kittonhead - 11-01-2026 03:08 PM

(11-01-2026 02:48 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 02:45 PM)Kittonhead Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 02:36 PM)Just Joe Wrote:  The MW is giving New Mexico a lot more to work with than the Pac 12 is to Boise.

MW has 5 decent teams; New Mexico has a win over one and closes with the other three. Pretty good chance that if they win out (not a guarantee) they’ll play at worst a 9-3 team in a rematch of one of those.

The Pac 12 might literally have only two teams that even make a bowl (Boise & OSU). Boise giving OSU a 4th loss isn’t going to impress nor is beating them in a rematch for the conference championship. And the Pac 12 flex game isn’t going to do them any favors either.

So Boise has a much easier road but if UNM wins out it’s theirs for the taking IMO.

No.

Strong argument. Um, care to expand on that? Just Joe was pretty persuasive there.

New Mexico doesn't have enough meat on its remaining schedule to pass Boise St if they both win out. I've been tracking the Top 6 of the Sagarins this year and three of those teams are in the PAC. Both played their P4 tough but Oregon was ranked #2 and Oklahoma #24 when those games were played giving Boise a higher quality loss.


Sagarin's updated for week of 10/31.

#40 7-1 Boise St. (#60 Oregon State)
#57 7-1 New Mexico (#89 Air Force)
#59 7-1 *Liberty (#121 Western Kentucky)
#60 5-3 Oregon State (@ #40 Boise St)
#65 7-1 UTSA (#71 North Texas)
#66 4-4 Texas St (@ #60 Oregon St)

Even UTSA has a better inside track than New Mexico IF they continue to win out.


RE: Week 10 polls - Just Joe - 11-01-2026 03:33 PM

(11-01-2026 03:08 PM)Kittonhead Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 02:48 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 02:45 PM)Kittonhead Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 02:36 PM)Just Joe Wrote:  The MW is giving New Mexico a lot more to work with than the Pac 12 is to Boise.

MW has 5 decent teams; New Mexico has a win over one and closes with the other three. Pretty good chance that if they win out (not a guarantee) they’ll play at worst a 9-3 team in a rematch of one of those.

The Pac 12 might literally have only two teams that even make a bowl (Boise & OSU). Boise giving OSU a 4th loss isn’t going to impress nor is beating them in a rematch for the conference championship. And the Pac 12 flex game isn’t going to do them any favors either.

So Boise has a much easier road but if UNM wins out it’s theirs for the taking IMO.

No.

Strong argument. Um, care to expand on that? Just Joe was pretty persuasive there.

New Mexico doesn't have enough meat on its remaining schedule to pass Boise St if they both win out. I've been tracking the Top 6 of the Sagarins this year and three of those teams are in the PAC. Both played their P4 tough but Oregon was ranked #2 and Oklahoma #24 when those games were played giving Boise a higher quality loss.


Sagarin's updated for week of 10/31.

#40 7-1 Boise St. (#60 Oregon State)
#57 7-1 New Mexico (#89 Air Force)
#59 7-1 *Liberty (#121 Western Kentucky)
#60 5-3 Oregon State (@ #40 Boise St)
#65 7-1 UTSA (#71 North Texas)
#66 4-4 Texas St (@ #60 Oregon St)

Even UTSA has a better inside track than New Mexico IF they continue to win out.

All the Sagarins in the world are pretty meaningless when it’s a human committee.

Neither P4 loss is good at this point. In fact Boise’s still probably getting an artificial boost from that “good loss” at Oregon that preceded Oregon losing three times (and counting?)

UNM is close to Boise right now and like I said has the best part of their schedule to close while Boise’s facing the graveyard that is the zombie Pac.

We’ll see how the first CFP has them, my guess is something like Boise at 21 and New Mexico at 25.


RE: Week 10 polls - PicksUp - 11-01-2026 03:57 PM

Graveyard? Come on. The bottom 5 teams in the MW are horrible, as bad or worse than Washington St. Wyoming is not that good. New Mexico has kept winning but has looked lackluster the past couple weeks. They are going to have to play a lot better if they want to stay unbeaten. Same with Boise, they could still slip up.

UTSA is being overlooked by some. They have to keep winning but they could easily overtake New Mexico. If Boise and New Mexico drop another game each even North Texas and Liberty have a shot.


RE: Week 10 polls - DavidSt - 11-01-2026 04:01 PM

It might come down between Boise State and UTSA if UTSA wins out. UTSA could face Memphis in the conference championship game. If UTSA blows Memphis out? They have a much better argument to be in the playoffs over Boise.


RE: Week 10 polls - DavidSt - 11-01-2026 04:13 PM

(11-01-2026 03:57 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Graveyard? Come on. The bottom 5 teams in the MW are horrible, as bad or worse than Washington St. Wyoming is not that good. New Mexico has kept winning but has looked lackluster the past couple weeks. They are going to have to play a lot better if they want to stay unbeaten. Same with Boise, they could still slip up.

UTSA is being overlooked by some. They have to keep winning but they could easily overtake New Mexico. If Boise and New Mexico drop another game each even North Texas and Liberty have a shot.

Fresno State have been terrible.


RE: Week 10 polls - Gemofthehills - 11-01-2026 04:19 PM

MWC looks better than the PAC. But Im not a computer.


RE: Week 10 polls - bryanw1995 - 11-01-2026 04:26 PM

(11-01-2026 03:57 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Graveyard? Come on. The bottom 5 teams in the MW are horrible, as bad or worse than Washington St. Wyoming is not that good. New Mexico has kept winning but has looked lackluster the past couple weeks. They are going to have to play a lot better if they want to stay unbeaten. Same with Boise, they could still slip up.

UTSA is being overlooked by some. They have to keep winning but they could easily overtake New Mexico. If Boise and New Mexico drop another game each even North Texas and Liberty have a shot.

Where I think it gets interesting is if everyone loses at least one more, then we get to choose amongst 2 loss champs in the MWC, Pac 12 and American vs 1 loss champs in CUSA, SBC and MAC. Not all that hard to imagine that scenario, either.


RE: Week 10 polls - bullet - 11-01-2026 04:53 PM

(11-01-2026 04:26 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 03:57 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Graveyard? Come on. The bottom 5 teams in the MW are horrible, as bad or worse than Washington St. Wyoming is not that good. New Mexico has kept winning but has looked lackluster the past couple weeks. They are going to have to play a lot better if they want to stay unbeaten. Same with Boise, they could still slip up.

UTSA is being overlooked by some. They have to keep winning but they could easily overtake New Mexico. If Boise and New Mexico drop another game each even North Texas and Liberty have a shot.

Where I think it gets interesting is if everyone loses at least one more, then we get to choose amongst 2 loss champs in the MWC, Pac 12 and American vs 1 loss champs in CUSA, SBC and MAC. Not all that hard to imagine that scenario, either.

Its REALLY hard to imagine. I guess Toledo, WMU, JMU or Louisiana Tech could get a forfet win to get back to 1 loss...04-cheers


RE: Week 10 polls - Just Joe - 11-01-2026 10:07 PM

(11-01-2026 03:57 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Graveyard? Come on. The bottom 5 teams in the MW are horrible, as bad or worse than Washington St. Wyoming is not that good. New Mexico has kept winning but has looked lackluster the past couple weeks. They are going to have to play a lot better if they want to stay unbeaten. Same with Boise, they could still slip up.

UTSA is being overlooked by some. They have to keep winning but they could easily overtake New Mexico. If Boise and New Mexico drop another game each even North Texas and Liberty have a shot.

MW has 5 decent to good teams at the start of November. Pac 12 has 2 in an 8 team conference. 75% of a conference being bad is a lot more noticeable to me than half. It’s the nature of what the Pac crew signed up for being a small conference. Boise’s best bet to impress anyone down the stretch was OSU having only two losses when they play and that’s not happening. I don’t think either conference has a great or exceptional team; I’ve watched Boise screw around and almost lose to South Dakota and Texas St.

You’re right about UTSA. If they keep winning it could easily be a toss up between them and either Boise or UNM.


RE: Week 10 polls - HawaiiMongoose - 11-02-2026 01:34 AM

(11-01-2026 10:07 PM)Just Joe Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 03:57 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Graveyard? Come on. The bottom 5 teams in the MW are horrible, as bad or worse than Washington St. Wyoming is not that good. New Mexico has kept winning but has looked lackluster the past couple weeks. They are going to have to play a lot better if they want to stay unbeaten. Same with Boise, they could still slip up.

UTSA is being overlooked by some. They have to keep winning but they could easily overtake New Mexico. If Boise and New Mexico drop another game each even North Texas and Liberty have a shot.

MW has 5 decent to good teams at the start of November. Pac 12 has 2 in an 8 team conference. 75% of a conference being bad is a lot more noticeable to me than half. It’s the nature of what the Pac crew signed up for being a small conference. Boise’s best bet to impress anyone down the stretch was OSU having only two losses when they play and that’s not happening. I don’t think either conference has a great or exceptional team; I’ve watched Boise screw around and almost lose to South Dakota and Texas St.

You’re right about UTSA. If they keep winning it could easily be a toss up between them and either Boise or UNM.

I agree with all of this, but the national perception of the MWC will change radically if or when New Mexico slips up. The Lobos have a challenging schedule ahead with a road game at Wyoming and home games against UNLV and Air Force. They’ll be very fortunate to win out.


RE: Week 10 polls - C2__ - 11-02-2026 02:29 AM

(11-01-2026 02:52 PM)Just Joe Wrote:  Worth noting this is UNM’s first appearance in the AP poll since… EVER. I knew it had been awhile but wouldn’t have guessed that.

First Coaches Poll appearance since Franchione’s last season in 1997 btw.

My brother redshirted at New Mexico. I knew they didn't have a rich history but geez, that's horrid.


RE: Week 10 polls - HP-TBDPITL - 11-02-2026 09:22 AM

Pollsters are struggling with all of this. Now that its November they are pretty much forced to rank New Mexico because their defense keeps winning games for them.

What's even more egregious is Wake Forest at #14. Since beating a ranked Louisville team (#16 at the time) they have outscored their last 4 ACC opponents 187-31. Yet they sit at #14 in the AP poll. Their only loss is to #1 Miami back in week 3. If they were just winning games I might could argue holding them outside the Top 10. But no, they are demolishing ACC opponents at home and on the road.

Maybe its time to show them on tv...give them a good slot. After an FCS game-they play @ SMU on Nov 14th. Lets see what the networks do.