CSNbbs
Realignment Game - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Realignment Game (/thread-1034977.html)

Pages: 1 2


Realignment Game - schmolik - 10-30-2026 02:07 PM

The perfect game for this board!



https://realign.cfbselect.com/

"Rivalries count for 45% (the big ones are worth more), travel for 30%, and parity for 25%. Parity compares each conference’s average program strength, based on roughly the last five years of SP+, and rewards maps where no league runs away from the rest"

"The real 2026 map grades a C: 44 of 79 rivalries kept, 759-mile average trip, parity D."

I did one and got a B-: 47 of 79 rivalries, 504 mile average trip, parity D.

My guess is it's going to be hard to keep all of the rivalries together without sacrificing parity.


RE: Realignment Game - Garrettabc - 10-30-2026 02:17 PM

Kinda cool, wish they'd allow you to break them up into divisions.


RE: Realignment Game - Crayton - 10-30-2026 02:29 PM

“Parity” is an odd metric. I would have expected parity to measure internal balance rather than balance between conferences.


RE: Realignment Game - goofus - 10-30-2026 02:38 PM

This is not how you play the realignment game. In realignment old rivals are left behind in the endless pursuit to end up in a better conference. The winners are the ones that move up and the losers are the ones left behind.


RE: Realignment Game - thrill_house - 10-30-2026 04:17 PM

I got it up to 93.16 / 100 while still maintaining the 10 conferences

[Image: 46e09c81-190a-44ba-8317-abc8698c7a67.png]


RE: Realignment Game - schmolik - 10-30-2026 05:02 PM

Of the 79 rivalries two of them are Cincinnati-Miami (Ohio) and LSU-Tulane. I'd think those would be of low priority although thrill_house did keep them together:)


RE: Realignment Game - thrill_house - 10-30-2026 05:42 PM

Yeah, that's the biggest problem with these guys' formula/grading scale. It puts way too much weight on historical "rivalries" and not enough on competitive games.

Ohio State, Notre Dame, and Michigan protect their "rivals" but have 9 warm-up games each year in this alignment.

I mean, that's basically what we have nowadays with the Big Ten / ND's malarkey, but instead of winning by 35 points/week (this alignment), they're only winning by 21 points/week (current alignment).


RE: Realignment Game - schmolik - 10-30-2026 06:30 PM

The other issue I have is one of their criteria is all conferences have to be balanced. For that to happen you'd have to evenly distribute the top teams as well as the bottom teams which leads to imbalance in conferences. I think having some "top" conferences and some "bottom" conferences lead to better games.


RE: Realignment Game - multicampus - 10-30-2026 06:32 PM

I wish there were a way to create two leagues or to relegate teams.


RE: Realignment Game - Blust3 - 10-30-2026 06:37 PM

Restore SWC, Big East and PAC12. Cut the super sized B1G and SEC.


RE: Realignment Game - Scoochpooch1 - 10-30-2026 07:49 PM

Pretty fun. Ran 2 scenarios.

1991 6x10 + 12. 16 team playoff, 7 autobids, 9 at large. 7 Conference winners get autobids but arent guaranteed 1-7 seeds nor home field advantage. G6 forms own subdivision.

2030 24x3 24 team playoff. Number of entries per conference based on coefficient like Champions League. 10-10-4.
16 team playoff would be 7-6-3 same system as CL. G6 forms own subdivision.


RE: Realignment Game - schmolik - 10-30-2026 10:09 PM

Here are the 79 rivalries they listed:

Big Ten:
Ohio State-Michigan
USC-UCLA
Minnesota-Wisconsin
Indiana-Purdue
Michigan-Michigan State
Oregon-Washington
Iowa-Minnesota
Iowa-Nebraska
Wisconsin-Iowa

SEC:
Alabama-Auburn
Texas-Oklahoma
Georgia-Florida
Texas-Texas A&M
Mississippi-Mississippi State
Alabama-Tennessee
Auburn-Georgia
Alabama-LSU
Texas-Arkansas
Arkansas-LSU
Mississippi-LSU
Tennessee-Kentucky
Tennessee-Vanderbilt

ACC:
Florida State-Miami
Cal-Stanford
Virginia-Virginia Tech
North Carolina-NC State
North Carolina-Duke

Big 12:
Kansas-Kansas State
Utah-BYU
Arizona-Arizona State
Baylor-TCU
Utah-Colorado

Pac 12:
Boise State-Fresno State
San Diego State-Fresno State

MWC:
Nevada-UNLV

AAC:
Army-Navy

MAC:
Toledo-Bowling Green
Central Michigan-Western Michigan
Akron-Kent State
Miami Ohio-Ohio

Sun Belt:
Troy-South Alabama
Appalachian State-Georgia Southern
James Madison-Old Dominion

CUSA:
Middle Tennessee-Western Kentucky

Not Currently In a Conference:
Florida-Florida State
Georgia-Georgia Tech
Clemson-South Carolina
Oregon-Oregon State
Washington-Washington State
Oklahoma-Oklahoma State
USC-Notre Dame
Iowa-Iowa State
Pittsburgh-West Virginia
Missouri-Kansas
Louisville-Kentucky
Nebraska-Oklahoma
Florida-Miami
Penn State-Pittsburgh
UCF-South Florida
Cincinnati-Louisville
Cincinnati-Miami OH
SMU-TCU
Houston-Rice
New Mexico St-New Mexico
Air Force-Army
Air Force-Navy
Colorado State-Wyoming
San Jose State-Fresno State
Navy-Notre Dame
Michigan-Notre Dame
Stanford-Notre Dame
Boston College-Notre Dame
Nebraska-Colorado
Tulane-LSU
BYU-Utah State
Utah-Utah State
West Virginia-Virginia Tech
West Virginia-Marshall
Texas Tech-Texas

Which non conference rivalries do you think should be prioritized?
Which rivalries here do you think are pointless?
Which rivalries not listed do you think should be here?

I was able to protect 65 of 79 of these. The 14 that wound up separated:
USC vs. Notre Dame
Pitt vs. West Virginia
Cincinnati vs. Louisville
Cincinnati vs. Miami (OH)
Navy vs. Notre Dame
Stanford vs. Notre Dame
Boston College vs. Notre Dame
Iowa vs. Nebraska
Arkansas vs. LSU
Tulane vs. LSU
BYU vs. Utah St
Utah vs. Utah St
Utah vs. Colorado
West Virginia vs. Marshall

I put Notre Dame in the Big Ten so they got their Michigan rivalry protected. Nebraska lost Iowa but gained both Oklahoma and Colorado in a new Big 12. Arkansas went with Texas/Oklahoma to the Big 12 and lost LSU but kept Texas. Pittsburgh got Penn State as part of the Big Ten.


RE: Realignment Game - schmolik - 11-02-2026 07:52 AM

Here's a picture of my current conferences.

[Image: my-custom-conferences-revised-v0-m1w7pv6...a3ba5b83e0]

BTW: Sim champ: Illinois was just a coincidence if you believe it (and I'm sure you don't)


RE: Realignment Game - ccd494 - 11-02-2026 08:22 AM

Is anyone else unable to click to change the name of the middle or right column of conferences?


RE: Realignment Game - Scoochpooch1 - 11-02-2026 09:32 AM

(11-02-2026 07:52 AM)schmolik Wrote:  Here's a picture of my current conferences.

[Image: my-custom-conferences-revised-v0-m1w7pv6...a3ba5b83e0]

BTW: Sim champ: Illinois was just a coincidence if you believe it (and I'm sure you don't)

Haha, I was going to ask you how many times you had to simulate to get Illinois.


RE: Realignment Game - ccd494 - 11-02-2026 09:35 AM

It's perfect: https://realign.cfbselect.com/?m=zTZFNj4IwEIb_CullLzRpO6W0nBZqSTz4ET-yB8OhIq4cRKO4Hoz_fQdF44SZvn1mOlPgRv5IwkPiSUIYsKcJwRjAmnMeoQvOpeJKSokhQlMKHSTGSEoQSoBAA9BCxdRoHQPVVGsNFM28w1OgjL33lKLj6iVKaTquKdWme9aKhKQkyWpF5s6iHsjUAApWhCuS1b_BomoQ8zzKsugDa4RWcyZcD-eHS7u7VucWEyqDPGV9YupLygVSxyJh4p6mtpvGpY7i9KOt848GjsUpz3tuD_u9bzbVidYNLXd1tcUKmacwMH3FyC1mk8dcmYtXOzsZ527mxtYFyzlCojPu4NV0dLg0ra-b4Od5ZbAmfb_3EKcdKwxNe8ZcZiyzeHFeFCFp8e8N269zMK1O26rszu4QfZflRhqJuyNJbo-qY7e74rfloQihuN__AQ

FBS cut down to 105. Ten 10 team conferences. 5 independents: the Commander-in-Chief schools, Notre Dame, and Vanderbilt.

The SEC is back to pre-Arkansas expansion.
The Big Ten is back to pre-Penn State expansion.
We've resurrected the Big 8 and added Utah/BYU.
We've resurrected the SWC, booted Rice, and added UTSA and North Texas.
The PAC is back to 10, pre-Utah/Colorado expansion.
The ACC makes sense again.
The Big East resurrects Northeastern football (plus old friend Miami).
And we've got three mid-majors in the Mountain West/Metro/Conference USA.

The MAC (minus escapees Toledo and Ohio) and the majority of the recent additions are down to FCS, along with "we don't invest in our program" schools like Rice, UTEP and Temple.

Side benefit: FCS is going to be AWESOME again.


RE: Realignment Game - ccd494 - 11-02-2026 09:40 AM

Hey I figured out how to post images. Huge day.

[Image: perfect-conferences.png]

Ignore the playoff information. We wouldn't have one.


RE: Realignment Game - DFW HOYA - 11-02-2026 10:04 AM

Big East football:
Army
Boston College
Connecticut
Georgetown
Navy
Pittsburgh
Rutgers
St. John's
Syracuse
Villanova


RE: Realignment Game - tf8693 - 11-02-2026 10:27 AM

(10-30-2026 10:09 PM)schmolik Wrote:  Here are the 79 rivalries they listed:

Big Ten:
Ohio State-Michigan
USC-UCLA
Minnesota-Wisconsin
Indiana-Purdue
Michigan-Michigan State
Oregon-Washington
Iowa-Minnesota
Iowa-Nebraska
Wisconsin-Iowa

SEC:
Alabama-Auburn
Texas-Oklahoma
Georgia-Florida
Texas-Texas A&M
Mississippi-Mississippi State
Alabama-Tennessee
Auburn-Georgia
Alabama-LSU
Texas-Arkansas
Arkansas-LSU
Mississippi-LSU
Tennessee-Kentucky
Tennessee-Vanderbilt

ACC:
Florida State-Miami
Cal-Stanford
Virginia-Virginia Tech
North Carolina-NC State
North Carolina-Duke

Big 12:
Kansas-Kansas State
Utah-BYU
Arizona-Arizona State
Baylor-TCU
Utah-Colorado

Pac 12:
Boise State-Fresno State
San Diego State-Fresno State

MWC:
Nevada-UNLV

AAC:
Army-Navy

MAC:
Toledo-Bowling Green
Central Michigan-Western Michigan
Akron-Kent State
Miami Ohio-Ohio

Sun Belt:
Troy-South Alabama
Appalachian State-Georgia Southern
James Madison-Old Dominion

CUSA:
Middle Tennessee-Western Kentucky

Not Currently In a Conference:
Florida-Florida State
Georgia-Georgia Tech
Clemson-South Carolina
Oregon-Oregon State
Washington-Washington State
Oklahoma-Oklahoma State
USC-Notre Dame
Iowa-Iowa State
Pittsburgh-West Virginia
Missouri-Kansas
Louisville-Kentucky
Nebraska-Oklahoma
Florida-Miami
Penn State-Pittsburgh
UCF-South Florida
Cincinnati-Louisville
Cincinnati-Miami OH
SMU-TCU
Houston-Rice
New Mexico St-New Mexico
Air Force-Army
Air Force-Navy
Colorado State-Wyoming
San Jose State-Fresno State
Navy-Notre Dame
Michigan-Notre Dame
Stanford-Notre Dame
Boston College-Notre Dame
Nebraska-Colorado
Tulane-LSU
BYU-Utah State
Utah-Utah State
West Virginia-Virginia Tech
West Virginia-Marshall
Texas Tech-Texas

Which non conference rivalries do you think should be prioritized?
Which rivalries here do you think are pointless?
Which rivalries not listed do you think should be here?

I was able to protect 65 of 79 of these. The 14 that wound up separated:
USC vs. Notre Dame
Pitt vs. West Virginia
Cincinnati vs. Louisville
Cincinnati vs. Miami (OH)
Navy vs. Notre Dame
Stanford vs. Notre Dame
Boston College vs. Notre Dame
Iowa vs. Nebraska
Arkansas vs. LSU
Tulane vs. LSU
BYU vs. Utah St
Utah vs. Utah St
Utah vs. Colorado
West Virginia vs. Marshall

I put Notre Dame in the Big Ten so they got their Michigan rivalry protected. Nebraska lost Iowa but gained both Oklahoma and Colorado in a new Big 12. Arkansas went with Texas/Oklahoma to the Big 12 and lost LSU but kept Texas. Pittsburgh got Penn State as part of the Big Ten.

So, according to this game, ND has four rivalry games.

USC: No argument here, that's a rivalry.

Michigan: Has all the trappings of a rivalry, except for one thing: only two meetings between 1910 and 1977, inclusive. I have Michigan in my *shoulda woulda coulda* category, along with Miami and Penn State.

Navy: Our *debt of honor* game, but a rivalry? The series is far too lopsided to be a rivalry, at least IMHO.

Stanford: Are you kidding me? 39 games all-time, only two prior to 1988. Further, if the series went away tomorrow, I doubt anyone at ND would care all that much (and I suspect Stanford is similar in that regard). Definitely not a rivalry.


RE: Realignment Game - TerryD - 11-02-2026 11:37 AM

(11-02-2026 10:27 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(10-30-2026 10:09 PM)schmolik Wrote:  Here are the 79 rivalries they listed:

Big Ten:
Ohio State-Michigan
USC-UCLA
Minnesota-Wisconsin
Indiana-Purdue
Michigan-Michigan State
Oregon-Washington
Iowa-Minnesota
Iowa-Nebraska
Wisconsin-Iowa

SEC:
Alabama-Auburn
Texas-Oklahoma
Georgia-Florida
Texas-Texas A&M
Mississippi-Mississippi State
Alabama-Tennessee
Auburn-Georgia
Alabama-LSU
Texas-Arkansas
Arkansas-LSU
Mississippi-LSU
Tennessee-Kentucky
Tennessee-Vanderbilt

ACC:
Florida State-Miami
Cal-Stanford
Virginia-Virginia Tech
North Carolina-NC State
North Carolina-Duke

Big 12:
Kansas-Kansas State
Utah-BYU
Arizona-Arizona State
Baylor-TCU
Utah-Colorado

Pac 12:
Boise State-Fresno State
San Diego State-Fresno State

MWC:
Nevada-UNLV

AAC:
Army-Navy

MAC:
Toledo-Bowling Green
Central Michigan-Western Michigan
Akron-Kent State
Miami Ohio-Ohio

Sun Belt:
Troy-South Alabama
Appalachian State-Georgia Southern
James Madison-Old Dominion

CUSA:
Middle Tennessee-Western Kentucky

Not Currently In a Conference:
Florida-Florida State
Georgia-Georgia Tech
Clemson-South Carolina
Oregon-Oregon State
Washington-Washington State
Oklahoma-Oklahoma State
USC-Notre Dame
Iowa-Iowa State
Pittsburgh-West Virginia
Missouri-Kansas
Louisville-Kentucky
Nebraska-Oklahoma
Florida-Miami
Penn State-Pittsburgh
UCF-South Florida
Cincinnati-Louisville
Cincinnati-Miami OH
SMU-TCU
Houston-Rice
New Mexico St-New Mexico
Air Force-Army
Air Force-Navy
Colorado State-Wyoming
San Jose State-Fresno State
Navy-Notre Dame
Michigan-Notre Dame
Stanford-Notre Dame
Boston College-Notre Dame
Nebraska-Colorado
Tulane-LSU
BYU-Utah State
Utah-Utah State
West Virginia-Virginia Tech
West Virginia-Marshall
Texas Tech-Texas

Which non conference rivalries do you think should be prioritized?
Which rivalries here do you think are pointless?
Which rivalries not listed do you think should be here?

I was able to protect 65 of 79 of these. The 14 that wound up separated:
USC vs. Notre Dame
Pitt vs. West Virginia
Cincinnati vs. Louisville
Cincinnati vs. Miami (OH)
Navy vs. Notre Dame
Stanford vs. Notre Dame
Boston College vs. Notre Dame
Iowa vs. Nebraska
Arkansas vs. LSU
Tulane vs. LSU
BYU vs. Utah St
Utah vs. Utah St
Utah vs. Colorado
West Virginia vs. Marshall

I put Notre Dame in the Big Ten so they got their Michigan rivalry protected. Nebraska lost Iowa but gained both Oklahoma and Colorado in a new Big 12. Arkansas went with Texas/Oklahoma to the Big 12 and lost LSU but kept Texas. Pittsburgh got Penn State as part of the Big Ten.

So, according to this game, ND has four rivalry games.

USC: No argument here, that's a rivalry.

Michigan: Has all the trappings of a rivalry, except for one thing: only two meetings between 1910 and 1977, inclusive. I have Michigan in my *shoulda woulda coulda* category, along with Miami and Penn State.

Navy: Our *debt of honor* game, but a rivalry? The series is far too lopsided to be a rivalry, at least IMHO.

Stanford: Are you kidding me? 39 games all-time, only two prior to 1988. Further, if the series went away tomorrow, I doubt anyone at ND would care all that much (and I suspect Stanford is similar in that regard). Definitely not a rivalry.

It is a strange "rivalry" to have no games scheduled between 2019 and 2033, plus only 2 games (1942; 1943) played between 1910 and 1978.

1978-2019 is a Johnny Come Lately "rivalry" to me and seems the anomaly, not the norm, between the two schools over a long period of time.

Boo hiss on placing ND into the Big Ten to "protect" a "rivalry" where neither school seems to want to play the other.

(Navy and Stanford are also not "rivals" as far as ND is concerned)