CSNbbs
CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week (/thread-1034873.html)

Pages: 1 2


CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Oklahoma Guy - 10-28-2026 02:28 PM

BYU 28, Notre Dame 24
UCF 39, BYU 31
Cincinnati 37, Texas Tech 24


"All week, the conversation has focused on the once-in-a-lifetime opportunity facing the Big-12. Had the league powers taken care of business, the league would have had a realistic shot at three College Football Playoff teams. After a chaotic Week 8, that path is diminished."

I agree and I disagree. In the present structure of a 12 team National Playoff, it was a disastrous weekend for the Big-12.

But in the longer run...and with the 24 team playoff, the past weekend may prove to be a positive for the Big-12. Can the B-12 conference grow in football strength? Can the Big-12 provide the platform and exposure for new and existing teams to grow in strength?

Who knows? But I would argue that BYU beating Notre Dame, that UCF beating BYU, by Cincinnati beating Texas Tech, and by Houston being ranked #18, this "disastrous" weekend may have provided an indication of growing strength of Big-12 teams. It will be interesting to watch this play out. The SEC and B1G have been raiders of strong football teams. For the Big-12, we will have to grow our own. This weekend provided that goal may not be out of reach.

While the 4-Corner schools have deservedly received a lot of public attention, it was the addition of Cincinnati, UCF, Houston, and BYU that was the key to Big-12's recent success. These four schools have the population base requisite to building a strong football program.


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Fighting Muskie - 10-28-2026 03:25 PM

(10-28-2026 02:33 PM)Oklahoma Guy Wrote:  
(10-28-2026 02:28 PM)Oklahoma Guy Wrote:  BYU 28, Notre Dame 24
UCF 39, BYU 31
Cincinnati 37, Texas Tech 24


"All week, the conversation has focused on the once-in-a-lifetime opportunity facing the Big-12. Had the league powers taken care of business, the league would have had a realistic shot at three College Football Playoff teams. After a chaotic Week 8, that path is diminished."

I agree and I disagree. In the present structure of a 12 team National Playoff, it was a disastrous weekend for the Big-12.

But in the longer run...and with the 24 team playoff, the past weekend may prove to be a positive for the Big-12. Can the B-12 conference grow in football strength? Can the Big-12 provide the platform and exposure for new and existing teams to grow in strength?

Who knows? But I would argue that BYU beating Notre Dame, that UCF beating BYU, by Cincinnati beating Texas Tech, and by Houston being ranked #18, this "disastrous" weekend may have provided an indication of growing strength of Big-12 teams. It will be interesting to watch this play out. The SEC and B1G have been raiders of strong football teams. For the Big-12, we will have to grow our own. This weekend provided that goal may not be out of reach.

While the 4-Corner schools have deservedly received a lot of public attention, it was the addition of Cincinnati, UCF, Houston, and BYU that was the key to Big-12's recent success. These four schools have the population base requisite to building a strong football program.

Moderators, please delete this double post. The cat walked over my key board and distracted me.

Your cat just got a lifetime ban lol.


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Bear Catlett - 10-28-2026 04:33 PM

The B12 shouldn’t have to apologize for not having any chumps in their league like the B1G, SEC and ACC do.


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - The Beaver - 10-28-2026 05:49 PM

(10-28-2026 04:33 PM)Bear Catlett Wrote:  The B12 shouldn’t have to apologize for not having any chumps in their league like the B1G, SEC and ACC do.

No champs either. What is the last current member national champion? The ridiculous 92 Colorado squad that should have went to GT or the even worse 84 BYU squad who played a single ranked opponent all year (a Pitt squad who ended up 3-7-1.)


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Dr Dawgma III - 10-28-2026 05:58 PM

(10-28-2026 04:33 PM)Bear Catlett Wrote:  The B12 shouldn’t have to apologize for not having any chumps in their league like the B1G, SEC and ACC do.

Everyone in the ACC has a conference win.

Thanks to freaking Syracuse


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - ProfessorBooty - 10-28-2026 06:04 PM

(10-28-2026 03:25 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(10-28-2026 02:33 PM)Oklahoma Guy Wrote:  
(10-28-2026 02:28 PM)Oklahoma Guy Wrote:  BYU 28, Notre Dame 24
UCF 39, BYU 31
Cincinnati 37, Texas Tech 24


"All week, the conversation has focused on the once-in-a-lifetime opportunity facing the Big-12. Had the league powers taken care of business, the league would have had a realistic shot at three College Football Playoff teams. After a chaotic Week 8, that path is diminished."

I agree and I disagree. In the present structure of a 12 team National Playoff, it was a disastrous weekend for the Big-12.

But in the longer run...and with the 24 team playoff, the past weekend may prove to be a positive for the Big-12. Can the B-12 conference grow in football strength? Can the Big-12 provide the platform and exposure for new and existing teams to grow in strength?

Who knows? But I would argue that BYU beating Notre Dame, that UCF beating BYU, by Cincinnati beating Texas Tech, and by Houston being ranked #18, this "disastrous" weekend may have provided an indication of growing strength of Big-12 teams. It will be interesting to watch this play out. The SEC and B1G have been raiders of strong football teams. For the Big-12, we will have to grow our own. This weekend provided that goal may not be out of reach.

While the 4-Corner schools have deservedly received a lot of public attention, it was the addition of Cincinnati, UCF, Houston, and BYU that was the key to Big-12's recent success. These four schools have the population base requisite to building a strong football program.

Moderators, please delete this double post. The cat walked over my key board and distracted me.

Your cat just got a lifetime ban lol.

Justice for Oklahoma Cat!
[Image: ok_cat_pc.jpg]


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - UCGrad1992 - 10-28-2026 07:58 PM

Why is it disastrous? How many undefeated teams are left in FBS? Right, three! One remains in the B12. Six B12 teams are ranked in the top 25. If anything, the B12's quality depth is a sign of strength this year. Next topic!

Signed,
Brett Yormark

[Image: 1783547093135?e=2147483647&v=bet...cJzHcYgCS8]


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Todor - 10-28-2026 08:30 PM

Moderators, please delete both posts for him having a cat lol.

Cat owners always give me paws. And blaming the poor cat for his error, well, that just sounds like a wild tail.


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - TexanMark - 10-28-2026 08:46 PM

(10-28-2026 05:58 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(10-28-2026 04:33 PM)Bear Catlett Wrote:  The B12 shouldn’t have to apologize for not having any chumps in their league like the B1G, SEC and ACC do.

Everyone in the ACC has a conference win.

Thanks to freaking Syracuse

I'm not feeling the love...03-lmfao

We were due as we were in every game


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - TexanMark - 10-28-2026 08:46 PM

(10-28-2026 08:30 PM)Todor Wrote:  Moderators, please delete both posts for him having a cat lol.

Cat owners always give me paws. And blaming the poor cat for his error, well, that just sounds like a wild tail.

The OP can delete his duplicate post himself.


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Scoochpooch1 - 10-28-2026 09:45 PM

(10-28-2026 04:33 PM)Bear Catlett Wrote:  The B12 shouldn’t have to apologize for not having any chumps in their league like the B1G, SEC and ACC do.

Haha, you really believe this? In the CFP era, what has any team done outside of Oklahoma and Texas who left?


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - UCGrad1992 - 10-28-2026 10:30 PM

(10-28-2026 09:45 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(10-28-2026 04:33 PM)Bear Catlett Wrote:  The B12 shouldn’t have to apologize for not having any chumps in their league like the B1G, SEC and ACC do.

Haha, you really believe this? In the CFP era, what has any team done outside of Oklahoma and Texas who left?

I believe every league has chumps. That said, TCU (2022), Arizona St (2024), and Texas Tech (2025) made the CFP outside of TexaHoma. You can add to the list this year.


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - e-parade - 10-29-2026 08:44 AM

(10-28-2026 07:58 PM)UCGrad1992 Wrote:  Why is it disastrous? How many undefeated teams are left in FBS? Right, three! One remains in the B12. Six B12 teams are ranked in the top 25. If anything, the B12's quality depth is a sign of strength this year. Next topic!

Signed,
Brett Yormark

[Image: 1783547093135?e=2147483647&v=bet...cJzHcYgCS8]

It's not utter disaster for sure, but having two undefeated teams ranked in the top 10 both go down to unranked opponents in the same week is pretty bad. They were potentially cruising toward having 3 teams in the CFP this year (if the combination of Utah, BYU, and TT only lost to each other in the BYU vs. Utah game on the 7th and then in the championship game between TT and whoever won between BYU and Utah) and now might drop down to 1 if BYU loses to Utah and TT loses in the championship game.

That's obviously not guaranteed, but it's an "oh what could have been" scenario for the B12 with the potential playoff seeding they could have ended up with.

Still. It's only one week and the conference definitely seems legit this year.


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - bryanw1995 - 10-29-2026 08:47 AM

(10-28-2026 08:30 PM)Todor Wrote:  Moderators, please delete both posts for him having a cat lol.

Cat owners always give me paws. And blaming the poor cat for his error, well, that just sounds like a wild tail.

I need you to stop making cat puns right meow.


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Gitanole - 10-29-2026 08:48 AM

(10-29-2026 08:44 AM)e-parade Wrote:  It's not utter disaster for sure, but having two undefeated teams ranked in the top 10 both go down to unranked opponents in the same week is pretty bad. They were potentially cruising toward having 3 teams in the CFP this year (if the combination of Utah, BYU, and TT only lost to each other in the BYU vs. Utah game on the 7th and then in the championship game between TT and whoever won between BYU and Utah) and now might drop down to 1 if BYU loses to Utah and TT loses in the championship game.

That's obviously not guaranteed, but it's an "oh what could have been" scenario for the B12 with the potential playoff seeding they could have ended up with.

Still. It's only one week and the conference definitely seems legit this year.

It’s the 2026 college football season. If everything looks awful, wait a week.

Things will look differently awful.

___


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - ArmoredUpKnight - 10-29-2026 09:22 AM

I’d much rather the Big 12 front runner lose a close conference game than make it to the playoff unscathed and get completely blown out by the P2.

If BYU makes it to the playoffs and gets blown out, you can now point at the UCF loss and say there were signs. I can’t imagine the hype around BYU if they continued their undefeated run. It would have been more harmful for the XII brand


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Dr Dawgma III - 10-29-2026 10:22 AM

This a great example of why conference pride is stupid.

I WANT ALL OUR RIVALS TO LOSE


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - bryanw1995 - 10-29-2026 10:49 AM

(10-29-2026 08:48 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(10-29-2026 08:44 AM)e-parade Wrote:  It's not utter disaster for sure, but having two undefeated teams ranked in the top 10 both go down to unranked opponents in the same week is pretty bad. They were potentially cruising toward having 3 teams in the CFP this year (if the combination of Utah, BYU, and TT only lost to each other in the BYU vs. Utah game on the 7th and then in the championship game between TT and whoever won between BYU and Utah) and now might drop down to 1 if BYU loses to Utah and TT loses in the championship game.

That's obviously not guaranteed, but it's an "oh what could have been" scenario for the B12 with the potential playoff seeding they could have ended up with.

Still. It's only one week and the conference definitely seems legit this year.

It’s the 2026 college football season. If everything looks awful, wait a week.

Things will look differently awful.

___

People so easily forget that Texas Tech played an absolute cake schedule last year and still got the 4 seed with a loss. 1/4 of the Big 12 probably gets a bye if any of them wins out, and 2 others easily make the CFP as an at large if they win out. Losing a couple games last week will only matter if nobody escapes with 2 or fewer losses, potentially giving some 3 loss SEC schools an opening. I’d put the Big 12 closer to 2 bids than 2.5 today, but that can change in a hurry.


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Oklahoma Guy - 10-29-2026 01:34 PM

I hope you guys are satisfied. I read your posts to my two kitties and were they ever pissed. As a result, they are tearing up my curtains, tearing up my furniture, and tearing up my new living room carpet. Not to mention they are pushing all my papers off my desk.


RE: CBS: Big-12's disastrous week - Oklahoma Guy - 10-29-2026 01:44 PM

(10-28-2026 07:58 PM)UCGrad1992 Wrote:  Why is it disastrous? How many undefeated teams are left in FBS? Right, three! One remains in the B12. Six B12 teams are ranked in the top 25. If anything, the B12's quality depth is a sign of strength this year. Next topic!

Signed,
Brett Yormark

[Image: 1783547093135?e=2147483647&v=bet...cJzHcYgCS8]

I am looking forward to watching the Utah @Cincy game. Utah will not want to be upset like BYU last week. Cincy will be out to prove that beating Texas Tech was not a fluke. It should be a hard fought game.

I call it the "4-Corner versus 4-First" battle!