CSNbbs
Elites and pragmatics - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Elites and pragmatics (/thread-1034837.html)



Elites and pragmatics - bullet - 10-27-2026 06:06 PM

https://www.realcleareducation.com/articles/2026/10/26/inside_the_black_box_of_higher_education_1213631.html

Interesting discussion of the marketing of colleges in an era of declining enrollment.
The elite schools are doing well.


"...Analysis of federal enrollment data for 2004–2024 shows that the share of institutions reporting acceptance rates of 70% or higher increased from 58% to 64%. Enrollment at these institutions rose from approximately 767,000 to 1.04 million. Simultaneously, at the opposite end of the market, the number of institutions accepting fewer than 10% of applicants grew from seven to 37.

Hundreds of IHEs are boxed out of both markets and are far more financially challenged than much of the public understands. They are too expensive or geographically inconvenient for Pragmatics and lack the reputation or selectivity to attract Elites. For these institutions, recruiting enough students has become a matter of financial survival. It is a problem that marketing alone cannot solve.

This split explains why financial pressures are not affecting every institution equally.

Enrollment at universities catering successfully to either Elites or Pragmatics continues to grow with a few schools addressing both markets—a prestigious brick-and-mortar campus along with a well-established online program. But colleges unable to compete in either market face a more difficult challenge: They must persuade students to enroll even when they lack the prestige to compete with Category 1 schools and lack the affordability and convenience to compete with Category 2 schools...."


RE: Elites and pragmatics - Todor - 10-28-2026 07:21 AM

First comment from the attached article-

“Few things are more satisfying than watching a group of elites who believe they own the franchise on enlightened thinking getting the comeuppance they so richly deserve.

And maybe, as an added bonus, younger generations of Americans will no longer look down on blue collar workers, based on the arrogant notion that a college education of any kind automatically signified superior status.

Welcome to AI.”

Lol. Well stated comment.


RE: Elites and pragmatics - Frank the Tank - 10-28-2026 08:21 AM

(10-28-2026 07:21 AM)Todor Wrote:  First comment from the attached article-

“Few things are more satisfying than watching a group of elites who believe they own the franchise on enlightened thinking getting the comeuppance they so richly deserve.

And maybe, as an added bonus, younger generations of Americans will no longer look down on blue collar workers, based on the arrogant notion that a college education of any kind automatically signified superior status.

Welcome to AI.”

Lol. Well stated comment.

Eh - I think that comment (as satisfying as it might be for a certain group of people) misses a lot of the point of the article. The actual elites - the Ivies, other top 20-30 private schools, top flagship and other AAU research universities - are doing very well in this market. The top privates can still charge tuition at top rates and still get sub-10% acceptance rates because they are direct funnels to the elite sectors of society such as tech, finance, management consulting, politics, etc… the people that get to make the decisions on who to hire or fire with advancements in AI or whatever other technology or other outside force that comes along. The top flagships have their own brand name advantages and are increasingly taking market share from everyone below them.

It’s the classic non-flagship public universities (the directional schools and their peers) that are decidedly non-elite that are getting hammered in this environment as they are caught in the middle as described in the article (not prestigious enough to be elite and not inexpensive enough to be “pragmatic”). It’s just as bad or worse at many non-elite private universities.

If anything, we are seeing the professional job market place even more importance on the prestige of an institution as opposed to merely putting all college grads in the same bucket. HR software has already been screening resumes like this for many years and AI is making it even easier.


RE: Elites and pragmatics - Bear Catlett - 10-28-2026 08:23 AM

Analysis of federal enrollment data… ZZZ


RE: Elites and pragmatics - BirdstheWord - 10-28-2026 08:27 AM

(10-28-2026 08:23 AM)Bear Catlett Wrote:  Analysis of federal enrollment data… ZZZ

You might think it's boring, but I love seeing articles based off of data and not just feelings even if it misses the mark a bit.


RE: Elites and pragmatics - Gitanole - 10-29-2026 10:06 AM

(10-28-2026 08:21 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  ....
The actual elites - the Ivies, other top 20-30 private schools, top flagship and other AAU research universities - are doing very well in this market. The top privates can still charge tuition at top rates and still get sub-10% acceptance rates because they are direct funnels to the elite sectors of society such as tech, finance, management consulting, politics, etc… the people that get to make the decisions on who to hire or fire with advancements in AI or whatever other technology or other outside force that comes along. The top flagships have their own brand name advantages and are increasingly taking market share from everyone below them.

It’s the classic non-flagship public universities (the directional schools and their peers) that are decidedly non-elite that are getting hammered in this environment as they are caught in the middle as described in the article (not prestigious enough to be elite and not inexpensive enough to be “pragmatic”). It’s just as bad or worse at many non-elite private universities.

If anything, we are seeing the professional job market place even more importance on the prestige of an institution as opposed to merely putting all college grads in the same bucket. HR software has already been screening resumes like this for many years and AI is making it even easier.

In addition to directional publics, a group being hammered is sectarian privates.

In the wake of the Scopes trial, small liberal arts colleges proliferated across the American landscape. Some of the sectarian lines were drawn pretty fine. The college for the Protestant People’s Front was not to be confused with colleges for the People’s Front of Protestantism or the People’s Protestant Front, or the Protestant People’s Front (Orthodox, Iowa Synod) and Protestant People’s Front (Reformed, Montana Confession).

Key goals of such institutions, whether officially advertised in their literature or not, were (1) training and certification of clergy holding “right beliefs” and (2) courtship between young people of “right belief.” Both goals helped the founding sects feel a bit more confident about their ability to endure.

Time threw curve balls anyway. Students’ expectations changed. Ecumenism and evangelicalism blurred the old sectarian lines that had once mattered so much.

A few schools evolved and grew past their original charters to redefine their missions in a durable way. Many more had difficulty managing it and are now folding.

As the article acknowledges, a private school charging double what a public university does today has to be Princeton or Duke, or else face some tough sledding. “Right belief” isn’t the clincher it once was. Yet trying to evolve past that at this late date risks undercutting the only thing that makes most of these schools distinct.

___