![]() |
|
16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money (/thread-1034440.html) Pages: 1 2 |
16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - Crayton - 10-19-2026 11:53 AM Maybe by the time I even get this posted, the clock will strike midnight on a possible 16-team playoff. But, I figured I'd post at least 1 last time the "Perfect" playoff. Finances: Under the current ESPN agreement, this would net MORE money than the proposed 24-team format. This is because ESPN had already agreed to pay for the 14th and 15th game prorata. $1.3B over 13 games is $100M each, for games #14 and #15. This overshadows the $150M total the CFP are getting after subtracting the value of the CCGs. Not to mention there 'may' be a way to package these "Wild Card Games" as non-playoff "regular season" games and take them to market outside the existing CFP framework. Those are some big brands, and the Wild Card 'should' always be SEC heavy. TV Appeal: 4 big games on each of the first three weekends of December. The 5th best slot can still be used for Army-Navy. No midweek games. No games overlapping on Saturdays. It 'is' weird seeing 6-0 teams play in the first round, but the teams will become much more stratified as the season reaches its conclusion. 16-Team Playoff that never was - b2b - 10-19-2026 12:09 PM The perfect playoff was a straight 8 with auto bids for the P4 and G6 with 3 at large. Sent from my Pixel 7 using CSNbbs mobile app RE: 16-Team Playoff that never was - Crayton - 10-19-2026 12:15 PM (10-19-2026 12:09 PM)b2b Wrote: The perfect playoff was a straight 8 with auto bids for the P4 and G6 with 3 at large. I am evaluating not only “preservation of college football tradition” but also “maximizing revenue”. An 8-team playoff won’t be worth more than the proposed 24-teams playoff. But, almost counter-intuitively, this 16-team playoff would be. RE: 16-Team Playoff that never was - Fighting Muskie - 10-19-2026 12:21 PM Ideally, the playoff would just be the P4 champions RE: 16-Team Playoff that never was - bullet - 10-19-2026 12:22 PM (10-19-2026 12:15 PM)Crayton Wrote:(10-19-2026 12:09 PM)b2b Wrote: The perfect playoff was a straight 8 with auto bids for the P4 and G6 with 3 at large. Interesting. RE: 16-Team Playoff that never was - Dr Dawgma III - 10-19-2026 12:47 PM (10-19-2026 12:09 PM)b2b Wrote: The perfect playoff was a straight 8 with auto bids for the P4 and G6 with 3 at large. This was effectively the non-NCAA proposal from the 80's with six auto-bids (ACC, B1G, SEC, Big 8, SWC, and Pac 10) and two at-larges. RE: 16-Team Playoff that never was - goofus - 10-19-2026 12:55 PM (10-19-2026 12:21 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: Ideally, the playoff would just be the P4 champions That could work, I guess, if each conference/region had its own 4-team playoff. You could group the regions like this. Pick the top4 teams from each region. North : Big Ten South: SEC East: ACC, Notre Dame, American, MAC, UConn West: Big 12, Pac-12, MWC, Sunbelt, CUSA RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - schmolik - 10-20-2026 06:24 AM I want 16 over 24 if it means the conference championship games stay. RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - b2b - 10-20-2026 08:45 AM (10-19-2026 12:15 PM)Crayton Wrote:(10-19-2026 12:09 PM)b2b Wrote: The perfect playoff was a straight 8 with auto bids for the P4 and G6 with 3 at large. OK. I'm not sure I follow most of your math in your spreadsheets but that's fine. It's jmho that the 8 format would be perfect in terms of competitiveness and fan interest. RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - Crayton - 10-20-2026 11:07 AM (10-20-2026 08:45 AM)b2b Wrote:(10-19-2026 12:15 PM)Crayton Wrote:(10-19-2026 12:09 PM)b2b Wrote: The perfect playoff was a straight 8 with auto bids for the P4 and G6 with 3 at large. I think the current 12-team format captures most of the competitiveness of the 8-team format PLUS extra competition. Win a major conference championship game and you are in the Round of 8. What the 12-team adds is play-ins for those 3 or 4 wild card spots so that they are decided “on the field” rather than “behind closed doors.” That ENHANCES the competition. The 16-team format outlined in the OP also adds upon those. Win a major conference championship game and you STILL go straight to the New Years Quarterfinals. The preliminary rounds allow even more teams a chance to play-in WITHOUT asking them to play more than 1 game more than your traditional 8-team playoff. RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - OdinFrigg - 10-20-2026 11:57 AM (10-19-2026 11:53 AM)Crayton Wrote: Maybe by the time I even get this posted, the clock will strike midnight on a possible 16-team playoff. But, I figured I'd post at least 1 last time the "Perfect" playoff. A 16–team playoff with no byes makes the most sense. 24 is excessive and unnecessary to determine a true playoff championship. With collegiate football decision making, making sense is not the norm. They must have their political placements. RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - bryanw1995 - 10-20-2026 11:59 AM (10-20-2026 06:24 AM)schmolik Wrote: I want 16 over 24 if it means the conference championship games stay. Me, too, but even the SEC coaches and ADs seem to want to kill off that extra game. RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - Just Joe - 10-20-2026 12:07 PM (10-20-2026 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:(10-20-2026 06:24 AM)schmolik Wrote: I want 16 over 24 if it means the conference championship games stay. I could do 16 if the SEC title game was preserved. It's still too many IMO but it's not an absurd amount and it lets people like me (traditionalists/old men yelling at clouds/whatever) keep something. And you're right but in five years over half of those coaches/ADs will have washed out of the SEC because that's the nature of the beast. We're letting very well paid temp labor carve up our sport. RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - Crayton - 10-20-2026 01:27 PM (10-20-2026 11:57 AM)OdinFrigg Wrote: A 16–team playoff with no byes makes the most sense. 24 is excessive and unnecessary to determine a true playoff championship. The most sense if we value…? A flat 16 is probably the “worst” format for preserving the value of the regular season. Once an SEC team gets that 9th win the rest of their games are for seeding. And when multiple teams are “playing for seeding” the resultant seeding no longer reflects actual strength. The only thing excessive about the 24-team playoff will be the non-traditional kick off times. From a wear-and-tear perspective; teams will still play, at most, 2 December games. From a competitive perspective, teams cannot coast as they can in your flat 16-team model. RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - Ned Low - 10-20-2026 01:37 PM The only source I have on this matter is ECU's AD, Jon Gilbert. He stated that the thinking "among ADs" is that there is not a large increase in going from 12 to 14 or 16 teams. There is a huge increase in money in expanding the field to 24. There seems to be a bunch of hand-wringing, complaining and such going on about this. Prediction: the games will all have good viewership, will make money for all and will not harm the regular season. I have no idea how they will crown conference champions or if they even try to do at all. That's my only gripe... and it's a small one. RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - ken d - 10-20-2026 02:52 PM (10-19-2026 11:53 AM)Crayton Wrote: Maybe by the time I even get this posted, the clock will strike midnight on a possible 16-team playoff. But, I figured I'd post at least 1 last time the "Perfect" playoff. I'm not sure I follow your math, and I don't know for certain what ESPN had previously committed to with respect to expansion. Currently they are paying $1.3 billion for the 11 game playoff (12 teams), or $118 million per game. If they had agreed to pay pro rata for 4 more games (16 teams total) that would add $472 million. I don't believe this was the agreement. I'm guessing the agreement was they would pay $1.3 billion for either a 12 team playoff or a 14 team playoff (2 byes and 6 first round games), or $1.5 billion for a 16 team playoff. Instead, they are proposing to pay $1.645 billion for a 24 team playoff, or $145 million for the additional 8 games ($18 million per game). My question for the P2 - was it worth it to give up your CCG for this? RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - cowboysrule - 10-20-2026 04:30 PM (10-19-2026 12:09 PM)b2b Wrote: The perfect playoff was a straight 8 with auto bids for the P4 and G6 with 3 at large. the only truly perfect formula for the CFP is my manifesto..... stop trying to revinent the wheel...click below boys! RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - Crayton - 10-20-2026 05:41 PM (10-20-2026 02:52 PM)ken d Wrote: I'm not sure I follow your math, and I don't know for certain what ESPN had previously committed to with respect to expansion. You’ve got the right values so we can start there. What you are missing is the negative $200M in media revenue for killing the CCGs. That makes the equation: $1645M - $200M < $1500M Plus some sources are estimating an additional $100M in licensing rights and revenue directly from the neutral sites such that the actual financial bump vis-à-vis the status quo is nearly nominal. There is a reason ($$) the big leagues “sell” hosting rights to certain sites years in advance. RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - Crayton - 10-20-2026 05:43 PM (10-20-2026 04:30 PM)cowboysrule Wrote:(10-19-2026 12:09 PM)b2b Wrote: The perfect playoff was a straight 8 with auto bids for the P4 and G6 with 3 at large. Yours is more a realignment fantasy than a playoff format hinged to reality. Fun, but not something real enough to undergo a financial analysis. RE: 16-Team Playoff would have gotten more money - Frank the Tank - 10-21-2026 06:54 AM (10-20-2026 01:37 PM)Ned Low Wrote: The only source I have on this matter is ECU's AD, Jon Gilbert. He stated that the thinking "among ADs" is that there is not a large increase in going from 12 to 14 or 16 teams. It will be like the old pre-CCG where there can be conference co-champions. That still happens for the basketball regular season now. Each P4 league will still need a tiebreaker of some sort to determine who gets their champion AQ, but co-champions were quite common in history (certainly in the Big Ten). |