CSNbbs
By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: MACbbs (/forum-513.html)
+---- Forum: ☠️ Jolly Rogers ☠️ (/forum-463.html)
+----- Forum: Western Michigan (/forum-469.html)
+------ Forum: The Dan Burgardt Memorial Bronco Football Forum (/forum-489.html)
+------ Thread: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective (/thread-1034287.html)



By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - sdsly - 10-16-2026 09:54 AM

I thought this was a very interesting read: https://www.bythebelt.com/college-football-playoff-24-team-expansion-column/?fbclid=IwY2xjawU_GZdleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBwZG9mAXNydGMGYXBwX2lkEDIyMjAzOTE3ODgyMDA4OTIAAR54i8crhVPB6_9SIBxZ8o9-R7GY5HLLBX0BU2Nlqi7bhv8RKsap7pSFth1SCw_aem_KWKrFf5ad5Fn8n7MQk58CQ


By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - SilentStryk09 - 10-16-2026 09:59 AM

The 24 team proposal as written effectively kills the G6 on a national scale. Unless you somehow win the one pay game you’re likely to get now, you won’t have a playoff shot and therefore get zero postseason with the CCGs being killed.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - BroncoMinor - 10-16-2026 10:39 AM

(10-16-2026 09:59 AM)SilentStryk09 Wrote:  The 24 team proposal as written effectively kills the G6 on a national scale. Unless you somehow win the one pay game you’re likely to get now, you won’t have a playoff shot and therefore get zero postseason with the CCGs being killed.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yeah, this will push the G6's to another tier of college football.

FBS+
FBS basic cable

We'll be in FBS basic cable.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - PezKingGL1 - 10-16-2026 10:44 AM

Will all depend on what the Kalamazoo $$ wants to do.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - okgc - 10-16-2026 12:12 PM

(10-16-2026 10:44 AM)PezKingGL1 Wrote:  Will all depend on what the Kalamazoo $$ wants to do.

WMU needs MORE significant donors as the current high dollar donations will have an ending sometime. Spread the support


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - BroncoFilly - 10-16-2026 12:36 PM

(10-16-2026 12:12 PM)okgc Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 10:44 AM)PezKingGL1 Wrote:  Will all depend on what the Kalamazoo $$ wants to do.

WMU needs MORE significant donors as the current high dollar donations will have an ending sometime. Spread the support

That is the challenge for our new AD, to promote more giving from the WMU fanbase.

Mike Gary has done a good job in the past, I'm not sure what their current numbers look like? It can always be improved.

We sure are blessed to have the folks funding the arena downtown, that will be a big boon to our ice hockey, bball and vball programs.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - PezKingGL1 - 10-16-2026 02:21 PM

The sad thing is the powers that be can't just bring themselves to gove every FBS chanp a bid. That would leave 14 at large spots for the B1G and SEC but that's just not enough.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - wmubroncopilot - 10-16-2026 02:53 PM

(10-16-2026 02:21 PM)PezKingGL1 Wrote:  The sad thing is the powers that be can't just bring themselves to gove every FBS chanp a bid. That would leave 14 at large spots for the B1G and SEC but that's just not enough.

My view is that this is yet another failure of the NCAA. They could have instituted a real playoff, the same way all the other sports have, decades ago. Long before they lost control of FBS football. It would have been much harder for the big conferences to take the postseason control they have now if there was a longstanding, popular NCAA tournament in place already.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - sdsly - 11-09-2026 02:19 PM

New article posted today: https://www.bythebelt.com/mac-commissioner-jon-steinbrecher-statement-on-24-team-college-football-playoff-critique-opposition/


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - Ubish - 11-09-2026 02:53 PM

(10-16-2026 02:21 PM)PezKingGL1 Wrote:  The sad thing is the powers that be can't just bring themselves to gove every FBS chanp a bid. That would leave 14 at large spots for the B1G and SEC but that's just not enough.

The craziest thing are the fans that have convinced themselves that letting all conference champs in would make for a bad tournament, when letting in all conference champions is the reason why March Madness is fun in basketball.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - Cocksman - 11-09-2026 03:46 PM

So do we have a MAC championship game in 2027?


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - SilentStryk09 - 11-09-2026 04:01 PM

(11-09-2026 03:46 PM)Cocksman Wrote:  So do we have a MAC championship game in 2027?

I'm imagining we won't. they're probably going to have the playoffs starting that weekend.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - Cocksman - 11-09-2026 04:17 PM

(11-09-2026 04:01 PM)SilentStryk09 Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 03:46 PM)Cocksman Wrote:  So do we have a MAC championship game in 2027?

I'm imagining we won't. they're probably going to have the playoffs starting that weekend.

The army navy game moves up a week next year. The playoffs would start the week after or what used to be the army navy weekend. I know other games can’t be played in the army navy window. So if g5 still have championship games it would have to be before or after the army navy game on the first Saturday in December.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - Dirty Ernie - 11-09-2026 04:50 PM

Im wondering if the leftover bowls, which the word is some bowls would get left out, might like to host the G6 champs or a mini- G6 playoff. If G6 continued Divisions champ, each conference could qualify 2 teams? Coach Tayler indicated some options are being considered.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - Motown Bronco - 11-10-2026 09:38 AM

(11-09-2026 02:53 PM)Ubish Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 02:21 PM)PezKingGL1 Wrote:  The sad thing is the powers that be can't just bring themselves to gove every FBS chanp a bid. That would leave 14 at large spots for the B1G and SEC but that's just not enough.

The craziest thing are the fans that have convinced themselves that letting all conference champs in would make for a bad tournament, when letting in all conference champions is the reason why March Madness is fun in basketball.

One compromise I had was to have 3 play-in games among the G6 conference champions, and those 3 winners get playoff berths. (Conference championship games eliminated) It'd placate those who think 6 is too many and it'd give ESPN a few more fun "win or go home" games before the big tourney starts. And to your point, it's like March Madness where everyone has a puncher's chance, no matter how small.

But I assume there are powers that be who already cringe at allowing even one seat for the G6, let alone tripling that.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - Nacho - 11-10-2026 04:25 PM

Really going to miss the conference championship games. Seems silly they are going away. We are going to have so many regular season co-champions.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - Ubish - 11-11-2026 08:12 AM

The MAC should say F U to espn and have a championship game anyway.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - sdsly - 11-11-2026 10:09 AM

(11-11-2026 08:12 AM)Ubish Wrote:  The MAC should say F U to espn and have a championship game anyway.

I hope they keep the championship game.


RE: By The Belt Article On 24 Team Playoff From The MAC Perspective - toddjnsn - 11-12-2026 12:09 AM

Quote:The MAC should say F U to espn and have a championship game anyway.

I could see an argument for it, making a comparison to the NFL which doesn't have divisional champ games. But at the same time, there's fewer teams in each VS conferences in NCAA (especially now)... and they play each other twice. AND the [tie-breaking?] winner of each division in NFL goes to the playoffs. One may in response: "Yeah, but we can't let ANY conference champ in!" Sure, you push said POV for many years in many conferences by not having a conference championship game (sometimes not so clear/needed tho).

But in All followed sports of college & pro, nothing is pure-rankings, conference or divisional standing be damned. Nothing. For A REASON. :)

I see what they're thinking: Oh, if we let 24 teams ranked get in, it'll get all teams who deserve it!

Well, who would you like to see & who earned a playoff spot? A 10-2 G6 who wasn't in official Top 24 rankings, but ranked #24 & #27 in the AP and Coaches poll and clearly won their Conference -- Or the 9-3 P4 team who solidly wasn't tied to the top of theirs, and to be said last pick instead in said playoffs?

IMO, if not having conference championship games to make more 'room' for Playoffs, include all conferences with teams fitting the mold of, say, being over .500 with more than 1 win over losses, and not including wins over any FCS teams who are not Top 10 at end of said regular season + winning your conference in regular season outright [not by tie for 1st within it]. Meaning, for most teams who are 7-5 but somehow are also rarely outright 1st place in their conference, that won't be enough due to their FCS win doesn't count, as they'd be treated as 6-5 instead. Thus, generally speaking, 8-4 or better + holding 1st in your conference above the rest in it, would instead guarantee an entry in said Very Expanded playoff.

Need to make top-of-your Conference mean something, especially when forced to play 9 not 8 games in it now if you have enough teams -- otherwise this whole thing will backfire. Maybe given some time, but it'll end up backfiring.