CSNbbs
Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? (/thread-1033730.html)

Pages: 1 2


Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - billybobby777 - 10-03-2026 11:28 PM

There’s no question that Charlotte is the worst team in FBS in 2026, but are they the worst team in the past decade? Thoughts and suggestions please.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - debragga - 10-03-2026 11:40 PM

I think there might be a few teams that have been worse


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - UIWElite2 - 10-04-2026 12:02 AM

I mean UMass was just 0-12 last year


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - The Beaver - 10-04-2026 12:03 AM

(10-03-2026 11:28 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  There’s no question that Charlotte is the worst team in FBS in 2026, but are they the worst team in the past decade? Thoughts and suggestions please.

Sac State is worse than them this year.

As to the whole decade, nope, there's clearly worse out there than them.

ULM, who have failed to go above .500 in the Sun Belt the past ten years, clearly have a worse body of work than them. That is opposed to Charlotte, who made it 5-3 in 2019 in a stronger conference, of course. So in that sense Monroe has clearly been worse than them and you're letting your personal animosity towards the school get in the way of the facts.

Oh, and then UTEP has the same history of ULM, failing to make it above .500 in conference in CUSA ten years in a row. So clearly worse than the 49ers. If you want to go on in-conference winlessness then the Miners have Charlotte beat too.

And then there's UMass, who have been playing as an independent. I'd argue their total record has been worse than Charlotte's, but just due to the brutality of their schedules its hard to say. Take, for instance, the 2018 season, where they went 4-8 but had Charlotte as one of the wins. Charlotte went 4-4 in the American that year, it was one of their good seasons. They also had what I'd argue was a G6 strong team in 2017, but went 4-8 that year due to an obscenely tough schedule where they played two SEC teams away and only lost by a combined total of 13.

EMU is also likely worse than Charlotte, they had two 5-3 MAC records over the past decade, plus at least one 4-4, but since the MAC is significantly worse than CUSA its likely that Charlotte would have equaled or bettered them if given their schedules.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - Michael in Raleigh - 10-04-2026 03:29 AM

(10-04-2026 12:03 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(10-03-2026 11:28 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  There’s no question that Charlotte is the worst team in FBS in 2026, but are they the worst team in the past decade? Thoughts and suggestions please.

Sac State is worse than them this year.

As to the whole decade, nope, there's clearly worse out there than them.

ULM, who have failed to go above .500 in the Sun Belt the past ten years, clearly have a worse body of work than them. That is opposed to Charlotte, who made it 5-3 in 2019 in a stronger conference, of course. So in that sense Monroe has clearly been worse than them and you're letting your personal animosity towards the school get in the way of the facts.

Oh, and then UTEP has the same history of ULM, failing to make it above .500 in conference in CUSA ten years in a row. So clearly worse than the 49ers. If you want to go on in-conference winlessness then the Miners have Charlotte beat too.

And then there's UMass, who have been playing as an independent. I'd argue their total record has been worse than Charlotte's, but just due to the brutality of their schedules it’s hard to say. Take, for instance, the 2018 season, where they went 4-8 but had Charlotte as one of the wins. Charlotte went 4-4 in the American that year, it was one of their good seasons. They also had what I'd argue was a G6 strong team in 2017, but went 4-8 that year due to an obscenely tough schedule where they played two SEC teams away and only lost by a combined total of 13.

EMU is also likely worse than Charlotte, they had two 5-3 MAC records over the past decade, plus at least one 4-4, but since the MAC is significantly worse than CUSA its likely that Charlotte would have equaled or bettered them if given their schedules.

By 2019, the SBC was better than CUSA. App State went 13-1, and Louisiana won 11 games. App finished in the Top 25. CUSA had no Top 25 teams.

Also, in 2018, Charlotte was in CUSA, not the American. CUSA was miles below the American at that stage.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - Michael in Raleigh - 10-04-2026 03:49 AM

I think ULM takes the cake. UMass is a close second. EMU had bowl teams six times since 2016, so they’re not even in the conversation.

Charlotte has to be right up there. Top five worst in the FBS over the past decade. That’s pretty bad for a subdivision with over 130 teams.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - The Cutter of Bish - 10-04-2026 05:07 AM

UMass wins four games and are magically relieved from this burden? Heck no. Still at the top of that stinky heap. If they win another game this season, it'll have been the most since 2011...their transitional year.

In the last decade, though, Charlotte's amongst that gang. Akron's up there. ULM. I see you, UTEP.

Honorable mentions to New Mexico State and Rice. Rice, who gets to go to bowls with sub-.500 records due to APR and conference commitments.

Historically, UNLV's been a dud. The last four seasons are probably the best they've ever been consistency-wise.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - PicksUp - 10-04-2026 06:33 AM

It depends what you mean, over a single season or two? Or do you mean over the entire decade? I swear this has been brought up before but maybe it was in another forum.

I also think you are being unfair to Charlotte. They were worse last year and likely in 2017, too.

Really, really bad FBS teams the past 10 seasons….

2017-19 UTEP
Went 2-34, with wins only over Rice and Houston Baptist. I remember this era well. This was right after Aaron Jones graduated and it was the transition from Kugler to Dimel. Mike Price made an appearance as the interim HC.

2023-24 Kent St
Went 1-23

2019 UMass
Allowed nearly 53 pts a game and lost by 20+ vs FCS Southern Illinois. Did beat Akron.

2019 Akron
Averaged just under 11 points per game on offense, probably the worst offensive team the past 10 years

2018 UConn
Allowed over 50 points per game

2020 UL-Monroe

2021 and 2025 UMass are also up there (or in the bottom) in terms of futility


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - Dr Dawgma III - 10-04-2026 08:42 AM

Unfortunately, UMass was housed at home by a historically terrible Eastern Michigan Huron team. They had the chance to do something that's never been done too: be the first team to go 5-0 after going 0-fer the prior season. I was pulling for them!


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - debragga - 10-04-2026 08:50 AM

That 2020 ULM team was a few inches away from beating Georgia Southern, I was at that game. That team had it rough. In addition to COVID which everyone was dealing with, there was Hurricane Delta that rolled through in the middle of the season and knocked out power for the whole region for a few weeks. And they also had players having to live in hotels because the on-campus apartments for athletes were delayed.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - shere khan - 10-04-2026 08:56 AM

Worst in 50 years. Memphis played everyone down to the waterboy.

Could have scored 100.

And Memphis is average at best


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - mj4life - 10-04-2026 09:05 AM

Charlotte is bad but let's be realistic about what they tried to do. They announce the transition to FBS before they even field a team. Most schools play FCS for a period of time before moving up. So they haven't been able to develop any type of program identity & it shows.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - The Beaver - 10-04-2026 10:00 AM

(10-04-2026 05:07 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  UMass wins four games and are magically relieved from this burden? Heck no. Still at the top of that stinky heap. If they win another game this season, it'll have been the most since 2011...their transitional year.

In the last decade, though, Charlotte's amongst that gang. Akron's up there. ULM. I see you, UTEP.

Honorable mentions to New Mexico State and Rice. Rice, who gets to go to bowls with sub-.500 records due to APR and conference commitments.

Historically, UNLV's been a dud. The last four seasons are probably the best they've ever been consistency-wise.
UMass also "cheated" this year by scheduling two FCS teams. Congrats on the Rutgers win, guys, but other than that you beat a pair of FCS teams and Sac State, who in most regards are of FCS quality.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - UIWElite2 - 10-04-2026 11:42 AM

(10-04-2026 10:00 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(10-04-2026 05:07 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  UMass wins four games and are magically relieved from this burden? Heck no. Still at the top of that stinky heap. If they win another game this season, it'll have been the most since 2011...their transitional year.

In the last decade, though, Charlotte's amongst that gang. Akron's up there. ULM. I see you, UTEP.

Honorable mentions to New Mexico State and Rice. Rice, who gets to go to bowls with sub-.500 records due to APR and conference commitments.

Historically, UNLV's been a dud. The last four seasons are probably the best they've ever been consistency-wise.
UMass also "cheated" this year by scheduling two FCS teams. Congrats on the Rutgers win, guys, but other than that you beat a pair of FCS teams and Sac State, who in most regards are of FCS quality.

4 wins after winning 0 last year, is an accomplishment. They lost to Bryant last year.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - The Cutter of Bish - 10-04-2026 11:42 AM

(10-04-2026 09:05 AM)mj4life Wrote:  Charlotte is bad but let's be realistic about what they tried to do. They announce the transition to FBS before they even field a team. Most schools play FCS for a period of time before moving up. So they haven't been able to develop any type of program identity & it shows.

They are where they are because of the work not done. Look past the ambition and prior relationships with other schools in CUSA (and then again in AAC). They were said to have been offered football memberships to both SoCon and CAAFC, even as short-term placements, and they nixed them both because they prioritized their "fast-track" path.

It's annoying that you have to have a school like Charlotte with a vote in places like CUSA and now AAC. Could have decent options turned away just because UNCC is part of any opposition. They don't deserve the spot.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - The Beaver - 10-04-2026 11:58 AM

(10-04-2026 11:42 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(10-04-2026 09:05 AM)mj4life Wrote:  Charlotte is bad but let's be realistic about what they tried to do. They announce the transition to FBS before they even field a team. Most schools play FCS for a period of time before moving up. So they haven't been able to develop any type of program identity & it shows.

They are where they are because of the work not done. Look past the ambition and prior relationships with other schools in CUSA (and then again in AAC). They were said to have been offered football memberships to both SoCon and CAAFC, even as short-term placements, and they nixed them both because they prioritized their "fast-track" path.

It's annoying that you have to have a school like Charlotte with a vote in places like CUSA and now AAC. Could have decent options turned away just because UNCC is part of any opposition. They don't deserve the spot.
UTSA did the exact same thing except it worked. Granted, the Roadrunners didn't have NFL football deal with (or a bunch of in-market long-established college teams) and they actually tried their hardest to build a football program and fanbase.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - thrill_house - 10-04-2026 12:30 PM

Chris Creighton deserves a bronze statue for his work in Ypsilanti.

That program was dead from 1990-2016. They had 5 consecutive awful coaching hires. There was no football culture there.

The fact that they have fans (not much, but it was better than the 500 at best in the pre-Creighton era) showing up and NFL alums making capital investments to the football program tells the story here.

Very thankful that EMU never lost him to a better job.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - mj4life - 10-04-2026 01:54 PM

(10-04-2026 11:58 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(10-04-2026 11:42 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(10-04-2026 09:05 AM)mj4life Wrote:  Charlotte is bad but let's be realistic about what they tried to do. They announce the transition to FBS before they even field a team. Most schools play FCS for a period of time before moving up. So they haven't been able to develop any type of program identity & it shows.

They are where they are because of the work not done. Look past the ambition and prior relationships with other schools in CUSA (and then again in AAC). They were said to have been offered football memberships to both SoCon and CAAFC, even as short-term placements, and they nixed them both because they prioritized their "fast-track" path.

It's annoying that you have to have a school like Charlotte with a vote in places like CUSA and now AAC. Could have decent options turned away just because UNCC is part of any opposition. They don't deserve the spot.
UTSA did the exact same thing except it worked. Granted, the Roadrunners didn't have NFL football deal with (or a bunch of in-market long-established college teams) and they actually tried their hardest to build a football program and fanbase.

They did but Charlotte just didn't have the infrastructure in place to build a solid program & probably still doesn't. They should have made the investment in early 90's. before App State,JMU,Coastal etc decided to move up & long before everybody started recruiting Charlotte.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - Fighting Muskie - 10-04-2026 02:00 PM

There’s an easy way to evaluate this— compile the records from the past 10 years, drop the victories against FCS, and see who has the most miserable record.


RE: Is Charlotte the worst team in FBS over past decade? - PicksUp - 10-04-2026 02:09 PM

(10-04-2026 02:00 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  There’s an easy way to evaluate this— compile the records from the past 10 years, drop the victories against FCS, and see who has the most miserable record.

UMass is probably it then.

22-95 since 2016. 9-4 vs FCS.

So 13-91 vs FBS.