Week 5 game thread - bryanw1995 - 10-03-2026 09:21 AM
Let's get this started.
1-4 Idaho ended defending FCS Champions Montana State's 19 game win streak, 35-34 in what they're calling the Miracle in Moscow.
https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/50088928/idaho-ends-montana-state-19-game-win-streak-2-point-conversion
NW dominated PSU to open Ryan field, too. Interesting Friday.
RE: Week 5 game thread - Sitting bull - 10-03-2026 09:30 AM
(10-03-2026 09:21 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: Let's get this started.
1-4 Idaho ended defending FCS Champions Montana State's 19 game win streak, 35-34 in what they're calling the Miracle in Moscow.
https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/50088928/idaho-ends-montana-state-19-game-win-streak-2-point-conversion
NW dominated PSU to open Ryan field, too. Interesting Friday.
Incredible finish. Pass out the Bozo noses to the “no one cares about FCS football” crowd. Idaho fans appear quite excited.
RE: Week 5 game thread - schmolik - 10-03-2026 02:01 PM
 :
RE: Week 5 game thread - copycat - 10-03-2026 07:03 PM
Well we do have a theme for the day: Go for 2.
Syracuse does it in OT at UConn and wins it.
Kentucky does it in OT at South Carolina and wins it.
RE: Week 5 game thread - bryanw1995 - 10-03-2026 08:24 PM
A&M looking good against (mutters quietly) Arkansas. Whatever, being on the right end of a blowout is better than the last 2 games.
RE: Week 5 game thread - cubucks - 10-03-2026 08:27 PM
Florida getting blown out was not on my bingo card.
RE: Week 5 game thread - schmolik - 10-04-2026 05:29 AM
Courtesy of RedditCFP X:
And then there were 15:
![[Image: HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small]](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small)
Pitt, Duke, and Nebraska weren't ranked as of last week's AP poll (Duke was #21 in the Coaches poll). They all better be in the polls today!
James Madison and North Dakota State have not played a Power 4 opponent as of yet. I'm not sure it can be justified to rank them as I'm sure there are G6's who played a P4 and lost like Boise State who lost at Oregon. Neither of these schools is scheduled to play a P4 this season. I'm surprised G6's can survive most seasons without playing a P4. This is North Dakota State's first year in FBS. Maybe they're used to being "poor". But they've played Power 4 schools when they were still FCS, even beat some of them! You would think teams would be more likely to play South Dakota State these days now that they're no longer FCS.
RE: Week 5 game thread - AssKickingChicken - 10-04-2026 06:02 AM
There are two all-undefeated games next week, one in the Big Ten and the other in the SEC.
RE: Week 5 game thread - quo vadis - 10-04-2026 07:03 AM
Good day for the new Mountain West, chalking up wins over American and ACC teams
With the UNLV victory over Cal I think that makes it something like three wins for the G6 versus 70 losses against the A4 this year
RE: Week 5 game thread - The Beaver - 10-04-2026 10:14 AM
(10-04-2026 05:29 AM)schmolik Wrote: Courtesy of RedditCFP X:
And then there were 15:
![[Image: HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small]](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small)
Pitt, Duke, and Nebraska weren't ranked as of last week's AP poll (Duke was #21 in the Coaches poll). They all better be in the polls today!
James Madison and North Dakota State have not played a Power 4 opponent as of yet. I'm not sure it can be justified to rank them as I'm sure there are G6's who played a P4 and lost like Boise State who lost at Oregon. Neither of these schools is scheduled to play a P4 this season. I'm surprised G6's can survive most seasons without playing a P4. This is North Dakota State's first year in FBS. Maybe they're used to being "poor". But they've played Power 4 schools when they were still FCS, even beat some of them! You would think teams would be more likely to play South Dakota State these days now that they're no longer FCS.
I could see the case for Pitt, they have small wins over UCF, VT and a 14 pointer over Syracuse but those first two teams are pretty good (certainly not bad) by P4 standards, as to Nebraska and UCLA, sure put them in. UCLA already are.
RE: Week 5 game thread - quo vadis - 10-04-2026 12:33 PM
The SEC it's far and away the best as usual, while the G6 is a collective 3-70 against the A4.
RE: Week 5 game thread - bryanw1995 - 10-04-2026 06:51 PM
(10-04-2026 05:29 AM)schmolik Wrote: Courtesy of RedditCFP X:
And then there were 15:
![[Image: HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small]](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small)
Pitt, Duke, and Nebraska weren't ranked as of last week's AP poll (Duke was #21 in the Coaches poll). They all better be in the polls today!
James Madison and North Dakota State have not played a Power 4 opponent as of yet. I'm not sure it can be justified to rank them as I'm sure there are G6's who played a P4 and lost like Boise State who lost at Oregon. Neither of these schools is scheduled to play a P4 this season. I'm surprised G6's can survive most seasons without playing a P4. This is North Dakota State's first year in FBS. Maybe they're used to being "poor". But they've played Power 4 schools when they were still FCS, even beat some of them! You would think teams would be more likely to play South Dakota State these days now that they're no longer FCS.
Buy games pay, what $1-2m? NDSU is pretty isolated, it might just not be worth it to them to take any of the buy games that were on offer to them this season?
RE: Week 5 game thread - schmolik - 10-04-2026 09:47 PM
(10-04-2026 06:51 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (10-04-2026 05:29 AM)schmolik Wrote: Courtesy of RedditCFP X:
And then there were 15:
![[Image: HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small]](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small)
Pitt, Duke, and Nebraska weren't ranked as of last week's AP poll (Duke was #21 in the Coaches poll). They all better be in the polls today!
James Madison and North Dakota State have not played a Power 4 opponent as of yet. I'm not sure it can be justified to rank them as I'm sure there are G6's who played a P4 and lost like Boise State who lost at Oregon. Neither of these schools is scheduled to play a P4 this season. I'm surprised G6's can survive most seasons without playing a P4. This is North Dakota State's first year in FBS. Maybe they're used to being "poor". But they've played Power 4 schools when they were still FCS, even beat some of them! You would think teams would be more likely to play South Dakota State these days now that they're no longer FCS.
Buy games pay, what $1-2m? NDSU is pretty isolated, it might just not be worth it to them to take any of the buy games that were on offer to them this season?
You don't think 1-2 million isn't a lot for schools like North Dakota State and James Madison?
RE: Week 5 game thread - bryanw1995 - 10-04-2026 10:18 PM
(10-04-2026 09:47 PM)schmolik Wrote: (10-04-2026 06:51 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (10-04-2026 05:29 AM)schmolik Wrote: Courtesy of RedditCFP X:
And then there were 15:
![[Image: HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small]](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small)
Pitt, Duke, and Nebraska weren't ranked as of last week's AP poll (Duke was #21 in the Coaches poll). They all better be in the polls today!
James Madison and North Dakota State have not played a Power 4 opponent as of yet. I'm not sure it can be justified to rank them as I'm sure there are G6's who played a P4 and lost like Boise State who lost at Oregon. Neither of these schools is scheduled to play a P4 this season. I'm surprised G6's can survive most seasons without playing a P4. This is North Dakota State's first year in FBS. Maybe they're used to being "poor". But they've played Power 4 schools when they were still FCS, even beat some of them! You would think teams would be more likely to play South Dakota State these days now that they're no longer FCS.
Buy games pay, what $1-2m? NDSU is pretty isolated, it might just not be worth it to them to take any of the buy games that were on offer to them this season?
You don't think 1-2 million isn't a lot for schools like North Dakota State and James Madison?
Sure, it's a decent chunk of change, but JMU can take that buy game from a school within easy driving distance, while NDSU can drive to...um, Wisconsin or Minnesota maybe? Assuming either of them wants a trap game against one of the best non-P4 schools around? I wonder what it would cost NDSU to travel to USC or Miami for a buy game? The experience would probably be worth it, but it also probably wouldn't make them very much money after expenses were factored in.
RE: Week 5 game thread - jacksfan29! - 10-05-2026 10:10 AM
(10-04-2026 10:18 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (10-04-2026 09:47 PM)schmolik Wrote: (10-04-2026 06:51 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (10-04-2026 05:29 AM)schmolik Wrote: Courtesy of RedditCFP X:
And then there were 15:
![[Image: HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small]](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small)
Pitt, Duke, and Nebraska weren't ranked as of last week's AP poll (Duke was #21 in the Coaches poll). They all better be in the polls today!
James Madison and North Dakota State have not played a Power 4 opponent as of yet. I'm not sure it can be justified to rank them as I'm sure there are G6's who played a P4 and lost like Boise State who lost at Oregon. Neither of these schools is scheduled to play a P4 this season. I'm surprised G6's can survive most seasons without playing a P4. This is North Dakota State's first year in FBS. Maybe they're used to being "poor". But they've played Power 4 schools when they were still FCS, even beat some of them! You would think teams would be more likely to play South Dakota State these days now that they're no longer FCS.
Buy games pay, what $1-2m? NDSU is pretty isolated, it might just not be worth it to them to take any of the buy games that were on offer to them this season?
You don't think 1-2 million isn't a lot for schools like North Dakota State and James Madison?
Sure, it's a decent chunk of change, but JMU can take that buy game from a school within easy driving distance, while NDSU can drive to...um, Wisconsin or Minnesota maybe? Assuming either of them wants a trap game against one of the best non-P4 schools around? I wonder what it would cost NDSU to travel to USC or Miami for a buy game? The experience would probably be worth it, but it also probably wouldn't make them very much money after expenses were factored in.
Short flight to Nebraska, Iowa, Iowa State, Wisconsin, Illinois State, Northwestern; they can drive to Minnesota.
RE: Week 5 game thread - bryanw1995 - 10-05-2026 03:30 PM
(10-05-2026 10:10 AM)jacksfan29! Wrote: (10-04-2026 10:18 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (10-04-2026 09:47 PM)schmolik Wrote: (10-04-2026 06:51 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (10-04-2026 05:29 AM)schmolik Wrote: Courtesy of RedditCFP X:
And then there were 15:
![[Image: HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small]](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HTxRH3ZbUAAi6XG?format=jpg&name=small)
Pitt, Duke, and Nebraska weren't ranked as of last week's AP poll (Duke was #21 in the Coaches poll). They all better be in the polls today!
James Madison and North Dakota State have not played a Power 4 opponent as of yet. I'm not sure it can be justified to rank them as I'm sure there are G6's who played a P4 and lost like Boise State who lost at Oregon. Neither of these schools is scheduled to play a P4 this season. I'm surprised G6's can survive most seasons without playing a P4. This is North Dakota State's first year in FBS. Maybe they're used to being "poor". But they've played Power 4 schools when they were still FCS, even beat some of them! You would think teams would be more likely to play South Dakota State these days now that they're no longer FCS.
Buy games pay, what $1-2m? NDSU is pretty isolated, it might just not be worth it to them to take any of the buy games that were on offer to them this season?
You don't think 1-2 million isn't a lot for schools like North Dakota State and James Madison?
Sure, it's a decent chunk of change, but JMU can take that buy game from a school within easy driving distance, while NDSU can drive to...um, Wisconsin or Minnesota maybe? Assuming either of them wants a trap game against one of the best non-P4 schools around? I wonder what it would cost NDSU to travel to USC or Miami for a buy game? The experience would probably be worth it, but it also probably wouldn't make them very much money after expenses were factored in.
Short flight to Nebraska, Iowa, Iowa State, Wisconsin, Illinois State, Northwestern; they can drive to Minnesota.
How many P4 schools want to play Boise st, other than Oregon? NDSU used to be a particularly terrible trade off as an FCS school that was as good as almost any g6. Potential upset waiting to happen. Their move up to FBS was at the last minute, too, though I’m not sure that any of the schools you listed would be very excited to take a break from a very difficult conference schedule to pay a very difficult opponent to come to town. It’s even worse bc you get a difficult opponent but get little credit for winning, again unless it’s a program like Boise or UCF in their decade before joining the Big 12.
I say we give NDSU a few years and see how their non conference slate shakes out.
|