![]() |
|
What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? (/thread-1033566.html) |
What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - random asian guy - 09-30-2026 11:38 AM I really don’t understand why some people act like the PCSA will make the SEC and the Big Ten rush to add teams up to the maximum. If anything, don’t you think they would take a lot more caution with any expansion? For the B10, this is their last chance to expand. Why should they make a hasty decision? I would say the 20-team cap is still fairly restrictive in this regard. Anyway we have to solve the Big Ten and ND puzzle first to figure out conference realignment. As I said before, if the Big Ten adds two ACC football schools now, that means they will never get ND. Will they wait or give up on ND? I don’t know.But I do know ND is by far the most valuable target for the Big Ten. So what would they do with ND for 2030? I’ll list the options and you tell me what will happen (not what you want to see): 1. ND caves in and joins the Big Ten with another school. 2. The Big Ten gives up on ND, adds two schools, and reaches 20. 3. The Big Ten waits for ND and does not expand. 4. The Big Ten adds only one school, leaving one spot open. 5. The Big Ten adds one school as a full member and ND as a non-football member with a scheduling agreement. 6. The Big Ten adds ND as a non-football member with a scheduling agreement and doesn’t add anyone else. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - BirdHawkEagle - 09-30-2026 11:59 AM Move on from Notre Dame, and add California and Stanford, or Georgia Tech and Miami (FL). RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - Gitanole - 09-30-2026 12:01 PM The B1G makes one call to the Irish, then moves on with them or without them. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - DFW HOYA - 09-30-2026 12:02 PM The ghost of Fritz Crisler reappears and the B10 moves on. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - bullet - 09-30-2026 12:27 PM (09-30-2026 12:01 PM)Gitanole Wrote: The B1G makes one call to the Irish, then moves on with them or without them. Agreed. ND probably says no, so they move on with two of Miami/FSU/UNC/UVA/Stanford. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - ken d - 09-30-2026 12:44 PM (09-30-2026 12:01 PM)Gitanole Wrote: The B1G makes one call to the Irish, then moves on with them or without them. Agreed. And when they say no, which they will, the B1G stays at 18. So I answered the poll question as "other". RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - stechs02 - 09-30-2026 03:32 PM (09-30-2026 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote:(09-30-2026 12:01 PM)Gitanole Wrote: The B1G makes one call to the Irish, then moves on with them or without them. Agree with the final call on Notre Dame and the outcome. Where I disagree is that the Big Ten would stay at 20 if Miami became available and if Stanford was willing to join the Big Ten Academic Alliance, I think there's a 0.01% chance they pass. Miami is simply too attractive to media partners in the current landscape, while Stanford is exactly the kind of addition presidents would want. On top of that, adding both the Bay Area and South Florida expands the conference footprint in two valuable markets. That's a hard package to turn down. I also think there is a good chance it happens. Miami at full share, Stanford at .50 RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - TerryD - 09-30-2026 03:33 PM The Big Ten should give up the ghost after 30+ years of "No" and take two other schools instead. Why it would want a school that absolutely wants no part of joining them has always baffled me. (I mean I understand that ND would be a cash cow for the Big Ten but, seriously, no means no) Doesn't everyone understand by now how much ND does not want to join the Big Ten? Even if ND joined, it would only be by a "forced', don't really want to be there situation. Neither ND nor its fans/alumni/donors would be happy about it. Why incorporate an insurgent, angry school and fanbase that dislikes the conference it is in ? There are a number of schools who want to join it. Take them instead. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - Gitanole - 09-30-2026 03:36 PM (09-30-2026 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote:(09-30-2026 12:01 PM)Gitanole Wrote: The B1G makes one call to the Irish, then moves on with them or without them. The B1G could do that. Or do other things. So I didn’t answer. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - The Beaver - 09-30-2026 03:36 PM Voted add 1 and wait. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - Gitanole - 09-30-2026 03:39 PM (09-30-2026 03:33 PM)TerryD Wrote: The Big Ten should give up the ghost after 30+ years of "No" and take two other schools instead. Agree. One phone call and everyone involved should be able to smell the coffee. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - TerryD - 09-30-2026 03:41 PM (09-30-2026 03:39 PM)Gitanole Wrote:(09-30-2026 03:33 PM)TerryD Wrote: The Big Ten should give up the ghost after 30+ years of "No" and take two other schools instead. ND has told the Big Ten no on countless phone calls, in 1999, 2011 and otherwise. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - Wahoowa84 - 09-30-2026 03:51 PM The B1G will not expand in 2030. They'll call Notre Dame and make an offer, but Notre Dame will continue as a football independent, partial ACC. B1G won't expand until much later, maybe in 2036. For the record, it's not that the B1G is waiting for Notre Dame...IMHO, the B1G could take Stanford and Cal in 2036 when expansion makes sense and the programs are stronger. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - 46566 - 09-30-2026 03:52 PM I'd say one final push for ND but move on when they say no. I think ND currently in the SEC plans. I see ND staying independent and going all sports to Big East personally. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - bryanw1995 - 09-30-2026 03:57 PM I don't think that the B1G can get any school that the SEC wants, so they'll wait on ND and only make a move if ND comes available. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - stechs02 - 09-30-2026 04:36 PM (09-30-2026 03:57 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: I don't think that the B1G can get any school that the SEC wants, so they'll wait on ND and only make a move if ND comes available. Out of all the schools available not named ND, I’d choose Miami for the Big Ten 100% of the time. I think if Miami had offers from both the SEC and Big Ten, they’d still choose Big Ten. I know if Miami ends up in the Big Ten it’s because the SEC passed of course, but Miami isn’t a consolation prize... RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - goofus - 09-30-2026 05:00 PM I really don't see the big deal with Big Ten giving ND a special deal. But instead of a non-football member with a football scheduling agreement, make them a full member with special conditions. ND only has to play 6 football conference games each year and can keep its own TV contract and own start times for home football games. Why wouldn't ND and Big Ten agree to this? RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - The Beaver - 09-30-2026 05:34 PM (09-30-2026 05:00 PM)goofus Wrote: I really don't see the big deal with Big Ten giving ND a special deal. But instead of a non-football member with a football scheduling agreement, make them a full member with special conditions. ND only has to play 6 football conference games each year and can keep its own TV contract and own start times for home football games. Just to confirm, they're ineligible for the Big Ten championship? Because thats already what the ACC deal is except with fewer games. edit: And the reason not to, of course, is because then OSU will demand the same deal, then Michigan, then Penn State, etc, etc. RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - gosports1 - 09-30-2026 05:45 PM What would ND do if the P4 declared they were only playing each other? RE: What would the Big Ten do with respect to Notre Dame? - TerryD - 09-30-2026 05:46 PM (09-30-2026 05:00 PM)goofus Wrote: I really don't see the big deal with Big Ten giving ND a special deal. But instead of a non-football member with a football scheduling agreement, make them a full member with special conditions. ND only has to play 6 football conference games each year and can keep its own TV contract and own start times for home football games. ND has zero desire to be a full member of the Big Ten, "special deal" or not. Why can't people understand and accept this? |