CSNbbs
SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game (/thread-1033495.html)



SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - bullet - 09-28-2026 06:37 PM

https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/50052902/sec-says-vols-side-kick-vs-texas-penalty

Apparently none of the refs knew the rules. Tennessee violated two different ones. Tennessee apparently didn't know the rules either.


"An onside kick during last Saturday's Tennessee-Texas game that gave the Volunteers the ball with a chance to either tie or go ahead should have resulted in a penalty and retry of the kick, the SEC said on Monday....

"The onside kick with 1:22 to play in the Texas at Tennessee football game on Saturday was incorrectly officiated and should have resulted in a five-yard penalty on Tennessee and a replay of the down," the SEC said in a statement. "A drop kick is permissible, but a free kick must be made from the kicking team's restraining line which is the 35-yard line on a kickoff, unless relocated by penalty.

"The ball was at least one yard behind the 35-yard line when it was kicked. In addition, after the ball is ready for play the kicker may not change his lateral position between the hash marks. That spot can change only after a charged timeout or on a subsequent kick. The kicker movement after the ready signal violated the rule. The correct enforcement is a five-yard penalty and a replay of the down....""


RE: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - BirdHawkEagle - 09-28-2026 06:47 PM

I'm not sure why it matters now.

Tennessee lost.

This wasn't another Michigan vs. Western Michigan situation.


RE: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - Bear Catlett - 09-29-2026 07:54 AM

I wondered why Texas couldn’t manage to just recover it.


RE: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - AssKickingChicken - 09-29-2026 08:01 AM

(09-28-2026 06:47 PM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:  I'm not sure why it matters now.

Tennessee lost.

This wasn't another Michigan vs. Western Michigan situation.

So they shouldn’t investigate and call out misapplications of the rules if the error didn’t affect the outcome of the game?


RE: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - goofus - 09-29-2026 08:14 AM

I am not sure if I understand. Are they saying the kicker can't move at all from side to side? And the kick itself must be exactly from the 35 yard line?


RE: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - AssKickingChicken - 09-29-2026 08:19 AM

(09-29-2026 08:14 AM)goofus Wrote:  I am not sure if I understand. Are they saying the kicker can't move at all from side to side? And the kick itself must be exactly from the 35 yard line?

I have never seen a kickoff performed by a drop kick so I am unfamiliar with the rules but based on what I’ve read that seems to be the case.


RE: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - Keswick_Crusaders_Forever51 - 09-29-2026 09:41 AM

Wow, a conference admitting their refs messed something up? Maybe the Big Ten should take notes...


RE: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - bryanw1995 - 09-29-2026 09:50 AM

(09-28-2026 06:47 PM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:  I'm not sure why it matters now.

Tennessee lost.

This wasn't another Michigan vs. Western Michigan situation.

I think that it matters a lot. 2 officiating mistakes at the very end of games, one altered the outcome, one didn't. Let's learn from them both and prevent them from happening in the future.


RE: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - bullet - 09-29-2026 09:52 AM

https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/middle-tennessee-head-coach-derek-042323792.html
MTSU coach reprimanded for publicly criticizing officials. Sent tapes of 17 holding calls against Jacksonville St. not callled.
Seems like an odd thing to go public about. Holding calls can be made on every play and rarely are.

""...I just got off the phone with (Conference USA Associate Commissioner) Tre (Stallings). I just had some serious dialogue about the referre calls in this damn ballgame," Mason said. "I'm tired of the bulls**t. Excuse my French. I'm tired. At the end of the day man, we gotta get to a point where these damn referees show up and do their damn job. Okay, man, there's over 17 submitted holding calls against a really good Jax State team that were ready and available and they were at the point of confrontation. I thought it was straight up bull."

The Gamecocks were flagged three times for 30 penalties, while Mason's Blue Raiders committed seven penalties for 55 yards.

"I don't mind a loss, and I'm not one to ever get in front of the media and talk about these types of things," Mason said. "But at the end of the day, these referees have to be better. They have to do their damn job and be better. Okay, man, and that's the message going out to everybody who refs these damn games. Be better....""


RE: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - OdinFrigg - 09-30-2026 05:46 PM

The SEC refs at a South Carolina - LSU game a couple of years ago, did a horrible and highly biased job officiating. Their calls were blatantly favoring LSU and assured an LSU win. There was an abundance of questionable calls in the decisions that were in LSU’s behalf. I was physically at the game and had a very good view for most of it.


RE: SEC refs messed up onsides kick in Texas-Tennessee game - The Beaver - 09-30-2026 05:56 PM

(09-30-2026 05:46 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote:  The SEC refs at a South Carolina - LSU game a couple of years ago, did a horrible and highly biased job officiating. Their calls were blatantly favoring LSU and assured an LSU win. There was an abundance of questionable calls in the decisions that were in LSU’s behalf. I was physically at the game and had a very good view for most of it.

Hasn't LSU stolen that game two years in a row now?