CSNbbs
Why College Football is still cool - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: MACbbs (/forum-513.html)
+---- Forum: ☠️ Jolly Rogers ☠️ (/forum-463.html)
+----- Forum: Western Michigan (/forum-469.html)
+------ Forum: The Dan Burgardt Memorial Bronco Football Forum (/forum-489.html)
+------ Thread: Why College Football is still cool (/thread-1033294.html)



Why College Football is still cool - MajorHoople - 09-24-2026 09:29 AM

https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/football/the-illibuck-is-pointless-ridiculous-and-exactly-why-i-love-college-football/ar-AA2cTgsY?ocid=msedgntp&pc=DCTS&cvid=6ab514df39704715b38d1590e613f263&ei=37


RE: Why College Football is still cool - Motown Bronco - 10-15-2026 08:31 AM

I still love me some college football, and it's a large reason why I do look forward to fall Saturdays.

But I'm not gonna lie... NIL, transfer portal, whacked-out geography mega conferences, the widening 'wealth' gulf, longtime MAC members jumping ship... it's certainly taking its toll on my usual passion.


RE: Why College Football is still cool - ColinApocalypse - 10-15-2026 08:37 AM

(10-15-2026 08:31 AM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  I still love me some college football, and it's a large reason why I do look forward to fall Saturdays.

But I'm not gonna lie... NIL, transfer portal, whacked-out geography mega conferences, the widening 'wealth' gulf, longtime MAC members jumping ship... it's certainly taking its toll on my usual passion.

These are my feelings as well. All the things people loved about college football are being pushed to the wayside for the usual reasons....$$$$$


RE: Why College Football is still cool - BrewtownBronco - 10-15-2026 09:04 AM

(10-15-2026 08:37 AM)ColinApocalypse Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 08:31 AM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  I still love me some college football, and it's a large reason why I do look forward to fall Saturdays.

But I'm not gonna lie... NIL, transfer portal, whacked-out geography mega conferences, the widening 'wealth' gulf, longtime MAC members jumping ship... it's certainly taking its toll on my usual passion.

These are my feelings as well. All the things people loved about college football are being pushed to the wayside for the usual reasons....$$$$$

I'll double down and say I'm actually enjoying where WMU sits in the Div. I pecking order. Realistically, we (or any G5 team) weren't going to compete for a Natty in football. That could be said for 1980, 1999 or 2026. Our goal in most years was/is to win 8+ games, win the conference, and win a bowl game. This still remains mostly true for G5 schools even in today's wild west world.

This beats where most Power 4 teams are. For every Indiana, we can all point to 20 so-called Power 4 schools that have virtually no chance, anymore, at a conference championship let alone a playoff spot. This situation, in my opinion, is far worse than being highly competitive in the MAC (or Sun Belt, MWC, etc.) each year playing for SOMETHING at least.

Unrelated, screw CMU!!!


RE: Why College Football is still cool - Swagner - 10-15-2026 09:07 AM

Competing for MAC, Bowl Games, and giving P4 teams a scare here and there. That's plenty for me.


RE: Why College Football is still cool - BroncoFilly - 10-15-2026 09:53 AM

(10-15-2026 08:31 AM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  I still love me some college football, and it's a large reason why I do look forward to fall Saturdays.

But I'm not gonna lie... NIL, transfer portal, whacked-out geography mega conferences, the widening 'wealth' gulf, longtime MAC members jumping ship... it's certainly taking its toll on my usual passion.

Exactly. I watch WMU games because of my affiliation, but I don't watch major college football anymore. I do watch the occasional Div 2 or Div 3 games, where they still play for the fun of it.

BIG MONEY has wrecked college football, we saw that at Michigan Stadium.


RE: Why College Football is still cool - BroncoFilly - 10-15-2026 09:57 AM

(10-15-2026 09:04 AM)BrewtownBronco Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 08:37 AM)ColinApocalypse Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 08:31 AM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  I still love me some college football, and it's a large reason why I do look forward to fall Saturdays.

But I'm not gonna lie... NIL, transfer portal, whacked-out geography mega conferences, the widening 'wealth' gulf, longtime MAC members jumping ship... it's certainly taking its toll on my usual passion.

These are my feelings as well. All the things people loved about college football are being pushed to the wayside for the usual reasons....$$$$$

I'll double down and say I'm actually enjoying where WMU sits in the Div. I pecking order. Realistically, we (or any G5 team) weren't going to compete for a Natty in football. That could be said for 1980, 1999 or 2026. Our goal in most years was/is to win 8+ games, win the conference, and win a bowl game. This still remains mostly true for G5 schools even in today's wild west world.

This beats where most Power 4 teams are. For every Indiana, we can all point to 20 so-called Power 4 schools that have virtually no chance, anymore, at a conference championship let alone a playoff spot. This situation, in my opinion, is far worse than being highly competitive in the MAC (or Sun Belt, MWC, etc.) each year playing for SOMETHING at least.

Who needs all the grief that goes with following big time college football programs? The Wolverine fans are miserable these days and they went out and spent $ 12 Million on a 'sure thing' QB that hasn't panned-out. He won't transfer, why should he? He gets $ 3 million every season he stays with UM, even if he sits on the bench. People are laughing at them behind their backs and that's a storied program with a lot of history. That's what BIG MONEY does, it wrecks the character of a program.


RE: Why College Football is still cool - Motown Bronco - 10-15-2026 01:58 PM

We also need to consider that an expanded 24-team playoff is likely coming by the 2027 season (and yes, still only one G6 allowed). This will certainly have downstream implications on bowl games.


RE: Why College Football is still cool - Motown Bronco - 10-15-2026 01:58 PM

(10-15-2026 09:57 AM)BroncoFilly Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 09:04 AM)BrewtownBronco Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 08:37 AM)ColinApocalypse Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 08:31 AM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  I still love me some college football, and it's a large reason why I do look forward to fall Saturdays.

But I'm not gonna lie... NIL, transfer portal, whacked-out geography mega conferences, the widening 'wealth' gulf, longtime MAC members jumping ship... it's certainly taking its toll on my usual passion.

These are my feelings as well. All the things people loved about college football are being pushed to the wayside for the usual reasons....$$$$$

I'll double down and say I'm actually enjoying where WMU sits in the Div. I pecking order. Realistically, we (or any G5 team) weren't going to compete for a Natty in football. That could be said for 1980, 1999 or 2026. Our goal in most years was/is to win 8+ games, win the conference, and win a bowl game. This still remains mostly true for G5 schools even in today's wild west world.

This beats where most Power 4 teams are. For every Indiana, we can all point to 20 so-called Power 4 schools that have virtually no chance, anymore, at a conference championship let alone a playoff spot. This situation, in my opinion, is far worse than being highly competitive in the MAC (or Sun Belt, MWC, etc.) each year playing for SOMETHING at least.

Who needs all the grief that goes with following big time college football programs? The Wolverine fans are miserable these days and they went out and spent $ 12 Million on a 'sure thing' QB that hasn't panned-out. He won't transfer, why should he? He gets $ 3 million every season he stays with UM, even if he sits on the bench. People are laughing at them behind their backs and that's a storied program with a lot of history. That's what BIG MONEY does, it wrecks the character of a program.

I'm loving the Underwood saga as well.


RE: Why College Football is still cool - sdsly - 10-15-2026 04:05 PM

(10-15-2026 01:58 PM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  We also need to consider that an expanded 24-team playoff is likely coming by the 2027 season (and yes, still only one G6 allowed). This will certainly have downstream implications on bowl games.

It will probably eliminate conference championship games as well.


RE: Why College Football is still cool - Motown Bronco - 10-15-2026 04:06 PM

(10-15-2026 04:05 PM)sdsly Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 01:58 PM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  We also need to consider that an expanded 24-team playoff is likely coming by the 2027 season (and yes, still only one G6 allowed). This will certainly have downstream implications on bowl games.

It will probably eliminate conference championship games as well.

That part feels fuzzy. My hunch is definitely the P4s, but not sure about the G6 conferences.


RE: Why College Football is still cool - Nacho - 10-17-2026 11:45 AM

(10-15-2026 04:06 PM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 04:05 PM)sdsly Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 01:58 PM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  We also need to consider that an expanded 24-team playoff is likely coming by the 2027 season (and yes, still only one G6 allowed). This will certainly have downstream implications on bowl games.

It will probably eliminate conference championship games as well.

That part feels fuzzy. My hunch is definitely the P4s, but not sure about the G6 conferences.

Would a G6 conference really want to risk its top team losing in a conference championship game if that team is already positioned to earn a playoff spot?


RE: Why College Football is still cool - wmubroncopilot - 10-17-2026 12:14 PM

(10-17-2026 11:45 AM)Nacho Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 04:06 PM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 04:05 PM)sdsly Wrote:  
(10-15-2026 01:58 PM)Motown Bronco Wrote:  We also need to consider that an expanded 24-team playoff is likely coming by the 2027 season (and yes, still only one G6 allowed). This will certainly have downstream implications on bowl games.

It will probably eliminate conference championship games as well.

That part feels fuzzy. My hunch is definitely the P4s, but not sure about the G6 conferences.

Would a G6 conference really want to risk its top team losing in a conference championship game if that team is already positioned to earn a playoff spot?

If it’s up to the conference, I hope the MAC keeps the championship game. There’s an off chance it could hurt like you say but I don’t see that as worth losing the game that’s the biggest prize most years.


RE: Why College Football is still cool - Cocksman - 10-17-2026 01:22 PM

B1G is ruining college football. It all points to them with the big TV deals and them wanting more of their teams in the play-off. Hence now expanding to 24. What made college football great before was the debate, the regular sea season mattered, the rivalries. That’s all going away. Sad.