CSNbbs
Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html)
+---- Forum: American Conference Talk (/forum-409.html)
+---- Thread: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) (/thread-1033156.html)

Pages: 1 2


Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - B easy - 09-20-2026 03:25 PM

1. Tulsa 3-0
2. Memphis 3-1
3. South Florida 3-0 (1-0)
4. UTSA 2-1
5. Florida Atlantic 2-1 (1-0)
6. Tulane 1-2
7. East Carolina 1-2
8. Army 1-1 (0-1)
9. North Texas 1-2
10. Navy 1-1 (0-1)
11. Temple 1-2
12. UAB 1-2
13. Rice 1-2
14. UNCC 0-3


Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - pcm0103 - 09-20-2026 03:42 PM

Sorry I just don't see us at #7. #12 or #13 at best

Sent from my SM-S942U using Tapatalk


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - Sellular1 - 09-20-2026 05:43 PM

(09-20-2026 03:42 PM)pcm0103 Wrote:  Sorry I just don't see us at #7. #2 or #3 at best

Sent from my SM-S942U using Tapatalk

Definitely agree.


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - B easy - 09-20-2026 08:07 PM

I asked Gemini to average current FPI, Massey and Sagarin to create a top 10 G5 and to rank the American (looks like it is still giving too much weight to last season so far):

? Group of 5 (G5) Top 10 Consensus Rankings : This strictly filters the highest-rated G5 teams based on the verified data grids

1. Boise State 59.32
2. James Madison 65.03
3. New Mexico 71.74
4. North Dakota State 72.05
5. South Florida 72.36
6. Tulane 72.37
7. UTSA 77.08
8. Army West Point 77.31
9. Memphis 77.39
10. East Carolina 84.0

? American Athletic Conference (AAC)

1. South Florida
2. Tulane
3. UTSA
4. Army West Point
5. Memphis
6. East Carolina
7. Tulsa
8. North Texas
9. Navy
10. Temple
11. FAU
12. Rice
13. UAB
14. Charlotte


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - billybobby777 - 09-20-2026 09:47 PM

(09-20-2026 03:25 PM)B easy Wrote:  1. Tulsa 3-0
2. Memphis 3-1
3. South Florida 3-0 (1-0)
4. UTSA 2-1
5. Florida Atlantic 2-1 (1-0)
6. Tulane 1-2
7. East Carolina 1-2
8. Army 1-1 (0-1)
9. North Texas 1-2
10. Navy 1-1 (0-1)
11. Temple 1-2
12. UAB 1-2
13. Rice 1-2
14. UNCC 0-3

Teams 12-14 are way too high.


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - Frank Grimes - 09-20-2026 11:52 PM

(09-20-2026 09:47 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(09-20-2026 03:25 PM)B easy Wrote:  1. Tulsa 3-0
2. Memphis 3-1
3. South Florida 3-0 (1-0)
4. UTSA 2-1
5. Florida Atlantic 2-1 (1-0)
6. Tulane 1-2
7. East Carolina 1-2
8. Army 1-1 (0-1)
9. North Texas 1-2
10. Navy 1-1 (0-1)
11. Temple 1-2
12. UAB 1-2
13. Rice 1-2
14. UNCC 0-3

Teams 12-14 are way too high.

Can you make another post about who deserves the boot? I’m a little unclear on your stance.


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - gopirates11 - 09-21-2026 07:41 AM

lol ECU is no higher than 12th. With the way UNCC played against app state I could see them beating ECU as well


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - SFLFB - 09-21-2026 07:50 AM

(09-20-2026 08:07 PM)B easy Wrote:  I asked Gemini to average current FPI, Massey and Sagarin to create a top 10 G5 and to rank the American (looks like it is still giving too much weight to last season so far):

? Group of 5 (G5) Top 10 Consensus Rankings : This strictly filters the highest-rated G5 teams based on the verified data grids

1. Boise State 59.32
2. James Madison 65.03
3. New Mexico 71.74
4. North Dakota State 72.05
5. South Florida 72.36
6. Tulane 72.37
7. UTSA 77.08
8. Army West Point 77.31
9. Memphis 77.39
10. East Carolina 84.0

? American Athletic Conference (AAC)

1. South Florida
2. Tulane
3. UTSA
4. Army West Point
5. Memphis
6. East Carolina
7. Tulsa
8. North Texas
9. Navy
10. Temple
11. FAU
12. Rice
13. UAB
14. Charlotte

I think the jury is still out on USF. We certainly look disciplined and have a better roster (except receivers) from last season, but outside of Army (which will always be a good win in my book), we've played two softer teams with a third to come this weekend.

Also Tulsa is criminally low in these.

Mine:
Tulane
Tulsa
UTSA
Memphis
USF
Army
UNT
FAU
ECU
Temple
Navy
Rice
UAB
Charlotte


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - WTXOwl - 09-21-2026 08:35 AM

(09-20-2026 09:47 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(09-20-2026 03:25 PM)B easy Wrote:  1. Tulsa 3-0
2. Memphis 3-1
3. South Florida 3-0 (1-0)
4. UTSA 2-1
5. Florida Atlantic 2-1 (1-0)
6. Tulane 1-2
7. East Carolina 1-2
8. Army 1-1 (0-1)
9. North Texas 1-2
10. Navy 1-1 (0-1)
11. Temple 1-2
12. UAB 1-2
13. Rice 1-2
14. UNCC 0-3

Teams 12-14 are way too high.

07-coffee3 I'm sure you'll appreciate the following few games this season:
Rice at home
UAB in B'Ham
Temple at Home
Charlotte in Charlotte


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - Saint3333 - 09-21-2026 09:33 AM

(09-21-2026 07:41 AM)gopirates11 Wrote:  lol ECU is no higher than 12th. With the way UNCC played against app state I could see them beating ECU as well

ECU's QB isn't good, but UNCC's is terrible. ECU's dline should do well in that one and be the difference in the outcome.


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - Frank Grimes - 09-21-2026 09:51 AM

(09-21-2026 07:41 AM)gopirates11 Wrote:  lol ECU is no higher than 12th. With the way UNCC played against app state I could see them beating ECU as well

I think teams 7-12/13 are pretty interchangeable. I think it’s:

Tulsa

USF/NT/Memphis/UTSA

FAU

Most of the rest of us(maybe including Rice)

Charlotte


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - Pirate Rep - 09-21-2026 11:15 AM

ECU is not #7 as I type right now. More like 11 and that's just because of the defense. Our offensive passing attack is anemic. QB 1 went 4 of 12 passing vs ODU. Missed a wide open receiver badly inside the opponents 5 in the 4th quarter with the game on the line!!

Our best play on offense is punt. He's a weapon and our coverage has been great.

Until we figure out who we are offensively, we need to play defense, no turnovers, no stupid penalties, run the football playing field position win games 10 to 7.

It's that bad on offense, but the run is improving.05-stirthepot


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - Ned Low - 09-21-2026 11:58 AM

1. Memphis
2. Tulsa
3. UTSA
4. South Florida
5. Florida Atlantic
6. Tulane
7. North Texas
8. Army
9. East Carolina
10. Navy
11. Temple
12. Rice
13. UAB
14. UNCC

Memphis, Tulsa, UTSA and -to a lesser degree- USF are the class of the league so far. I don' t think that there's much difference between teams 5-13.

Charlotte is just bad.

Rice can absolutely beat Fresno State this upcoming weekend. That game, along with the Tulsa @ Arkansas game are the most intriguing of the week. Both of these games are toos-ups in my opinion.

I predict that Army and Navy will win their conference games. I think that the rest of the AC will win this weekend with the lone exception of Charlotte... who I think loses by 7-10 points to Louisiana at home.

Of note, UTSA beats Colorado State by three or more TDs on Saturday.


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - WTXOwl - 09-21-2026 12:40 PM

Week 3 made things a little murky, but as the great Muddy Waters sang, "I'm Ready"

1. South Florida - The South-ish Florida Greenies eventually pulled the stinger from Delaware State to remain 3-0.

2. Memphis - The River Cats defeated the Martins of Tennessee and get a week off.

3. UTSA - Meep Meep didn't take down Big Brother Bevo, but they are No 1 for a reason right now.

4. Tulane - Merely staying competitive against Power 4 Teams isn't what the Nola Greenies hoped for (or got used to over the past couple seasons), but the conference is still wide open.

5. Tulsa - The Gold Plated Storm is 3-0, but the wins are over Sam Houston and East-ish Texas A&M and the win over Oklahoma State is hard to judge; how flat were the No-Pokes?

6. FAU - The Atlantic-ish F-Owls took a beating from a Florida Man in Week 1, but have handled business against the Middies and International-ish Florida Man.

7. Army - A 1-1 Academy team with a win over an FCS and a loss to a team from Florida higher on this list . . . I give the edge to the Cadets based upon the Florida school of their defeat.

8. Navy - A 1-1 Academy team with a win over an FCS and a loss to a team from Florida higher on this list . . . I give the edge to the Cadets based upon the Florida school of their defeat.

9. North Texas - A loss to the State of Texas Nay-Cats was not a great look for the Conference. (Believe me, I get that a Rice fan is saying this . . . )

10. East Carolina - A win over the Not so Monarchs gets the Pirates into the win column, but not too high on this list.

11. Temple - The T-Owls traveled to Toledo, then tragedy. Twenty-One Tallies; Terminal Twenty-Five %. OT - Too much for the T-Owls

12. Rice - The R-Owls dropped their first ever game to Directional Michigan. The Parliament played respectable, but the remainder of the season without Quinton Jackson could be a long one indeed.

13. UAB - The Bammy Greenies were boiled in Cajun Country. Pass the Tony Chachere's.

14. Charlotte - The N. Car'lina Greenies decided to make sure the W. Car'lina Mounteers beat all Car'ina teams in the American.


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - TigerBill - 09-21-2026 05:25 PM

Memphis at 2 is too high. Our secondary is highly suspect. I'd say 4-5. Tulsa #1 until knocked off, USF #2.


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - Miami Pirate - 09-21-2026 05:37 PM

(09-20-2026 03:25 PM)B easy Wrote:  1. Tulsa 3-0
2. Memphis 3-1
3. South Florida 3-0 (1-0)
4. UTSA 2-1
5. Florida Atlantic 2-1 (1-0)
6. Tulane 1-2
7. East Carolina 1-2
8. Army 1-1 (0-1)
9. North Texas 1-2
10. Navy 1-1 (0-1)
11. Temple 1-2
12. UAB 1-2
13. Rice 1-2
14. UNCC 0-3

ECU 7? LMAO. Did you see the offensive display our offense has been showing? 12-13 at best.


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - msu35 - 09-21-2026 05:43 PM

(09-21-2026 05:25 PM)TigerBill Wrote:  Memphis at 2 is too high. Our secondary is highly suspect. I'd say 4-5. Tulsa #1 until knocked off, USF #2.

Memphis is too high at #2 because our secondary is suspect, but you're willing to rank USF #2 when their defense looks no better? Interesting take.


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - surrealpirate - 09-21-2026 05:52 PM

Hot take. I think UAB will end up being a decent team. Their first year coach will take some lumps but I have them going bowling this year.


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - surrealpirate - 09-21-2026 05:54 PM

(09-21-2026 05:37 PM)Miami Pirate Wrote:  
(09-20-2026 03:25 PM)B easy Wrote:  1. Tulsa 3-0
2. Memphis 3-1
3. South Florida 3-0 (1-0)
4. UTSA 2-1
5. Florida Atlantic 2-1 (1-0)
6. Tulane 1-2
7. East Carolina 1-2
8. Army 1-1 (0-1)
9. North Texas 1-2
10. Navy 1-1 (0-1)
11. Temple 1-2
12. UAB 1-2
13. Rice 1-2
14. UNCC 0-3

ECU 7? LMAO. Did you see the offensive display our offense has been showing? 12-13 at best.

Agreed. Our offense is more like 20 out of 14. Our defense is competent but I'm not willing to give them much more than that yet. I think the D gets us to 10 or 11ish barring a complete turnaround by our OC


RE: Rank the American (Sept. 20, 2026) - msu35 - 09-21-2026 06:17 PM

(09-21-2026 05:52 PM)surrealpirate Wrote:  Hot take. I think UAB will end up being a decent team. Their first year coach will take some lumps but I have them going bowling this year.

Not a hot take at all, and I agree with your conclusion. UAB isn't winning the conference this year, but I feel a bowl game is a very reasonable goal.