CSNbbs
Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? (/thread-1033071.html)

Pages: 1 2


Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - billybobby777 - 09-18-2026 04:37 PM

Would the rules allow this?:
Big 12:
POD WACS: Arizona, ASU, BYU, Utah
POD Big 8’s: Colorado, Oklahoma St, Kansas, Kansas St
POD SWC: Texas Tech, Baylor, TCU, Houston
POD Big East: Iowa St, Cincinnati, West Virginia, UCF

The Big 12 picks the 2 POD winners it wants out of the 4 and puts them in a CCG. This year it’s likely the winner of the POD WAC’s play on one side. Could the conference select which of the 3 POD winners of POD Big 8, SWC and Big East they wanted? Say BYU out of the POD WAC’s is the highest ranked and they want them to go against a POD winner they haven’t already played, so they choose a POD champ they haven’t played even if that’s not the 2nd highest ranked Big 12 team. Thoughts?


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - goofus - 09-18-2026 05:12 PM

I don't know why you want to limit your choices for scheduling and for the CCG if don't have to....

But if they were forced to go with pods, I would tweak them a little

4 corners
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col

Old Big 8
Iowa St, Kan, Kan St, Ok St

Southwest
TT, TCU, Bay, BYU

East
WV, Cincy, UCF, Hou


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - The Beaver - 09-18-2026 05:13 PM

Worse than the current system. If schools want to protect rivalries let them but there's no need for the rest of it.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - goofus - 09-18-2026 05:15 PM

Or if you go with 3 pods

West-5
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col, BYU

Central-6
Iowa St, Kan, Kan St, Ok St, TT, TCU

East-5
WV, Cincy, UCF, Hou, Bay


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - Crayton - 09-18-2026 05:49 PM

I think Divisions are great to make more “winners”; maybe have them tied to certain bowl slots or AQ spots if the playoff expands. But no reason to limit the CCG to division/pod champs.

This was my pitch when the SEC gathered OUT:
[Image: attachment.php?aid=11437]


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - goofus - 09-18-2026 06:43 PM

I am not a big fan of divisions or pods but if forced to, I would recommend these divisions for the Big Ten

East-6
Rut, MD, Penn St, Ohio St, Mich, Mich St

North-4
Wisc, Minn, Iowa, Neb

South-4
Ind, Pur, NW, ILL

West-4
Wash, Ore, USC, UCLA

Play everybody in your division every year
East plays everybody else 2 times in 6 years
Everybody else plays everybody else 3 times in 6 years.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - GoBuckeyes1047 - 09-18-2026 07:04 PM

Personally, I'm with Beaver and prefer a flex protect (protect who you want), but I would like to see everyone play everyone or mostly everyone H&H in 4 years and try to balance conference schedules as best as you can, and if desired, you could create defacto divisions that changes every year in terms of scheduling, not is not used in conference standings.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - billybobby777 - 09-19-2026 07:13 AM

(09-18-2026 05:12 PM)goofus Wrote:  I don't know why you want to limit your choices for scheduling and for the CCG if don't have to....

But if they were forced to go with pods, I would tweak them a little

4 corners
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col

Old Big 8
Iowa St, Kan, Kan St, Ok St

Southwest
TT, TCU, Bay, BYU

East
WV, Cincy, USF, Hou

You took BYU out of the POD WAC’s and put them in the SWC POD and Colorado in the POD WAC’s. Interesting. BYU is as POD WACK as they get.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - GoBuckeyes1047 - 09-19-2026 07:39 AM

(09-18-2026 05:12 PM)goofus Wrote:  I don't know why you want to limit your choices for scheduling and for the CCG if don't have to....

But if they were forced to go with pods, I would tweak them a little

4 corners
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col

Old Big 8
Iowa St, Kan, Kan St, Ok St

Southwest
TT, TCU, Bay, BYU

East
WV, Cincy, USF, Hou

I think I would do OSU in the SW or Big 12 south pod, Colorado in the Big 8 or B12 North pod, and BYU in the 4 corners or WAC pod personally, but I think if pods were ever used, it would be up to the teams, I don't think there is a clear correct answer. Also, I see the Big 12 traded UCF for USF lol 02-13-banana


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - goofus - 09-19-2026 07:53 AM

(09-19-2026 07:39 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 05:12 PM)goofus Wrote:  I don't know why you want to limit your choices for scheduling and for the CCG if don't have to....

But if they were forced to go with pods, I would tweak them a little

4 corners
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col

Old Big 8
Iowa St, Kan, Kan St, Ok St

Southwest
TT, TCU, Bay, BYU

East
WV, Cincy, USF, Hou

I think I would do OSU in the SW or Big 12 south pod, Colorado in the Big 8 or B12 North pod, and BYU in the 4 corners or WAC pod personally, but I think if pods were ever used, it would be up to the teams, I don't think there is a clear correct answer. Also, I see the Big 12 traded UCF for USF lol 02-13-banana

Yes, thanks, I fixed the UCF/USF mistake.

Putting Col in the 4 corners pods and BYU in the SW pod was more of a cultural thing, I guess. The 4C schools have similar institutional profiles and have recent history together in the Pac. BYU can hang out with other "religious schools" and the did share a conference with TCU for a little bit. Ok St could go either way but I figure they had a longer history with Big 8 schools.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - schmolik - 09-19-2026 08:13 AM

(09-19-2026 07:53 AM)goofus Wrote:  
(09-19-2026 07:39 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 05:12 PM)goofus Wrote:  I don't know why you want to limit your choices for scheduling and for the CCG if don't have to....

But if they were forced to go with pods, I would tweak them a little

4 corners
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col

Old Big 8
Iowa St, Kan, Kan St, Ok St

Southwest
TT, TCU, Bay, BYU

East
WV, Cincy, USF, Hou

I think I would do OSU in the SW or Big 12 south pod, Colorado in the Big 8 or B12 North pod, and BYU in the 4 corners or WAC pod personally, but I think if pods were ever used, it would be up to the teams, I don't think there is a clear correct answer. Also, I see the Big 12 traded UCF for USF lol 02-13-banana

Yes, thanks, I fixed the UCF/USF mistake.

Putting Col in the 4 corners pods and BYU in the SW pod was more of a cultural thing, I guess. The 4C schools have similar institutional profiles and have recent history together in the Pac. BYU can hang out with other "religious schools" and the did share a conference with TCU for a little bit. Ok St could go either way but I figure they had a longer history with Big 8 schools.

I would think the 4 Texas/SWC schools together makes the most sense.

Oklahoma State should be with the Texas schools but there are 4 of them already.

The dilemma is there are ...
5 Mountain Time Zone schools
5 Big 8 schools
3 schools East of the Mississippi

None of the other schools want to be stuck with the Eastern schools.

Of the Western schools, BYU is the only private school but you also don't want to break up BYU and Utah. Colorado could go with three of ISU, KSU, Kan, and OkSt and one of them gets shoved East (putting Colorado East not only punishes them but the Eastern schools).

I'd probably screw over Oklahoma State as they really have no remaining rivals.

The Big 12 is the only conference where 4 equal sized pods has a chance of working. The Big 10 and ACC don't work mathematically and the SEC can't form clean pods without breaking up established annual rivals (Alabama would want to play Tennessee annually while Auburn would want to play Georgia annually and you can't put those schools in with Alabama and Auburn without breaking up Georgia and Florida).


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - bullet - 09-19-2026 08:40 AM

(09-18-2026 05:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Worse than the current system. If schools want to protect rivalries let them but there's no need for the rest of it.

Yes. And the fewer teams you have in a division, the less likely you are to get the best teams. You are almost certain to get someone much weaker than the top 4.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - goofus - 09-19-2026 08:42 AM

(09-19-2026 08:13 AM)schmolik Wrote:  
(09-19-2026 07:53 AM)goofus Wrote:  
(09-19-2026 07:39 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 05:12 PM)goofus Wrote:  I don't know why you want to limit your choices for scheduling and for the CCG if don't have to....

But if they were forced to go with pods, I would tweak them a little

4 corners
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col

Old Big 8
Iowa St, Kan, Kan St, Ok St

Southwest
TT, TCU, Bay, BYU

East
WV, Cincy, USF, Hou

I think I would do OSU in the SW or Big 12 south pod, Colorado in the Big 8 or B12 North pod, and BYU in the 4 corners or WAC pod personally, but I think if pods were ever used, it would be up to the teams, I don't think there is a clear correct answer. Also, I see the Big 12 traded UCF for USF lol 02-13-banana

Yes, thanks, I fixed the UCF/USF mistake.

Putting Col in the 4 corners pods and BYU in the SW pod was more of a cultural thing, I guess. The 4C schools have similar institutional profiles and have recent history together in the Pac. BYU can hang out with other "religious schools" and the did share a conference with TCU for a little bit. Ok St could go either way but I figure they had a longer history with Big 8 schools.

I would think the 4 Texas/SWC schools together makes the most sense.

Oklahoma State should be with the Texas schools but there are 4 of them already.

The dilemma is there are ...
5 Mountain Time Zone schools
5 Big 8 schools
3 schools East of the Mississippi

None of the other schools want to be stuck with the Eastern schools.

Of the Western schools, BYU is the only private school but you also don't want to break up BYU and Utah. Colorado could go with three of ISU, KSU, Kan, and OkSt and one of them gets shoved East (putting Colorado East not only punishes them but the Eastern schools).

I'd probably screw over Oklahoma State as they really have no remaining rivals.

The Big 12 is the only conference where 4 equal sized pods has a chance of working. The Big 10 and ACC don't work mathematically and the SEC can't form clean pods without breaking up established annual rivals (Alabama would want to play Tennessee annually while Auburn would want to play Georgia annually and you can't put those schools in with Alabama and Auburn without breaking up Georgia and Florida).

I think you just summed up why nobody is doing pods.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - goofus - 09-19-2026 08:49 AM

(09-19-2026 08:13 AM)schmolik Wrote:  
(09-19-2026 07:53 AM)goofus Wrote:  
(09-19-2026 07:39 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 05:12 PM)goofus Wrote:  I don't know why you want to limit your choices for scheduling and for the CCG if don't have to....

But if they were forced to go with pods, I would tweak them a little

4 corners
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col

Old Big 8
Iowa St, Kan, Kan St, Ok St

Southwest
TT, TCU, Bay, BYU

East
WV, Cincy, UCF, Hou

I think I would do OSU in the SW or Big 12 south pod, Colorado in the Big 8 or B12 North pod, and BYU in the 4 corners or WAC pod personally, but I think if pods were ever used, it would be up to the teams, I don't think there is a clear correct answer. Also, I see the Big 12 traded UCF for USF lol 02-13-banana

Yes, thanks, I fixed the UCF/USF mistake.

Putting Col in the 4 corners pods and BYU in the SW pod was more of a cultural thing, I guess. The 4C schools have similar institutional profiles and have recent history together in the Pac. BYU can hang out with other "religious schools" and the did share a conference with TCU for a little bit. Ok St could go either way but I figure they had a longer history with Big 8 schools.

I would think the 4 Texas/SWC schools together makes the most sense.

Oklahoma State should be with the Texas schools but there are 4 of them already.

The dilemma is there are ...
5 Mountain Time Zone schools
5 Big 8 schools
3 schools East of the Mississippi

None of the other schools want to be stuck with the Eastern schools.

Of the Western schools, BYU is the only private school but you also don't want to break up BYU and Utah. Colorado could go with three of ISU, KSU, Kan, and OkSt and one of them gets shoved East (putting Colorado East not only punishes them but the Eastern schools).

I'd probably screw over Oklahoma State as they really have no remaining rivals.

The Big 12 is the only conference where 4 equal sized pods has a chance of working. The Big 10 and ACC don't work mathematically and the SEC can't form clean pods without breaking up established annual rivals (Alabama would want to play Tennessee annually while Auburn would want to play Georgia annually and you can't put those schools in with Alabama and Auburn without breaking up Georgia and Florida).

Maybe it would work better to just have simple East- West divisions

West-8
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col,
BYU, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St

East-8
OK St, TT, TCU, Bay,
Hou, WV, Cincy, UCF


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - schmolik - 09-19-2026 09:16 AM

(09-19-2026 08:49 AM)goofus Wrote:  
(09-19-2026 08:13 AM)schmolik Wrote:  
(09-19-2026 07:53 AM)goofus Wrote:  
(09-19-2026 07:39 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 05:12 PM)goofus Wrote:  I don't know why you want to limit your choices for scheduling and for the CCG if don't have to....

But if they were forced to go with pods, I would tweak them a little

4 corners
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col

Old Big 8
Iowa St, Kan, Kan St, Ok St

Southwest
TT, TCU, Bay, BYU

East
WV, Cincy, UCF, Hou

I think I would do OSU in the SW or Big 12 south pod, Colorado in the Big 8 or B12 North pod, and BYU in the 4 corners or WAC pod personally, but I think if pods were ever used, it would be up to the teams, I don't think there is a clear correct answer. Also, I see the Big 12 traded UCF for USF lol 02-13-banana

Yes, thanks, I fixed the UCF/USF mistake.

Putting Col in the 4 corners pods and BYU in the SW pod was more of a cultural thing, I guess. The 4C schools have similar institutional profiles and have recent history together in the Pac. BYU can hang out with other "religious schools" and the did share a conference with TCU for a little bit. Ok St could go either way but I figure they had a longer history with Big 8 schools.

I would think the 4 Texas/SWC schools together makes the most sense.

Oklahoma State should be with the Texas schools but there are 4 of them already.

The dilemma is there are ...
5 Mountain Time Zone schools
5 Big 8 schools
3 schools East of the Mississippi

None of the other schools want to be stuck with the Eastern schools.

Of the Western schools, BYU is the only private school but you also don't want to break up BYU and Utah. Colorado could go with three of ISU, KSU, Kan, and OkSt and one of them gets shoved East (putting Colorado East not only punishes them but the Eastern schools).

I'd probably screw over Oklahoma State as they really have no remaining rivals.

The Big 12 is the only conference where 4 equal sized pods has a chance of working. The Big 10 and ACC don't work mathematically and the SEC can't form clean pods without breaking up established annual rivals (Alabama would want to play Tennessee annually while Auburn would want to play Georgia annually and you can't put those schools in with Alabama and Auburn without breaking up Georgia and Florida).

Maybe it would work better to just have simple East- West divisions

West-8
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col,
BYU, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St

East-8
OK St, TT, TCU, Bay,
Hou, WV, Cincy, UCF

Then half of the conference would never get to visit Texas.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - Frank the Tank - 09-19-2026 09:21 AM

We crave order and natural divisions or pods.

I get it.

But we’re simply not ever going back to them. Not in the Big 12 or any other P4 conference. The media networks have made it clear that what they want is more brand name helmet games, and anything that artificially restricts the frequency of such games (such as forcing teams into divisions or pods) is a negative.

Plus, schools want to be able to play everyone in their league with frequency, as well. To the prior point, schools from the entire Big 12 want to play in Texas frequently. You certainly want to make sure all true rivalries are played annually, but forcing unnatural rivalries into pods or divisions simply shouldn’t happen in today’s environment.

Having said that, I do think all of the Texas-based old SWC schools should play annually and the Iowa State/Kansas/Kansas State trifecta should play annually, too. This is where a Big Ten-style flex protect format could come in where teams can have anywhere from 1-3 annual rivals. Play real rivalries, but don’t force annual games between teams where it’s just not meaningful.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - Jhawkinva - 09-19-2026 09:34 AM

This entire thread is a microaggression.

The obvious pods are:

Big 12 North - Colorado, Iowa St, Kansas, Kansas St

Big 12 South - Baylor, Oklahoma St, TCU, Texas Tech

Big East / American - Cincinnati, Houston, UCF, West Virginia

WAC - Arizona, Arizona St, BYU, Utah


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - Fighting Muskie - 09-19-2026 10:00 AM

Here’s how I’d do pods:

Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Colorado

Iowa St, Kansas, Kansas St, Okla St

Baylor, TCU, TTU, Houston

UCF, Cincinnati, WVU, and BYU

With BYU having a national fan base because of the LDS connection, putting them in a pod where they’d play in the Ohio River Valley (easily accessible from the Midwest, Upper South, and Northeast) annually and Orlando semi-annually gives them a connection to fans that might otherwise not fly to Provo for games.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - schmolik - 09-19-2026 10:03 AM

(09-19-2026 09:21 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  We crave order and natural divisions or pods.

I get it.

But we’re simply not ever going back to them. Not in the Big 12 or any other P4 conference. The media networks have made it clear that what they want is more brand name helmet games, and anything that artificially restricts the frequency of such games (such as forcing teams into divisions or pods) is a negative.

Plus, schools want to be able to play everyone in their league with frequency, as well. To the prior point, schools from the entire Big 12 want to play in Texas frequently. You certainly want to make sure all true rivalries are played annually, but forcing unnatural rivalries into pods or divisions simply shouldn’t happen in today’s environment.

Having said that, I do think all of the Texas-based old SWC schools should play annually and the Iowa State/Kansas/Kansas State trifecta should play annually, too. This is where a Big Ten-style flex protect format could come in where teams can have anywhere from 1-3 annual rivals. Play real rivalries, but don’t force annual games between teams where it’s just not meaningful.

I agree with you.

The Big Ten, ACC, and Big 12 agree with you.

The SEC? Three permanent rivals per team and Alabama gets Mississippi State annually instead of LSU. Granted that decision was made before Lane Kiffin became the head coach. Now it looks really idiotic for Bama and LSU to not meet annually.


RE: Could PODS work for the big 12 in a CCG? - Fighting Muskie - 09-19-2026 10:04 AM

(09-19-2026 09:21 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  We crave order and natural divisions or pods.

I get it.

But we’re simply not ever going back to them. Not in the Big 12 or any other P4 conference. The media networks have made it clear that what they want is more brand name helmet games, and anything that artificially restricts the frequency of such games (such as forcing teams into divisions or pods) is a negative.

Plus, schools want to be able to play everyone in their league with frequency, as well. To the prior point, schools from the entire Big 12 want to play in Texas frequently. You certainly want to make sure all true rivalries are played annually, but forcing unnatural rivalries into pods or divisions simply shouldn’t happen in today’s environment.

Having said that, I do think all of the Texas-based old SWC schools should play annually and the Iowa State/Kansas/Kansas State trifecta should play annually, too. This is where a Big Ten-style flex protect format could come in where teams can have anywhere from 1-3 annual rivals. Play real rivalries, but don’t force annual games between teams where it’s just not meaningful.

And pods are a relatively simple way to ensure everyone gets to play their rivals and give a semblance of an ordered, predictable, and balanced schedule.