CSNbbs
Massey Composite Rankings - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html)
+---- Forum: American Conference Talk (/forum-409.html)
+---- Thread: Massey Composite Rankings (/thread-1032965.html)

Pages: 1 2


Massey Composite Rankings - Cubanbull1 - 09-16-2026 09:16 AM

After Week 2 here are the Top 20
1. Boise 1-1 #38
2. JMU 2-0 #43
3. USF 2-0 #46
4. North Texas 1-1 #49

5. New Mexico 2-0 #56

6. North Dakota St 2-0 #59
7.UTSA 2-0 #60
8. W.Michigan 1-1 #65
9.Tulane 1–1 #66
10. Memphis 2-1 #68

11. Army 1-1 #71

12. Fresno 1-1 #73
13. SDSU 1-1 #74
14. Toledo 1-1 #76
15. Navy 1-1 #77

16. ODU 1-1 #79
17. App State 2-0 #81
18. ECU 0-2 #83
19. UNLV 1-2 #84
20. Tulsa 2-0 #85

Still early and effects from last season are still weighing on many polls.

In Top 5
2 American Schools
1 PAC
1 MWC
1 SBC

In Top 10
5 American
2 MWC
1 PAC
1 SBC
1 MAC

In Top 20
9 American
3 PAC
3 MWC
3 SBC
2 MAC


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - b2b - 09-16-2026 09:20 AM

Just shows how worthless the Massey Composite really is. Having ECU over Tulsa, UNT over Memphis/UTSA is idiotic.


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - SFLFB - 09-16-2026 09:33 AM

(09-16-2026 09:20 AM)b2b Wrote:  Just shows how worthless the Massey Composite really is. Having ECU over Tulsa, UNT over Memphis/UTSA is idiotic.

I mean, it's a composite of like 20+ rankings.

FWIW, here are Massey's individual rankings:
43 Boise
47 USF
51 JMU
58 UNT
63 NDSU
64 UTSA
65 Memphis
66 Tulane
70 Washington St
74 New Mexico
75 Fresno St
76 App St
78 Toledo
79 Army
80 Tulsa
81 SDSU
82 UNLV
85 WMU
86 Colorado St
87 Ohio

(ECU 90, Navy 91, FAU 98, Temple 99 also inside top 100)


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - BeatNavy - 09-16-2026 12:34 PM

(09-16-2026 09:33 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 09:20 AM)b2b Wrote:  Just shows how worthless the Massey Composite really is. Having ECU over Tulsa, UNT over Memphis/UTSA is idiotic.

I mean, it's a composite of like 20+ rankings.

FWIW, here are Massey's individual rankings:
43 Boise
47 USF
51 JMU
58 UNT
63 NDSU
64 UTSA
65 Memphis
66 Tulane
70 Washington St
74 New Mexico
75 Fresno St
76 App St
78 Toledo
79 Army
80 Tulsa
81 SDSU
82 UNLV
85 WMU
86 Colorado St
87 Ohio

(ECU 90, Navy 91, FAU 98, Temple 99 also inside top 100)

The composite is a bit of a mess this early in the season though. Many systems are still giving weight to results from previous seasons, which makes even less sense in 2026 than it did in 2016.


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - Cubanbull1 - 09-16-2026 01:12 PM

(09-16-2026 12:34 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 09:33 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 09:20 AM)b2b Wrote:  Just shows how worthless the Massey Composite really is. Having ECU over Tulsa, UNT over Memphis/UTSA is idiotic.

I mean, it's a composite of like 20+ rankings.

FWIW, here are Massey's individual rankings:
43 Boise
47 USF
51 JMU
58 UNT
63 NDSU
64 UTSA
65 Memphis
66 Tulane
70 Washington St
74 New Mexico
75 Fresno St
76 App St
78 Toledo
79 Army
80 Tulsa
81 SDSU
82 UNLV
85 WMU
86 Colorado St
87 Ohio

(ECU 90, Navy 91, FAU 98, Temple 99 also inside top 100)

The composite is a bit of a mess this early in the season though. Many systems are still giving weight to results from previous seasons, which makes even less sense in 2026 than it did in 2016.

Yes I mentioned it in the starting post. Anyways is just another poll, the only one that really will matter is the CFP one


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - Side.Show.Joe - 09-16-2026 01:37 PM

(09-16-2026 09:20 AM)b2b Wrote:  Just shows how worthless the Massey Composite really is. Having ECU over Tulsa, UNT over Memphis/UTSA is idiotic.

It will all get settled on the field.


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - Volkmar - 09-16-2026 01:39 PM

(09-16-2026 09:20 AM)b2b Wrote:  Just shows how worthless the Massey Composite really is. Having ECU over Tulsa, UNT over Memphis/UTSA is idiotic.

ECU over Tulsa is a bit surprising. I think that UNT over Memphis and UTSA is fair. UNT and Memphis faced a common opponent in UNLV with a large discrepancy in the outcomes. Memphis lost to Boise State and beat Ark. State while UNT lost to the national champions in their other games. UNT actually was even with Indiana in yards and first downs though. The score wasn’t an accurate reflection of how well UNT played. It was a two-score game (31-16) heading into the 4th before Indy pulled away.

And I think that UNT’s blowout o UNLV was far more impressive than UTSA’s narrow win over TXST. I think you’ll find that UNT will beat TXST much more handily this weekend than we did. They’ve just shown themselves to be a stronger and more balanced team so far.


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - virgosports - 09-17-2026 12:30 PM

(09-16-2026 01:39 PM)Volkmar Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 09:20 AM)b2b Wrote:  Just shows how worthless the Massey Composite really is. Having ECU over Tulsa, UNT over Memphis/UTSA is idiotic.

ECU over Tulsa is a bit surprising. I think that UNT over Memphis and UTSA is fair. UNT and Memphis faced a common opponent in UNLV with a large discrepancy in the outcomes. Memphis lost to Boise State and beat Ark. State while UNT lost to the national champions in their other games. UNT actually was even with Indiana in yards and first downs though. The score wasn’t an accurate reflection of how well UNT played. It was a two-score game (31-16) heading into the 4th before Indy pulled away.

And I think that UNT’s blowout o UNLV was far more impressive than UTSA’s narrow win over TXST. I think you’ll find that UNT will beat TXST much more handily this weekend than we did. They’ve just shown themselves to be a stronger and more balanced team so far.

I dont have an issue with UNT over Memphis. Had Memphis been a lot closet to Boise with a very close loss - maybe there can be more of a debate at that point. Now Tulsa in my mind should be significantly higher.


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - Tiger1983 - 09-17-2026 01:55 PM

(09-17-2026 12:30 PM)virgosports Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 01:39 PM)Volkmar Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 09:20 AM)b2b Wrote:  Just shows how worthless the Massey Composite really is. Having ECU over Tulsa, UNT over Memphis/UTSA is idiotic.

ECU over Tulsa is a bit surprising. I think that UNT over Memphis and UTSA is fair. UNT and Memphis faced a common opponent in UNLV with a large discrepancy in the outcomes. Memphis lost to Boise State and beat Ark. State while UNT lost to the national champions in their other games. UNT actually was even with Indiana in yards and first downs though. The score wasn’t an accurate reflection of how well UNT played. It was a two-score game (31-16) heading into the 4th before Indy pulled away.

And I think that UNT’s blowout o UNLV was far more impressive than UTSA’s narrow win over TXST. I think you’ll find that UNT will beat TXST much more handily this weekend than we did. They’ve just shown themselves to be a stronger and more balanced team so far.

I dont have an issue with UNT over Memphis. Had Memphis been a lot closet to Boise with a very close loss - maybe there can be more of a debate at that point. Now Tulsa in my mind should be significantly higher.

Agree.


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - otown - 09-18-2026 03:09 PM

I think Oregon just isn't that good this year. They literally lost to Okie State, who are not projected to be good at all. As the year goes on, the luster of that close loss will wear off and Boise will drop.


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - panicstricken - 09-20-2026 02:54 PM

Makes Zero Sense

We beat Okie State

USF beat FIU and Army


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - quo vadis - 09-21-2026 07:02 AM

FWIW I love the MC, but I ignore all computer rankings until about week 6. Before then a lot of computers use "filler" data from last year or something to generate enough data points to do their calculations.


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - SFLFB - 09-21-2026 07:45 AM

Post week 3 MC rankings -

39 JMU
45 Boise
46 USF
58 New Mexico
60 NDSU
62 UTSA
63 W Michigan
64 Tulane
65 Army
66 Memphis
70 Fresno St
71 UNT
72 Tulsa
73 Toledo
76 Navy
79 ECU


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - BeatNavy - 09-21-2026 01:51 PM

I don't know what criteria Massey uses for inclusion in the composite, but among the 34 systems being used right now, Tulsa is a high as 6th and as low as 107th -- four other systems have them 100th or lower

Navy is 45th to 117th (two have them 117th) and Temple is 59th to 117th


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - Cubanbull1 - 09-21-2026 02:07 PM

(09-21-2026 01:51 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  I don't know what criteria Massey uses for inclusion in the composite, but among the 34 systems being used right now, Tulsa is a high as 6th and as low as 107th -- four other systems have them 100th or lower

Navy is 45th to 117th (two have them 117th) and Temple is 59th to 117th

If you look at their Consensus rank, it gives you an idea on spread
https://masseyratings.com/ranks?s=cf&top=-9


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - BeatNavy - 09-21-2026 02:27 PM

(09-21-2026 02:07 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(09-21-2026 01:51 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  I don't know what criteria Massey uses for inclusion in the composite, but among the 34 systems being used right now, Tulsa is a high as 6th and as low as 107th -- four other systems have them 100th or lower

Navy is 45th to 117th (two have them 117th) and Temple is 59th to 117th

If you look at their Consensus rank, it gives you an idea on spread
https://masseyratings.com/ranks?s=cf&top=-9

Yes, that falls directly out of the numbers I cited

The spread on Tulsa is ridiculous, the spreads on Navy and Temple are silly

oh, and the spread on Charlotte is reasonable even though it is larger than the spread on Temple


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - Cubanbull1 - 09-21-2026 04:34 PM

(09-21-2026 02:27 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  
(09-21-2026 02:07 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(09-21-2026 01:51 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  I don't know what criteria Massey uses for inclusion in the composite, but among the 34 systems being used right now, Tulsa is a high as 6th and as low as 107th -- four other systems have them 100th or lower

Navy is 45th to 117th (two have them 117th) and Temple is 59th to 117th

If you look at their Consensus rank, it gives you an idea on spread
https://masseyratings.com/ranks?s=cf&top=-9

Yes, that falls directly out of the numbers I cited

The spread on Tulsa is ridiculous, the spreads on Navy and Temple are silly

oh, and the spread on Charlotte is reasonable even though it is larger than the spread on Temple

I think a lot has to do with that after only 3 games many of the polls are taking last years results with more weight. That should change slowly as season progresses.
The biggest gaps would be in teams doing much better than last year or much worse.


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - steves - 09-21-2026 09:44 PM

Memphis beats Charlotte. Just too much offense and defense is coming around. Only way we loose is if our QB gets taken out. Marcus Stokes is a dealer playing with a stacked deck. Sorry Charlie !!


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - BeatNavy - 09-21-2026 10:32 PM

(09-21-2026 04:34 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(09-21-2026 02:27 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  
(09-21-2026 02:07 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(09-21-2026 01:51 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  I don't know what criteria Massey uses for inclusion in the composite, but among the 34 systems being used right now, Tulsa is a high as 6th and as low as 107th -- four other systems have them 100th or lower

Navy is 45th to 117th (two have them 117th) and Temple is 59th to 117th

If you look at their Consensus rank, it gives you an idea on spread
https://masseyratings.com/ranks?s=cf&top=-9

Yes, that falls directly out of the numbers I cited

The spread on Tulsa is ridiculous, the spreads on Navy and Temple are silly

oh, and the spread on Charlotte is reasonable even though it is larger than the spread on Temple

I think a lot has to do with that after only 3 games many of the polls are taking last years results with more weight. That should change slowly as season progresses.
The biggest gaps would be in teams doing much better than last year or much worse.

And in this era of free agency, those systems that rely on previous season(s) results should just not publish rankings until they are clear of historical influence

Just as there should be no preseason AP or coaches poll....


RE: Massey Composite Rankings - Cubanbull1 - 09-21-2026 10:41 PM

(09-21-2026 10:32 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  
(09-21-2026 04:34 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(09-21-2026 02:27 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  
(09-21-2026 02:07 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(09-21-2026 01:51 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  I don't know what criteria Massey uses for inclusion in the composite, but among the 34 systems being used right now, Tulsa is a high as 6th and as low as 107th -- four other systems have them 100th or lower

Navy is 45th to 117th (two have them 117th) and Temple is 59th to 117th

If you look at their Consensus rank, it gives you an idea on spread
https://masseyratings.com/ranks?s=cf&top=-9

Yes, that falls directly out of the numbers I cited

The spread on Tulsa is ridiculous, the spreads on Navy and Temple are silly

oh, and the spread on Charlotte is reasonable even though it is larger than the spread on Temple

I think a lot has to do with that after only 3 games many of the polls are taking last years results with more weight. That should change slowly as season progresses.
The biggest gaps would be in teams doing much better than last year or much worse.

And in this era of free agency, those systems that rely on previous season(s) results should just not publish rankings until they are clear of historical influence

Just as there should be no preseason AP or coaches poll....

Anyways is just another ranking system at the end the only one that matters is the CFP poll at the end that says who gets playoff spot.