![]() |
|
Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada (/thread-1032955.html) Pages: 1 2 |
Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - AllTideUp - 09-16-2026 12:16 AM I like enchiladas. They're versatile. They're delicious in many ways and actually quite simple at the same time. Enchiladas are college football. They are meaty, delectable, and come in a variety of flavors. Want to know one of the best things about enchiladas? They're small and you can consume several in a single sitting. They're made in large batches and baked together to enhance the goodness. Batches of enchiladas are like conferences. They're large and taste best when properly blended with similar creations. The following is the buffet at the local gourmet enchilada kitchen. Enjoy! BEHOLD! YOUR POWER TWO! SEC(22): Texas, Texas A&M, Oklahoma, Missouri, Arkansas, LSU, Ole Miss, Mississippi State, Alabama, Auburn, Florida, Florida State, Miami, Georgia, South Carolina, Clemson, Kentucky, Vanderbilt, Tennessee, Virginia, North Carolina, Duke Big Ten(22): Georgia Tech, Penn State, Rutgers, Maryland, Michigan, Michigan State, Ohio State, Notre Dame, Indiana, Purdue, Illinois, Northwestern, Nebraska, Iowa, Minnesota, Wisconsin, USC, UCLA, Stanford, California, Oregon, Washington BEHOLD! YOUR MIDDLE TIER! ACC(16): Boston College, UConn, Syracuse, Pittsburgh, West Virginia, Cincinnati, Louisville, Virginia Tech, NC State, Wake Forest, UCF, USF, Tulane, Memphis, SMU, Houston Big 12(16): Iowa State, Kansas, Kansas State, Oklahoma State, TCU, Baylor, Texas Tech, Colorado, Utah, BYU, Arizona, Arizona State, Washington State, Oregon State, Boise State, San Diego State *Each conference champion in the P2 and Middle Tier are guaranteed entry into the CFP. BEHOLD! YOUR MID-MAJORS! SWC(10): Tulsa, Texas State, UTEP, UTSA, Tarleton State, Sam Houston State, Stephen F. Austin, Rice, North Texas, New Mexico State PAC 12(12): Hawaii, Nevada, UNLV, Utah State, Colorado State, Air Force, Wyoming, New Mexico, Sacramento State, San Jose State, Fresno State, UC Davis The American(10): North Dakota State, Northern Illinois, Missouri State, UMass, Army, Navy, Temple, UAB, East Carolina, Marshall Sun Belt(10): Louisiana Tech, Louisiana, UL-Monroe, Arkansas State, Western Kentucky, MTSU, Southern Miss, South Alabama, Troy, Jacksonville State Conference USA(12): Florida Atlantic, Florida International, Georgia Southern, Georgia State, Kennesaw State, Coastal Carolina, Charlotte, Appalachian State, James Madison, Old Dominion, Liberty, Delaware MAC(10): Ball State, Western Michigan, Central Michigan, Eastern Michigan, Ohio, Miami of Ohio, Bowling Green, Toledo, Akron, Kent State *The conference champions from each of the 6 Mid-Major leagues will meet for a series of play-in games. 6 champs, 3 games, 3 winners play into the CFP. The match-ups are determined by a random drawing. CFP of 24 schools. Not that I'm a big fan of this 24 school idea, but it does look like it's going to happen at this point. So you've got P2 champs, Middle Tier champs, and 3 Mid-Major champs. That's 7 automatic entrants. The other 17 schools are picked by a committee. The schools are seeded and then we get to playin'. All games are on-campus(or a nearby facility) and played at the higher seed until the championship game. That's the only true neutral site game. It can be bid out annually to a different site if the CFP so chooses. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - 46566 - 09-16-2026 12:52 AM I'm curious why 22 teams? Wouldn't 20 work with 4 pods of 5 for scheduling work better for the P2? Shift 4 back to the M2 for 18 each. I can see bottom tier conference going to 12. Bowl season still happens as a zombie version of itself with games Weekdays while CFP are probably Friday Saturday RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - Scoochpooch1 - 09-16-2026 07:32 AM I thought fantasy posts where limited to offseason? RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - DFW HOYA - 09-16-2026 07:55 AM (09-16-2026 12:16 AM)AllTideUp Wrote: BEHOLD! Where this is all headed: SEC: Texas, Texas A&M, Oklahoma, Missouri, Arkansas, LSU, Ole Miss, Big Ten: RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - billybobby777 - 09-16-2026 08:02 AM (09-16-2026 12:16 AM)AllTideUp Wrote: I like enchiladas. They're versatile. They're delicious in many ways and actually quite simple at the same time. Enchiladas are college football. They are meaty, delectable, and come in a variety of flavors. I like my enchiladas stirred, not shaken. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - billybobby777 - 09-16-2026 08:08 AM (09-16-2026 12:16 AM)AllTideUp Wrote: I like enchiladas. They're versatile. They're delicious in many ways and actually quite simple at the same time. Enchiladas are college football. They are meaty, delectable, and come in a variety of flavors. So is Buffalo playing as an independent in this scenario? RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - Side.Show.Joe - 09-16-2026 08:27 AM (09-16-2026 12:16 AM)AllTideUp Wrote: I like enchiladas. They're versatile. They're delicious in many ways and actually quite simple at the same time. Enchiladas are college football. They are meaty, delectable, and come in a variety of flavors. North Texas is a rising program and appears to be among the best G programs. UNT has raised the financial commitment and managed to replace a successful head coach with another successful head coach, and could challenge for a Playoff spot for the second year in a row. North Texas would never settle for mid-major status while fellow American programs like Memphis, USF, & Tulane get elevated to the middle tier. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - ken d - 09-16-2026 09:22 AM As long as we're fantasizing, I like my enchiladas capped at 20 to a conference. Teams that change conferences shown in bold. SEC: Alabama, Arkansas, Auburn, Duke, Florida, Georgia, Kansas, Kentucky, LSU, Mississippi State, Missouri, Oklahoma, Ole Miss, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Texas A&M, UNC, Vanderbilt, Virginia. B1G: California, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Maryland, Michigan, Michigan State, Minnesota, Nebraska, Northwestern, Ohio State, Oregon, Penn State, Purdue, Rutgers, Stanford, UCLA, USC, Washington, Wisconsin. Big 12: Arizona, Arizona State, Baylor, Boise State, BYU, Colorado, Fresno State, Houston, Iowa State, Kansas State, Memphis, Oklahoma State, Oregon State, San Diego State, TCU, Texas Tech, Utah, Washington State. ACC: Boston College, Cincinnati, Clemson, Florida State, Georgia Tech, James Madison, Louisville, Miami, NC State, Pitt, SMU, Syracuse, Tulane, UCF, USF, Virginia Tech, Wake Forest, West Virginia. *************************************************************** In the interest of inclusiveness, I would give the SEC and B1G autobids to the CFP to the Top 4 finishers in their conference standing, and give the Big 12 and ACC bids to their Top 3. The regular season winners of the (now) G5 also get autobids. A seeding committee adds 5 at large teams (which could include Notre Dame). In the first week of December, the 9th seeded team hosts the #24 seed and so on through #16 hosting #17. In the second and third weeks, the Top 8 seeds host the first round winners, with the winners advancing to the QF round at New Year's. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - Blust3 - 09-16-2026 10:41 AM (09-16-2026 12:52 AM)46566 Wrote: I'm curious why 22 teams? Wouldn't 20 work with 4 pods of 5 for scheduling work better for the P2? Shift 4 back to the M2 for 18 each. I can see bottom tier conference going to 12. Bowl season still happens as a zombie version of itself with games Weekdays while CFP are probably Friday Saturday PCSA will likely pass. The conference will be capped at 19. Most will choose 18. B1G will not add more. SEC will likely add two. I think SEC will choose footprint expansion. Choose two from Colorado, Utah, Arizona, UNC and Virginia. They can choose Colorado, Utah and Arizona and go to 19 as they don't have to wait for Notre Dame. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - indianasniff - 09-16-2026 11:25 AM MAC should include Buffalo and UMass RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - SFLFB - 09-16-2026 11:32 AM (09-16-2026 09:22 AM)ken d Wrote: As long as we're fantasizing, I like my enchiladas capped at 20 to a conference. Teams that change conferences shown in bold. Hmm these enchiladas look enticing, although if the ACC were to snag a few enchiladas from the B12, I'd prefer one of them be Houston or TCU (instead of JMU). Then the B12 adds UNLV. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - goofus - 09-16-2026 01:00 PM If we start with the assumption that the ACC loses 10 members to the P2, then I think at that point the remaining 8 ACC schools will be begging the Big 12 to join. So let me paint an alternate version YOUR POWER TWO! SEC(22): Texas, Texas A&M, Oklahoma, Missouri, Arkansas, LSU, Ole Miss, Mississippi State, Alabama, Auburn, Florida, Florida State, Miami, Georgia, South Carolina, Clemson, Kentucky, Vanderbilt, Tennessee, Virginia, North Carolina, Duke Big Ten(22): Georgia Tech, Penn State, Rutgers, Maryland, Michigan, Michigan State, Ohio State, Notre Dame, Indiana, Purdue, Illinois, Northwestern, Nebraska, Iowa, Minnesota, Wisconsin, USC, UCLA, Stanford, California, Oregon, Washington BEHOLD! YOUR MIDDLE TIER! Big 12(24): Iowa State, Kansas, Kansas State, Oklahoma State, TCU, Baylor, Texas Tech, Colorado, Utah, BYU, Arizona, Arizona State, UCF, West Virginia, Cincinnati, Houston, Syracuse, Pittsburgh, West Virginia, Louisville, Virginia Tech, NC State, UConn, USF *Each conference champion in the P2 and Middle Tier are guaranteed entry into the CFP. BEHOLD! YOUR new G6! ACC(14): Boston College, Wake Forest, UMass, Army, Navy, Temple, Buffalo, James Madison, Old Dominion, Delaware, East Carolina, UAB, Tulsa, FAU PAC 12(16): Washington State, Oregon State, Boise State, San Diego State, Fresno State , Utah State, Colorado State, Texas St , SMU, Tulane, Memphis, Rice, UTSA, UNT, UNLV, New Mexico MWC(10) Hawaii, Nevada, Air Force, Wyoming, Sacramento State, San Jose State, UC Davis, UTEP, North Dakota State, Northern Illinois The American(11): Marshall, Liberty, Western Kentucky, MTSU, Florida International, Georgia Southern, Georgia State, Kennesaw State, Coastal Carolina, Charlotte, Appalachian State Sun Belt(13): Louisiana Tech, Louisiana, UL-Monroe, Arkansas State, , Southern Miss, South Alabama, Troy, Jacksonville State, Tarleton State, Sam Houston State, Stephen F. Austin, New Mexico State, Missouri State Conference USA(0): MAC(10): Ball State, Western Michigan, Central Michigan, Eastern Michigan, Ohio, Miami of Ohio, Bowling Green, Toledo, Akron, Kent State RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - BePcr07 - 09-16-2026 04:40 PM Networks get involved even more and make some decisions. > 4 Tier I conferences in a P2/M2 setup with no independents. > Schools currently in the P2 will stay in the P2 but the M2 will do some geographic reshuffling. > The conferences will sit at 22 schools each. No conference championship game. > 24-school playoff: P2 (4 autobids each), M2 (2 autobids each), At-Large (12 bids). > They take their membership input directly from BePcr07. --------------------------------- - The B1G lands Notre Dame who demands Stanford and access to Florida which the B1G grants in adding Miami. That expansion trio is rounded out with California. - The SEC nabs the big two historical ACC football brands in Clemson and Florida St then finishes off basketball with Duke, Kansas, North Carolina, and Virginia. - The ACC takes a more Eastern approach while the XII takes a more Western approach. --------------------------------- 4x22: --------------------------------- B1G California, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Maryland, Miami, Michigan, Michigan St, Minnesota, Nebraska, Northwestern, Notre Dame, Ohio St, Oregon, Penn St, Purdue, Rutgers, Stanford, UCLA, USC, Washington, Wisconsin SEC Alabama, Arkansas, Auburn, Clemson, Duke, Florida, Florida St, Georgia, Kansas, Kentucky, LSU, Mississippi, Mississippi St, Missouri, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Texas A&M, Virginia, Vanderbilt --------------------------------- ACC Army, Boston College, Central Florida, Cincinnati, Connecticut, East Carolina, Georgia Tech, Louisville, Memphis, Navy, North Carolina St, Pittsburgh, Rice, SMU, South Florida, Southern Miss, Syracuse, Temple, Tulane, Virginia Tech, Wake Forest, West Virginia XII Air Force, Arizona, Arizona St, Baylor, Boise St, BYU, Colorado, Colorado St, Fresno St, Houston, Iowa St, Kansas St, Oklahoma St, Oregon St, San Diego St, TCU, Texas Tech, Tulsa, UNLV, Utah, UTSA, Washington St --------------------------------- Playoffs based on 2025 final CFP rankings. Autobids: B1G - Indiana, Ohio St, Oregon, Miami SEC - Georgia, Mississippi, Texas A&M, Oklahoma ACC - Tulane, Georgia Tech XII - Texas Tech, BYU At-Large Bids: Alabama, Notre Dame, Texas, Vanderbilt, Utah, USC, Arizona, Michigan, Virginia, Houston, Iowa, Navy* * Not enough teams in CFP poll. Highest ranked team in AP poll that isn't in the field. Bids by Conference 8 - B1G, SEC 5 - XII 3 - ACC Second Round (First Round) - Home Site to Higher Ranked School #1 Indiana vs (#24 Navy @ #9 Alabama) #2 Ohio St vs (#23 Iowa @ #10 Miami) #3 Georgia vs (#22 Georgia Tech @ #11 Notre Dame) #4 Texas Tech vs (#21 Houston @ #12 BYU) #5 Oregon vs (#20 Tulane @ #13 Texas) #6 Mississippi (#19 Virginia @ #14 Vanderbilt) #7 Texas A&M (#18 Michigan @ #15 Utah) #8 Oklahoma vs (#17 Arizona @ #16 USC) Quarterfinals - Bowls (Selected by Higher Seeds) - Projected Winners Cotton: #4 Texas Tech vs #5 Oregon Orange: #2 Miami vs #7 Texas A&M Rose: #1 Indiana vs #8 Oklahoma Sugar: #3 Georgia vs #6 Mississippi Semifinals - Bowls (Selected by Higher Seeds) - Projected Winners Fiesta: #1 Indiana vs #5 Oregon Peach: #6 Mississippi vs #10 Miami Championship - Neutral Site Miami: #1 Indiana vs #10 Miami RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - billybobby777 - 09-16-2026 05:51 PM (09-16-2026 07:32 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote: I thought fantasy posts where limited to offseason? Don’t shake too hard after eating enchiladas. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - AllTideUp - 09-17-2026 12:07 AM (09-16-2026 08:08 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:(09-16-2026 12:16 AM)AllTideUp Wrote: I like enchiladas. They're versatile. They're delicious in many ways and actually quite simple at the same time. Enchiladas are college football. They are meaty, delectable, and come in a variety of flavors. True story, I literally forgot Buffalo. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - AllTideUp - 09-17-2026 12:11 AM (09-16-2026 07:32 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote: I thought fantasy posts where limited to offseason? I was thinking the fantasy posts were defined as the ones that rewrite history or propose alternate events rather than propose hypotheticals. This post was intended more as a "this seems like this might work." But if I've misunderstood then the mods can delete the thread. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - Gitanole - 09-17-2026 01:15 AM (09-17-2026 12:07 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:(09-16-2026 08:08 AM)billybobby777 Wrote: So is Buffalo playing as an independent in this scenario? A sports site exists for everything—imcluding bison mascots. https://www.ranker.com/list/bison-mascot-school-list/reference RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - thrill_house - 09-17-2026 07:28 AM The biggest issue with this sport is that we have games like Kent State vs. Ohio State, Michigan State vs. Notre Dame, Georgia vs. Arkansas, BYU vs. Colorado State that make up 50% of the OTA games this weekend. What's the point in even turning the TV on? You already know the 4 winners of those matchups. More than anything else, we need competitive games that can be broadcast nationally on Saturdays that the viewing audience can not only watch, but be vested in, as their state/region is involved in the game. You're not growing the sport if the same 5 schools are playing bully to the other 130+. Take last weeks Ohio State vs. Texas matchup. That was potentially best on best. Big Ten vs. SEC. Midwest vs. South. It got 8 digit viewership which is rivaling NFL games. Games like this should be an every week occurrence. All groupings / matchups that fit the following criteria need to be removed from the sport: - Minimum of 10 games between the schools - A winning percentage of >67% (or <33%) for one party since 2000 - AND an average margin of victory of 14 points or more No more Alabama vs. Mississippi State. No more Georgia vs. Georgia Tech. No more Notre Dame vs. Navy. No more Ohio State vs. just about everyone in the Big Ten. We have the data that suggests that these games are no longer competitive / don't need to be played. Try something else. We would all be better off if Ohio State played Georgia, Notre Dame played BYU, Michigan State played Arkansas, and Kent State played Colorado State this weekend. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - billybobby777 - 09-17-2026 07:32 AM (09-17-2026 07:28 AM)thrill_house Wrote: The biggest issue with this sport is that we have games like Kent State vs. Ohio State, Michigan State vs. Notre Dame, Georgia vs. Arkansas, BYU vs. Colorado State that make up 50% of the OTA games this weekend. What's the point in even turning the TV on? You already know the 4 winners of those matchups. I actually like the BYU at CSU matchup with Mora as their HC and it’s at CSU in their nice new stadium. Old rivals. Michigan State vs ND is an old rivalry game too that is interesting. RE: Shaking Up the Whole Enchilada - chess - 09-17-2026 07:38 AM (09-16-2026 07:55 AM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(09-16-2026 12:16 AM)AllTideUp Wrote: BEHOLD! I agree. When the haves start crunching numbers, like hedge funds, they will start excluding their members. It may start with a core like Texas, Texas A&M, LSU, Georgia, Southern Cal, Notre Dame, Ohio State... |