CSNbbs
What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved"? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved"? (/thread-1032658.html)

Pages: 1 2 3


What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved"? - bryanw1995 - 09-09-2026 03:58 PM

Now that LSU has completely caved in once they realized that the other 15 Presidents were actually serious, it seems likely that they'll still be mad enough to demand some sort of punishment for LSU.

What punishment, if any, do you expect? If you think "no punishment", then please click "other" option.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - quo vadis - 09-09-2026 04:01 PM

I think the matter will just be dropped, with no punishment.

Either that, or they will still be booted from the conference. I don't see a middle ground where there are suspensions and fines. But with the developments of the last day, I think the odds now heavily favor just moving on.

We'll see.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - Gitanole - 09-09-2026 04:11 PM

The conference may want an official public statement of some sort from LSU’s coach or university president. If so, an ultimatum—involving the threat of a financial or game penalty—may be necessary to leverage it.

Once an appropriate statement is made, bygone are bygones. Play ball.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - quo vadis - 09-09-2026 04:16 PM

(09-09-2026 04:11 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  The conference may want an official public statement of some sort from LSU’s coach or university president. If so, an ultimatum—involving the threat of a financial or game penalty—may be necessary to leverage it.

Once an appropriate statement is made, bygone are bygones. Play ball.

FWIW, I think the SEC got just that with the publication of the letter from the SEC president, saying they were in compliance with roster rules and would not seek to disrupt the planned SEC meeting. But maybe they will want more.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved"? - LatahCounty - 09-09-2026 04:37 PM

A lot of anonymous quotes from "sources close to..." besmirching Lane Kiffin's previously pristine image. That is all.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved"? - TerryD - 09-09-2026 04:41 PM

A fairly large fine and some indeterminate Lane Kiffin suspension is my guess.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - TrojanCampaign - 09-09-2026 05:01 PM

I personally want to see them go to court. As I have said many times, I am pro-players, not pro-old men wanting to keep the status quo.

I'm a working professional right now. And I have a master's degree from the University of Alabama. When I was a student at UA, I participated in several on-campus activities. I joined a fraternity, I joined an engineering club, I joined a religious group. And guess what the only criteria was? Being a student.

Isn't the whole premise of NIL and all this other nonsense the fact that these guys are considered amateurs, not professionals? I can understand not being eligible to play on a college team while actively a member of an NFL roster. But if you're no longer on an NFL team, how are you still a professional?

This whole concept of if you declare for the NFL you're no longer eligible to play in college doesn't seem fair to the players. you don't magically gain a million experience points and become a level 99 player just because you spent one year practicing with an NFL team. If this goes to court, I suspect this is going to be yet again another thing that the establishment loses on when challenged.

If these guys are students, they meet the academic requirements to be enrolled in the school, and they haven't exhausted their four years of eligibility. Why should they be denied the opportunity to play if the school wants them to?


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved"? - Bronco'14 - 09-09-2026 05:21 PM

Voted Other (no punishment)


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - ken d - 09-09-2026 06:07 PM

(09-09-2026 05:01 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  I personally want to see them go to court. As I have said many times, I am pro-players, not pro-old men wanting to keep the status quo.

I'm a working professional right now. And I have a master's degree from the University of Alabama. When I was a student at UA, I participated in several on-campus activities. I joined a fraternity, I joined an engineering club, I joined a religious group. And guess what the only criteria was? Being a student.

Isn't the whole premise of NIL and all this other nonsense the fact that these guys are considered amateurs, not professionals? I can understand not being eligible to play on a college team while actively a member of an NFL roster. But if you're no longer on an NFL team, how are you still a professional?

This whole concept of if you declare for the NFL you're no longer eligible to play in college doesn't seem fair to the players. you don't magically gain a million experience points and become a level 99 player just because you spent one year practicing with an NFL team. If this goes to court, I suspect this is going to be yet again another thing that the establishment loses on when challenged.

If these guys are students, they meet the academic requirements to be enrolled in the school, and they haven't exhausted their four years of eligibility. Why should they be denied the opportunity to play if the school wants them to?

What happens if this does go to court and the result is that at least some players who have not actually signed an NFL contract are allowed to return to college (like the LSU players)? That doesn't have to be a suit between the SEC and LSU. It could be a suit brought by the affected players themselves.

If there were such a ruling, and the SEC had imposed some penalty on LSU before the ruling was issued, wouldn't LSU have grounds to have the penalty overturned? Because of that possibility, I could imagine LSU appealing the punishment or even seeking an injunction if the penalty can not be reversed (like a suspension of the coach).

I'm not sure tomorrow will be the last we hear about this.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - sigke - 09-09-2026 06:12 PM

The LSU President will be excluded from the next golf outing with other SEC Presidents....


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - The Beaver - 09-09-2026 07:28 PM

Voted other, they will have to write one earnest apology letter and read it in front of the other presidents at the next SEC meeting.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - bullet - 09-09-2026 07:32 PM

(09-09-2026 03:58 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Now that LSU has completely caved in once they realized that the other 15 Presidents were actually serious, it seems likely that they'll still be mad enough to demand some sort of punishment for LSU.

What punishment, if any, do you expect? If you think "no punishment", then please click "other" option.

An extra holding call in every road conference game.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - bullet - 09-09-2026 07:35 PM

(09-09-2026 05:01 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  I personally want to see them go to court. As I have said many times, I am pro-players, not pro-old men wanting to keep the status quo.

I'm a working professional right now. And I have a master's degree from the University of Alabama. When I was a student at UA, I participated in several on-campus activities. I joined a fraternity, I joined an engineering club, I joined a religious group. And guess what the only criteria was? Being a student.

Isn't the whole premise of NIL and all this other nonsense the fact that these guys are considered amateurs, not professionals? I can understand not being eligible to play on a college team while actively a member of an NFL roster. But if you're no longer on an NFL team, how are you still a professional?

This whole concept of if you declare for the NFL you're no longer eligible to play in college doesn't seem fair to the players. you don't magically gain a million experience points and become a level 99 player just because you spent one year practicing with an NFL team. If this goes to court, I suspect this is going to be yet again another thing that the establishment loses on when challenged.

If these guys are students, they meet the academic requirements to be enrolled in the school, and they haven't exhausted their four years of eligibility. Why should they be denied the opportunity to play if the school wants them to?

Its a really thin line. The potential rule violation that so upset them is based on 2020 college football, not that of 2026.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - TrojanCampaign - 09-09-2026 07:51 PM

(09-09-2026 06:07 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 05:01 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  I personally want to see them go to court. As I have said many times, I am pro-players, not pro-old men wanting to keep the status quo.

I'm a working professional right now. And I have a master's degree from the University of Alabama. When I was a student at UA, I participated in several on-campus activities. I joined a fraternity, I joined an engineering club, I joined a religious group. And guess what the only criteria was? Being a student.

Isn't the whole premise of NIL and all this other nonsense the fact that these guys are considered amateurs, not professionals? I can understand not being eligible to play on a college team while actively a member of an NFL roster. But if you're no longer on an NFL team, how are you still a professional?

This whole concept of if you declare for the NFL you're no longer eligible to play in college doesn't seem fair to the players. you don't magically gain a million experience points and become a level 99 player just because you spent one year practicing with an NFL team. If this goes to court, I suspect this is going to be yet again another thing that the establishment loses on when challenged.

If these guys are students, they meet the academic requirements to be enrolled in the school, and they haven't exhausted their four years of eligibility. Why should they be denied the opportunity to play if the school wants them to?

What happens if this does go to court and the result is that at least some players who have not actually signed an NFL contract are allowed to return to college (like the LSU players)? That doesn't have to be a suit between the SEC and LSU. It could be a suit brought by the affected players themselves.

If there were such a ruling, and the SEC had imposed some penalty on LSU before the ruling was issued, wouldn't LSU have grounds to have the penalty overturned? Because of that possibility, I could imagine LSU appealing the punishment or even seeking an injunction if the penalty can not be reversed (like a suspension of the coach).

I'm not sure tomorrow will be the last we hear about this.

It's not going to be the last of it and that's probably why the SEC is so furious. This isn't about LSU. This is about the trying to monopolize the top level talent. They aren't worried about guys in their 30s keeping up with 17 -24yo guys. They are worried about those 21-25yo NFL busts playing at Texas Tech and SMU.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - bryanw1995 - 09-09-2026 09:03 PM

(09-09-2026 06:12 PM)sigke Wrote:  The LSU President will be excluded from the next golf outing with other SEC Presidents....

Dang, that's a good one. I should have thought of that.

edit: I voted since we've had a lot of votes already. My vote: Kiffin suspension (I'm guessing 3 games) and fine ($10m). If they get nothing I'd be ok with that, and if they get a $100m fine and 6 game suspension for Kiffin I'd understand that, too however.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - bryanw1995 - 09-09-2026 09:06 PM

(09-09-2026 07:51 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 06:07 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 05:01 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  I personally want to see them go to court. As I have said many times, I am pro-players, not pro-old men wanting to keep the status quo.

I'm a working professional right now. And I have a master's degree from the University of Alabama. When I was a student at UA, I participated in several on-campus activities. I joined a fraternity, I joined an engineering club, I joined a religious group. And guess what the only criteria was? Being a student.

Isn't the whole premise of NIL and all this other nonsense the fact that these guys are considered amateurs, not professionals? I can understand not being eligible to play on a college team while actively a member of an NFL roster. But if you're no longer on an NFL team, how are you still a professional?

This whole concept of if you declare for the NFL you're no longer eligible to play in college doesn't seem fair to the players. you don't magically gain a million experience points and become a level 99 player just because you spent one year practicing with an NFL team. If this goes to court, I suspect this is going to be yet again another thing that the establishment loses on when challenged.

If these guys are students, they meet the academic requirements to be enrolled in the school, and they haven't exhausted their four years of eligibility. Why should they be denied the opportunity to play if the school wants them to?

What happens if this does go to court and the result is that at least some players who have not actually signed an NFL contract are allowed to return to college (like the LSU players)? That doesn't have to be a suit between the SEC and LSU. It could be a suit brought by the affected players themselves.

If there were such a ruling, and the SEC had imposed some penalty on LSU before the ruling was issued, wouldn't LSU have grounds to have the penalty overturned? Because of that possibility, I could imagine LSU appealing the punishment or even seeking an injunction if the penalty can not be reversed (like a suspension of the coach).

I'm not sure tomorrow will be the last we hear about this.

It's not going to be the last of it and that's probably why the SEC is so furious. This isn't about LSU. This is about the trying to monopolize the top level talent. They aren't worried about guys in their 30s keeping up with 17 -24yo guys. They are worried about those 21-25yo NFL busts playing at Texas Tech and SMU.

Or LSU more like it. And the other Conferences are just as enthusiastic about keeping NFL players out of college locker rooms as the SEC is. The whole point of college, including college athletics, is that you do it for a couple of years and then you get on with your life. That's as true at Alabama as it is at Alabama St.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - otown - 09-10-2026 02:54 AM

(09-09-2026 05:01 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  I personally want to see them go to court. As I have said many times, I am pro-players, not pro-old men wanting to keep the status quo.

I'm a working professional right now. And I have a master's degree from the University of Alabama. When I was a student at UA, I participated in several on-campus activities. I joined a fraternity, I joined an engineering club, I joined a religious group. And guess what the only criteria was? Being a student.

Isn't the whole premise of NIL and all this other nonsense the fact that these guys are considered amateurs, not professionals? I can understand not being eligible to play on a college team while actively a member of an NFL roster. But if you're no longer on an NFL team, how are you still a professional?

This whole concept of if you declare for the NFL you're no longer eligible to play in college doesn't seem fair to the players. you don't magically gain a million experience points and become a level 99 player just because you spent one year practicing with an NFL team. If this goes to court, I suspect this is going to be yet again another thing that the establishment loses on when challenged.

If these guys are students, they meet the academic requirements to be enrolled in the school, and they haven't exhausted their four years of eligibility. Why should they be denied the opportunity to play if the school wants them to?

Its because money is money. NIL money and rich booster money will be used to directly compete with the NFL. Let me run a scenario of this went to court and the outcome you described happens. Its a slippery slope. Athlete A signs an NFL contract, he is a mediocre player, or maybe jist an average player. He doesnt command a huge salary, just an average non guaranteed salary. He is now 27 years old with 4 years NFL experience. He then get some offers from the NFL for decent money, but LSU via boosters and an NIL package offer him much more money to go back to school and play on the team. Athlete A chooses LSU. He makes bank at LSU while hedging it for a bigger NFL contract during round 2 of an NFL stint after he tears up college football. Now multiply this all over FBS and you now see a very big problem.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved"? - Stugray2 - 09-10-2026 03:06 AM

None. A strongly written reprimand that doesn't name LSU or Kiffin.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - Gitanole - 09-10-2026 04:07 AM

(09-09-2026 04:16 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 04:11 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  The conference may want an official public statement of some sort from LSU’s coach or university president. If so, an ultimatum—involving the threat of a financial or game penalty—may be necessary to leverage it.

Once an appropriate statement is made, bygone are bygones. Play ball.

FWIW, I think the SEC got just that with the publication of the letter from the SEC president, saying they were in compliance with roster rules and would not seek to disrupt the planned SEC meeting. But maybe they will want more.

I think so, too. Odds strike me as around 60% that this takes care of it.

I was just thinking of what might get those 40% odds. I can see how SEC members might also want a public statement made to counter some recent, equally public Lane Kiffin mouthery.


RE: What will be LSU's punishment from the SEC now that situation is "resolved&qu... - Gitanole - 09-10-2026 04:14 AM

(09-09-2026 05:01 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  I personally want to see them go to court. As I have said many times, I am pro-players, not pro-old men wanting to keep the status quo.

I'm a working professional right now. And I have a master's degree from the University of Alabama. When I was a student at UA, I participated in several on-campus activities. I joined a fraternity, I joined an engineering club, I joined a religious group. And guess what the only criteria was? Being a student.

Isn't the whole premise of NIL and all this other nonsense the fact that these guys are considered amateurs, not professionals? I can understand not being eligible to play on a college team while actively a member of an NFL roster. But if you're no longer on an NFL team, how are you still a professional?

This whole concept of if you declare for the NFL you're no longer eligible to play in college doesn't seem fair to the players. you don't magically gain a million experience points and become a level 99 player just because you spent one year practicing with an NFL team. If this goes to court, I suspect this is going to be yet again another thing that the establishment loses on when challenged.

If these guys are students, they meet the academic requirements to be enrolled in the school, and they haven't exhausted their four years of eligibility. Why should they be denied the opportunity to play if the school wants them to?

College athletic opportunity is morphing into a domain where student rights and professional (labor) rights overlap. We can still expect to see people going to court to settle the inevitable issues that come up.

On the bright side: what is new for athletics is not new for everyone on campus. In other fields it has been possible for decades to be both a professional and a student. So legal precedents and organizational models do exist.