![]() |
|
How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? (/thread-1032588.html) Pages: 1 2 |
How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - mlb - 09-08-2026 12:58 PM I ask this question genuinely... A buddy of mine (Ohio State graduate) and I were talking about this over the weekend. He is in a group of 8-10 people who own season tickets to Ohio State for the last 25-30 years. They have gotten to the 47 yard line in row 5 of the upper deck at Ohio Stadium (great seats in the C deck). He said that they had decided this is their last year because outside of the social aspect (their tailgate) they don't enjoy it like they used to. They don't like the lack of loyalty among players in college any more, they don't like how it is professional sports now, and they hate that they struggle to learn the roster each year now because of the turnover. He said they can enjoy the social aspect at someone's house or a sports bar rather than driving 90+ minutes each direction to watch a game (and save a lot of money at the same time). I know as a Cincinnati grad that this is the least excited I've been for UC football since I decided to go to school there in the mid-1990s. If Ohio State alums, boosters, and season ticket holders are tired of it, how will the have-nots of college football do in this new world? G6 and smaller P4 ADs have a real problem brewing, IMO. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - The Beaver - 09-08-2026 01:04 PM Having to relearn the roster every single year sucks. I've pretty much given up. And if you think its hard when attending all of the home games just wait until you try it at home and start flipping to other games. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - e-parade - 09-08-2026 01:14 PM People who have owned season tickets for nearly 3 decades are not casual fans. Casual fans are the ones who will almost always watch from home and turn on whatever games are available (they won't go out of their way to subscribe to whatever platforms are required to watch the same teams every week if those teams aren't available on a local broadcast every week, but if their local sports package happens to come with the Big 10 network or something equivalent they'll probably sign up for that). Those fans likely barely learned rosters outside of a few star players anyway. What we're seeing is more hardcore fans becoming less hardcore fans, which will likely lead to worse attendance in person...or at least attendance by the same people each week. That anecdote aligns with that very well: people who used to go to all the games in person will instead start watching at home or somewhere they spend less money at. They still enjoy being fans, but want a lower level of investment to do so. Seems like moving forward everyone is going to need to hope to rely on more and more t-shirt fans for attendance and other revenue sources. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - No Bull - 09-08-2026 01:18 PM I watched North Texas vs Indiana. North Texas was playing UCF’s QB from last season. It gave me extra incentive to watch the game. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - Frank the Tank - 09-08-2026 01:21 PM What matters is what people *do* as opposed to what people *say*. People *say* that they don’t like such high levels of NIL and unlimited transfers. Yet, what people *do* is that they have watched college football more than ever during this NIL/transfer portal era. People *say* they don’t like the transfer portal as an overall premise, but when it then allows their favorite team (whoever it might be) get an experienced QB over the offseason or reload their football or basketball team overall as opposed to having to rebuild for 2-3 years, people will take the better team 100 times out the 100 over the less talented “homegrown” team no matter what they say. Offseasons used to be boring affairs where we’d have to effectively make up content. Now, NIL and the transfer portal constitute the college version of free agency, and, once again, fans say that they don’t like free agency and wish players were more loyal… and then turn around and absolutely consume every single bit of free agency news out there. The NFL, NBA, and MLB have all effectively made their free agency calendar into their own content machines and now college football and basketball are doing the exact same thing. It’s the old Yogi Berra axiom: “Nobody goes there anymore. It’s too crowded.” There are few more evergreen complaints of sports fans everywhere that they’re “losing interest” because of “X” and it will cause fans to stop watching “Y”. And then when you actually look at the objective data, it turns out that “Y” is more popular and broadly watched than ever. More often than not, it turns out that the old fans that are complaining are the gatekeeping equivalent of the first fans of a garage band that hits it big. Those old school fans may say that their favorite band sold out… but then they still buy their records, anyway. That’s college sports right now - it’s actually adding more *new* fans at a higher pace than ever. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - mlb - 09-08-2026 01:23 PM (09-08-2026 01:14 PM)e-parade Wrote: People who have owned season tickets for nearly 3 decades are not casual fans. Casual fans are the ones who will almost always watch from home and turn on whatever games are available (they won't go out of their way to subscribe to whatever platforms are required to watch the same teams every week if those teams aren't available on a local broadcast every week, but if their local sports package happens to come with the Big 10 network or something equivalent they'll probably sign up for that). Those fans likely barely learned rosters outside of a few star players anyway. My point is if the hardcore fans are walking away, how long will the casual fans hang on? Usually the hardcore fans are the ones who talk up the games to the casual fans, who then tune in to see what the hardcore fans are talking about. If those fans are not out selling their school/team at work, or the bar, or with family, etc., then will those casual fans have their interest peaked or will they go do something else on a Saturday? RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - DFW HOYA - 09-08-2026 01:23 PM (09-08-2026 01:14 PM)e-parade Wrote: What we're seeing is more hardcore fans becoming less hardcore fans, which will likely lead to worse attendance in person...or at least attendance by the same people each week. That anecdote aligns with that very well: people who used to go to all the games in person will instead start watching at home or somewhere they spend less money at. They still enjoy being fans, but want a lower level of investment to do so. What we're seeing is college teams charging NFL prices for games that really aren't determinative, and are just as exciting watching in front of a TV set at home. Forget Texas and Ohio State, a pair of end zone seats this weekend at Missouri vs. Kansas will run $220 each and start at $35 for parking. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - bullet - 09-08-2026 01:24 PM (09-08-2026 01:14 PM)e-parade Wrote: People who have owned season tickets for nearly 3 decades are not casual fans. Casual fans are the ones who will almost always watch from home and turn on whatever games are available (they won't go out of their way to subscribe to whatever platforms are required to watch the same teams every week if those teams aren't available on a local broadcast every week, but if their local sports package happens to come with the Big 10 network or something equivalent they'll probably sign up for that). Those fans likely barely learned rosters outside of a few star players anyway. I've certainly seen that with some long time Georgia fans. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - mlb - 09-08-2026 01:25 PM (09-08-2026 01:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: What matters is what people *do* as opposed to what people *say*. Very true... I will say that he prefaced it by saying "we've said enough is enough to Ohio State, the question is will Ohio State start asking why people who have had season tickets for 30 years are walking away not only from football, but from their donations to the school in general." Time will tell, but they seem pretty set at the moment. Typically people don't talk about canceling season tickets when your school is ranked number 1 in the country. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - ccd494 - 09-08-2026 01:26 PM (09-08-2026 01:23 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(09-08-2026 01:14 PM)e-parade Wrote: What we're seeing is more hardcore fans becoming less hardcore fans, which will likely lead to worse attendance in person...or at least attendance by the same people each week. That anecdote aligns with that very well: people who used to go to all the games in person will instead start watching at home or somewhere they spend less money at. They still enjoy being fans, but want a lower level of investment to do so. I wouldn't exactly use Mizzou-Kansas, the Border War is a huge deal to those fan bases and it is just back after a decade and a half hiatus. But, clicking around this past weekend there were a lot of empty seats. I was way too lazy, but I think people may have been premature throwing USC under the bus for their attendance. Some more traditional college football locales didn't exactly pack their stadiums. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - The Beaver - 09-08-2026 01:26 PM (09-08-2026 01:23 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(09-08-2026 01:14 PM)e-parade Wrote: What we're seeing is more hardcore fans becoming less hardcore fans, which will likely lead to worse attendance in person...or at least attendance by the same people each week. That anecdote aligns with that very well: people who used to go to all the games in person will instead start watching at home or somewhere they spend less money at. They still enjoy being fans, but want a lower level of investment to do so. Thats a rivalry game. People care more about it than about "determinative" conference games. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - bullet - 09-08-2026 01:29 PM (09-08-2026 01:23 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(09-08-2026 01:14 PM)e-parade Wrote: What we're seeing is more hardcore fans becoming less hardcore fans, which will likely lead to worse attendance in person...or at least attendance by the same people each week. That anecdote aligns with that very well: people who used to go to all the games in person will instead start watching at home or somewhere they spend less money at. They still enjoy being fans, but want a lower level of investment to do so. Its a combination of the OP's comments, the rapidly rising prices and a decline in the in-game experience. They blast so much noise in between plays (ie piped in, not the bands), its hard to talk to your neighbors or even the people you came with. Commercial breaks have disrupted the flow of the game and made the games much longer. They are also trying to squeeze more money out of each customer, which is starting to make it more of an elite experience instead of a common one. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - Frank the Tank - 09-08-2026 01:30 PM And I’ll say it from a personal fan perspective: Illinois has gone to the Final Four along with having its best stretch of football in generations over the past few years. None of that would have been possible in the pre-NIL/transfer portal era. Ohio State and Alabama can’t just stack waves and waves of 4 and 5 star recruits on the bench for years and years while the top basketball programs are no longer just based on how many one-and-done McDonald’s All-Americans that they can accumulate. As much as NIL is significant, playing time is a finite resource. Spreading talent via the transfer portal so that the top talent can go where they get playing time increases the number of competitive teams across the board. While how women’s and Olympic sports are funded is a legit concern, I have zero qualms about how football and basketball talent are getting allocated now. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - e-parade - 09-08-2026 01:31 PM (09-08-2026 01:23 PM)mlb Wrote:(09-08-2026 01:14 PM)e-parade Wrote: People who have owned season tickets for nearly 3 decades are not casual fans. Casual fans are the ones who will almost always watch from home and turn on whatever games are available (they won't go out of their way to subscribe to whatever platforms are required to watch the same teams every week if those teams aren't available on a local broadcast every week, but if their local sports package happens to come with the Big 10 network or something equivalent they'll probably sign up for that). Those fans likely barely learned rosters outside of a few star players anyway. And I'm saying (though not super clearly in that first post to be fair) that I don't believe the casual fans are going to be impacted by this. They watch what's available and maybe try to find what might be the best game on at any moment. Not having the hardcore fans talk the games up to them isn't going to do too much to that. It could have a secondary impact of fewer casuals going to the occasional game though, because fewer hardcore fans are inviting them to come along. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - SFLFB - 09-08-2026 01:32 PM I think there will eventually be rules passed that discourages such frequent transfers. For example, if a player has signed a multi-year contract, the acquirer to pay a % of the rev share/NIL contract amount to the previous school, which would count against the rev share cap for the acquirer and be added to the rev share cap for the school losing the player. This is purely an example, but I agree something needs to happen to promote continuity of rosters annually. My brief example: QB at XYZ school is earning $250k this year (and next) and school ABC wants to offer $2MM for next season. 20% fee to the previous school is a transfer fee of $50k, which is added to the salary for a total cap hit of $2.05MM for school ABC, while school XYZ adds $50k to their cap space. Make the acquisitions more expensive. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - bullet - 09-08-2026 01:35 PM (09-08-2026 01:30 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: And I’ll say it from a personal fan perspective: Illinois has gone to the Final Four along with having its best stretch of football in generations over the past few years. None of that would have been possible in the pre-NIL/transfer portal era. Ohio State and Alabama can’t just stack waves and waves of 4 and 5 star recruits on the bench for years and years while the top basketball programs are no longer just based on how many one-and-done McDonald’s All-Americans that they can accumulate. People are concerned about the churn every year, not the spread of talent. It gets harder to relate with the team. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - Frank the Tank - 09-08-2026 01:45 PM (09-08-2026 01:35 PM)bullet Wrote:(09-08-2026 01:30 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: And I’ll say it from a personal fan perspective: Illinois has gone to the Final Four along with having its best stretch of football in generations over the past few years. None of that would have been possible in the pre-NIL/transfer portal era. Ohio State and Alabama can’t just stack waves and waves of 4 and 5 star recruits on the bench for years and years while the top basketball programs are no longer just based on how many one-and-done McDonald’s All-Americans that they can accumulate. And that’s fine. I get it. We all would rather have a 4-year star player that we see grow up for their whole career in college just as we have a different attachment to pro players that stay with a team for a decade versus those that hop around. No doubt that there is this emotion. However, if you give fans truth serum, would they take a worse “homegrown” team with multi-year players over a more successful team consisting of transfers any more than the players would want to go to a team that gives them more NIL and playing time versus sticking with a team that will pay them less and/or stick them on the bench? And are fans going to be more patient with coaches if they don’t win right away if we somehow revert back to less talent moving around? I think the reality is that fans talk out of both sides of their mouths all of the time. Of course fans don’t want to see their team’s best players leave via the transfer portal (or free agency or trade in the pro context)… but they sure as heck are quick to drive any player to the airport to leave if they aren’t as productive as the replacement no matter how loyal they may have been to the team or have been a good “character guy”. Fans are just as mercenary as the players and frankly often far worse. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - bullet - 09-08-2026 01:51 PM (09-08-2026 01:45 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:(09-08-2026 01:35 PM)bullet Wrote:(09-08-2026 01:30 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: And I’ll say it from a personal fan perspective: Illinois has gone to the Final Four along with having its best stretch of football in generations over the past few years. None of that would have been possible in the pre-NIL/transfer portal era. Ohio State and Alabama can’t just stack waves and waves of 4 and 5 star recruits on the bench for years and years while the top basketball programs are no longer just based on how many one-and-done McDonald’s All-Americans that they can accumulate. But a significant number aren't buying in even if the majority still are. That is long run bad for the sport. Many fans buy in to losers when its "their guys." See Iowa St. for an example. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - JRsec - 09-08-2026 01:52 PM (09-08-2026 01:30 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: And I’ll say it from a personal fan perspective: Illinois has gone to the Final Four along with having its best stretch of football in generations over the past few years. None of that would have been possible in the pre-NIL/transfer portal era. Ohio State and Alabama can’t just stack waves and waves of 4 and 5 star recruits on the bench for years and years while the top basketball programs are no longer just based on how many one-and-done McDonald’s All-Americans that they can accumulate. The trend is in Frank. I held season tickets and gave half scholarships, until the university started farming out its athletic department responsibilities to hucksters, sold its stadium wall space for advertising, piped in music so loud between plays I couldn't talk to people who had sat next to my family at ball games for over 4 decades. Then I basically told them to kiss my ass! They didn't just lose me but a whole generation of supporters. Just as with our government corporate money became more important than alumni and donor money. The alumni are waking up to how unappreciated they are. And this generation doesn't have the pockets I had at their age. The cost of their educations were multiple that of mine, and they earn less, pay more for what their kids need than I did, and don't have the opportunities to choose from I had. College athletics is like a runaway bull market. The components of its destruction have been overlooked on the way up. The fall will be precipitous and considerably faster than the rise. The Football talent pool is already in decline. Adding gambling made the results and experiences less believable and less enjoyable. Hell, they even shortened the games to fit TV schedules so the tickets you buy are buying less football as each quarter with a running clock is nowhere near the time it took for a game in the 80's or 90's. That added commercial time between aired games. Now they are wanting to precipitously lengthen the seasons with this B.S. 24 team playoff model. That's just wear and tear on players and a means to squeeze more out of attending fans and viewers. People are voting with their feet and their wallets. There are more important things in life than those who sell their allegiance for a buck. The big turn off has begun. It will die last in the South, but when Southerners between the ages of 50 and the grave have already distanced themselves from programs, it's not just coming Frank, it's here! But like a quick razor sharp slash you just haven't felt the fatal blow yet. RE: How long until NIL causes the casual fan to stop watching college sports? - Frank the Tank - 09-08-2026 02:30 PM (09-08-2026 01:52 PM)JRsec Wrote:(09-08-2026 01:30 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: And I’ll say it from a personal fan perspective: Illinois has gone to the Final Four along with having its best stretch of football in generations over the past few years. None of that would have been possible in the pre-NIL/transfer portal era. Ohio State and Alabama can’t just stack waves and waves of 4 and 5 star recruits on the bench for years and years while the top basketball programs are no longer just based on how many one-and-done McDonald’s All-Americans that they can accumulate. I think the old adage of killing the golden goose is always a worry. However, just look at my own experience as an Illinois fan. Now think about Indiana fans across the border. This was arguably the very worst football program historically in all of the power conferences and they freaking won a national championship and did it in a dominant fashion. Are those Indiana fans giving up their tickets or are they in more demand than ever? Similarly, my own Illini (always marked as a “bad football fan base”) sold out all of its football and basketball season tickets. Throw other names out there: SMU, Iowa State, BYU, even a school like Ole Miss and (look out for the chair being thrown) Texas Tech. CFP and Final Four contenders draw because winning over everything else draws. Think of it the other way: a system just based on real or perceived loyalty or attachment to players was never going to be sustainable in today’s world. College sports (specifically football and basketball) HAD to adapt. Illinois had plenty of 4-year players in the 2010s that we got to know very well… and our football and basketball teams were terrible and the attendance and fan interest reflected that terribleness. There were players liked, but I would be outright lying to you if I said that I liked those *teams* that would go winless in the Big Ten season. No thank you. Sure - the Ohio States and Alabamas and Texases of the world might have some level of fatigue because they were used to being at the top, but now they actually have to work harder to stay on top because they can’t simply lock in multiple years of talent and keep it away from everyone each National Signing Day. It was the same thing with basketball when every McDonald’s All-American seemingly ended up at Duke, UNC, Kentucky or Kansas. There are far more teams that actually have a chance to compete at the top level now. Will there be fans that grumble? Absolutely. And look - just because I think the current state of NIL and the transfer portal is a net positive for Illinois doesn’t mean that the unfettered Wild West can continue as-is without eventually breaking, either. However, the chaste system that ruled college football and, to a lesser extent, college basketball for so long is finally getting mitigated (even if it’s not totally going away) and that’s a good thing for everyone. There are far more schools like Illinois or Iowa State or Texas Tech than there are Ohio States and Michigans. We have a lot of old school fans here, so we’re probably overindexed in those that see the recent changes as a net negative, but the numbers don’t lie. I’ve got two Gen Z kids about to go to college - this generation might not watch sports like we did, but they actually care about the social atmosphere of football schools MORE than our generations (as every college counselor will tell you that it’s a bigger factor in people applying to college compared to 20/30/40-plus years ago) and they simply don’t care if players “go get their bag” with NIL any more than they lionize YouTube and TikTok stars that make a ton of revenue off of their followings. They’re way more entrepreneurial and less institutional as a generation, which tracks with how athletes approach their schools, too. |