CSNbbs
Complete Non-Conference Records (1991-2025) - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Complete Non-Conference Records (1991-2025) (/thread-1032561.html)



Complete Non-Conference Records (1991-2025) - PicksUp - 09-07-2026 09:40 PM

I went ahead and compiled non-conference records for the major/power conferences since 1991. I looked at the records from three different time periods. 1991 to 2004, 2005 to 2012 and 2014 to 2025. I skipped 2013 but will likely post those records separately.

Why did I choose 1991? Simple, that was the first year of Big East football. Florida State, South Carolina, and Penn State were on the verge of joining a conference after decades of independence. Major realignment in the early to mid-2000s resulted in different lineups for the ACC, Big East, C-USA and WAC from 2005 to 2012. Further realignment in the 2010s led to the demise of the Big East as a football conference (although some say the American is a continuation of it) and also the WAC. The CFP era began in 2014 with new members for the ACC, Big Ten and American. This initial post will only include the total records but I will make additional edits/posts to include complete records vs each conference. I also have the records of Power conferences vs G5/6 and FCS opponents and will post them in this thread later.

1991 to 2004
Conference - Record - Winning %

SEC 130-103-1 .558
Big Ten 177-156-4 .531
ACC 142-139-2 .505
Big Eight 51-50-3 .505
PAC 121-121-2 .500
Big XII 73-85 .462
Big East 116-165-1 .413
SWC 35-67-3 .348

Notre Dame 84-54-1 .608

*Includes games vs Independents Florida St (1991) & Penn St (1991/92)

2005 to 2012
Conference - Record - Winning %

SEC 102-69 .596
PAC 74-64 .536
Big XII 75-67 .528
Big East 73-86 .459
Big Ten 74-91 .448
ACC 89-124 .418

Notre Dame 47-33 .588

2014 to 2025
Conference - Record - Winning %

SEC 159-125 .560
Big Ten 133-126 .514
Big XII 93-96 .492
PAC 72-79 .477
ACC 124-211 .370

Notre Dame 90-33 .732

Note: Only games for teams in conferences considered major/power counted, e.g., Washington St and Oregon St are classified as Independents from 2024-present. 2020 Notre Dame games not included in the ACC totals.


RE: Complete Non-Conference Records (1991-2025) - GTFletch - 09-07-2026 10:26 PM

The Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) added Syracuse and Pittsburgh primarily to secure its long-term survival, expand its television market media footprint, and solidify its status as a basketball powerhouse during a volatile era of college sports realignment.

1. Defensive Survival and Conference Stability: In 2011, college athletics was undergoing massive, chaotic shifts. The Big Ten and Pac-12 were expanding, and rumors swirled that the SEC or Big Ten might raid the ACC for top programs like Florida State, Maryland, or Clemson. By preemptively adding Syracuse and Pitt, the ACC expanded its membership to 14 teams, making the conference more stable, structurally secure, and less vulnerable to falling apart if a member chose to leave.

2. TV Markets and Media Footprint: At the time, conference revenue was heavily driven by cable television subscriptions and the looming creation of conference-specific networks.Syracuse brought the massive New York City television market (as Syracuse has a dominant alumni and fan base there), as well as the upstate New York region.Pitt delivered the Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania markets.Expanding into these heavily populated northern territories allowed the ACC to command higher per-subscriber fees from cable providers across the entire Northeast.

3. Basketball Supremacy: While football has traditionally driven the financials of conference realignment, the ACC took immense pride in its identity as the premier college basketball conference. Adding Syracuse (under Jim Boeheim) and Pitt (then a consistent Top-25 program under Jamie Dixon) from the Big East instantly created an unrivaled basketball mega-conference, combining them with historic giants like North Carolina and Duke.

4. Academic and Geographic Alignment: The ACC has strict academic standards for its member institutions. Both Syracuse and Pitt are prestigious research universities that fit the academic profile of existing members like Virginia, Duke, and Boston College. Geographically, they also bridged the gap between Boston College and the rest of the Atlantic coast members.

The Domino Effect: The departure of Syracuse and Pitt was part of a larger exodus that ultimately caused the original football-playing Big East to fracture completely. During that exact realignment cycle, schools fled in all directions:

- West Virginia (2012): Left for the Big 12 Conference.
- Syracuse & Pittsburgh (2013): Formally joined the ACC after paying a $7.5 million exit fee.
- Notre Dame (2013): Moved its non-football sports to the ACC while maintaining its football independence.
- Rutgers (2014): Headed to the Big Ten Conference.
- Louisville (2014): Followed Syracuse and Pitt to the ACC to replace Maryland (who left for the Big Ten).
- The "Catholic 7" (2013): The non-football schools (DePaul, Georgetown, Marquette, Providence, Seton Hall, St. John's, and Villanova) split off entirely. They purchased the "Big East" name and rights to the Madison Square Garden tournament to form the current basketball-centric Big East.
- The Remaining Football Schools: Cincinnati, UConn, and USF stayed behind, added new members, and rebranded the original charter as the American Athletic Conference (AAC).

Financial Growth:] ACC Revenue (2011 vs. Today) The decision to expand and lock down larger TV markets was an enormous financial success for the ACC, even as it continues to chase the massive payouts of the Big Ten and SEC.
Total Conference Revenue
2011–2012 Season - $223.6 million vs 2024–2025 Season $826.5 million +269.6% Growth
Average Per-School Payouts
2011–2012 Season - $16.9 million vs 2024–2025 Season $47.1 million +178.7% Growth


RE: Complete Non-Conference Records (1991-2025) - The Beaver - 09-07-2026 11:27 PM

(09-07-2026 10:26 PM)GTFletch Wrote:  The Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) added Syracuse and Pittsburgh primarily to secure its long-term survival, expand its television market media footprint, and solidify its status as a basketball powerhouse during a volatile era of college sports realignment.

1. Defensive Survival and Conference Stability: In 2011, college athletics was undergoing massive, chaotic shifts. The Big Ten and Pac-12 were expanding, and rumors swirled that the SEC or Big Ten might raid the ACC for top programs like Florida State, Maryland, or Clemson. By preemptively adding Syracuse and Pitt, the ACC expanded its membership to 14 teams, making the conference more stable, structurally secure, and less vulnerable to falling apart if a member chose to leave.

2. TV Markets and Media Footprint: At the time, conference revenue was heavily driven by cable television subscriptions and the looming creation of conference-specific networks.Syracuse brought the massive New York City television market (as Syracuse has a dominant alumni and fan base there), as well as the upstate New York region.Pitt delivered the Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania markets.Expanding into these heavily populated northern territories allowed the ACC to command higher per-subscriber fees from cable providers across the entire Northeast.

3. Basketball Supremacy: While football has traditionally driven the financials of conference realignment, the ACC took immense pride in its identity as the premier college basketball conference. Adding Syracuse (under Jim Boeheim) and Pitt (then a consistent Top-25 program under Jamie Dixon) from the Big East instantly created an unrivaled basketball mega-conference, combining them with historic giants like North Carolina and Duke.

4. Academic and Geographic Alignment: The ACC has strict academic standards for its member institutions. Both Syracuse and Pitt are prestigious research universities that fit the academic profile of existing members like Virginia, Duke, and Boston College. Geographically, they also bridged the gap between Boston College and the rest of the Atlantic coast members.

The Domino Effect: The departure of Syracuse and Pitt was part of a larger exodus that ultimately caused the original football-playing Big East to fracture completely. During that exact realignment cycle, schools fled in all directions:

- West Virginia (2012): Left for the Big 12 Conference.
- Syracuse & Pittsburgh (2013): Formally joined the ACC after paying a $7.5 million exit fee.
- Notre Dame (2013): Moved its non-football sports to the ACC while maintaining its football independence.
- Rutgers (2014): Headed to the Big Ten Conference.
- Louisville (2014): Followed Syracuse and Pitt to the ACC to replace Maryland (who left for the Big Ten).
- The "Catholic 7" (2013): The non-football schools (DePaul, Georgetown, Marquette, Providence, Seton Hall, St. John's, and Villanova) split off entirely. They purchased the "Big East" name and rights to the Madison Square Garden tournament to form the current basketball-centric Big East.
- The Remaining Football Schools: Cincinnati, UConn, and USF stayed behind, added new members, and rebranded the original charter as the American Athletic Conference (AAC).

Financial Growth:] ACC Revenue (2011 vs. Today) The decision to expand and lock down larger TV markets was an enormous financial success for the ACC, even as it continues to chase the massive payouts of the Big Ten and SEC.
Total Conference Revenue
2011–2012 Season - $223.6 million vs 2024–2025 Season $826.5 million +269.6% Growth
Average Per-School Payouts
2011–2012 Season - $16.9 million vs 2024–2025 Season $47.1 million +178.7% Growth
Slop.


RE: Complete Non-Conference Records (1991-2025) - PicksUp - 09-08-2026 09:27 PM

Power vs Non-Power

1991 to 2004
Conference - Record - Winning %

Big Eight 51-9-1 .844
SEC 285-58-1 .830
Big Ten 191-43-1 .815
Big XII 182-44 .805
PAC 199-58-1 .773
ACC 115-35-1 .765
Big East 180-66-1 .731
SWC 42-17-2 .705

Major Independents 9-1 .900
Notre Dame 26-3 .897

Total 1280-334-8 .792

Note: All games against Independents (except Notre Dame, Penn St and Florida St) included

2005 to 2012
Conference - Record - Winning %

SEC 179-16 .918
Big Ten 154-29 .842
Big XII 159-30 .841
Big East 110-24 .821
ACC 102-35 .745
PAC 81-42 .659

Notre Dame 16-5 .762

Total 801-181 .816

2014 to 2025
Conference - Record - Winning %

SEC 289-35 .892
Big Ten 250-39 .865
Big XII 132-37 .781
ACC 211-67 .759
PAC 121-49 .712

Notre Dame 28-4 .875

Total 1031-231 .817

Note: Independent BYU (2011-2022) included in these totals


RE: Complete Non-Conference Records (1991-2025) - PicksUp - 09-08-2026 09:34 PM

Non-Power vs Power

1991 to 2004

MWC 36-79 .313
CUSA 59-145 .289
WAC 79-242-3 .248
Ind 95-365-2 .208
MAC 48-229-2 .176
Big West 13-143-1 .086
Sun Belt 4-77 .049

334-1280-8 .208

2005 to 2012

MWC 51-75 .405
Independent 24-67 .264
WAC 29-103 .220
CUSA 30-179 .144
MAC 34-211 .139
Sun Belt 13-166 .073

181-801 .184

2014 to 2025

American 72-179 .287
MWC 53-175 .232
Independent 32-106 .232
MAC 34-215 .137
Sun Belt 24-163 .128
CUSA 16-193 .077

231-1031 .183


RE: Complete Non-Conference Records (1991-2025) - goofus - 09-09-2026 08:38 AM

Interesting numbers. Thanks

I wonder what was driving the drop-off for the Big Ten from 2005 to 2012? Was the Big Ten playing more games against the SEC?


RE: Complete Non-Conference Records (1991-2025) - bullet - 09-09-2026 09:07 AM

(09-09-2026 08:38 AM)goofus Wrote:  Interesting numbers. Thanks

I wonder what was driving the drop-off for the Big Ten from 2005 to 2012? Was the Big Ten playing more games against the SEC?

Almost everybody but Ohio St. was down during that time frame.


RE: Complete Non-Conference Records (1991-2025) - bullet - 09-09-2026 09:20 AM

2005 to 2012
Conference - Record - Winning %

SEC 102-69 .596
PAC 74-64 .536
Big XII 75-67 .528
Big East 73-86 .459
Big Ten 74-91 .448
ACC 89-124 .418

Notre Dame 47-33 .588


MWC 51-75 .405

Note how close the MWC was during that time frame. They were very close to qualifying for the BCS, so the Big East took TCU and Pac took Utah. And the ACC took much of the best of the Big East to help them get out of 6th place. They had taken Miami and Virginia Tech in 2004 and Boston College in 2005. They followed with Pittsburg and Syracuse in 2013 followed shortly by Louisville. West Virginia had seen the writing on the wall and left for the Big 12 in 2012. That left Rutgers (Big Ten 2014), Cincinnati (Big 12 2023), USF and UConn.