CSNbbs
The Citadel to the AAC! - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: The Citadel to the AAC! (/thread-1032437.html)



The Citadel to the AAC! - billybobby777 - 09-05-2026 08:10 PM

Straight up trade for Charlotte!


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - solohawks - 09-05-2026 08:27 PM

This Citadel team got throttled @ Wofford last week 42-14

Charlotte defense is atrocious


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - OdinFrigg - 09-05-2026 08:38 PM

(09-05-2026 08:10 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  Straight up trade for Charlotte!


3/0T win by The Citadel in Charlotte. 43-41.

May be the weekend’s most dramatic game.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - The Beaver - 09-05-2026 08:52 PM

Charlotte in the AAC is the gift that keeps on taking.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - quo vadis - 09-05-2026 09:57 PM

Charlotte is just a terrible addition I don't know who thought adding them was a good idea.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - b2b - 09-05-2026 10:14 PM

UNCC is absolute trash. They're a middling FCS program at best.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - BcatMatt13 - 09-05-2026 10:17 PM

AAC adding Charlotte was a…uh…decision.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - Thewavefan - 09-05-2026 11:08 PM

(09-05-2026 10:17 PM)BcatMatt13 Wrote:  AAC adding Charlotte was a…uh…decision.

Eh people said the same thing about Tulane and Memphis over a decade ago when the AAC added them, now they are national powerhouses. It will take time but schools in big markets always pays off, the American knows what it’s doing. Big markets are all that matters in the end.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - PicksUp - 09-05-2026 11:10 PM

(09-05-2026 11:08 PM)Thewavefan Wrote:  
(09-05-2026 10:17 PM)BcatMatt13 Wrote:  AAC adding Charlotte was a…uh…decision.

Eh people said the same thing about Tulane and Memphis over a decade ago when the AAC added them, now they are national powerhouses. It will take time but schools in big markets always pays off, the American knows what it’s doing. Big markets are all that matters in the end.

Powerhouses, sure. 07-coffee3

I bet this thread gets locked like your other thread bobby.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - billybobby777 - 09-05-2026 11:14 PM

(09-05-2026 08:52 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Charlotte in the AAC is the gift that keeps on taking.

I thought that was Chlt or the ghost of him?


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - Scoochpooch1 - 09-06-2026 12:51 AM

(09-05-2026 08:38 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote:  
(09-05-2026 08:10 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  Straight up trade for Charlotte!


3/0T win by The Citadel in Charlotte. 43-41.

May be the weekend’s most dramatic game.

"Win", OT is such a joke in CFB.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - Memphis Yankee - 09-06-2026 09:48 AM

(09-05-2026 11:08 PM)Thewavefan Wrote:  
(09-05-2026 10:17 PM)BcatMatt13 Wrote:  AAC adding Charlotte was a…uh…decision.

Eh people said the same thing about Tulane and Memphis over a decade ago when the AAC added them, now they are national powerhouses. It will take time but schools in big markets always pays off, the American knows what it’s doing. Big markets are all that matters in the end.

The AAC didn't add Memphis. The Big East added Memphis which became the AAC.

“July 1,2013: The AAC is formed. It consists of 10 teams: UCF, UConn, Cincinnati, Houston, Louisville, Memphis, Rutgers, SMU, USF, Temple.”

After Louisville and Rutgers left, Tulane, ECU, Tulsa, and Navy were added in 2014, and 2015. Memphis, USF, and Temple are the only original AAC teams left in the conference.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - The Cutter of Bish - 09-06-2026 10:56 AM

A10’s sending a thank you bouquet.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - Fighting Muskie - 09-06-2026 06:08 PM

I think the AAC really thought their logo would bring UNC Charlotte football up a level but it really hasn’t panned out. It makes you wonder if it would have been smarter to cut off expansion at 12 and leave Charlotte and one of Rice/UAB/FAU out.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - BirdHawkEagle - 09-06-2026 06:10 PM

(09-06-2026 06:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think the AAC really thought their logo would bring UNC Charlotte football up a level but it really hasn’t panned out. It makes you wonder if it would have been smarter to cut off expansion at 12 and leave Charlotte and one of Rice/UAB/FAU out.

I agree.

The AAC should have only taken UAB and UTSA at the time.

They bit off more of the CUSA than they could chew.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - billybobby777 - 09-06-2026 09:17 PM

(09-06-2026 06:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think the AAC really thought their logo would bring UNC Charlotte football up a level but it really hasn’t panned out. It makes you wonder if it would have been smarter to cut off expansion at 12 and leave Charlotte and one of Rice/UAB/FAU out.

Take all 4 of those out and the AC could get the 4 best of the new PAC plus Gonzaga.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - The Cutter of Bish - 09-07-2026 07:52 AM

(09-06-2026 06:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think the AAC really thought their logo would bring UNC Charlotte football up a level but it really hasn’t panned out. It makes you wonder if it would have been smarter to cut off expansion at 12 and leave Charlotte and one of Rice/UAB/FAU out.

If we're looking at the AAC as a "best of the rest" of eastern, southern, and mid-southern independents and castaways, it puts those like North Texas, UTSA, and FAU out, while those like Charlotte and even UAB in there as recognizable for their basketball in the old Metro, Great Midwest, and CUSA 1.0 days. Toss in the likes of Southern Miss? I don't know. Maybe not even a place for Tulsa? Technically, should probably leave a spot for UConn, as well.

We're fortunate to see Tulane in this competitive slot, but, those like Rice, Temple, Charlotte, and UAB...it's "old guard" with some connections that have kept them glued with other schools at the level, but, their programs just aren't good on the eyes. Charlotte is probably the most disappointing in all of FBS for what starting a program did: where their football program is now and how basketball fell off a cliff, too.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - billybobby777 - 09-07-2026 08:18 AM

(09-07-2026 07:52 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(09-06-2026 06:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think the AAC really thought their logo would bring UNC Charlotte football up a level but it really hasn’t panned out. It makes you wonder if it would have been smarter to cut off expansion at 12 and leave Charlotte and one of Rice/UAB/FAU out.

If we're looking at the AAC as a "best of the rest" of eastern, southern, and mid-southern independents and castaways, it puts those like North Texas, UTSA, and FAU out, while those like Charlotte and even UAB in there as recognizable for their basketball in the old Metro, Great Midwest, and CUSA 1.0 days. Toss in the likes of Southern Miss? I don't know. Maybe not even a place for Tulsa? Technically, should probably leave a spot for UConn, as well.

We're fortunate to see Tulane in this competitive slot, but, those like Rice, Temple, Charlotte, and UAB...it's "old guard" with some connections that have kept them glued with other schools at the level, but, their programs just aren't good on the eyes. Charlotte is probably the most disappointing in all of FBS for what starting a program did: where their football program is now and how basketball fell off a cliff, too.

I still like the metro idea for everything but FB. Pick the best 16 of the castaways in Texas, the South, Mid Atlantic and Upper Eastern regions and make a conference. As they are Indi in FB, they can schedule each other when not playing a P4 school and work out their own Bowls. Maybe even a 24 team conference of 8 schools in each division for Olympic sport scheduling purposes. All the AC schools, and a few from the SB, MAC, CUSA and UConn.


RE: The Citadel to the AAC! - army56mike - 09-08-2026 06:16 PM

(09-07-2026 08:18 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(09-07-2026 07:52 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(09-06-2026 06:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think the AAC really thought their logo would bring UNC Charlotte football up a level but it really hasn’t panned out. It makes you wonder if it would have been smarter to cut off expansion at 12 and leave Charlotte and one of Rice/UAB/FAU out.

If we're looking at the AAC as a "best of the rest" of eastern, southern, and mid-southern independents and castaways, it puts those like North Texas, UTSA, and FAU out, while those like Charlotte and even UAB in there as recognizable for their basketball in the old Metro, Great Midwest, and CUSA 1.0 days. Toss in the likes of Southern Miss? I don't know. Maybe not even a place for Tulsa? Technically, should probably leave a spot for UConn, as well.

We're fortunate to see Tulane in this competitive slot, but, those like Rice, Temple, Charlotte, and UAB...it's "old guard" with some connections that have kept them glued with other schools at the level, but, their programs just aren't good on the eyes. Charlotte is probably the most disappointing in all of FBS for what starting a program did: where their football program is now and how basketball fell off a cliff, too.

I still like the metro idea for everything but FB. Pick the best 16 of the castaways in Texas, the South, Mid Atlantic and Upper Eastern regions and make a conference. As they are Indi in FB, they can schedule each other when not playing a P4 school and work out their own Bowls. Maybe even a 24 team conference of 8 schools in each division for Olympic sport scheduling purposes. All the AC schools, and a few from the SB, MAC, CUSA and UConn.

I imagine some of the more successful current teams (Memphis, Tulane, S. Florida, etc.) will get lucky and move on to greener pastures. I think when everything shakes out the AAC would be happy to be.....

Temple..........Delaware
Marshall........JMU
Liberty..........ODU
App St..........Charlotte
ECU..............CCU
UAB..............Georgia St.
FAU..............FIU
WKU.............MTSU
Tulsa.............Missouri St.